Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi guys!  Here is the next part of our Prisoner of Azkaban series! :D  We cover 2 chapters instead of the usual 3... but somehow it is still nearly 5 hours! XD

I think this is largely down to how good Snape's Grudge is, but if I do start waffling, I am sorry!! I also try to limit my snide comments about Quidditch, I think I went too far last episode.

Either way, I hope you enjoy!  Great Book Club again with many great discussion points!Love you, guys! Hope your weekend is going well! :)

Files

(No title)

Comments

Ian Graham

I personally much prefer the 2 chapters per video format if it means you can produce these videos more often. And of course if it’s easier for you.

Hawwah

I personally thought your quidditch rant was spot on :) I prefer 2 chapters per video as well. Re: Neville. I think the main issue isn't that he wrote the passwords down, but that he didn't inform anyone when the list went missing. That was irresponsible. Re: Professor Snape. It made my day when you said you agreed with Snape :) Of course I agree completely (surely that doesn't surprise anyone). That's Severus Snape for you. He isn't nice. He doesn't sugarcoat things. He speaks harsh truths and doesn't care if people don't want to hear them. But he always has Harry's best interests at heart. And he deeply cares about students' safety (primarily Harry's, but not just his). It's his priority number 1, which is something which can't always be said about the rest of the professors. (*cough* McGonagall *cough* Hagrid *cough* spoilers) Is Trelawney a charlatan? I'm sure we will discuss it exhaustively in the next Book Club (just look at the title of chapter 16!). Re: Prejudice against Slytherin. That's something I've wanted to write about for some time now but I was unsure where to start (also because I was afraid I might accidentally spoil something). For now I'll just say that I agree with everything you've said on this. The Slytherins have a very unfortunate position at Hogwarts and they're treated unfairly (I'm looking at you, Dumbledore). In my opinion this plays a huge role in why so many Slytherins turn out the way they do. "What Lee Jordan said was messed up" - absolutely. It's actually very similar to what Draco Malfoy says about muggleborns. And this is something that bothers me a lot - there appears to be a double standard when it comes to the "good guys" and the "bad guys". When the Slytherins have better brooms than everyone else, they're cheaters. When Harry has a better broom than everyone else, it's amazing and we're supposed to cheer for him. When Draco discriminates against a group of people, it's wrong, when Lee does the same, no one bats an eye. There will be more examples of this in the later books and we will probably have a lot of discussion about it in the future.

Emiel Callaars

First comment on here i think. I think that McGonagall's punishment is more about her being at her limit with Neville. He is forgetfull which causes problems in lessons and i think she has turned a blind eye a lot of times. It is probably her tipping point now. It is a bit overreacting but a lot of people who reach their tipping point overreact. And to keep her reputation for being strict she might not want to go back on her own decision.

Katik

To be fair he did say it to Sir Cadogan in the previous chapter! Harry and Ron heard it too. None of them thought it was a problem so it's not all on Neville. Obviously Sir Cadogan was rubbish security all along but it was kind of his responsibility.

Giorgia M

Oh, don’t worry about my name!!! People usually get it wrong because it’s spelled differently than a normal “Georgia” I just felt bad because you say it ever video and I thought I should at least give you a hand!! If I’m being honest all these teachers are being irresponsible and unprofessional so it starts to become a matter of what’s average professionalism in a magic world and what’s over the top unprofessionalism. You kind of have to suspend your disbelief a little. Also, I really agreed with you about quidditch in previous chapters, I just forget to say it and then don’t want to use the next chapter comments on it. I have a problem with the no standardised equipment across teams or whatever. I don’t think it means everything in terms of skill but it does have a big impact. I think it’s interesting that it became more of an issue of discussion when it was Harry that had the privilege rather than Slytherin or even from the first book. I mean from the start everyone had different brooms. It is a class issue and it gives me a little peak in Rowling’s own mind on paying your way into sports and class issues in general. However, I don’t know how much of this is relevant to sports in real life. Does everyone have the same uniforms, the same shoes, the same footballs (or relevant equipment), is real life completely standardised? Because some athletes have skills that shines through regardless but what about personal training, care plans and shoes etc? That feels like something that only some players on a team may have access to because of their upbringing, especially at a non-professional level.

S1lm4r1l

SNUPIN The list of punishments McGonagall has available to her that aren't humiliating for Neville is a pretty short one. One could argue that removing him from the Hogsmeade list is humiliating as its only he and Harry that can't go now. If this were any other student, I'd expect the punishment to be similar, its not like the staff purposefully pick on Neville. I'd expect there to be reasonable traffic going into and out of the Common room. It's not like Neville is completely stuffed without the password. The movies even hint at this, Ron suggests that the commotion around the portrait is because "Neville's forgotten the password again." Lets not forget where that map comes from and who wrote it, don't you think there are other characters in the castle who have an even greater obligation to tell someone about those secret passages than Harry does? The injustice to Neville does rankle, and even more once you have the full story. I think the expectation that Harry should be a good little boy and never do anything risky and stay locked in Gryffindor Tower, which by the way has already proven vulnerable is ridiculous. It would not surprise me if Harry thought he was just as much at risk in the invisibility cloak walking around with Ron as he was in the Tower. Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff's support for Gryffindor is explained in-universe. Slytherin have won the House cup (and presumably the Quidditch Cup) for years and years in a row. They are desperate to see someone, anyone beat them. I completely agree with your views on Quidditch and the inequity between brooms. Much of the problem lies in the construction of the game itself. It would arguably have been better and simpler to have 7 players a side with only the Quaffle and they simply score points that way. I'm simply playing Devil's advocate. You'll be pleased to know that Quidditch becomes a lot more interesting and difficult for Gryffindor in later books. And you'll definitely appreciate the journey as a Rocky fan. And it's so difficult to not spoil anything because your criticisms and tactical thinking about Quidditch are addressed in later books. (Might edit this)

itsanursething

So excited to watch this when I get home from work! But first, I must wish Messers Gred and Forge Weasley a very Happy Birthday!!!

Hawwah

Sir Cadogan was being unreasonable, no doubt about that. But that's exactly why Neville should have gone to McGonagall. Ron and Harry aren't Neville's baby-sitters. The list of passwords was Neville's responsibility, not theirs.

Dara Jeeling

I am also for two chapters! I usually do not have 5 hours at a time (hardly ever) so I appreciate shorter ones (like not to short) Have a lovely sunday! And let me know about the parcel, please!

Rebecca May

Snupin. 😊 For what it's worth, I really, sincerely appreciate how fair-minded you are in assessing the characters in these books - not just Severus Snape, but every single one of them. It's actually one of my very favourite things about watching these videos. ❤ (For the record, I think the two chapter thing is a great idea!) I loved what you said about Snape and Lupin possibly being friends in another life... I completely agree. Honestly it's sad. At the very least, I think that of all the Marauders, Lupin is by far the most patient and understanding with Snape, and Snape in turn seems to tolerate and act fairly civilly towards him, most of the time. I also found what you said about Hermione's reasons for not apologising to Ron really moving, I'd never thought about it that way before. As far as Harry, Crookshanks and the Grim are concerned, I feel like that whole thing was just Harry trying to convince himself he was being an idiot for worrying about the Grim. Finally, I believe that McGonagall would have written to Neville's grandmother to inform her of what had transpired... It's been established previously that when students seriously transgress, the Professors write home to their families.

Judith

Okay, I listened to your rant about McGonagall and the pubishment for Neville now. And for the most part, I agree with you. Not telling him the passwort is super unreasonable. Plus, i doesnt make any sense! He has been punished enough to ensure that he will never write them down ever again! And the fat lady isnt stupid, so she wont tell him the passwords in advance. So whats the point?! I disagree with you on the Hogsmeade thing though. Yes its part of a new kind of freedom for the students. But its also a privilege. And its usually the case, that you loose your privileges as a punishment. Magic school or not. So that kind of punishment might be hard and you can argue about how effective it really is, but its the normal thing to happen. Kind of. Maybe not for the whole year, but at least for a while. Sorry if that sounds heartless!

Hawwah

I finally got to part where you read my comment. First of all, I absolutely understand why you skipped parts of my comment. It was too long, I was really pushing it this time. I will make sure I won't do it next time. The part you skipped was just me listing several examples of Neville's irresponsible behavior in the books so far. Looking back, it was probably not neccessary. On the other hand, I really do think that readers tend to overlook/downplay Neville's flaws. And I feel it's unfair to the teachers, who have to deal with Neville's behavior. The fact is that Neville frequently endangers himself and/or others with his behavior. I'm not saying he does it on purpose. Unfortunately, that doesn't change the fact that he's a nightmare material for the teachers who are responsible for everyone's safety. I don't have a big issue with Neville writing the passwords down. I don't blame him for losing the list either. But I have a real issue with him not informing McGonagall about this huge security breach. That was just morally wrong in my opinion. Because Neville *knew* the passwords were missing. It's explicitly said in chapter 13. Neville realized the passwords were gone the day Harry got his Firebolt back, which was Thursday. The match and Black's attack happened on Saturday. That means that Neville had 3 days to inform McGonagall. He did nothing. I think we was afraid McGonagall would scold him - which, to be fair, she probably would. However, is not being scolded worth risking everyone's safety? Last time we talked about Hermione and how she put Harry's safety first, even when she knew the boys would be angry at her. Well, I see a parallel with her choice and Neville's. Hermione decided that Harry's safety was more important than being yelled at. Neville made the opposite choice. I think it was morally wrong. Neville's fans will probably disagree with me. That's ok - everyone is entitled to their opinion. But let's not pretend he was punished for having a bad memory of for the passwords being stolen from him. He was punished for failing to inform McGonagall about this huge security breach.

Will

Snupin, I can tell you, is absolutely a ship that exists. I think that you should do chapters 16 and 17 in one video and then 18, 19 and maybe 20 in one. Just based on what the chapters are about.

Ziro the Hutt

Big Neville and McGonagal fan, and I am going to side with her on Neville's punishment. Are they harsh? Yes. Will it teach him to remember his passwords going forward, and why they are a rule to gain access to the Common Rooms? Also, yes. As you say Veggie, though we know Sirius is a good egg, had he not been, Ron or one of the other kids may have been put in serious jeopardy or been killed. Draconian as these measures against Neville are, and as you say humiliating having to wait outside the frame of the Fat Lady on someone opening the painting, he has to learn about responsibility. At 13 you are no longer a young child, you are starting adolescence and Neville has to start growing up. It is faster for some than for others admittedly, but you learn more about yourself by your errors, than you do your victories - and this too is 'character building'. His Grandmother (who is a legend btw, wait till you meet her!) would approve of McGonagal's punishment. I agree with you about why these measures about the troll's and the wall cracks, not being looked at before as a possibly security issue, and that blame lies with Dumbledore. He shows complacency here thinking the dementors outside the ground and his presence in the castle, would keep wannabe intruders from entering. Hagrid without a wand would be enough to protect Harry. Dumbledore is right when he says he would trust Hagrid with his own life. I agree Harry is being reckless by still wanting to go to Hogsmeade during this time, when finally, lots of protection is being implemented for him and around the school. He has confidence in himself and his abilities - rightly so - however he would be putting himself and his friends at serious risk by going there just now if Black truly wanted him dead. Harry is very much James's son at times. On GoT, has George Martin finished a book on the series, since he stopped having anything to do with the tv show? Doubt it. That series will never get done. Trelawney IS an old fraud when it comes to her 'predictions'. However when she doesn't know it, she does make true predictions. More to come on this in Phoenix. Yes, as a Gryffindor myself (supposedly!) I was happy for everyone in that House that they won the Cup, they haven't won it since Charlie's time 8 years back or so. Anyway you won't have to bother about Quidditch for the next book at least Veggie, with the Tri-Wizard Tournament, so it will give you a break. Also things do change in books 5 and 6 for Quidditch, and obviously they don't play it in book 7 on the run looking for Horcruxes. The sporting incident I think you are thinking of, was in the World Cup knockouts, maybe 2014(?). Luis Suarez for Uruguay deliberately handled the ball which was going in the goal. He got sent off, a penalty was awarded to Ghana, and the player missed, to which Suarez became a national hero. Uruguay subsequently qualified as Ghana couldn't score with the remaining time. (God I love Suarez, just such a bastard!) On "An Inspector Calls", the best one is with Alastair Sim. Check that one out Veggie.

ambiture

SNUPINNNNN that is all

John Phillips

I will say that while the Gryffindors are not underdogs, neither are the Slytherins. They have lost to Gryffindor so far in these books, but they always seem to beat Hufflepuff and Ravenclaw so it makes sense that they would be rooting for Gryffindor to win. Just to be clear, I don't think all Slytherins are bad and Harry does have a bias against Slytherin, however Gryffindor hadn't won the Quidditch Cup for years prior to this and I think they deserve a victory.

Svetlana Grabar

As a Slytherin, I don't mind that the other houses were rooting against Slytherin. Because of the core trait of ambition, the book portrays Slytherins as "doing anything to win", aka doing things that are unsportsmanlike but technically within the rules. It makes sense to me that Hufflepuffs in particular, who value fairness, would not like this and would rather Gryffindor win. I completely agree about Quidditch being pay-to-win. It's important to Harry though. He needs something that makes him special that isn't related to his parents dying. As an adult I can see that this game isn't great, but when I read this as a kid, I was excited for Harry as he got this awesome gift and was able to feel special.

Garry (Not Jerry)

For what it’s worth, when I played badminton at school, some people did buy really expensive professional rackets and it made a big difference to their ability, whereas the school rackets were old, made of wood and the strings were all loose and flimsy 🤣

Florian

So when it comes to Snape calling himself Master of this school, it is a reference to his offical title as potions master. Its not just, that he is extremly brilliant with potions, I think it is an offical title, so he is the potions master of Hogwarts.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Snupin. In quidditch there is also the possible tactic of two teams agreeing NOT to catch the snitch on purpose so that they can just rack up loads of points

S1lm4r1l

There's plenty of other students that are difficult and endanger their fellow students though. The Golden Trio for one. Hermione literally sets Snape on fire. Malfoy frequently bullies other students and we know that magic occasionally gets performed in the corridors. As for Neville not informing McGonagall about the list, it is a security breach, but Neville doesn't know whether he lost them, or whether they were taken. He has no way of knowing who has it, or where it ended up. He was probably embarrassed and didn't want to admit to failing at something yet again. All very teenage boy-ish. There are a number of other characters who also don't open their mouths about possible 'massive security breaches' who are older and perhaps cleverer than Neville. The castle's security as a whole is pretty lax up until this point. And even without Neville's list, Black is a resourceful, clever and powerful wizard, he'd have found a way to get what he was after anyway.

Diego Zenhäusern

Snupin I definitely prefer 2 chapters per video. Firstly, I think this vidoe was the perfect example to show that doing 3 chapters would-more often than not-just not be supportable in the future. Secondly, I like the idea of getting them a little more regular (not that I'm blaming you, I knwo how life can get in the way and they obviously take a lot of time for you to sit down and produce them!) I also fully agree with your qualms about the fairness of Quidditch and the treatment of Slytherins. Especially the latter one is something that didn't bother me when I first read tham as a child but has on every re-read ever since.

Diego Zenhäusern

Though I'd assume that that would be manipulation of the game and therefore forbidden, so you would have to watch out not to make it too obvious😅 But it would be difficult to proof either way🤔

Shiby23

I was just snupin around while i was hunting in a game (sorry vegan) :P was a very enjoyable 3:25 so far :) Next time i listen i'm'a have to break out a post it note so i can rebuttal or comment on your comments. Garlic + Buffy <3 as far as what you were saying about quidich and sports. You always see the confrontation, you don't always see the instigation.

Janie

Snupin! :) For some reason I thought with only 2 chapters the video would be shorter. Silly me :) Yes, the fairness of Quidditch is slightly questionable, but being a Gryffindor, I really can't complain much. But I do love your ranting about it so please don't stop doing it. Hagrid would definitely be enough to protect Harry. Dumbledore trusts him with his life, after all. And it's not the only time Hagrid acts like Harry's "bodyguard" either. Funny, I've always imagined McGonagall as Maggie Smith. She was a perfect choice for the character. For me, the main trio looks completely different and for example Dumbledore looks nothing like either of the two actors.

Ashley Faith Reacts

Ok, maybe these are a bit too long :-D I still want the FULL rxns, but if you have time, maybe editing it down to 90 mins also would be great

Garry (Not Jerry)

Honestly Veggie you could take this further and try 1 chapter per video! And.. maybe just be a tad stricter about the "3-4 sentences" rule. 😆 That way you might be able to make it weekly (or fortnightly)

Jake M

The way it's described in the book is as "all future Hogsmeade visits" which makes it seem beyond a year, like Umbridge's "lifetime bans" in OotP. The teachers really do go all-in with their punishments, don't they?

Jake M

Just a tip if you haven't already, try watching the video on 1.5x speed if you're pushed for time. Everything is still understandable as Veggie speaks so clearly. 😅

Jake M

The problem there is he might get just as long comments, but now for every single chapter not every two or three. Turns out, fans all have a lot to say XD.

Judith

Yeah, they do. The problem is that they are not consistent. If they were, Harry, Ron and Hermione would never be allowed to go anywhere. They would probably have been kicked out! So this kind of punishment is "normal", just not to that extent...

Garry (Not Jerry)

Hey Jake. Yes, Hence - stricter rules on the comment length (heck if they’re too long just skip ‘em) Also part of the reason he gets so many comments is the amount of time between episodes. I think if it was weekly l, we might not get 100+ comments per episode. Just a thought.

Garry (Not Jerry)

I just listen to it as a podcast tbh so the length is fine for me. You don’t have to watch it all at once and there’s plenty of time between episodes

Gothic Llama

I agree! I think it would be good to be more strict about the length of the book club comments, or maybe disable the comments after about a week so there are not like a hundred of them

Gothic Llama

Hi Veggie! There is one thing about Quidditch I just realised has not been even mentioned in the books so far - they should have back ups! I mean there has been soo much said about players being injured and these past two chapters showed the whole team being very worried about Harry's safety before the final game. Well, if it's so dangerous, why Hogwart's quidditch teams don't have back up players or Madamme Pompfrey being present at every match? (I don't have much experience with sports, but when I volunteered at a couple of showjumping competitions, there were always paramedics present)

Kate Bogd

Snupin! I just want to say thank you Veggie for sticking with the book club and giving us so much content each time! Each time it's so fun to watch you read my comment and respond to it, feels like we really have a discussion :D Can't wait for the end of this book!

McStick

Hey veggie my dude! Don’t stop with the book review love them :)

Michelle Linardis

Snuuuupin! Not a bad ship! In all honesty, they would have made great friends if the past didn't treat them both with such unkindness. Just adding on since I forgot what else you asked me - I definitely think you are very fair to Snape and I applaud you for seeing him with a mature and logical lens, along with other members of staff. So I really do thank you for that!

Kunzite Blossom

For the firebolt, I can understand you thinking Harry is getting an advantage since hes the ONLY one with it in school. The thing is most parents, even if rich probably wouldn't think to buy a school age kid such an expensive broom, even Draco doesn't get one and his dad could probably afford a bunch. It was no different then McGonagall getting Harry a Nimbus 2000 when it came out, which was the best broom at that time OR when Draco's dad did buy the entire Slytherin team the Nimbus 2001 to get Draco on the team, which was better then the Nimbus 2000. I don't really think the school can just be like "oh your broom is too good, you can't use it" That wouldn't be fair. I don't know much about sports so maybe I'm wrong. However I think you are forgetting this isn't just a school sport only. There are professional teams. They are probably all buy a firebolt now. Meaning it would be an even playing field. Even if its just the seekers that get it, and maybe not the entire team. So just cause you own one, doesn't mean it's a guaranteed win. It still all comes down to skill. For Draco, Harry is naturally a better flyer so even without a firebolt it's possible he could have out flown Draco and caught the snitch with a nimbus 2000, we've seen it in Chamber of Secrets. With Cho....she had a comet two sixty, which was what came out before the latest (comet two ninety) and came out before the nimbus 2000/2001. Most likely she probably didn't fair well against either nimbus given the 260 is not that fast which is why the team was saying Ravenclaw stood no chance against Harry having a firebolt now. I'm not saying it's fair because it isn't. But in order for it to be fair everyone on a school level would have to be using the same broom and the school brooms aren't fast as I believe they are for teaching 1st years. I doubt teaching on a fast broom would go over well. Which in my opinion, they COULD use them but that would make the game boring to see them fly slowly I don't think there would be much excitement. It would mean them having to go out and buy 14 new brooms. Not really sure how the school makes money to pay professors, let alone buy 14 new brooms. Even in my high school, if teams wanted better equipment they had to fundraise. Now about Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff rooting for Gryffindor, I don't think EVERY student is, im sure plenty have friends in Slytherin but its probably a majority rooting for Gryffindor. I feel its like sports. If you're favorite team isn't playing, you're just gonna root for one of the two teams playing. It's the same here. Their house isn't playing but that doesn't mean they just won't watch. They will still go, they will root for one of them. It just happens to be they root for Gryffindor over Slytherin as Slytherin won the house cup so many times, meaning they probably won the quidditch cup too. They would be happy to see someone other then Slytherin win. One last thing about the password issue. At the time of the punishment The Fat Lady wasn't back yet. So him not being allowed to know the password is harsh. Now that she IS back, she doesn't change it that much. So i'm sure he will eventually learn the password, which makes me wonder....if he does manage to learn it, would she have to let him in?

Kunzite Blossom

The chapters only get longer, and the more differences from the book to movie the more people have to say. But definitely people keeping it shorter would be great. The mini essay's can be hard to stay focused it seems. I do agree the main issue is the amount of comments, not the length of each. The long comments weren't bad at the start of book club as it wasn't too many comments. I do think leaving it open to comment for such a long time just keeps adding comments. Maybe closing the discussion after a few days would help. I believe he did that for the first book. Which hey, if he did 1 chapter a video would probably really help getting them out quicker. Also keep the comments more focused. And shorter videos then 5 hours.

itsanursething

SNUPIN!!! Pretty sure you can find PLENTY of fanfictions with this ship out there on the interwebs. haha! Thank you, thank you, thank you for standing up for Neville! He's one of my favorite characters and he tries SO hard. I hate how much people keep putting him down. He's not making all these mistakes on purpose and he does feel bad about all of them. I can't wait for you to see how much he grows over the rest of the series :) I think the reason Hufflepuff and Ravenclaw are cheering for Gryffindor to win is because (to my knowledge) Slytherin has won the Quidditch Cup EVERY YEAR for the last 7 years. I think they just don't want them to win anymore. I don't think it's meant to be: Slytherin bad! As for them all being big, I think it's meant to imply that the Slytherin team was trying to go for an intimidation factor rather than skill. I mean, they were very physical during the game...

Judith

I listened to your reaction again and I just had a thought. Your annoyance on the Firebolt is kind of true, but on the other hand, Draco bought his way onto the team! His father gave everyone to newest broom available at the time! So why not Harry? I agree, that they should all use the same kind of broom to make it fair, but since that isnt the case, I dont see is being unfair for Harry to have the best possible broom!

Hilde

A lot to agree with here, just wanna point out that the parts about Gran and Trelawny could be considered spoilers for Veggie :)

Hilde

It is (or perhaps was?) the same at least with horse riding as well, to an extent even on lower levels. To do well in competitions you’re largely dependent on a good horse/pony, which costs a lot of money. Riders who don’t come from wealthy families depend on sponsors and such. It’s not fair or cool, but in some sports money definitely talks 🤷🏼‍♀️

Lisette C.

Hey Veggie ^^ Well you said that you would pay good money to see a full adaptation of the books 😅 And today is the day HBO Max and Discovery+ announced their 10 commitment to make a Harry Potter series 😉❤️ One season per book...! Finally!!!!

Frederique Gillespie

Thank you!!! For days now, I've been thinking to myself "have I forgotten the similar outrage over the Number 2001?" Draco literally bought them for the whole team during Chamber. If having a better broom was that much of an advantage, then Slytherin should have dominated ever since they got them.

Regina

Just a little addition to the Directors debate about Hermione being their favourite character. I‘m personally of the opinion that they did the best they could with the script they got and I feel like it‘s more the script writer‘s „fault“ (in lack of a better word) that Hermione is so much different.