Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

 

by Keith Phipps

So help us out: Scott and I are planning to do a special bonus episode looking back at the 2010s, and we’re toying with a couple of different approaches. In one, we’d bring a list of our favorite films of the decade and count them down and discuss them. (Mine’s been public for a while, but we’d still get a pretty good conversation out of this format, I’m guessing.) Scott has proposed mixing it up with a best directors of the decade approach. 

I think they both have their advantages. Everyone does lists, but that’s because we like lists. There’s something satisfying about shaping order out of chaos and there’s a kind of art to curating and crafting a list. It’s a fool’s game to try for a list that’s objectively the best film of a decade (or of a year, or a genre). The trick is to use the list to tell a story. You begin with the odd and the unexpected then build to the titles that loom largest over the subject.

I like Scott’s idea too, however. In making my list, I limited myself to one film per director. This presented some conundrums: Which Paul Thomas Anderson movie? Which Jarmusch? Which Reichardt? Etc. It would be nice to talk about which directors had great decades, ten years that they helped define or used to redefine themselves. (And you know who didn’t slow down or rest on his laurels? Scorsese. Scott and I discovered that when talking about The Irishman.) 

At the same time, this works against late arrivers and slow workers. Upstream Color feels like one of the decade’s signature movies, but it’s all Shane Carruth did as a director. Paul Schrader, out of nowhere, turned in one of the best movies of his career.

Do you have a preference? Let us know. (And maybe we’ll end up dong both, who knows?)

In the meanwhile, get ready for a pair of World War I movies starting with Peter Weir’s great Gallipoli and carrying over with next week’s discussion of Sam Mendes’ 1917, a Best Picture nominee (and current favorite to win).

Also, some stuff to read:

• At Vulture, Bilge Ebiri offered a behind-the-scenes look at Terrence Malick’s A Hidden Life (great movie, see it if you can).

• For Fangoria, Keith Phipps took a late look at Jim Jarmusch’s despairingly funny The Dead Don’t Die.

• At The New York Times, Jason Bailey talked to David Letterman about his divisive stint hosting the Oscars.

• Want more Bong Joon-Ho? Sandi Tan has you covered at Vanity Fair.

Files

Comments

Steve Schaeffer

I would love for you to do both approaches because I feel they are very different discussions. However, if you were inspired by last weekend's release of "The [Homophobic, Racist] Gentlemen" so pointed a gun at my head and made me choose...I'd pick the director approach because I don't think anyone has had that specific conversation in regards to the 2010s. But I'd rather hear both!

Justin Kim

If I had to choose, I'd pick the more traditional individual films list. Especially since after seeing Keith's list, I've been curious to see how Scott's would compare. The best directors idea sounds interesting too, though! As the Old El Paso taco commerical would say... "Why not both?"

Alberto Manuel Lamoso

My preference is both, but if I have to chose one, I'd go with the list of directors

Tom Speaker

Do a 2010s list please! I can't believe Scott has not yet released one. It is your constitutional duty.

Brendan Steele

I'd like to hear the "best films of the decade" discussion. As Keith mentioned, focusing on directors might shut out people who only had one great film or who were late arrivals.

Jamie Vann Struth

Films. And Keith, it's not about creating an objective list of the best films. That's impossible. It's a subjective list, based on YOUR preference. None of us need to care what you think, but we do, so I'd rather you just tell us what movies you think are the best, rather than playing story-telling games. Hence my objection (on your Twitter timeline) about excluding amazing 2nd films by a director. The Master and Phantom Thread are both amazing. The Wolf of Wall Street and The Irishman are both amazing. Moonlight and If Beale Street Could Talk are both amazing. I don't know why this is hard.