Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This week on Be Gay Solve Crimes, Mia and Lucy investigate that one time Captain Picard spent an entire episode cosplaying as a 1940s detective. It's The Big Goodbye!

Join us as we give ourselves Stardate 41997.7 / 1990s /1940s woman dysphoria, ponder the philosophical merits of Plato's Allegory of the Goon Cave, and accidentally install jiggle physics on the late Patrick Stewart.

Be Gay Solve Crimes are on Bluesky, where you can find each of the team: November Kelly, Mia Mulder, and your local librarian Lucy, who writes all the music for the show.

Next time, in our quest to document every transgender detective, we continue to catch 'em all... it's Detective Pikachu (2019).

If you’re reading this, thank you so much for subscribing to our Patreon! Your support means the world to us. Be sure to share us far and wide if you like what we do and want us to be able to keep doing it!

Files

Comments

The Mad Scientist's toolkit

Just FYI I found another Agatha Christie Doctor Who, it's from 1977 called The Robots of Death. It's also based on Isaac Asimov's robot detective novels so I guess it also ties into I Robot. Also Dune but I don't know if there's a detective in that.

Alex

R.I.P Patrick Stewart, you would have loved be gay solve crimes

James Rule

The other trick original Trek would do to just not be in space is that sometimes a planet would be full of Nazis or gangsters because reasons.

James Rule

Dune is kind of a mystery story if you ignore they tell you who the traitor was immediately.

Nah

lol I did wonder why I hadn't noticed for years and years that Dr Yanega wasn't cis, your confidence shook my genuine dozens of hours of listening to her podcasting

The Mad Scientist's toolkit

It can be hard to find sci-fi mystery/detective episodes that don't devolve into weird bullshit and drop the mystery element.

RipleyInSpace

FWIW - I agree with Mia about the voice training thing. And also, have personal experience for my more traditionally trans siblings - I'm masc-presenting enby, have a beard (atm) and have always had a deep voice and broad chest. Before I realised I wasn't cis, at my most in-denial masc presenting, I was mistaken by a (wonderfully well-meaning) barmaid for not only a woman, but my own mother's girlfriend. I had been speaking to her. Voice training ain't the be-all and sure as hell ain't necessary: do what's right for you, lovies, fuck what strangers say or think.

SabTab

Now, I was not a Star Trek or Doctor Who kid. The space show of my childhood was, in fact, Red Dwarf. So, when I heard the line about thermodynamics and things having an equal and opposite reason, I was activated and forced to finish it with “A black hole sucks time and matter out of the universe, a white hole returns it.”

Hovis

In Lower Decks there are a bunch of jokes about being assigned to holodeck cleanup detail. It's not fun. It's also canonically freaky nasty in there. The only time this has been seen as a real problem was when somebody was using deepfakes of the crew for it. There's an episode where a guy gets a bit parasocial with a deepfake of an engineer but the show plays it off as mostly okay because 1990s and Rick Berman.

Will Morphet

Lucy doing the "500 cigarettes" bit for real. Genuinely though whenever people bring up smoking in relation to Star Trek, I always think about the story from the filming of Star Trek II: Wrath of Khan where Nicholas Meyer (the film's director) and Gene Roddenberry (original Star Trek creator) had a full on shouting match on set about the former placing a NO SMOKING sign on the bridge; Meyer argued that people have smoked for millennia and always will, whereas Roddenberry said it would be stupid to think people will still be inhaling cancerous fumes for fun 300 years in the future. So holodeck ciggies are probably just barebones simulacra with all the actual active ingredients omitted. P.S. even though Star Trek eps on gender identity/politics tend to be prettty hit and miss, it is basically canon that their medical technology is so good you could every kind of gender reaffirming surgery in the space of, like, an afternoon.

Woeful_Imp

I've never watched Star Trek before and this episode honestly made me feel like I'm missing out. If only the days were longer ^^' One more thing, if I may...is there a preferred way to make suggestions? The mention of being able to cram lawyer in the format made me think of one but I'm not sure of the appropriate way to suggest it?

Will Morphet

I always laugh at that first Barclay episode when Riker and Picard see it and are like "ok new regulation: no simulating real people" implying that in all the time since the holodecks were installed this hadn't occurred to anyone to safeguard against.

Camoose the Uncrackable Egg

The Most Toys would be a cool detective trek episode. The gang does a great job finding out what happened to data.

skedazzle

For Dr. Who the Tom Baker episode "The Deadly Assassin" is noir detective themed and for new who "Angels Take Manhattan" is a mystery episode, but devolving into weird bullshit is kind of their whole deal My favorite detective themed episode of a scifi show would have to be the Fringe episode "Brown Betty" which is also a musical and wild all around, highly recommend There's Legends of Tomorrow, which did "Miss Me, Kiss Me, Love Me" Supernatural did one called "A Most Holy Man", Quantum Leap did one called "Play it Again, Sam" and Warehouse 13 did one called "The Big Snag". I kind of love these kind of episodes because the actors seem like they are having the time of their lives

Hovis

DS9 has a canonically trans character. It's got a handwavey science fiction justification, but in practical terms it's just like, "Hey my old buddy Curzon is a 10/10 smokeshow baddie now and it fucking rules."

Sammi

"So what is it?"

NowhereMan661

It's always been crazy how you can just disable the safety features on a Holodeck and actually die. The more we see the Holodeck in this series, the more it seems like a really bad idea.

David Munro

Okay, regarding lawyers potentially being in scope for the detective podcast. I would love a Ace Attorney Phoenix Wright episode

Will Morphet

Oh for sure I think Dax is amazing, but as you say it can sort of be handwaved away as "oh that's different cos they're aliens, different hosts different lifetimes etc." whereas the point I was trying emphasise is that even if you're just a 24th century human you would have an insane amount of options for transing your sex. I mean in one (admittedly not great) episode Quark essentially gets SRS for a business scheme lol. Also as rough as TNG season 1 is, they try to show crew members in androgynous/ gender-nonconforming clothing so I imagine they're just extremely chill about gender presentation anyway.

NowhereMan661

What does is say about me, a cis het guy, that I also knew about the mare piss thing?

Ashley F

Standing in the rain crying as I listen to this Comedy Pocast TM (positive)

Sammi

The fact that the holo-deck doesn't generate clothing for you becomes a running joke in Deep Space 9; characters keep showing up in bizarre period costumes because they're going to or from a booking on the holo-deck.

vercingix

I do want the hostage to do some DS9, there are great mystery episodes. But mostly I want to hear everyone's read of Jadzia Dax

MissDemeanor

when Lucy referenced voice training, I did immediately repeat "heat from fire, fire from heat" in solid snake voice out loud in the middle of a restaurant

vercingix

City of Death features a detective, though I'd hardly call that a mystery story. Duggan's only approach to any given problem is hitting someone.

Nazunii

I got a question on På Spåret right thanks to this podcast. I knew Kenneth Branagh played Wallander thanks to you

Nazunii

Omg Lucy's mom emailing oculus rift and asking for a prototype is so sweet

eeple

The 'silver catsuit' Lucy mentioned has got to be Seven of Nine's outfit in Voyager.

SabTab

“Only joking :)”

Frank Leonard

Doing Detective Pikachu on the fly before any of the Ghost in the Shell movies is wild, but I respect it

Dr Grasshopper

When you run out of letters you can do the NATO phoenetic alphabet as a bit

Ari

we'll make a trekkie of lucy yet!!

Deb

I'd be interested in hearing people's reads on Odo, too. Dax is the obvious transfem character, but I always kinda felt for how Odo had to physically present in a certain way to survive, but could never quite get the details right.

Forever Bulking

Congrats! You have unlocked the Path of the Grungler. Tread carefully. Many traps of Baleful Polymorph(Egg) lay ahead.

Forever Bulking

Me, upon hearing the Dr Yanega discussion: Getting the piss joke makes you a doll or a grungler? Ah! Another Binary that I am Non-! Foiled again! ✨

Liz

Detective Pikachu is more transgender than you may be anticipating, I'm excited to hear what y'all think as non-Pokemon fans!

NowhereMan661

Well I guess that definition mostly fits, I'm just not bisexual or really uncertain with my gender identity. I just like history and want to be a good ally.

Australian Estuary Pirate

No Gods No Mayors was apparently literally side-splittingly funny. Fuck yeah Detective Pikachu! The human character looks wierdly similar to Axe, Melee's best Pikachu player.

Synestia

Wesley almost enabled Hot Coffee Mode on several members of command staff.

aae19422

Holodeck in TNG is definitely an improvement over the original series when the writers wanted to flip things up. Not so much time travel as "Here's the 20s Gangster planet. Here's the Nazi Germany planet. Don't worry about it."

Kris J

Silver catsuit? I go straight to Jeri Ryans, 7of9 from Voyager

Just Miss Yang

That was a pretty an on point Wesley Snipes impression Mia! HRT 4 month mark!!!

Andrew Dunn

Hopefully you'll be able to find something transgender about the Justice Smith movie

Matthew Brown

When I first saw this episode I thought they couldn't take LaForge because of his visor since they made a big thing about Picard's uniform beforehand....I was 10 at the time so y'know purity of youth not realising it was due to Geordi being black. Better times.

Mia

dont fret about the length of the episodes etc! you are both doing wonderfully and its just as funny as always :) ps i think the silver body suit lucy remembers was probably Seven of Nine

SpaceWizard

Can't wait for when they get around to the Data Sherlock Holmes holodeck episodes because, without spoilers, lots of trans shit happening there (and also more goofy inconsistent holodeck behaviors) Edit: Hell yeah, Mia mentioned it Also I love that Original Series 1920s gangster episode because they don't even go back in time for that, it's an alien planet where an Earth ship crashed and the inhabitants found a book on 1920s gangsters and decided to base their entire society off of that

Andrew T. Wilson

I'm just going to assume that Jessie Earl had a scheduling conflict.

NotGagarin

Okay I'm going to be the annoying Star Trek nerd and say the reason the lipstick stays on is because the holodeck doesn't just use visual holograms but replicator technology as well. So the lipstick was actual material that was synthesised. I can't remember if that explanation was in the show or just a fan theory to explain moments like that, but I'm pretty sure it's on a wiki somewhere. Also! Holodecks were actually an idea that Roddenberry had back in the original series already, and the first version actually appears in The Animated Series!

PenniePepper

Oh, Gosh, that line about Klingons being some kind of saran wrap maybe? made me laugh so much, and I think I'll have a little chuckle whenever I encounter Klingons or saran wrap in my life from now on hahahaha

rakslice

i feel like the times are ripe for a rewatch, depending on how you feel about teeth

aceplym

I mean, if we want to do detective Star Treks with a side of gender there is always that episode of TOS where Scotty catches misogyny and then Jack the Ripper gets involved...