Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This week on Be Gay Solve Crimes, we're joined by the incomparable Dr Eleanor Janega to provide us with her magnificent medieval history expertise as we tackle the classic Cadfael chronicle, The Virgin In The Ice (1995)!

Join us as Eleanor advises us on which haircut is the best choice if your aim is to never get laid again, Mia gets awarded a Good Grade In Religion, while Lucy by contrast accidentally starts a cult devoted to pregnant horse piss.

If you like this episode, you should subscribe to our Patreon. For as little as £5 a month you get access to every bonus episode we've ever made, plus a new bonus episode every other week!

Likewise, if you want more Dr Janega, you should check out her podcasts Going Medieval and We're Not So Different, as well as her new book The Once and Future Sex!

Next time, we pay tribute to the late great Patrick Stewart with a classic episode of Star Trek, The Big Goodbye!

Be Gay Solve Crimes are on Bluesky, where you can find Dr Janega, as well as each of the team: November Kelly, Mia Mulder, and your local librarian Lucy, who writes all the music for the show.

Files

Comments

Gwen, Charm of the Ozarks

It’s Clever Clau-Clau from hit 1970’s BBC historical drama series “I, Claudius”

Em Sculfor

Pretty sure the Welsh pronunciation would be "cad-veil" FYI

Edwin Bent

Strange how you never mentioned that uncle Stephen was being played by a Polish bear.

Alex

Guessing the horse piss joke is about gunpowder and saltpeter? Wasn’t aware they had to be pregnant though

skedazzle

I was the kind of kid who did my middle school book report on I, Claudius and did not understand why that was weird

Gwen, Charm of the Ozarks

I’d kill for the greater transgender podcasting community to cover I, Claudius. Like where else can you see a blonde German mercenary say “KAISER? JA?!”

Alex

Estrogen joke, forgot what podcast I was listening too, just got to the part

Loqi finally stopped using her real name

I dont know if Unitarian Universalism is as god optional in Europe as it is in the US, but I have found it very useful for religious longing without belief in the big G. Of course I grew up Agnostic UU so kinda biased.

SabTab

AO3 being down right now is a travesty, I can’t update my Hildergaard von Bingen lesbian erotica 💔

skedazzle

Idk about the idea of hell reining in the nobility at all, it barely reined in the clergy. I mean the monks were doing the necromantic alchemical underground stuff trafficking in literal summoning of demons to find buried treasure Certainly made the church a lot of money, though I think the thing that possibly reined in the nobility was the idea that divine favor was a points system and humility, good works and piety showed how much better you were than other people. That idea has potential political power. Hell is a bit too abstract for the rich, probably much more of a concrete concept for the poor

James Rule

I love Cadfael so much. Great episode. Need to hunt down the show, and dig up my copies of the novels that are buried somewhere in the vortex that is my office.

Vanessa P

there's definitely a distinction to be drawn between religion as a tool and institution of social control and maintenance of hierarchy and religion as a vector of cultural transmission and production and communitarian binding through ritual, and the conflation of the two has caused a great deal of unnecessary grief

BrailleCortex

someone frozen in ice happened at least twice in SG-1 that I can remember. First was that time they found Maybourne in a freezer in russia when dealing with the microscopic water creatures planet that was keeping the gate open, and second was the time they found that woman in antarctica who they thought was dead, but turned out to be an actual living Ancient who had been frozen for some millions of years, and woke back up for a bit before dying properly

Mcitso

An 1130s episodes just when I've taken up Crusader Kings 2 again? Joyous tidings! Thank you all for another banger. Also, no worries about the Estrogen bit, just an attempted tongue twister that Lucy fucking BREEZED past. Was struggling for a name this week.

Funder

Ladies, I know the dick-tree marginalia because i have an enamel pin of the orchard sister herself! And I have amazing news for you: penis trees are real. I invite you to look up the California buckeye, and to imagine how you’d ask your new neighbors what that medieval penis tree is without calling it “that medieval penis tree.” I managed it somehow!

Meekle Tubas

Mia inadvertently defending Kevin O’Leary was not on my bingo card.

NowhereMan661

The life of a monk has always seemed appealing to me as well, but mostly just because those were the guys doing all the nerd stuff in the medieval era. I want to be working with ancient texts, making manuscript art, and discussing theology and philosophy, not dirt farming or metalworking.

NowhereMan661

How the hell do you have sex after being stabbed? I feel like the pain would put you out of it.

Lain of the Wired

I just wanted to be a priest due to the visions from God telling me to transition idk what neurodivergence that is maybe that egg just needed a miracle to crack

Nazunii

I'm duckduckgoing "martin luther horse piss" and all i get is some qoute about how peasants are drunk driving or something

Kristaps Porzingis

Getting a bit near the knuckle with the "join our cult" bit in a show that's themed around one weird trick that'll solve all your problems

Nazunii

I look forward to hearing more of the whiteship disaster on WTYP

Chibigodzilla

Seeing Dr Janega's name written down, it does make me think that she might be a top tier Final Fantasy spell; early on you can cast Jane, then you get Janea, and finally Janega (exceptions allowed for the games where you have four tiers and eventually get Janeja)

The Mad Scientist's toolkit

I think the author is on record as saying she should have done a pronunciation guide for the books.

The Mad Scientist's toolkit

It's so funny to think of Edith Pageter reading Robert of Shrewsbury's Hagioagraphy of Saint Winifred and thinking fuck this guy in particular, which is basically what the first book is about.

Gil the Gilded Dragon

it's not stolen valour to tonsure; like those french fucks with the fancy garnets cloissone and the hot wives kept doing (wait is the garnet-pomegranate why the Sisters W have persephone married to the MEROVINGIAN?) doing the tonsuring to each other to get their male relatives unwittingly commited to monasticism. "Brother Albofledis! Why hast tho tied all our habits together and dangled them out the cloister? Why i understand the zeal to wring out all the water out of the garments but if you do not air them they will become musty! Besides there is no time to loose, brother Hurzosarctos has finally tied himself out and we can finally access the scriptorium!" and chastity schmastity. There's so many "by [intranscribable names of angels and spirits[ make the new Abbot's secretrary burn with lust, burning like a coal in this brazier, unable to sleep until tender we know each other in the brassicava"

Gil the Gilded Dragon

the monastery is where you put your neurodivergent medievals. What are you gonna do if your kid is very into growing strange peas? or has illustrated the inn's back wall using a a single of the cat's whiskers... or has started speaking to the sublunar intelligences. You send the uncanny child to a monastery lest he become a pagan... or a priest-tyrant for the Christmastime nativity plays. .. A horrid visionhas struck me of the adult theatre kid small parish friar who wants to use the fullness of the town to stage THE WHOLE BIBLE

Gil the Gilded Dragon

That time period a big bootied latina is a curvy Jewish milkmaid in Cordova; she'd speak Ladino

The Mad Scientist's toolkit

I'm pretty sure discount Alan Rickman from Prince of Theives was actually discount Alan Rickman IN Prince of Theives.

Gil the Gilded Dragon

some brothers NEED to take a fucking vow of silence, someone send that boy to Mount Athos and hwat doth the sister mean?! Heresy is not a natural part of human emotion;one can grieve but not yearn that she were deprived of the beatific pressence

Simon Bitdiddle

I can't wait to hear November relitigate Name of the Rose and reuse that quote from the Illustrious Nate B.

Andrew Dunn

Priest doing mass in big booty latin Speaking of "a religious young man being faced with a lustful situation and then people dying" the HBO show watchmen has a thing where Tim Blake Nelson's character Looking Glass has a flashback to him as a religious young man who is about to have sex despite being some Protestant Evangelical kid and the ozymandias plan happens while his pants are down and he survives out of everyone in the surrounding area because he gave into his temptations and went inside a big hall of mirrors and thus was protected God what a good show

Shiv

Dr. J is right: if you’re here, you get the horse piss jokes

Poppy

Despite not having a religion, while burnt out from a tough job, I researched nuns. A lot of young nuns/sisters now have to work a normal job on top of their other duties, so you don't get to escape the rat race.

3mix2yoo

Dragon Quest historians of gender be like Eleanor Kajane

Andrew Dunn

From what I understand, along with Unitarian universalism, there is also quakerism if you want a meditative pacifistic believe in something greater than yourself style joint.

Julia Schaible

AND dovetails with a tribute to Patrick Stewart and weird little wigs to see him as Sejanus

Andrew Dunn

Samurai barbers are hobbyists, they just cut hair on the side

sam p

Oh shit! Mia had to heat herself like the kidnappers from Fargo

Whisky_Delta

As a network design manager, just hearing this as "CAD file"

May I recommend Hit Indie Game SIGNALIS???

I struggle a little when religion comes up, because it is something people draw meaning from. It is a cultural vector, and it does create community. But I grew up religious, and I think it's easy for people who believe in a better future to get nostalgic about religion being more just and principled than it really was. This is still the era when people will be murdered in broad daylight for being of the wrong race or faith or even type of faith, and it was widely-accepted that the victims weren't even human. This is still the era of the Crusades and all of the horrific mass-slaughters that came with them, fully endorsed and pardoned by the Church through universal indulgences granted to any who died in or on-route to the Crusades. It is still the era of the complete disenfranchisement and commodification of women. And I think it's easy to forget that the philosophies of Abrahamic faiths are rooted in inherent systemic injustice, being that God/Allah/Yaweh sees fit to serve as judge, jury, and executioner of humankind for failing to live up to its rules, despite those rules constantly being broken on order of God/Allah/YWH; and that it is held to be somehow just that people can be property of their Creator, so should it be any surprise that these faiths perpetuate, justify, and willingly enact slavery, patriarchy, and colonialism? The social control and hierarchy is what God/YWH/Allah imposes upon us and tells us is just.

Vanessa P

I get it but I think what I'm responding to is the instinct towards thinking that the underlying beliefs about what should be done in the material world is what is most important to most religious people and hence religion should be suppressed or ridiculed. If it was critical to read the books literally the only Abrahamic religious people would be ultra-reactionary crackpots in weird communes, you know? Whereas in the real world we have everything from capital-worshipping American protestants to liberation theologists to tradcaths to semi-agnostic boring Anglicans. It's just the application of a set of cultural signifiers to different underlying ideologies and material conditions. "Gay people are sinners" and "God loves everyone, including homosexuals" are both statements that can be made by religious people, and you can argue that one of the other is doctrinally wrong but it ultimately doesn't really matter; both have an underlying set of beliefs that are completely different (the first, disgust, a desire for people to conform with "the proper order of things", the second, tolerance, a desire for people who aren't hurting anyone not to be hurt in turn) and are simply choosing to express that underlying belief in a common language which can easily be mistaken for the actual *cause* of the underlying belief. You can reasonably argue that the adoption of a common cultural symbology is an instinct that naturally tends towards conservatism and so all such symbologies should be marginalised, whether it be explicitly religious or the pseudo-religions of modernist societies like American "Democracy"(tm) or Chinese "Communism"(tm), to which I say, good luck trying to create a society that has some sense of collective solidarity yet doesn't use mythology and shared cultural language to draw people together and to explain and justify its own conditions and contradictions lol, let me know when you've accomplished that one

Vanessa P

To elaborate I am not an antitheist for the reason that I do not call myself an anarchist even though I share a lot of their beliefs; although the specific way they've evolved are heavily influenced by the need to continue the rule of some upper stratum, I think religion/the state emerge partly from a genuine organic need, whether for a unified system of cultural signifiers or a mechanism of social coordination, and if you were to evaporate either with a magical laser the world wouldn't end but something not quite the same but approximately like them would reemerge over time. To some extent this has already happened with religion: modern society has much less overt religious symbolism; but as I mentioned before there are many things which have come to occupy the same role, such as the Euro-American belief in the trappings and rituals of capital D "Democracy". There's no eliminating those instincts, try as you might.

Al

OMG I had a phase where I wanted to be either a Catholic nun or a Lutheran minister. Turns out I'm just a dude.

Simon Bitdiddle

I have a new proposal for a metric: The DIG Axis. Detective: How effective are they at detectiveness. Things like interrogation, investigating and noticing clues, that sort of thing. Inspector: How effective are they at administrative stuff. Things like "Do they get along with the police, government and other resources. Are they able to research or use their situational authority well." Gumshoe: How intergrated are they to the story and the movie. Are they phoning it in? Are they genre savvy or are they acting like a normal person thrust into the story? Feedback and refinement would be appreciated.

Sammi

Aww, no laugh on the Camp Miasma joke?