DEEP DISCOG DIVE UPDATE 6.16.26 (Patreon)
Content
Hey gang!! Hope you're all doing well and staying cool. NYC is still riding the high of the Knicks' first championship win in over 50 years, and while I don't follow basketball closely, it was very fun to get swept up in it all. The last time the Knicks won was in 1973 - my dad was my age when it happened. That's surreal as hell!!!
I wish I had a smoother tie-in to the rest of this point, but sadly none of the members of this band I'm doing a DDD on were Knicks fans. (Though one of them was related to an NBA player, more on that later.) To make up for this, the DDD after this one will be on Ben Stiller.
Anyway...
WHERE WE'RE AT NOW
When we last left off, the Beach Boys had just bottomed out with Summer in Paradise. If you haven't heard it, it's bad! No charting, no reissue, no streaming, no nothing. By the time SIP came out, the band was in arguably the worst spot of their whole career. Brian was legally blocked from participating by his psychiatrist and Very Bad Person Eugene Landy, who refused to let him work on anything that didn't also credit himself. (More on that later too!) Carl showed up for vocals but wrote and played nothing, spending his real creative energy on a side project with members of America and Chicago. Al got suspended from the sessions early on for objecting to the material, then quietly brought back to sing two leads. Bruce was the only member who actually played an instrument on the whole record. And Mike Love, with total creative control for the first time, was convinced they were about to recreate Kokomo. They didn't!
After SIP, the Boys released two more studio albums over the next twenty years, and the space between all of them is filled with lawsuits, fractured lineups, and unfortunate deaths. It was a long, painful decline that only occasionally has a bright spot to show for it. The era does have a genuine highlight, one last moment where the full band came back together and actually made something decent and good and cool. But getting there takes a wee bit.
ALBUMS I'VE LISTENED TO
Stars and Stripes Vol. 1: So after the SIP catastrophe, Brian was finally free of Eugene Landy and in a way better headspace. He and a songwriter named Andy Paley got to work on what historians now call the Paley Sessions. By all accounts the sessions created a bunch of genuinely good material, but the project got shelved. Instead, what we got was Stars and Stripes Vol. 1.
Stars and Stripes is a collaborative album with various country musicians, co-produced by Brian Wilson and Joe Thomas. The concept was that twelve country stars sang Beach Boys classics, while the Boys themselves were just backing vocalists. It was the last studio album to feature founding member Carl Wilson, who sadly died in 1998.
Maybe this album has shooters, but imma be real, I don't know why... you would listen to this! It's just covers of the band's big songs, but in a country style. I suppose it's interesting to hear folks like Willie Nelson and Toby Keith on BB songs, but like, I wouldn't recommend it? And not because it's bad, but because I don't know who would want this in the first place. It outsold Summer in Paradise, but was not a major hit and was poorly received by critics, and plans for further volumes in the series were cancelled.
That's Why God Made the Radio: There is a sixteen-year gap between these two albums, during which Carl Wilson died, the band fractured into competing touring factions, and everyone sued everyone else approximately 400,000 times (give or take 399,997). More on that below. But in 2012, for the band's 50th anniversary, the Boys actually did it: they all reunited for a new album and 50th anniversary tour.
And man it's good! Not a classic, but more than anyone had any right to expect. It plays like another episode in the longtime struggle between Mike Love's fun-in-the-sun approach and Wilson's grander, darker themes. The three songs that close the album - From There to Back Again, Pacific Coast Highway, and Summer's Gone are stellar. I didn't have the highest expectations, given the amount of the time that had passed and the downtrend trend the band has been on previously, but I can't imagine a better album from these guys at this stage in the game.
That's Why God Made the Radio debuted at number 3 on the Billboard Top 200, setting the band's highest-ever American album chart start. Not a bad send-off tbh.
Adult/Child: With the main discography done, I decided to check out some side projects that you fine folks had previously recommended. First up - the album that was originally gonna follow up The Beach Boys Love You. This one has never technically been released, but a healthy chunk of it was released as part of the recent We Gotta Groove compilation from this year. And I liked it! Didn't love it, probably need another listen or two. But I was impressed with how orchestral and lavish the production was. I read that some of the songs were meant for folks like Sinatra, and oh boy does that come across when you listen. I should check out bootlegs from this time too.
Smile (2004): I'd already listened to the Smile Sessions from 2011, but I also wanted to check out the version of Smile Brian recorded on his own and released in 2004. This version has Brian's band the Wondermints supporting him throughout instead of any of the BBs. Of course this is a good album - I already knew from listening to the 2011 release, and critics went wild over this upon release. As of now, it's the third highest rated album ever on Metacritic. (if you're curious, one and two are Wadada Leo Smith's Ten Freedom Summers and Fiona Apple's Fetch The Bolt Cutters respectively.) If anything, this album makes for a fascinating counterpart to the 2011 version - what sounds similar, what sounds different, etc. Brian's way more present in the mix throughout, which is nice but I feel like some songs lost a haziness that I really liked before. (I'm thinking Cabin Essence and Surf's Up specifically.) Still, these are the minor-est of nitpicks. Smile's excellent, regardless of how you listen to it.
INTERESTING FACTS FROM THIS TIME
Mike Love's brother Stan was an NBA player! And Stan's son Kevin plays for the Utah Jazz currently.
The Paley Sessions are one of the great "what ifs" in Beach Boys history. The day after California courts issued a restraining order on Eugene Landy in February 1992, Wilson phoned Andy Paley and said they were now free to produce whatever they wanted. Without an album or recording contract in mind, the two proceeded to write and record several dozen songs that reflected Wilson's artistic sensibilities more than any work since The Beach Boys Love You. As far as I've seen, those original recordings have not seen any official release, but versions of the songs have come out in various ways.
Andy Paley worked with several big hitters like Brian and Madonna, but there's a chance you may know him best from his work on Spongebob. He did the song "Best Day Ever."
Carl Wilson passed away in 1998 due to lung cancer, and his death marked a rise in tension between band members. Carl had been the person holding the whole thing together through sheer force of will.
And here's proof of of the thing I just said: after Carl's death, it seemed like the Beach Boys couldn't stop suing each other. in 2001, Jardine filed a $4 million suit against Love and Brother Records, alleging that Love had excluded him from Beach Boys concerts that year. That got eventually dismissed. Then, Love and the Carl Wilson estate sued Jardine on behalf of Brother Records in 2003, and again in 2004 seeking $2.2 million in legal fees. Jardine, they claimed, was illegally using the Beach Boys name by touring as "Beach Boys Family & Friends." And then in 2004, Love filed suit accusing Brian of promoting his 2004 solo Smile album in a manner that "shamelessly misappropriated Mike Love's songs, likeness and the Beach Boys trademark." In 2007, the court threw it out, ruling that any partnership Love and Wilson had was creative, not business, and had ended in the 1960s.
In 2014, the Brian Wilson biopic Love & Mercy came out. Still gotta see it, but I've heard good things!
Brian Wilson died just over a year ago at age 82. His immediate cause of death was respiratory arrest. He was nine days away from his 83rd birthday. He was a complex legend and one of the best songwriters + composers in US history. If you like some musician, they likely have cited Brian as an inspiration.
As of right now, there are two different Beach Boys you can go and see live. There's the "official" band fronted by Mike Love and featuring no other members of the band. But there's also the newly formed (as of this year) band comprised of Al Jardine and Brian Wilson's touring band.
SONGS TO CHECK OUT
Don't Worry Baby: The one song off Stars and Stripes that I felt any emotion about. Lorrie Morgan sounds good on it.
That's Why God Made the Radio: A genuinely charming lead single. Classic-sounding in the best way. The way the gang sings the title (like at 1:01) gives me a bit of chills. A smidge even.
Summer's Gone: Originally written to be the last BBs songs on their last album. Apparently Brian scrapped the idea because he wanted to do a follow-up, but sadly he ended up getting that wish. Beautiful song.
Shortenin' Bread: WHO UP SHORTENIN THEY BREAD RN
Good Vibrations (2004): RIP Brian.
And that's it for now! My journey thru the main discography is now officially done, and mannnnn I've got loads of feelings about it. I'm very excited to start writing the script proper.
Which reminds me - now with the albums completed, I'll be moving to the next stage of the DDD and will start to write the script. I'll still share weekly updates, but they'll be less about discoveries on the band and more about peeks behind the scenes.
No new main-channel vid this week, but look out for a vid later this week compiling mine and y'alls picks for the best music of the year so far!