Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1bDoDb7G99jOFqbXT1fK7WvDxNBOLv9-Q/view?usp=share_link

####### EPISODE SPOILER REVIEW BELOW! APPARENTLY SOME OF YOU ARE WATCHING FOR THE FIRST TIME ALONG SIDE ME, SO PLEASE DON'T READ BEYOND THIS POINT UNTIL YOU HAVE SEEN THE EPISODE YOURSELF! ######

------

Loved it!! I was so confused halfway in, but really enjoyed the ending.  Really sad but sweet solid side-quest!  Spike's 'twist' sure will make for interesting watching, here on out!

... Ben did have a belt.

Love you, guys! Hope you had a great weekend and have an awesome week!

As always, if you click the video just after this post, you may need to download it first.  This should be fixed in a couple of hours!

Files

Buffy Redirect - Check out the Link in the Patreon Post!

Comments

Garry (Not Jerry)

Yes! I love Buffy Sundays! (For what it’s worth I also like Buffy Mondays, Tuesdays Wednesdays, Thursdays and Fridays. Buffy Saturdays I could take or leave. …just kidding I love them too 😆

Giorgia M

Oh I’m so excited!!! I love this one 🖤 perfect mix of side quest and main story.

Shiby23

You gotta quit teasing me with watching the movie :P I'm afraid you won't enjoy it because you've watched too much of the series itself now. Movie 92, TV show 97. Still can't wait for the movie bro <3

The Ginger Historian

Poor janitor... he didn't turn up late, he just doesn't have Buffy's speed and reflexes. I do love this episode - it's so well constructed, and I appreciate how constantly aware you were of the floppy disk's presence just underneath Willow and Giles. You really felt the frustration we all felt (sorry about that, it's rough). However, I must disagree with Angel's ableist "take a stand" and "roll with the punches" jokes being clever. More like the low-hanging fruit of the school bully. One last thing, I promise - I highly recommend watching the scene with Buffy and Angel as James and Grace again if you haven't already because the emotional parallels between them are so poignant. But I fully understand being more concerned with who has the gun on your first watch.

SapientButterfly

I had actually forgotten how much I love this episode. Such a clever idea for a twist at the end there. So so good, one of this seasons best for sure.

The Ginger Historian

Also a great Cordelia moment - As abrasive as her "Over-identify much?" line is, I really enjoy it. It's just further evidence that Cordelia is a keen observer of how people are feeling. Unfortunately, being able to read the room does not always coexist with a desire to alter one's behavior in any way.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Snupin. oh wait wrong comment... yes this is very very good episode, season two has some real bangers. A great twist. I feel bad for the janitor though, lest we forget he SHOT a teacher! The locker monster always confused me, but I guess it was just part of a series of random paranormal events that were going on alongside the re-enactments. So sad for Giles thinking that the ghost was Jenny only to be actually disappointed that it wasn't. It didn't really occur to me how close they were to the Floppy Disk the whole time, that's so cool that you noticed and it was really funny watching you squirm 😆 "Willow, what have you become?" - I just want you to remember you said this. That's all.

Frederique Gillespie

To me, this is the least side-quest-ish episodes of the side quest episodes since it is entirely about what Buffy "did" to Angel insofar as Angel "died" because of their love. The Grace/James situation is such a copy of the Buffy/Angel situation... right down to Grace/Angel telling James/Buffy "I loved you with my dying breath." Yes, the acting in this episode is superb. Yes, the fact that they can't get their hands on that floppy disk is maddening. In RL, I remember the weeks and weeks of suspense of wondering if they ever would find the darn thing. Yes, Cordy is, as always, MVP for spotting right away that Buffy is transfering unto James her own feelings of not being worthy of forgiveness for destroying the one he/she loves. But, this was all about Angel having loved Buffy till the very second Angelus took over. You might even say that, inasmuch as Angelus is capable of love (which is doubtful, but...) he also loves Buffy in his own twisted, sadistic way. He certainly obsesses about her. He certainly can't seem to try and kill her. Mind you, he really is a coward. Sad as it was, I also chuckled at Giles's "I encourage you to question authority, instead in this case where I am clearly right and you are clearly wrong." Jenny may not physically appear (or even appear at all) in this episode, but she looms large over Giles. It is terrible, but also glorious in its own way. His grief is almost tangible. 9/10

RavenLord

I agree, Vampires in this world can love, even love deeply, though it's often an obsessive, destructive love. Even Angel demonstrated that *before* he lost his soul; he couldn't keep himself away from Buffy, and losing his soul didn't remove that feeling, merely altered into into something far more sinister. I can't say more about how Vampires love, though, because that would involved details and hints that could easily become spoilers for Veggie.

RavenLord

They were wasps. :) Both Angel and Xander said "wasps." Yes, I agree with others, if you do decide to watch it over, focus on the dialogue between Angel and Buffy; it's a parallel to their situation. I feel horrible for the janitor, and I do wish that had been wrapped up/resolved at the end with him being acquitted because of lack of evidence. Though I imagine if he remembered the scene, he may have confessed. :( I feel horrible for the woman whom he shot, too. I love having big, bad Spike back! My favorite recurring villain in the entire series. "Willow, what have you become." heheheheheheh "Spike's going to snap, guys." "If he does snap, what happens?" :p I love your commentary.

Jake M

To be fair to Ben, our brains remember very odd things. The first time I met two of my closest friends was in a creative writing class ten years ago; don't recall anything about it, except that the guy next to us wrote about a World of Warcraft panda race and was trying to explain them to a relatively technophobic teacher. My friends think I'm mental. Noticed in this one James Masters was credited "as Spike"! Should've said "as two fingers guy" though. Hope it's not too spoilery to say I'm calling it now, this is not the last time you'll say "What have you become?" XD

Jake M

Well if he does in the next episode clearly he's going to lose, since it's Go Fish not Snap... 😏😆

Jake M

This has probably been said before, but the movie isn't really considered canon, and there is a flashback episode later on that answers some of the questions you ask. Not to say you shouldn't react to the movie; just don't expect it to answer all your questions about Buffy's past.

RavenLord

Clever! I didn't make the connection between the two card games, lol.

Ashley Evers

I honestly think this might be one of the best written episodes. It's heartbreaking to realize that every time Buffy goes on a rant about how James doesn't deserve forgiveness, it's herself she can't forgive. Even given that, it struck me at one point how unfair it was to have that attitude toward a student who I assume is under age, and therefore legally not able to consent to the relationship. And then it hit me for the first time that that is another parallel. Buffy is underage too. Angel is hundreds of years old. The relationship was just as inappropriate, and Angel was just as much at fault as Grace.

Katie

This was a great episode. I only watched Buffy when it was first on TV and I'm now watching it again with your reactions. Btw, not sure if you found out what else that song was used in but in case you didn't here's a website that lists all the TV shows and movies it's appeared in: https://music.fandom.com/wiki/I_Only_Have_Eyes_for_You

Catalina Saturnus

This is one of my favorite 'side-quest' episodes of the whole show, because of the way it blends the major arc of the season so perfectly into the monster of the week. And the way they switch it up and have James possess Buffy...so good! That scene with the quick cuts between the couple in the past / Angel and Buffy really stands out to me. I always look forward to it when rewatching. The editor of this episode deserves all the awards!

Tim Pierce

I recognized the janitor in Deadwood, after the fact. "Oh hey it's that janitor from the Buffy ghost episode'.

Brian Miller

This is maybe my favorite episode of season 2. The first time I watched it, I audibly gasped when I realized that James/Grace was a direct parallel to Buffy/Angel. "A person doesn't just wake up and stop loving someone" - Angel did exactly that. Woke up in the middle of the night, ran outside, lost his soul. "I killed you." "It was an accident." - Buffy feels guilt and like she killed Angel, and he is telling her it wasn't her fault. "I loved you until my last breath." - Angel was truly happy. True happiness is the trigger that took his soul. He was feeling deeply in love with her until the moment his soul was gone. If you haven't, I really recommend rewatching the scene but completely forget about James and Grace. Listen to every line as Buffy and Angel (NOT Angelus) having a conversation. Angel got to come back to her for a few minutes! :) I just love that it seems like a random side quest episode until the final act... And then it hits you like a ton of bricks that it was about Buffy/Angel the entire time :)

Saiyasha

The most important part in this episode is Buffy, seeing heself, not in the role of the victim, but the role of the murderer. She more or less feels like she murdered Angel and blames herself.

Thom Purdy

I was waiting for you to get to the Snyder line: "Pathetic no-life Vegan". You didn't dissapoint! LOL

K'Banj

I love this episode but it bugs me, particularly Buffy's attitude towards James. Not to victim blame, because the woman didnt deserve to be shot, but she was a grown ass woman, and a teacher, having an affair with a minor she had power over as her student, but all Buffy sees is a guy who shot and killed his girlfriend for breaking up with him, rather than a confused child who was taken advantage of and sexually abused by an adult who then decided to end things to avoid a messy situation that could harm her career nd both of them tragically died in a murder/suicide.

Todd Bolton

Brilliant.. that last observation.

Todd Bolton

Whedon's script was changed for the movie. A comic book has been done with his original script.

Todd Bolton

Yes, but the janitor had no agency. It was not him. He was possessed. Though, they can’t really do anything to prove it. Him being held responsible for it is really the biggest tragedy of the episode, that and the teacher’s death. But they kind of ignore that. In later seasons, they probably wouldn’t. I hadn’t noticed how close they were to the disk, either.

Todd Bolton

The great John Hawkes. Also in Eastbound and Down, True Detective and Lost. Seen them all, but nothing, except Buffy and Twin Peaks beats Deadwood.

Todd Bolton

Great reaction, though you missed several moments of dialogue, it seemed. One of my favorites being Willow telling Giles she did “the joke thing”, in the classroom. But, more importantly, some of the stuff that relates James/Grace to Buffy/Angel. Even so, you made me appreciate the paranormal weirdness of the episode more and just the oddness of the plot. When Cordelia says, “Over-identify much?” she is actually the most perceptive one in the room. Interesting behind-the-scenes trivia about the episode, Whedon and David Greenwalt had been considering a spinoff, and decided, due to his acting in this, that David Boreanaz could carry a series on his own.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Well yes that’s the point, I was meaning that I felt bad for him because he had to be burdened with the feeling of guilt even though it wasn’t his fault. He does also appear to remember what happened even though he was being possessed at the time