Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

THIS PART OF THE BOOK CLUB IS NOW COMPLETE!  SEE YOU ALL NEXT TIME! :)

Here is a chance to get your comment read out in the next Book review video!

If you are reading along with the reviews, we are covering chapters "Professor Trelawney's Prediction" and "Cat, Rat and Dog"! So if you have any thoughts, opinions, comparisons or questions regarding these, please leave a comment below!

I do have to ask, try to keep them fairly short, like 4 or 5 sentences.  That way I can cover more when making the video.  Also try to keep them on subject and not referencing anything that we are yet to cover. Ideally, keep it to 1 comment each if you can (if you have more to say after commenting, you can edit it and add to it! :) ).  These are just rough guidelines rather than rules, I want to be able to fit in as many of you as possible! :)

NEW FEATURE!! - As some of you may want to make a comment, but not have it replied to by others, you can now Message me your thoughts on the chapters by DM'ing me on here.  If you do, please follow all the above rules, especially avoiding mentioning things in future chapters or books!  Oh and please start your DM message with "Book Club -"!

To anyone that does reply to comments below, please make sure you are being friendly and respectful!  A lot of tone and meaning can be lost in text, after all!  If you disagree with someone on something, keep it polite and remember the golden rule in life - Sometimes you have to just agree to disagree! :)

Thanks, guys!! :)

Files

Comments

Jacob sparks

This is my favourite book however as a teacher this chapter is really frustrating for me. Hermione exam timetable is 9am arithmancy 9am transfiguration (core subject) 1pm charms (core subject) 1pm ancient runes This means no student would be able to take the ancient runes or arithmancy exams because all students have to take the charms and transfiguration exams. We also know students like Percy must have had full timetables like this so do they all have time turners. I just wish a little more thought was put into why hermione needed one as her timetable does not make since from a school point of view.

Jake M

What sort of system does Trelawney use for the order in which people take exams? 'Most likely to see the Grim'? Feels very contrived to have Ron and then Harry as the last two people to take it, just before her trance. And yet again we have Harry making up a prediction (Buckbeak is flying away, head intact), and Trelawney is not only disappointed (how heartless of her!) but penalises him for what ultimately comes true (as you know from the movie). She should retroactively award him marks, honestly, once the news gets out. At this point, Harry and Ron are already more psychic than Trelawney...no wonder McGonagall thinks so poorly of her! XD

Josh Z

I remember reading these chapters for the first time as a kid and being speechless at the plot developments. The movie does a decent job here with a few obvious exceptions. Once again Ron and Hermione get painted as though they hate each other bickering about their argument after scabbers is found. Not to mention they give Hermione Rons best moment to this point. The backstory is just gone which is frustrating because it makes sense of so much for both Lupin and Snape. Sadly these trends get worse with future movies.

Katherine

I love how Hermione looked flattered by Ron. Stating that he didn’t know what was going on with her. Also the movies butcher the brilliance of Ron. He has always been my fav of the trio by far. Who is yours currently?

Dara Jeeling

What do you think of Crooks, Hermiones cat? I love how he sees through superficual things also... "Harry you attaced a teacher on the film" and Harry is like "killed one in my first year!" ....

Annamarie schwirian

I love learning the maurader's back story and the real history in it.i feel it actually rounds out lupin, James, Sirius, and peters personality's.

Florian

Veggie, what do you think about Sirius portrail in the book vs the movie? Also what do you think about the seemingly additional ability of an animagus to communicate with normal animals, like how Crookshanks and Sirius planned their assassination of Peter Pettigrew.

Stephanie

Hey Veggie, loving these book clubs! Just for some context from the previous chapter based on your reaction, the reason Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff are so happy Gryffindor win the quidditch cup is because Slytherin has won it about 8 years in a row, and after the previous matches Slytherin is in first place with Gryffindor in 2nd so Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff have no hope of winning it but they’re tired of Slytherin holding the cup for so long. I’ve always liked thinking it’s a true sporting rivalry and not because Slytherins are “the evil house” and Gryffindors are “the hero house”, it’s like once the other two teams are out of the race they just want to see someone new win to shake up the games. I love crookshanks in the books, I get why they didn’t want to bother with getting a well trained cat but I just love seeing the pieces come together and how involved crookshanks becomes in the next chapter too. Can’t wait for you to reach the end! This is one of my favorite adaptations despite the difference and I can’t wait to hear your opinion!

Marianne

I would LOVE to have seen a montage of the 3rd year examinations in the films! Seeing Ron laughing his head off after Harry’s cheering charm, watching the hilarity of Lupin’s obstacle course with the grindylow paddling pool and Hermione’s boggart. I know it was probably a bit too silly to be shown near the end of the film but learning about these aspects of Hogwarts are my favourite things about the series! It would also have proven to the viewers how good Harry actually is at Defence Against the Dark Arts. With him achieving top marks in his exam, it proves how capable he really is. What was your favourite examination to hear about Veggie?

Embran

Besides a bit on these chapters which I don't really have much to comment on (next one for sure) I start with a remark on one of the things you said in previous video prior the bookclub. I apologize. I have to. To sooth your distress. - Regarding Cho's broom and Ravenclaw. don't take heated coach or players comments like that to heart. It might seem as a reader cruel but in my view harmless pep-talk for the team. I mean surely during whatever team sport in real life the coach says blunt stuff like that during training or before entering the field as well? - On meeting with Sirius: honestly that quasi-mocking bit 'I thought you'd come and help your friend...ending with '...Makes everything much easier.' Followed by 'there will only will be one murder tonight' with an added grin (instead of Lupin saying it) sounds sooo evil! Much more than the moment on the ground that left such an impact on you, Veggie. I always saw that movie moment as a slightly deranged person mocking a child, nothing more. But those lines? It defines the psychopath Sirius is made out to be. Scared me as a kid more than Barty Crouch Jr. removing his cover or even Bellatrix (apart from Hermione's torture). Grabbing Harry's throat saying 'I waited too long for this...' The struggle, cat on the chest. Protagonist wants to kill both... Man, talk about cinematic potential! - I think you're the only one that is distressed over you eating and drinking during the reaction. It's hours on end after all. Because you are on camera or you're raised like that it being rude? Don't let it bother you. It's not like we can't understand your speech or stuff sprays. Have a good day! You sure brighten mine. Across last month both of my grandparents passed away so I especially need that. Expect artwork of me in the future, of course one including Cornish Pixies. First Youtuber I crave to do it for. ^^

S1lm4r1l

You're likely to get a lot of people mixing things up for this book club. I know I certainly conflate the chapters in the Shrieking Shack in my head. Ron is the only person to disobey Trelawney's instructions not to talk about their Divination exam and a few hours later gets his leg bitten and broken by Sirius. He certainly did have a 'horrible accident' didn't he? Any comparison between the Hermione and Neville's Boggarts is deeply flawed to me. In my opinion, McGonagall is simply a manifestation of Hermione's fear of failure, whereas Neville is frightened of Snape as a person. Interested to know if you think differently. Hagrid's hopelessness and sorrow goes through me like a knife every time. Very realistic. I love Sirius but my god the man is a drama queen. *There'll only be 1 murder here tonight.* Just tell them who you're trying to murder! GAH! Don't think too harshly of Ron for his Werewolf comment, people who grow up in the Wizarding World tend to be very prejudicial towards certain beings, and Werewolves are one of them. When Dumbledore wouldn't listen to Snape about his concerns, Snape set an essay hoping the students would realize and out Lupin. Very sneaky. If given more time to decide, do you think Harry have killed/hurt Sirius?

Simon audsley

Greetings from Nora Batty's wrinkled stockings. Have to say Ron called it on Hermione's Bogart and we finally get to see trelawney's power 100% accurate predictions so long as she don't know she's making 'em. Have to say that black is a lot less unhinged than in the film, so you get a few hints he's not mad, and how I'm earth on the movie version does everyone get past the willow un-decapitated especially on the way out?

Embran

Not calling out the person but keeping it hazy...It's called being cryptic. People not good in their mind tend to do that (not just deranged). Plus build's suspense and guesswork for the reader.

S1lm4r1l

Oh yeah, I totally get that. Sirius is just terrible at expressing himself.

Rebecca May

I have to say, reading the book this time around, Ron saying “Get away from me, werewolf!” and asking if Dumbledore was mad to hire Lupin… That really hit me in the feels. The way he speaks to Lupin after finding out that he’s a werewolf is so vicious and demeaning, even after knowing Lupin for a whole year. I understand that Ron has grown up in a society that’s prejudiced against werewolves, and is probably lashing out because he believes that Lupin has betrayed them, but that doesn't make it okay. It also tells us so much about what Lupin has had to deal with his whole life... It just makes me want to give Lupin a hug. 😔 Also, I have a somewhat morbid curiosity about how Harry actually planned to kill Sirius, if he could bring himself to do it. I mean, I’m pretty sure they don’t go around teaching Avada Kedavra or Sectumsempra and the like to third years…

Will

Here he finally is, my favorite character, Sirius Black the drama queen. And he said the line. “Are you going to kill me, Harry?“ Though you must have noticed how different his tone is in the book. I also watched the movies before I read the books so for me Sirius always looks like Gary Oldman and that is a big part of why I like him so much. Gary is so fun as Sirius, he really brings out the madness. My favorite thing about chapter 17 is when Lupin hugs Sirius. He was in prison for 12 years and everyone thought that he was guilty, Lupin included. But that's his best friend and seeing Sirius again must have felt amazing, especially after James's passing. Fun fact: I have a tattoo of the code that is on Sirius's mugshot.

Kunzite Blossom

Being a movie watcher first, it surprised me to know Hermione throwing the stones at the window and the back of Harry's head was a movie only thing. The book really shows no hints of Hermione using time travel at all. Maybe the movie did this to show watchers that what happens happens. You can go back in time, but you can't change anything. Thoughts on Crookshanks protecting Sirius from Harry killing him? Hermione's little sob, she must feel really bad thinking her cat is working with Sirius.

itsanursething

Oh Veggie, I swear, I could go on for HOURS about these two chapters alone! Shorties, but PACKED with good stuff! But I’ll do my best not to. I want to preface everything I’m about to say with this: Prisoner of Azkaban is probably one of my favorite Harry Potter movies. That being said, WHY DID THEY CHANGE THE PROPHECY??? There was no reason to change the wording at all! It wouldn’t cost extra, it wouldn’t be difficult to shoot, or anything like that. That was probably my biggest gripe with this movie. I’ve been waiting to comment on Trelawney until this moment, because the prophecy hadn’t been made yet. But now that it has, I feel comfortable. Trelawney IS a real Seer. She has made legitimate prophecies (like the one Harry witnessed). But I think the fact that she can do that inflates her confidence just a bit too much. I don’t think Divination should be a subject taught at Hogwarts, unless it is theory only. You can’t teach someone to make prophecies like Trelawney does. You’re either born with the ability or you’re not. I think she makes up a lot of hooey to seem more knowledgable than she is. You saw, she didn’t even believe Harry when he told her he had just witnessed her prophesizing! The scene in the Shrieking Shack I think was MUCH better done in the book. I will say, I didn’t remember it being quite so violent though. I love how calm Sirius was, almost like he was numb and just on autopilot. Made him even a bit scarier. So much was explained, and so many questions were answered. Why Lupin knew about the map (never explained in the movie!) Why Black went after Ron in the dorm. Why Crookshanks was so hell bent on Scabbers. I love love love this section of the book. The movie fell a little flat for me in this part because it kind of answered some things, but it also left a lot out. And I can’t wait for the next chapter! Even more is explained that is SO INTERESTING! Final thought: what real-world application is there for turning a teapot into a tortoise? Why would you even need to know how to do that??

itsanursething

Yes! I was SO disappointed they left out so much backstory! That's the best part!!

itsanursething

Uhm...I think that's mostly in Ch 18. We're only covering Ch 16 and 17 this time around :)

itsanursething

This is a great comment, but I think the last half should be moved over to the reaction video for the last 2 chapters. This spot is specifically for the chapters he will cover in the next video :)

itsanursething

To be fair, he hasn't had to for a dozen years. I'm sure his emotional intelligence has taken a bit of a hit hanging out with all those dementors.

itsanursething

Right?! How hard would it have been to have added the little knot trick.

itsanursething

He did learn the killing curse the next year to be fair. But yeah, what WAS he planning on doing to him?

Rebecca May

True! But I’m not sure that would have been the case was the class not, as it turns out, being taught by a literal Death Eater 😅

itsanursething

I think you're talking about Ch 18 here. Veggie's only going over Ch 16 and 17 :)

Raider Max

Cat, Rat, and Dog is one of my favorite chapters in the entire series. Ron protecting Harry on one leg, Lupin questioning the situation before lowering his wand, the reveal that he is a werewolf AND writer of the map, and the involvement of Crookshanks and so much more. I read this after watching and my mind was blown as if I didn't know what was coming. Excellent chapter.

Embran

Thanks for the advice. I changed my reply. Will put the rest in some form at the end like you suggest. ;-)

itsanursething

Very true! What if the REAL Moody had taught the class??

Logan

I love how this book shows how feared and segregated werewolf’s are in this world. Remus doesn’t even react to how badly he is treated by the trio when outed as one which shows how used to these comments he must be; ‘He wants you dead too, he’s a werewolf’ -hermionie ‘Get away from me, werewolf!’- Ron ‘Dumbledore hired you when he knew you were a werewolf?!’ - Ron Also the fact dumbledore had to convince many staff members to be okay with the hiring of Lupin really shows how difficult finding employment must’ve been for him.

Kunzite Blossom

Thanks, I must have mixed my notes for 18 under 17. I'll give it a relisten and fix it. Edit: Skimmed through the audio book, its chapter 19. Idk how I messed up my notes that badly unless I just wasn't paying attention. I do usually color while I listen. Thank you for pointing it out to me!

John Phillips

Just to let you know, chapters 18 and 20 of this book are very short chapters. I don't know how many pages it takes up in the U.K. edition, but in the U.S. edition they only take up about 8-9 pages. I do find it Interesting that Harry thought of killing both Sirius and Crookshanks for protecting Sirius in the shrieking shack. I know he didn't have the heart to kill anyone, but I wonder how Hermione would feel about Harry's thought process about both Crookshanks and Sirius. I forgot to mention something when I first made this comment so I'll edit this comment and add another sentence. In the book, it was Ron who stood up to Sirius and said if you want to kill Harry, you'll have to kill us too! All while standing on a broken leg. In the movie, it was Hermione who said that line and Ron was just sitting in the background. This is yet another Ron moment they give to Hermione in the movies.

Michelle Linardis

Hey Veggie!=D I don't really have much to add at this point, since I am just really looking forward to your reactions from chapter 17 onwards...The history info-dumb will really knock your socks off, and I am very excited to hear your thoughts. Enjoy the rollercoaster!

itsanursething

There's so much good stuff in these upcoming chapters! I'm super excited for Veggie to get there too! :)

Chesca

Given that Professor Trelawny has a genuine vision but then doesn’t remember it, I wonder if she’s had other important genuine visions that no one (including her!) knows about. We know she spends a lot of her time alone in the astronomy tower so it seems possible! Also I love that Hermione’s biggest fear is failing her exams - it’s just so Hermione! 😆

Garry (Not Jerry)

Remember a few book-clubs ago, we were discussing what Hermione's boggart would be? You were so curious that you *accidentally* read my reply to the comment, which was a little spoiler-y (sorry!). Basically I was saying that Ron's joke-guess about Hermione's boggart - 'a piece of homework that only got nine out of ten' was actually very close! What do you think about the boggart appearing as McGonagall - especially considering that it also took the form of Snape. Why do you think Snape's appearance is held against him, but Mcgonagall's is not? (This is a debate that we were having in the comments at the time). Also, I wonder why Scabbers decided to hide in Hagrid's house. Perhaps he thought he would be safe from Crookshanks there?

Sandra

Hi Veggie, just joined the Patreon :) I've found yours and the book club's comments really insightful and interesting so thanks! I love JKR's ability to create dialogue so normal to age and personality: //"Have any of you ever seen anything in a crystal ball?" asked Neville. "Nope," said Ron in an offhand voice.// It's just so '13 year old doesn't care about a subject they hate', I love it. In the Shrieking Shack, I find it interesting how Ron embodies the wizarding community's negative attitude to werewolves. I know he must be terrified, but we also know that Ron comes from a family tolerant of everyone, regardless of their blood status or conditions. Maybe Ron would not be saying this were it not for Lupin seeming guilty of helping the 'criminal' Black. Just a 'fun' fact: the executioner, Macnair, is one of the Death Eaters called by Voldemort in the graveyard in the Goblet film. Cheers!

Kunzite Blossom

I think for the boggart, part of it might have to do with the fact that with Neville the entire class saw it. It was probably more of something funny for the students to talk about and it spread around school. Especially since Snape ended up in woman's clothes. But remember Neville's fear was Snape himself. For Hermione, her fear wasn't McGonagall but failing. It just happens that for the boggart, McGonagall was the one used to tell Hermione she failed. Which would make sense since McGonagall is her head of house. If anyone would tell Hermione she failed every class, it would be McGonagall.

Jacqueline Chaiton

I absolutely love the end of this book, chapter 16 through the end of the book is my favourite part of the series. I do prefer the time travel sequence in the movie, but it works better in movie form than it would in book form. So for me my own personal canon is the shrieking shack scenes from the book and the time travel sequence from the movie (up until after the dementors).

Hairy Pothead

Hi Veggie! First timer here. Thank you for this series, best Harry Potter content online. I've read the series many times, but now I get to relive the feeling of a first time reader. Harry feeling euphoria for a week after finally winning the Quidditch cup is so nice after all he's been through. Maybe you think it's a bit undeserved (due to the Firebolt) but I think having a better broom than someone is similar to kids sports/activities IRL. Someone will always have a better bicycle than someone else, or a better internet connection in online games etc. Harry has been practicing a lot, which is the only reason he was able to do the dive straight down and pull out at the last second to grab the snitch. I think 'Malfoy was miles ahead' is mostly in Harrys mind, but had Malfoy been as good as Harry at flying, then Malfoy probably would have won. If Harry had a worse broom he might have used a different strategy tho, and not done a fake 'attack' on the Slytherins. I see comments like 'Ravenclaw won't stand a chance now' as kids being excited about someone having the 'latest and greatest' equipment, not a literal statement. Btw: I believe the Hogwarts league is 'round robin' where all teams meet each other one time, so 6 matches total in a year: Gryffindor L - W Hufflepuff Ravenclaw W - L Hufflepuff Slytherin W - L Ravenclaw Gryffindor W - L Ravenclaw Slytherin W - L Hufflepuff Gryffindor W - L Slytherin Before the last game, Hufflepuff and Ravenclaw are 1-2, Slytherin 2-0 and Gryffindor 1-1. Gryffindor needs to win to have the same record as Slytherin. The points difference (from the entire season) is the tie breaker. It will often be a multi-way tie for first place with this system, which is why there's a big focus on points. I'm basing this on Gryffindors feeling like shit after the first loss since they know they can't win the cup if Hufflepuff win their other 2 games. After Hufflepuff loses to Ravenclaw, they feel hope again 'Gryffindor were not out of the running after all, but they can't afford to lose another match'.

Helen

I've always been interested in how Crookshanks is suspicious of Scabbers from the very beginning. Presumably because he could detect he was not actually a rat. I am curious though, at what point in the school year did Crookshanks meet Sirius? Was he suspicious at all of this Animagus Dog? Or did he know right away that Sirius could be trusted? Also, How many of his attacks on Scabbers, were done prior to him teaming up with Sirius?

Garry (Not Jerry)

I think I agree, but it certainly marks her as a strong disciplinarian - The fact that she can be scary enough to be a boggart. I just don’t feel movie mcgonagall has quite that ferocity.

Janie

It seems Trelawney doesn't even know she's the real Seer. She doesn't remember making the prediction, she even thinks Harry's crazy when he pointed it out to her. She wouldn't have been that surprised if she had known she can do that. I'm kind of confused by Hermione's exams. For example, she has Transfiguration and Arithmency at the same time. But that means that no other student can take Arithmency exam because the two exams are at the same time and no one else has a Time-turner. So is Hermione the only student that takes Arithmency classes? Chapter 17 and the next few chapters are my favourite ones in the whole book. I love the suspense just before Sirius is revealed, Ron defending Harry on a BROKEN leg (I hate they took this moment from him in the movie), Crookshanks defending Sirius and then Lupin explaining so many things. I wonder if people that only watched the movies even realised who the Marauders really were.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Maybe they don’t all take the exams at the same time?

Kattie Martin

These chapters are a good example of why I prefer the books. It shows that magic isn’t easy and shows the slow development of the characters. Ron was such an amazing character, fighting to get free unlike his perpetually terrified bumbling movie version. Plus being a top tier friend. Then there is Harry’s self discovery that no matter how angry he is, he is not a killer. This will be important for the rest of the series.

Thunderbird

Hi Veggie, what was your reaction, when you found out that the secret passageway lead to the Shrieking Shack? Did you already find out why it is the most haunted building in Great Britain? Also we finally meet the hero of this book: Crookshanks ^^. I would have loved to see your reaction when he freezed the Whomping Willow. What a lot of people don’t know, because it isn’t really mentioned in the books, is that Crookshanks is half-Kneazle. JK Rowling confirmed this only after writing "Fantastic beasts and where to find them". There it says that «The Kneazle has an uncanny ability to detect unsavoury or suspicious characters», which explains why he knew that Sirius was a good guy and Scabbers/Pettigrew was not! I love all the revelations that have just been made and I can’t wait for the next chapter. I’m so exited! 😊

Steven

These chapters are a good example of small but IMPORTANT details that are either not included in the movies or aren’t given enough importance. Like Scabbers being found in Hagrid’s milk and being happy there. It’s very telling that there’s something going on with him when you read it again. With these books its really little but important details that oftentimes get cut from the movies and I can’t help but feel like a lot of them were wrongly removed. Crookshanks is a great example since we see him scuttle off towards Sirius in the Shrieking Shack, which doesnt make sense without having those moments where we are led to believe that Crookshanks is more important than just rivalry between Ron and Hermione.

itsanursething

I never saw McGonagall as being scary as the boggart. I thought it manifested as her because Hermione respected her and looked up to her and it would have been all the more devastating to hear how she (Hermione) had disappointed her (McGonagall) by failing. I think that makes sense...

Darcy

Okay so now that you’ve seen Lupin and Black interact, I would love to hear your thoughts on Wolfstar, the ship between Remus and Sirius. Although never stated, there almost seems to be an implied relationship between the two. You have already heard about Lupin’s lycanthropy (being a werewolf) as a metaphor for HIV/AIDS (a potentially problematic comparison made by JK). A lot of people read Sirius as gay and Lupin as bisexual. It is interesting to note that the line “Then Lupin spoke, in an odd voice, a voice that shook with some suppressed emotion” was changed in the American version to “Then Lupin spoke, in a very tense voice”. It is interesting that they took out Lupin’s “suppressed emotion”, and, while it may be a stretch, could be so it would not be perceived as gay.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Ah yes the classic “I’m not mad I’m just disappointed” good point!

S1lm4r1l

I mean, how many of the things people were tested on in school have real-world applications?

Hawwah

We finally found out who Hermione's boggart turns into. It's Professor McGonagall herself. IMO this fact adds important perspective to Neville's boggart. It shows us that a boggart turning into a teacher isn't something unheard of, nor is it unique to Snape. I think people very often apply unfair double standards to these two professors. *Neville's boggart turns into Professor Snape.* Fandom: This proves Snape is a horrible person! *Hermione's boggart turns into Professor McGonagall.* Fandom: This doesn't prove anything! Several people have commented that Hermione's boggart isn't necessarily McGonagall herself, but failure. And that's a valid interpretation. Absolutely. The point is, Neville's boggart can be interpreted in the exact same way! We'll learn more about Neville's home life later, but so far it has already been established that Neville fears he's not good enough for his family, esp. his grandmother. It's plausible that this fear manifests as Snape because Potions are Neville's worst subject at school. On the other hand, Hermione's boggart *can* be interpreted literally. A boggart turns into whatever the person fears the most. If Hermione's fear was really just failed exams and nothing more, wouldn't the boggart change into a report card or an expulsion letter? My point is we should either interpret both boggarts literally or both figuratively. Not pick and choose what's most convenient to us.

Jake M

I never noticed that connection! Ron getting injured because he revealed what had gone on...🤯

Diego Zenhäusern

I know movie Moody said that the ministry doesn't want him to teach the unforgivable curses. I'm pretty sure book Moody says something similar, though I would have to reread the book to be sure🤔

Rebecca May

My thoughts exactly! He definitely had to get Dumbledore’s permission so it certainly isn’t standard practice

Diego Zenhäusern

To me personally this chapter always cemented that Trelawney is a fraud most of the time and that most of her predictions that come true are purely coincidental (like the thing with Lavender's Rabbit). Because: 1. She basically admits it here herself: "I would certainly not presume to predict anything quite as far-fetched as that!" 2.We see here how a genuine prediction of her looks like (which doesn't resemble at all to her predictions in class). 3. She does dissmiss Harry's correct prediction that Buckbeak will be fine and all but outright predicts his death instead (which is clearly a wrong prediction). 4. Other characters also "predict" stuff correctly (Harry: Buckbeak's survival; Ron (jockingly): Hermione's boggart and that Tom Riddle might have killed Myrtle to earn his medal for services to the school). So Trelawney's predictions sometimes coming true doesn't proof anything...especially since it is mentioned multiple times that she basically makes dozens of predictions per leson, so some of them are bound to end up being (at least kinda) right. But to be honest: I think it is quiet sad that Trelawney actually possesses the gift of sight but doesn't even seem to know about it (based on the fact that she dismisses Harry telling her about her prediction) and instead puts on a show for everyone (whether she herself actually believes in her normal "predictions" or not)🤔🙁.

Tomi Timonen

Weggie said in previous book club, that he only wants to hear comments about the current chapters. You can leave this comment into YouTube comment section so veggie can see this.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Let me ask you something Hawwah - Neville was asked what his fear was by Lupin, and he said professor snape. If Hermione was asked what her fear was, what do you think she would say?

itsanursething

I commented on another post about this. I think any teacher telling Hermione she failed would have been terrifying to her, BUT because McGonagall is her head of house and is someone Hermione admires and respects IMMENSELY, it had a much bigger impact. Which is why the boggart chose McGonagall's form and not anyone else.

Janie

The boggarts represent completely different things. Neville is literally scared of Snape as a person because he bullies him. Hermione is scared of a failure. The fact that it's McGonagall who tells her she failed is only because McGonagall is her head of house.

Garry (Not Jerry)

yes I agree with you on points - I think it only goes to points if no team outright leads on number of wins. This is quite normal for many sports.

Kevin Morris

Hey Veggie! I know that earlier you had questioned where the part of the story where Harry sees Pettigrew's name on the map went. Well, now you know. In the book, he never actually sees Pettigrew on the map, Lupin does...and that's how he realizes that Peter is alive and therefore Sirius is innocent. This has always raised a question with the HP fandom though. At some point in the last two years, Fred and George would have had to have seen Peter Pettigrew on the map in close proximity to Ron and Harry and have had questions. Why did they never say anything? I guess they just saw a lot of names in the area, as it would most likely be whenever they're in the Gryffindor Common Room and so there would likely be dozens on names in the vicinity so that it would probably go unnoticed.

Katik

Hi Veggie! Now things are getting interesting! Ron being a true Gryffindor again and putting himself between his friends and a (perceived) mass murderer. I hate that this was taken away from him in the film. Something that only occurred to me this time re-reading the book - Lupin describes how he followed everything that happened on the Marauders' Map, BUT has he seen the extra (time travelling) people there as well? They would be quite close at some points in time to the main trio so they should be spotted! I wonder if they just don't show on the map? Or Lupin didn't notice them, or did but didn't say anything? What do you think? And last thing with all the Animagus revelations (the dog is Sirius, the rat is Pettigrew), the first time I read the book I went "ok who's Crookshanks then"! It somehow didn't fit he'd be the only one left being just an animal. I know, silly of me, please someone tell me I wasn't the only one! :D

Katik

I agree that Trelawney is a fraud with the exception of these real prophecies in trance she's not aware of! I always considered the fact that everything she says actually does come true in one way or another just a joke easter egg from JKR we're not meant to take seriously. OR my second theory is JKR is on purpose showing us how any kind of fortune telling is "working" in the real world (ie not working) - if you keep your predictions vague enough someone will always find an interpretation fitting them. The only one that does not fit with either for me is the one in the Half Blood Prince about the lightning struck tower... My theory is her overconsumption of cherry in those days actually gave her some powers :D (which is a troubling thought!)

Diego Zenhäusern

Yeah, that's what I always kinda assumed as well🤔🙂

S1lm4r1l

Fred and George have better things to do with the Map than look at their little brother and his friend.

emmainkeri

They teach them transfiguration gradually, moving from small object to bigger objects and animals and living things. So it's just part of the learning process, turning a teapot into a tortoise isn't the end goal. Although, Cedric does use this skill to turn a rock into a dog in the 4th book 👀

emmainkeri

This is only covered in chapter 19!

emmainkeri

I'm sure it's fine, it's their first comment anyway.

emmainkeri

Hey Veggie! I'm FINALLY leaving a book club comment! (After over a year of Potter book clubs, I might add.. Siriusly, where has the time gone??) Hermione's boggart isn't McGonagall specifically, it's failing. Failing all her classes, failing at magic and even potentially getting kicked out of school and the wizarding community (which changed her life). Or at least that's a headcanon that exists. Let's just say that if I, a muggle, got accepted to Hogwarts, failing would probably be my boggart too. Hagrid's letter is heartbreaking. Just imagine being in his situation, feeling utterly hopeless. But I love Hermione for her determination and being there for Hagrid throughout this book. She's only 13. The way Lupin hands the trio back their wands without hesitation, means that at this point, he 100% trusts Sirius and believes Peter was the real mole. I think the fact that he didn't need any further proof speaks volumes to their friendship. I wonder if he'd been doubting the official version of the events in the back of his mind all this time, but dismissed it as being in denial. And now, just seeing Peter's name on the map is what makes it click for him and he's willing to risk everything for his old friend Sirius.

Hawwah

@Garry Hermione answered this question herself, didn't she? 'Hermione!' said Lupin, startled. 'What's the matter?' 'P-P-Professor McGonagall! Hermione gasped, pointing into the trunk. Sh-she said I'd failed everything!' Hermione didn't say *I failed everything*, *I'm a failure*, *I'm useless* etc. She said PROFESSOR MCGONAGALL. (Actually, she gasped and stuttered.) And then she added that PROFESSOR MCGONAGALL said that she (Hermione) had failed everything. One could argue that Hermione's boggart isn't *failing everything* but specifically PROFESSOR MCGONAGALL *telling* her she had failed everything. Or just PROFESSOR MCGONAGALL herself. And I think that's a valid interpretation as well.

Paloma LCR

SNUPIN! Hi Veggie! Im so glad to be here! Since your reaction in the movie HP and the Prisoner of Azkaban im been waiting for you to arrive to this chapters. Your reaction to the scenes were is all develop in the movie just make me think that will be nothing compare to ALL THE CRUCIAL INFORMATION that the books give the readers. Im not going to comment about it yet because y don’t want to split this 2 chapters for what’s come next. Just 1 question…. During the book, where you already know the relation between Sirius and Lupin, at this point, do you think Lupin believe Sirius is Inocent? O he blame him like everyone else?

Hawwah

@itsadancething So you're saying that the fact that the boggart turned into McGonagall of all people is just a pure coincidence? It has nothing to with McGonagall herself and how severely she punished Neville recently? The boggart might have turned into Professor Sprout and Hermione still would have run out of the trunk screaming and shaking? I'm sorry, but I don't believe that.

Hawwah

@Janie I don't mean to sound rude, but you're just proving my point. You choose which boggart to interpret literally and which one figuratively at your convenience. The fact is both can be interpreted literally OR figuratively. Also, if you continue claiming that Professor Snape bullies Neville, I'll stop engaging with you, because I see it as evidence that you're not interested in serious debate. Professor Snape reprimands Neville when Neville doesn't pay attention in class, disregards Snape's instructions and endangers everybody with his sloppy work. That's not bullying, that's literally a teacher doing his job. When Neville behaves in class, Snape has zero problems with him (as seen in the DADA lesson).

Frederique Gillespie

Personally, I don't think Trelawney is a fraud because her predictions do come true. But I also think that her predictions are completely made up, so the fact that they come true is utterly meaningless. She's not a fraud because she does have the ability, but she does act fraudulently. (It is not our abilities but our choices that define who we are, remember?) Now, the scene in the Shrieking Shack... It's so odd because it is probably my favourite scene in the entire HP movie series, or at least Top Three. But the book is so much richer with the details. We don't get Gary Oldman's superb performance, but we have both Hermione and Ron defending Harry. We get to see what Lily and James' death did to Remus and Sirius's friendship. How Remus lost all of his friends, one way or another, in one night. There's just so much more there... and it's only the first half!!!!

itsanursething

No. I think it's Hermione's respect and admiration for McGonagall that made the boggart turn into her. The thought of disappointing her mentor was what was so scary. As far as we know from the book, Hermione didn't seem to care at all or even acknowledge Neville's punishment, so I don't know what that has to do with anything. And I doubt the head of another house would be the one to break the news to Hermione that she had failed everything. Logically, it would have always been McGonagall.

Hawwah

@itsadancething 'Hermione's respect and admiration for McGonagall made the boggart turn into her' Um... no, that's not how boggarts work. Lupin: 'Nobody knows what a boggart looks like when he is alone, but when I let him out, he will IMMEDIATELY BECOME whatever each of us most FEARS.' (PoA ch. 7, emphasis mine.) A boggart turns into something you fear, not someone you respect and admire. Otherwise Harry's boggart would have turned into Dumbledore. Lupin's probably too. A boggart doesn't even have to turn into a person. Lupin's boggart was an inanimated object. If Hermione's fear was really just failed exams and nothing more, wouldn't the boggart change into a report card or an expulsion letter? Re: Professor Sprout. I worded that sentence badly. I meant if Sprout had been the head of Hermione's house, would the boggart have turned into her and would Hermione have reacted in the same way? I personally don't think so.

Janie

@ Hawwah No offence, but you're just going in circles here with your stubborn defence of Snape. I get it, you like him but seriously, this is getting a bit ridiculous. In your opinion, that character can do no wrong. He wasn't Neville's boggart for no reason. The fact is, Neville was scared of him, Snape knew this and yet he continued treating him the way he did. I will call it bullying whether you like it or not. (If I'm being too straightforward and somehow offended you, then I'm sorry but it had to be said.) And one more thing. Why would Hermione be scared of McGonagall? She was her favourite teacher. That just doesn't make sense at all. She was scared of a failure and if her head of house was Sprout or Flitwick, the boggart would have turned into them.

Kate Bogd

My thoughts exactly on Harry killing Sirius. Does he know any attacking spells at all at this point? Aside maybe from Expeliarmus and spells that work against creatures in Lupin's class. Maybe he was hesitating because he didn't know how to kill him :D

Kate Bogd

I wonder why Scabbers didn't run away and was hiding at Hagrid's. Were Crookshanks and Sirius patrolling the grounds to catch him? Or is there some sort of barrier preventing him from leaving Hogwarts grounds? He is still a rat and can hide easily, so seems like he had plenty of opportunity to escape. One of the best Ron's moments - protecting Harry with a broken leg! As someone who broke my leg a few months ago, I know how much agony he should be in and respect him so much for this! The map is fascinating and some things are never explained. It shows people under the invisibility cloak for once, but maybe because the marauders knew of the cloak when they were making the map (it was James's). And Harry never saw Petergrew on the map, only Lupin did. I personally think, it's because Marauders made it so that only Marauders can see other Marauders on it. Otherwise, it seems like a major plothole.

itz_Cherise

We finally got to one of the most EGREGIOUS Ron/Hermione book to movie mishaps! The movie made her out to be some sort of action hero! Dodging the tree like a pro and grabbing a stunned Harry, then selflessly putting herself between Harry and danger. Meanwhile Ron is bumbling and scared. What a big difference! Hermione is my fave, but this was insane. She was screaming for help while Harry figured things out, and she was trying to hush the boys while Ron stood on a BROKEN leg ready to die to protect his best friend. Were you surprised at this (unnecessary) change?

itsanursething

I think you're missing my point. I think combined with failure, Hermione's biggest fear is not being good enough and/or letting people down. McGonagall was the one to inform her she was a witch and invite her to Hogwarts. She's Hermione's favorite teacher, her mentor, someone she admires greatly. Being told by someone THAT important that she'd failed is so much more impactful than just a report card with bad grades. Hermione would be terrified of disappointing/letting down McGonagall, no questions. Going back to your original post, I don't think the boggarts of the professors are interpreted differently simply for convenience. Hermione respects McGonagall too much to be afraid of her. Afraid of disappointing her, yes, but not afraid of her as a person. That just doesn't make any logical senes to me. At this point in the story, I don't see Hermione's greatest fear as being a person, whereas Neville being afraid of a person seems highly plausible. He's a very timid person. What reason would Hermione have to fear McGonagall? I'm not trying to say your interpretation is wrong, it just doesn't logically make any sense to me.

Kunzite Blossom

It's crazy because I grew up on the movies, and a few years back first listened to the audio books. Overall I much prefer the books but theres just something about this film that remains great and I do prefer to the book in terms of order of certain events (like the broom. I will love the movie version way more) but i do love the details of the book. The depth of the arguments, the details in the stories told.

Frederique Gillespie

Honestly, even though I prefer the books, I found myself wishing in this specific chapter that book-Sirius was closer to movie-Sirius in terms of personality. I love all the details and the richness they bring to the story, but Gary Oldman is probably the reason I still prefer Sirius over Remus.

Kristen Campbell

I agree but I don't think Percy had as much classes. I think he had a regular schedule and just passed everything.

Jacob sparks

Percy got 12 owls. Which means he passed every class, which is what hermione is trying to do but needs a time turner

Annette Elliott

This is where all of the information is missing in the movie. So much more info about the Marauders and what actually led up to Sirius being in Azkaban and even HOW he escaped. Then there's Ron's heroism and how they actually got past the Whomping Willow. I love the barely seen interaction between Sirius and Crookshanks in this book that only Harry sees.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Interesting interpretation. Do you think Hermione was always scared of mcgonagall? I.e in all of her school years, Or just when she was younger? Has Hermione ever shown any other signs of being afraid of mcgonagall? I can’t think of any, but maybe you can.

Maria

I'm so excited that we're getting to my favorite part of the book! These chapters are so great. I'm a cat person, so one thing I especially like is how crucial Crookshanks is to this part of the plot. I think he is often overlooked, but he really is the MVP in chapter 17 (defending Sirius, helping Hermione and Harry with the whomping willow etc.). I think Crookshanks is supposed to have some magical intelligence (although I've met some real cats that are almost as smart as him), but animals in general are really good at identifying good people vs. bad people, so I think the fact that Crookshanks likes Sirius and hates Scabbers is a subtle hint to the reader about their true personalities. I also think that it's really sweet that Hermione asks for help and Crookshanks immediately responds; it really shows their bond! I think we should have had more Crookshanks in the movie!

itsanursething

Crookshanks is part Kneazle which is why he's so intuitive about good vs bad. But I do agree with you, animals (magical or not) are often very good judges of character :)

Yankee Veg

Hi, Veggie! I love your content because it feels like added value experiencing the HP movies and books again for the first time through the eyes of a friend. Now for these chapters: yay, Crookshanks! And why is Scabbers so edgy to start with? He doesn't seem to be in danger. Keep being you, Veg. We love you!

S1lm4r1l

I wouldn't call it a headcanon. Hermione's fear is failure. Naturally that manifests as McGonagall telling her she's failed everything and will have to leave Hogwarts. Whilst Neville genuinely fears Snape himself.

emmainkeri

Oh yeah, i meant that part about getting kicked out specifically being a headcanon! I totally agree.

Hawwah

Professor Snape saw Lupin on the map, so it's not true that only Marauders can see other Marauders on it.

Rebecca May

@S1lm4r1l - I’m interested as to why you think Ron shouldn’t be judged too harshly for his comments on werewolves… You and I have had a previous discussion where you’ve absolutely torn into Snape for holding essentially the same opinions as Ron appears to hold in this chapter. Why should Ron be forgiven, and Snape vilified? I'm not trying to be argumentative, I’m genuinely curious – I have stated in previous comments that Snape’s opinions on werewolves really bother me (though I know we disagree on the extent of his hatred of werewolves, we don’t need to go over that again), and Ron’s comments bother me just as much.

itsanursething

This just occurred to me, but what if he took all the electives just in different years? Is that an option? Like, third year he takes Ancient Runes and Care of Magical Creatures, and then fourth year, he takes Arithmancy and Divination. Or something like that. Would he still be able to take the OWLs for all of them even if he didn't take every class every year? I have no idea, I'm just wondering!

Methanoutput

I'm sorry, im gonna be a little bit off-topic, to the discussion you have here, but i never thought about the boggart scenes to be there, to show that they are scared of their teachers but rather to show, what Harry has already seen in his life, compared to some other students. So i never heard an opinion on those scenes from someone and never engaged online in HP discussions, so when i read that, my reaction was something like 'oh damn Harry has seen Voldemort and big scary floaty guys that suck the happiness out of you and the other guys are scared of bad grades or teachers, they don't get along with'.

Methanoutput

Hey Veggie, i have a point about this chapter 17 that always left me confused. I kind of got the feeling in the book Harry was planning to kill Black, i mean in the movie he shouts, that he wants to kill him in his emotional breakdown, but i mean, how would Harry go about this? He should not know how to kill someone with magic. Is he gonna Wingardium Leviosa a knife into Black or how exactly is this gonna play out? I think i read book 1 and 2 when i was very young and then later watched the movies up to number 4, before reading the books and i have to admit i did not understand the story that unfolds in chapter 17 and following chapters, in the portrayal of the movie. So i can't wait to see if you like them and if they maybe clear things up for you aswell. Hope you are doing good Veggie, can't wait to hear your thoughts!

Gothic Llama

The beginning of chapter 16 is why I have a bit of a beef with this book. The time of exams just doesn't make sense (I mean the whole plot about Hermione and her taking all of the classes is, but we discussed it previously); how is it possible and even logical for a school to set double exams for one year in two days??? I refuse to believe Hermione is the only student who wanted to pick Charms and Ancient Runes - normally the school would probably set up a Charms exam for 3rd years at 1 and Ancirnt Runes for 4th or 5th year at the same time and then, let's say have 3rd years take Ancient Runes exam at 3 or another day. That's how schools work! Other interesting things I picked up in these chapters: - In Trelawney's prediction she said "His servant has been chained these 12 years" which is a misdirect to Black (but Pettigrew has been chained to living as a rat) - Why did Hermione not use Reparo for Hagrid's broken kettle? - I like that the trio didn't actually see what happened with Buckbeak like in the film, but only heared noises behind them to make them believe Buckbeak really died. - Crookshanks being more important than in the film, love it! - How funny it must've looked, Sirius sitting on the bed with a cat on his lap, and Ron scooting away Anyway, sorry for the long comment and greetings from Poland!

Kate Bogd

Hm, I need to reread that part but you are probably right. Then it feels like a major plot hole from JKR. I just can’t imagine twins or Harry not once noticing Pettegrew on the map.

S1lm4r1l

Viewed in isolation you're quite correct. However, several things count in Ron's favour. Ron is a child, Snape is not. Ron gets over his prejudice towards werewolves extremely quickly. Snape does not. Snape is a member of an organisation that views werewolves as lesser and treats them so. Ron fights said organisation and argues with the Minister of Magic himself about the wizarding justice system in this very book. In a transparently heartless act, Snape outs Lupin to the entire wizarding world because he didn't get to witness the Dementor's kiss being administered to Sirius Black.

Rebecca May

Snape *was* a member of said organisation… I agree he is slower to grow out of his prejudice than Ron, but as I’ve mentioned previously, his attempt to save Lupin’s life in the final book weighs heavily in his favour for me. I don’t think he’d have tried to save Lupin if he didn’t recognise that he was human and therefore worth saving - we know Bellatrix in particular, and other Death Eaters, would argue otherwise. (Also, while Ron may be a child, his views are inherited from a significant number of adult wizards who feel the same as Snape does.) I also personally disagree with your stated reasons for Snape outing Lupin. I agree there may have been a level of personal disappointment at play, but I believe his primary motivation for outing Lupin was that he felt he had been proven correct in viewing Lupin as a danger to the students. I don’t like that Snape outed Lupin either, it makes me feel terrible for Lupin - but I can understand his motivations, as I believe them to be.

S1lm4r1l

Snape did not turn on said organisation because of their views on werewolves. Their views on werewolves did not discomfort him at all. Ah. But is Snape saving Lupin? Or is he saving someone who looks like Harry Potter? We never get any indications that Snape knows which Harry is the real one. I'm not convinced by that argument. He clearly went behind both their backs and blindsided them. He could have chosen to argue his case to Dumbledore, or urge Lupin to resign of his own free will. He chose to force the issue and make the decision for the both of them.

itsanursething

I think the reason they never noticed Pettigrew is because they were never looking for him. They were always looking out for professors or Filch to avoid, so it wasn't like they were inspecting every name. Also, until Harry heard about him from McGonagall and co., he probably would have over looked Pettigrew's name as just someone he didn't know; I'm assuming the same with the twins. Hogwarts is a big school, you can't know everyone.

Rebecca May

Snape was absolutely saving Lupin. During that chase Lupin looked like himself, not Harry - those that used the Polyjuice Potion were Hermione, Ron, Fred, George, Fleur and Mundungus. And it's confirmed in Snape's memories that he cast Sectumsempra specifically aiming at a Death Eater who was aiming for Lupin. Protecting Lupin was a deliberate choice. (I realise you may be implying that Snape is only trying to save Lupin because it is, by proxy, possibly helping Harry, but I think that's pretty tenuous). Snape may not have turned on said organisation *because* of their views on werewolves - I'm simply stating that by trying to save Lupin's life, he proves that his views are not entirely aligned with theirs either. And of course, it is your prerogative not to be convinced. I personally think he only blindsided them only because he had argued his case to Dumbledore for the whole year and been completely ignored, and he didn't think Lupin would resign of his own volition.

S1lm4r1l

You misunderstand me. Lupin was riding a broom with George. But George looked like Harry. So when the Death Eater was going to cast that spell. Snape intervened to protect Harry. Snape has no way of knowing whether that Harry is the real one. He was protecting Harry again. Snape did not discuss with either Lupin or Dumbledore what happened that night regarding Lupin's transformation. And Lupin very charitably says that he can see the Parent's perspective and that the information would've leaked anyway. There were other ways of going about protecting the students and obtaining Lupin's resignation. But Snape wanted to out Lupin in the way he wasn't able to during their school days. Petty revenge for Black's escape and the loss of his Order of Merit.

Rebecca May

I didn't entirely misunderstand - I covered this argument in the bracketed section of my reply. It was in parenthesis because I honestly hoped that was *not* your argument, as I find it so extremely tenuous. The way it's written is that Snape saw Lupin in danger and acted on impulse to protect him. But I suppose it's about time I stopped being surprised at the lengths people will go to in order to see the absolute worst in everything that Snape does. I'll leave it there, except to say that I could entirely empathise with why Snape might choose not to approach Lupin or Dumbledore with his views on the matter yet again, after being ignored for an entire year.

Chorafini (Luiz)

Hey Veggie, first time participating in the book club. Been watching your HP journey for over a year and it's been awesome, your videos make me a very happy brazilian Ravenclaw. Now, for the chapters, even though I love this book, the classes schedule for Hermione to me seems a bit forced so that she can have the timeturner and a convenient way to help Sirius and Buckbeak Did you notice the executioner's name? It's Macnair, he was mentioned one time in one of the movies, but I won't say which one in case you don't remember "Do it now! - said a voice in his head", this happened when Harry is pointing his wand at Sirius. As far as I remember everytime Harry thinks something the narrator just explains it with no dialogue, but this time it specifically mentions a voice in his head, I wonder if it has to do with the Horcrux or am I looking to much into it? Even if it's understandable, especially at their age (even though the majority of the wizard society is like that), it's sad to see the prejudice against werewolves here, the trio's comments were almost all regarding Lupin's condition rather than him helping a possible mass murderer. Interesting to note that Harry's scene seeing Pettigrew on the map was transferred to Harry, and what a good cliffhanger Sorry for the long comment, will try to get more to the point in the future!

Noi. S

Hi, its my first time here after I finally caught up on the discussions. I have read those books so much as a kid and its great to experience it again with you after a couple of years (and also reading it in English for the first time). I really love how different and more unique kinds of pets are a big part of this book, I have a pet snake (his name is Monty because he is a bull python) and i think its just really cool to try to learn about different characters buy looking at the animals they connect to. I honestly never really appreciated the movies as a kid because I loved the books to match, but i can still say this one is probably the best one in my opinion for the sole reason that they got a really good director to do it so it really stands out. The production of all the movies is still incredible (especially the practical affects and sets) but in my opinion after this one the most obvious problem is that the books just get way longer, (goblet of fire is almost triple the length of philosopher stone) to the point were they just can’t tell the whole story in a two and a half hours movie even if everything else is perfect (and its not, but I know you already talked enough about the portrayal of the main characters especially Ron in this chapter , and to the other problems I’ll get in later books ). Btw sorry if I have writing mistakes I’m still practicing writing in English

H

This is still from future chapters, so maybe it's better to delete it since you haven't changed it yet? It's an interesting comment when the time is right for it. :-)

H

Here are some things that I enjoy in these chapters (and I will try not to mention things mentioned by others above me): - The pointless flobberworm exam - Florean, the ice cream man, getting a mention again during the exams - Ron talking passionately to Fudge about Buckbeak (we're slowly seeing the trio losing faith in authorities, which obviously is an important part of the HP story in future books) - The description of Hagrid's helplessness. So sad, but such a good description of it, and it seems so right for the character. - Lupin throwing the wands back to the trio. I know this was mentioned in another comment, but I mostly like it because he understands how to get people to listen. It's a way of dealing with people which explains why he was such a good teacher (despite the whole Snape/boggart thing). I'll end this comment by guessing how long into the video you are when reading this sentence: 03.58.22 :D

Katik

Love the name Monty for a python! :)

Katik

That's an interesting point about the voice in his head telling Harry to kill Sirius, I did not pick up on that! Yes it does sound like it's the Voldemort's soul talking

S1lm4r1l

Such an optimist ;) JK Veggie we love the longer videos.

H

I do as well! I love that we get such an in-depth way of going through these books. (I changed the start of my comment now as it looked like I was having a dig at others who don't check other comments!)

S1lm4r1l

Don't worry about it. I tend to phrase things far more confrontationally than I intend. The situation was badly handled by Lupin, Dumbledore and Snape. But I don't agree that Lupin should lose his job, a safe place to live, access to the only thing that makes him safe during his periods of illness all because he made 1 single mistake. Lupin made that mistake due to seeing 3 of his favourite students in the presence of a 'friend' he thought dead and a convicted multiple murderer who betrayed 2 people he was extremely close to in school. I wouldn't have thought Snape fans would necessarily be so harsh given the number of mistakes Snape makes throughout his life that also put people in danger. The fact that Snape could have done it for noble reasons doesn't mean that he did. Likewise I'll leave it there.

Mate

There is a plot hole that’s always mentioned whenever the marauders map is discussed. Everyone wonders how in the three years at Hogwarts, the twins never noticed Peter on the map basically living in Rons dorm. Even if they dont know who peter is they would be suspicious if they ever see someone in Gryffindor common room that shouldn’t be there. There is a theory that the marauders were hidden on the map with some sort of password/spell and can only be seen by each other somehow which is why Lupin can see Sirius and Petigrew with the trio. Of course that would not work in the movies as harry saw Peter on the map but it does make perfect sense in the books. Also love that the books explain how Lupin found out where they were or how he found out they needed help. I understand making some scenes in the movie more grand for the sake of the movie but the books have always been more realistic and in that sense we’re able to connect with the characters more. This is common throughout the books/movies. Sorry for the long comment but there are 5 chapters left and you might want to consider covering 3 chapters in the next video as 2 of them are quite short relative to other chapters. But whatever you decide, We’ll all be eagerly waiting for your next book review! They have been amazing! Thank you

Hawwah

This has a potential to turn into a really dark discussion, but... Many mundane spells can be used to hurt or even kill someone. It's like in real life. Most things aren't good or bad - they can be *used* for good or bad. You can use a knife to prepare dinner for your family, or you can use it to stab someone. Same with magic. Wingardium Leviosa - you can levitate someone over the edge of a tall building, then stop the spell. Incendio - this one is obvious. Aguamenti - you can use it to waterboard someone, probably even to drown them. I'm sure there are many more. In this particular case, I think Harry could have used Diffindo to kill Black. Cut his carotid artery or something. Now, I'm not exactly sure when Harry learned this particular spell, but if he knows it already, I think that's an answer to your question. (One of many possible answers, I am sure.)

Methanoutput

Now that you mention it, I kind of wish the Death Eaters had used something like that. I think it would have added a more disturbing factor to them, had they been inventive with their cruelties instead of using the Cruciatus Curse for the hundredth time.

Dara Jeeling

I always thought that the "seeing Peter" is close to what you describe. KNowing Harry did not see Peter - I wonderif either has ever checked for "Scabbers/Wormtail" (like the mArauders shown in their Animagi form with their Animagi name AND if Harry would have been able to see that if the map was somehow keyed in to the Marauders/their blood.

Katie

I really like that theory. A simpler explanation though is the twins wouldn't want to look at what Ron's up to. They wouldn't care. They only need the map to sneak around the corridors to check if any teachers are coming.

Hawwah

I'm not sure about the Death Eaters, but James Potter used Scourgify (a cleaning spell) to choke and effectively waterboard Severus in SWM.

Hawwah

@Rebecca May I agree with the majority of your comments. Just a little correction - Severus didn't merely "try" to save Lupin in that scene, he did indeed save his life. (Unfortunately he also accidentally hurt George, but still, without him interfering, Lupin would have been dead at the spot.) "You and I have had a previous discussion where you’ve absolutely torn into Snape for holding essentially the same opinions as Ron appears to hold in this chapter. Why should Ron be forgiven, and Snape vilified? " Because this fandom is full of ridiculous double standards, that's why. Everything Snape says or does must be interpreted in the absolutely worst way possible, which is not the case with any other character. We saw it in abundance in the boggart debate. Someone - and I'm not referring to you, Rebecca - is also conveniently forgetting the fact that Severus isn't merely "prejudiced" against werewolves. He has an actual, valid reason to fear them, because he was almost slaughtered by one when he was 16. Prejudice is a preconceived opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience. Severus' opinion on Lupin is based both on reason AND personal experience.

Hawwah

I haven't been there for a while and now I've come back to this discussion only to find out how many replies I've got. Are you guys still interested in continuing this discussion? If so, I'm certainly very willing! I'm only asking because I wouldn't like to spend time composing answers (undoubtedly very lengthy) that nobody would read in the end.

Eshi

Hi Harry Pothead 😊 search John Voth on YouTube he did Harry Potter readings while experiencing the books first time... You will love it 😁

S1lm4r1l

"Joining the Death Eaters is okay if you were really frightened one time." Snape is straight-up terrible to Lupin as a person. He doesn't even attempt to understand Lupin's position, or the circumstances surrounding the incident, or Lupin's mistake in not taking the potion that night. Snape shouldn't get off lightly for being a terrible, awful human being because he makes a handful of grandiose gestures throughout his life.

Rebecca May

@S1lm4r1l - Just to clarify, I have so much empathy for Lupin's situation (he and Snape are my two favourite characters, in fact) and I don't for a second believe he should have lost his job... I hate that he did, it must have been awful for him. I just believe in seeing the best in people and I can empathise with Snape's reasoning and motivations, if not the result.

S1lm4r1l

@Rebecca, that wasn't directed at you. Apologies if you thought it was.

Rebecca May

@S1lm4r1l - That's totally okay! I just felt it something important to mention. :)

S1lm4r1l

For what its worth, I can empathise with that reasoning too. But I think its extremely charitable to think that revenge played no part in Snape's decision to out Lupin after all that has occurred between them. Especially because we know that Snape wanted to out Lupin whilst they were both students.

Rebecca May

I really appreciate you saying that. And also for what it’s worth, I’m not saying that Snape wasn’t extremely bitter about the way things played out and I’m sure getting back at Lupin crossed his mind… I personally just don’t think it was his primary motivation, that’s all. I also think wanting to out Lupin at school was wrong and childish and short-sighted, but I’d like to think Snape’s reasons have evolved in adulthood, even if the outcome still sucks.

Kunzite Blossom

Hi H, could you explain what is still spoilers? I'm honestly confused, I saw Veggie skipped my comment due to spoilers but I thought I had taken them all out? I'm not sure what here is still a spoiler. I mean we know from the scene in the movie when Ron gets Scabbers back 2 stones are thrown into Hagrids hut, which didn't happen in the book when Ron got him back. So I wouldn't really think it's a spoiler. In the movie the time travel hints would have happened already. And I had verified that Chapter 17 has Crookshanks protecting Sirius. Unless perhaps my audio book is split somewhere else.

Garry (Not Jerry)

The problem is that Patreon doesn’t notify you about a reply to a comment unless it’s your own comment. So I have to keep remembering to come back to a discussion every so often ☺️

H

Hi Kunzite Blossom! Sorry – you're right. I completely misread your comment, to be honest. When you mentioned the stones being thrown, and continued speaking about time travel, I thought you had misread which chapters was being covered since I thought "but that's in later chapters!". I don't know how many times I read you comment, but I still didn't get that you was talking about the hints being planted in that scene in the hut, which of course happened in these chapters in the movies. That's completely my fault, of course, not yours. As you can probably imagine, I was one of those warning Veggie about it since I completely misunderstood it (but I guess you didn't blame him anyway). Sorry!

Starryk

Maybe i am viewing that to technical but it could be that Lupin has a kind of admin code he used to activate the map and as he left it activated Snape could see Lupin on it too. Well probably it is a plothole but you can always explain stuff in your head if you really want.