A Little History about XYZprinting and My Channel (Patreon)
Content
Chuck,
"Your YT channel was free marketing/advertising/tech support tool to them. They should send you a new Pro for free"
So I thought it was time to share a background story with my Team Patreon supporters.
In March of 2014 I finally found the 3D Printer I was looking for, the Da Vinci 1.0. It had all the best features and included it's own software, which was not that common back then, nor were fully assembled printers for under $500. I had to wait for them to be in stock at Amazon because they sold out as quick as they arrived. By the beginning of May I had my printer. My plan was to write a book for beginners and this looked like the best printer to use.
I was incredibly pleased with how easy it was to get started. All the horror stories about temp settings, retraction, etc. were not a concern. I could print right out of the box. I thought, this is a great printer fro the beginner. Then I started reading how people were having trouble with theirs. How they couldn't get circles to print. How they couldn't get the first layer to stick. I realized I was starting to have the same issues. So as an engineer I saw the chance to fix them. I did and then decided to help others by showing my fixes on my YouTube Channel that I had launched back in 2010 but never did much with. I was immediately getting viewers. I also started creating my 3D printing book.
Then I had the hot end quit working on mine and I called XYZprinting and got a hold of the USA sales manager. When I told him I was writing a book, he seemed interested. I was able to get a new hot end sent to me without much hassle. I was impressed with the support.
My channel continued to grow and then I got a call from the XYZprinting sales office and they wanted to know if I would be interested in working with them. They were launching their own YouTube channel. I didn't have time to run two channels and I didn't want them just embedding my videos but I was interested in hearing more.
They wanted an exclusivity deal with my channel. They wanted me to use Da Vinci products exclusively. I was amazed as I was such a small channel but I had plans to try out and review other 3D printers and filaments and scanners. Plus I planned to buy a Shapeoko CNC for Christmas and hoped to do beginners videos and a book for that. I've written many books and they help pay for my hobbies. I wasn't really interested in an exclusivity deal but we continued to talk.
I never heard anything about compensation for this deal, so finally I asked: what was XYZprinting willing to pay me for exclusive use of my channel to feature their products..............Essentially Nothing!
In the end, we agreed that for the short term I would continue to use my Da Vinci (since that was the only printer I had) in the videos and they would promote my channel on their Facebook page, which had about 1400 followers, a lot more than mine. I never agreed to any exclusivity and never signed anything. Everything went fine until I had a broken bearing mount. I had to send them pictures and several emails to get them to finally send me one replacement. One!! For a guy who was promoting their products I thought I could at least get a set.
Then my son, who had bought a Da Vinci based on my recommendation, had the first of our illegal cartridge errors at 170 meters left. He had kept his firmware up to date to the latest and it cost him. I had a few generations prior and had not seen that issue. We ended up back and forth after seven emails with XYZprinting just throwing the bad cartridge aside because they would not do anything about it. They wanted proof of what our computer was showing and kept showing us PC screens. We had a Mac and could not find what they wanted. I contacted my sales guy but he just routed me to the same lame tech support.
Then the connector issue on the extruder failed on two of our machines so I figured out how to fix it myself rather than call tech support. I did a video on that. We had another cartridge fail but we switched it to a new machine and bypassed the error which seemed to occur once again around 170 meters of plastic left.
I soon purchased one of the first PLA cartridges to finally print PLA on my Da Vinci. It was advertised to print both ABS and PLA. Then I found out I needed to upgrade my hotend/extruder for $99 in order to use the PLA filament. No matter what I did I could not get it to work. I was able to get some Laywoo wood filament. Again, could not get it to work on the Da Vinci with a cartridge in place. Some people had reported the 1.0A had the better extruder but I had 1.0's so I just kept printing ABS.
My frustration was growing and so was the frustration of many of my viewers. I had a long talk with the XYZprinting sales guy and told him they have a problem on their hands. I have some of the top Da Vinci users and they are having lots of problems with the printers and cartridges. I said many are complaining they can't print with the new PLA cartridge. I said they need to correct this or they are gonna have a lot of people re-flashing to Repetier as that software hack was getting great reviews. Repetier re-falsh had proved that you didn't need the new hot end to get PLA to print. I told them they need to open the Da Vinci up. Let the community help fix the issues. They flatly refused.
Then I found out the firmware was blocking any downgrading of the firmware to where you could use a resetter or even Simplify3D features. I couldn't fully test Simplify3D that a subscriber had donated to my channel. I was beginning to see that using the Da Vinci was limiting my 3D printing experience.
Then the Jr. was announced and I asked for one to review on my Channel. Even if just for a week. They agreed when they were available they would look into it. Soon I saw others reviewing it on YouTube and I asked why couldn't I get one. Finally after much begging, I got one sent to me for 30 days. It was clearly already used but still not calibrated. I had to fix that in one of my videos.
Through all this I asked if there was any way they could supply my channel with a cartridge or two of filament since I was using my own printer and money to buy filament to promote their product. Again they said they would look into it.
During the release of my first Jr. review videos, they offered me this deal: If I bought a Jr. with my money on Amazon AND left a positive review, which they said was worth more because of my standing as an expert with the Da Vinci products, then they would give me 12 cartridges of filament in exchange at a later unspecified date.
So, I thought, I had to invest $350 for a printer I wasn't sure I wanted AND give a review that they felt was positive before I would see anything in return. Plus it felt like I was just selling my opinion which I refuse to do. I will always give my honest opinion or I won't review anything. At this same point in time Inventables.com was talking to me about doing an honest review on the X-Carve and they would give me a $1200 CNC to keep for the review. At that point I knew I was not getting a fair trade for my video promotion from XYZprinting.
Even though 12 cartridges were about equal in value to the Da Vinci Jr., I wasn't sure I wanted another cartridge only printer with potential errors and blocked software. And there were limited filament choices for it. It just didn't fit what I wanted to invest $350 in. Especially since I saw I could get Inland filament from Microcenter for $14.95 at 1000 grams instead of the 600 in the Da Vinci cartridges for $28. I also wanted to test Wood Filament and Metal Infused and glow in the dark filament. None of these were offered.
I again discussed all this with XYZ sales and how they need to open things up and decided to turn down the offer for the review/printer/plastic. I was also told that they would have wood filament but not until the end of 2015. This was around May 2015 so it seemed like a long time to wait.
Then we had another cartridge error on my sons machine. I went directly to XYZ sales on this one and again no help. We began to look at re-flashing my sons printer. In the process I learned about how to do it. It didn't seem tough at all. So I found a Da Vinci 1.0A, with the improved extruder, on EBAY that had an X-Axis problem for $225. I thought I could fix it but, if not, I had a parts machine and a new extruder. The fix was easy. A broken wire. I did a video on it. I ran it stock and still could not get the PLA cartridge to print. I was really frustrated now.
XYZprinting asked if I would hand out flyers at my Detroit MakerFaire booth which they found out I was going to be at. I agreed if I could take the Jr. along which meant I would have it 60 days instead of the 30 originally agree on. A week before the MakerFaire, I had a large 3D print order to complete for a good friend of mine. He was paying me to do it to help him and to help support my channel. That's when the Cartridge error hit my machine. I had no way to fix it and no way to get a replacement cartridge fast. So I decided my only choice was to re-flash the 1.0A and use some filament my friend had. It worked perfectly. Plus the print quality was better. I realized I had reached my limit with XYZprinting products.
I posted my re-flash video the day before MakerFaire and by the end of MakerFaire I had received a terse email from XYZ saying I violated the Exclusivity Deal (which I never agreed to) and would have to send back the Jr. immediately. They also would stop promoting my channel on Facebook immediately and they did. A few subscribers also noticed and contacted me about it asking what happened. I didn't have an answer.
So Duplicat, I agree. I feel that XYZprinting should have done more to help out my channel as I created a lot of helpful videos for them and their customers. I also helped sell a lot of printers. Apparently the issues I experienced and told them others experienced are affecting the bottom line or we would not see an open source filament Pro printer from XYZ.
One thing I want to make clear is one of the XYZ resellers in Poland; AEMCA (https://aemca.pl) has been a great supporter of my channel through Patreon from the beginning. They have done more for my Channel than anything XYZprinting has. If you are looking for a Pro consider buying from them.
Bottom line is, it's my supporters here at my Patreon who help keep this channel going, and for that I am ever so grateful.
My audience is who I do this for. I learned a lot from other people in my life and this is just one way I'm giving back. I hope I didn't bore you with that story but its been on my mind for a while and it was time to let somebody know.
Chuck Hellebuyck