Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi guys!  You will never guess what...

🎉 I start the video offf with an apology!! 🎉

So I misinterpreted something in these chapters, but luckily, you are all there to correct me in the Book Club!

We have a good and frank discussion about Snape, Black and the Marauders in general, as well as doing the usual indepth discussion on everything else!

Poor Hermione... I have a right go at her for no reason at one point. XD

Love you, guys!  WHAT a pair of chapters!!

Files

Movie Watcher Reads Harry Potter For the First Time! - Prisoner of Azkaban Chapters 18 & 19!

Check out the Patreon for the Full Length Movie reactions (you will need your own copy of the movie remember), and some other early access stuff coming soon! There is no minium Pay amount, so pay as little as you like! :) - https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer My Mail Box is Now OPEN! Find the Address and other info here! - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G362I7JPgWY Come join the official Veggie Discord server! :) - https://discord.gg/mw36C7d GET YOUR VEGGIE MERCHANDISE HERE! - https://www.redbubble.com/people/VeggieGamer GO GIVE ME A FOLLOW OVER AT TWITCH TO BE A PART OF THE FUN! - https://www.twitch.tv/veggie_gamer GET 15% OFF YOUR E-WIN RACING CHAIR BY USING PROMOTION CODE : Veggie US store: http://www.ewinracing.com/ European store: https://www.ewinracing.eu/ CCs used in my Sims 4 series can now be found here! - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1b2u8qVdJ0KAjbtG2ZPHv-DjIs2Ds4xUrtHTiKEVPahA/edit?usp=sharing CHECK ME OUT ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER! - Veggie_Gamer CAN WE GET THIS VIDEO TO 100 LIKES, VEGGIEKNIGHTS?? If you can spare anything, Patreon (NO pressure): Want to see more of this? Give the video a thumbs up and let me know in the comments :) Hit me up on the following websites! Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheVeggieGamer/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/Veggie_Gamer Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer Be sure to Follow me on Roblox (I can not accept Friend Requests) - https://www.roblox.com/users/135078748/profile End Card music - Artist: UnderwaterBeats Track: Evolution Licence:https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0

Comments

CR Ash

LETS GO RIGHT NOW!!! Veggie you always upload at the best time! Work is about to be amazing! Much love my friend!

S1lm4r1l

HYPE! MR BLACK! Regarding Snape and Quidditch, I think Lupin is trying to say that Snape was envious of the fame and adulation James got from being a player on a very successful Quidditch team. We've seen how everyone treats Harry because he's good at Quidditch. Animagi are extremely rare. The process to become one requires exceptional skill and patience. The ministry registers those attempting to do it because it can go horribly wrong. It's very complicated, one mis-step, one mistake and you screw it up. I think the Ministry believed the idea that a student could attempt it and actually pull it off without their knowledge was very far-fetched. Hermione said there's only been "7 (or something) this century". Even assuming one gets past the Dementors. You're on an island in the middle of the North Sea. You don't have a wand or broom. You (presumably,) cannot apparate anywhere without injuring yourself. It must seem incredibly unlikely that a prisoner could escape. (Although you're right to be annoyed about the 'inescapable prison,' being less than air-tight.) Black does explain why he encouraged James and Lily to switch. He was playing Voldemort. A bluff. He knew that Voldemort would assume L&J would pick him, and that he'd never believe they'd use Pettigrew. Voldemort only knows Pettigrew is the Secret Keeper because Pettigrew tells him. The idea was that Pettigrew would be in hiding too. Black's plan would've worked if Pettigrew wasn't already a spy working for Voldemort. Lupin is a character that battles with himself. He has his own internal demons. He gave Pettigrew and Black every opportunity to make their cases, but there's a quiet undercurrent of ruthlessness and rage to Lupin. The Dementor's Kiss is considered to be a fate worse than death, which is why the Ministry demonstrate restraint in using it. Snape was willing to let Sirius and Lupin receive one. Pretty disgusting behaviour. Lupin and Sirius wanting to murder Pettigrew seems pretty tame by comparison. A nice clean death. Probably wouldn't even feel it. Snape was perfectly happy torturing people when he thought they deserved it, we've seen this behaviour with Neville.

Hawwah

I've just returned home from the dentist. Perfect timing!

Dara Jeeling

me... yay! that will help me keeping my mind on Beasts and stuff... I want to get the box to the postal service... But I still need to work, which now is being easier Wolfsbane just makes sure the Werewolf can stay sane and transform without pain (if I am correct) and I always assumed, Dumbledore made sure Sape had to brew it. It's stated that it is a highly complex potion (and some ingredients are expensive - so usually werewolfes who live sort of as outlanders/outcasts and they could mostly not afford the potion) I am sure Snape is smug he can do it, but does not do so happily. Becoming an Animagus is short of described somewhere. You start with having a Mandrake leaf in your mouth for a month (no swallowing and such) and then you have bunches of other jobs. I hope this is not a spoiler... Also... Headboy has nothing to do with being a powerful wizard For me (yeah unpopular oppinion again) Snape is more powerful wizard then all 4 of the Maarauders put together. "Problem" is... Snape has both knowledge of the Dark Arts and the school stuff. For me all powerfull wizards in Harry Potter have knowledge of both sides. Dumbledore and McGonagall have as well. Also... Black und Potter sr were "purebloods" and the mostpowerfull wizards in the series are again not "pureblooded" but Half Blood. Again - Voldemort, Dumbledore, McGonagal (or Muggle born like Hermione). I could now argue with genetics and inbreeding XD But for now, let's not go there! Snaoe is Half Blood (not a spoiler) and as people always so kindly state he already was into the Dark Arts before he staretd school (which tells you something about his childhood - at least for me. I thnk Sape could easily have become an animagus - he was just not interested in it. Lily isn't either As for the kiss - yes bad decision by Snape but then IF he told that Lupin helped Black - the Minister would probably have made sure Lupin gets kissed, too! And yes, I think it's his only way - since Dumbledore always made sure the Marauders got off - free of anything. So WHY would that change?

Janie

Great, I just made something to eat so this is perfect :)

Hawwah

There is no actual cure for werewolves. When Lupin talks about a "cure", he refers to the Wolfsbane Potion Professor Snape had been brewing for him. You're absolutely right that it's technically not a cure, but it's the closest thing to an actual cure there is. That's why they refer to it as such. It's the best thing they have.

Josh Z

I believe the Curse Peter used is the exploding (reducter) curse. It's quite powerful and is the perfect way to fake his death. Harry has earned his bias against Snape imo. Snape doesn't see Harry, he sees James and Lilly and trauma. At a certain point he has to be the adult and most of the time he just isn't.

Josh Z

Also, I recommend three chapters next time specifically, but it is of course up to you.

Hawwah

Hey Dara! I find it very interesting that you think Dumbledore made Snape brew the potion and Snape reluctantly obeyed. I personally think it's more likely that Severus insisted he would be the person who would be brewing the potion. Severus' priority number one is students' safety (primarily Harry's, but not just his) PLUS he has a good reason to be wary of werewolves (his own near-death experience). So I think he wanted to personally make sure Lupin was harmless during his "time of the month". Of course this is just my theory (or headcanon), since we don't have it confirmed in the books, but I think it would be perfectly in Severus' character.

Hawwah

Veggie, have you forgotten Tom Riddle was a head boy? We learned it in Chamber.

VEGGIE GAMER

Very good point, Hawwah! Sorry, I had completely forgot!

Hawwah

About Severus supposedly being jealous of James because of Quidditch - I don't buy it. There's no evidence of it in the books. I think Lupin made it up to justify how he and his friends treated him. To me, it sounds a bit like "it was his own fault he got bullied", which is just awful. You're right, we will learn more about teenage Severus (and the Marauders) in later books. I can't really get into all that stuff now because of spoilers.

Katik

You mention Jacob in Twilight Veggie. He is indeed referred to as werewolf throughout but then in the end it's revealed that him and the other guys form the tribe are actually shape-shifters! So I view them much closer to Animagi in the HP world. There are differences in the choice and will that goes into turning into an animal of course, but otherwise I think it fits better. (Sorry for a Twilight post on a HP video! :D )

Judith

It's sooo difficult to listen to your reviews! I could write a comment on so many things you say! 😆 But that shows great quality on your end!! Okay. I will comment on a few things and than stop and just enjoy: - The potion Snape gives lupin allows him to turn into his werewolf form but keep his mind. So he can quietly stay in his room or office or whatever without going nuts and wanting to bite people. The danger to others is minimal that way. - There are head boys from other houses. Voldemort was head boy. As an example for Slytherin. I think James and Lilly being head boy and girl is just JK Rowlings preference for her characters and to make Harry's parents seem even more impressive to Harry. - of course do werewolfs attack animals. But I think what the book meant was that the bite of a werewolf is not dangerous in the same way. Yes, it can kill the animal. But it can't poison them and make them turn. And an animal usually doesn't attack another animal that is bigger and stronger than him. So because Sirius' and James' animagus were big enough, that there was no issue. At least that's how I understood that part... Okay, I am done now. I could go on and on, but no one wants a book for a comment! 😜

Hawwah

I don't think it was wise of Lupin to call Severus a fool. On the contrary, I think that was precisely the moment when Severus definitely lost it. Very counterproductive.

Katik

I hope it's a medieval banquet to last just under 5 hours :)

Hawwah

"Snape just could have killed him here." Yes. But he didn't. Because he is not a murderer. Black and Lupin were willing to commit murder that evening. Severus was not. Even when he rightfully hated Black for so many reasons - the years of relentless bullying, the murder attempt, the fact that he believed it was Black who betrayed Lily to her death - even then he wasn't going to murder him. That's why he is a so much better person than Black and Lupin. Do you see now why I admire him so much?

Keira Newren

Sirius is my absolute favorite character of all time, but I recognize that he has many flaws. He was definitely an arrogant bully in his youth, but I do think he was friendly to Peter for the most part. I think he knew that Peter thought highly of him even if he didn't think the same of Peter; but, Sirius also had 12 years of nothing better to do than to rehash and disect all of his relationships over and over again, leading him to the conclusion that Peter only ever followed powerful wizards. We also need to keep in mind that Sirius went to Azkaban at 21 which is hardly an adult, and he spent 12 years in a state of agony and arrested development, not to mention having his mind addled by dementors, even if it wasn't as bad as it could have been.

Hawwah

"There is now new information." But Severus doesn't know it! He doesn't know Pettigrew is alive. He never saw his name on the map and at this moment Pettigrew is still Scabbers. If only Lupin and Black instead of insulting Severus and mocking his trauma actually TOLD him that Pettigrew was alive and that they could prove it. So many things could have been different.

ambiture

there may or may not be a detailed description of the process of turning into an animagus in Hogwarts Legacy.. i guess you'll have to play more of the game to find out how it works xD

Dara Jeeling

As much as I love Snape, I see his flaws. I would hope he'd be brewing the potion for a noble reason - I just find it hard to see it that way. I aggree on student security being a big pont for him in my headcanon I just can not see him volunteer to brew for one of his childhood bullies. It can be taxing to be nice to someone who bullied you, even after years of not seeing them. I still have issues with the "girls" ( I am turning 45 this year) who bullied me in school. I can be civil - when we meet at school gatherings but I am not sure if I would volunteer to so something time consuming for them (I think I would if their lives depend on it - but otherwise not). So maybe in this instance I tend to think of Snape as being "human" and not willingly offering to spend time on one of his bullies.

Dara Jeeling

As stated the Marauders are not my favorites - but then I know they are all flawed - which makes them human. I mean - who is not flawed? Which is why I think there is this never ending discussion about a lot of characters. But then - I was already 21 when the 3rd book came out - so I guess I never had this "childrens" look ... The reat thing about the Marauders is the friendship part. It's extraordinary.

Lily Spungle

To be fair to Harry, Lupin described it as a joke first.

Lily Spungle

True he didn't murder them, but he wanted them to receive the dementor's kiss, which isn't really better.

VEGGIE GAMER

Really, Lily?? Damn, sorry about that. I must have missed it! That does change it a lot.

Hawwah

But Severus isn't brewing the potion to be nice to Lupin. He's doing it to ensure everyone in the castle would be safe. He's not doing it *for* Lupin. He's doing it for the students and staff and also for himself. Anyway, that's how I see it. You are entitled to your own opinion, of course. I absolutely understand what you wrote about your school bullies. I have similar experience. I don't want to write about it here too much because I am sure there are people who would gladly use it against me. But yes, I understand why Severus feels about the Marauders the way he does and I don't blame him for it one bit.

Hawwah

He chose to let the authorities deal with them instead of resorting to vigilante justice. Unlike Lupin and Black.

Hawwah

I don't know. The Marauders turned against each other pretty quickly after they graduated Hogwarts. Black suspected Lupin of being a traitor. Lupin suspected Black. Black considered Pettigrew "a weak, talentless thing". Is this how a person talks about his friend? I don't think so. It's implied Potter suspected Lupin too, that's why he didn't tell him about the switch. When Lupin learned that Black betrayed the Potters and murdered Pettigrew, he believed it immediately, zero doubts. He also never visited Black in Azkaban. And don't forget Pettigrew who actually betrayed one of his friends and framed another. With friends like this, who needs enemies?

Melanie P

I completely agree with you about Neville and the password list. I also have a soft spot for Neville. His story is just as tragic as Harry’s. Crookshanks is just a highly intelligent (magical?) cat. When Sirius is in dog form he can communicate with Crookshanks. Love these reviews. I love the idea of a book club, but I resist joining one locally because I don’t like being told what to read and when to read it! Haha

Hawwah

It's not illegal to become an animagus per se. It's illegal to become an UNREGISTERED animagus. If McGonagall was to be imprisoned in Azkaban, they would have needed to adopt extra security measures for sure. I assume that's another reason why the ministry requires animagi to register.

ambiture

mr black?!?!?

Will

Veggie, I would recommend you to react to a fan film by TheMischiefManagers called 1977. Hogsmeade. They don't really make videos anymore but they used to make a lot of Marauders content. I've wanted you to react to their videos for a long time now, but now that you've finally learned the story of the marauders, I think you could try to watch the fan film. I should mention too, in their videos wolfstar (sirius/remus) are a couple.

Sam-I-Am

I wouldn’t say that makes him a better person than Lupin, especially considering how he refuses to listen to the whole story (Lupin admittedly didn’t help by calling him a fool) and basically threatens Lupin with the dementor’s kiss (I agree with Veggie, it was probably just a quip in the heat of the moment but still awful to suggest). He also admits that for him it’s about vengeance, which isn’t exactly noble.

S1lm4r1l

@Sam. Snape straight up says to Black "Give me a reason and I'll do it." He gives every indication that he's prepared to end Black's life. Snape being the cruel person he is decides that a Dementor's kiss would be a suitable punishment for both Sirius and Lupin. No trial, no evidence. Snape as judge and jury. He's the sort of person that should never be in any position of authority or responsibility. And the Dementor's Kiss is reserved for exceptional circumstances and used incredibly sparingly, the Ministry are required to specifically okay it's use on Black. As Dumbledore says "There are far worse things than death." Forcing someone to endure the Dementor's Kiss is one of the worst things one person could do to another in this world. Like, I'm fairly certain most people in the Wizarding World would choose death over it. The idea that Snape was a decent person in this scene is fanciful at best.

Sam-I-Am

@S1lm4r1l I’m not arguing that Snape was a decent person in this scene? In fact, I’m pretty much in agreement with everything you said lol. Snape is just as petty and short sighted as Sirius. Not sure if you replied to me by accident?

Isis Peoples

There may or may not be....I love it

S1lm4r1l

@Sam My bad. I was replying to you because I thought you were downplaying what Snape was doing. He might as well have joked about using the Cruciatus Curse on them. I'm also kinda surprised Snape would be so stupid. Black literally tells him the conditions under which he'd come quietly. But Snape apparently thought antagonism and threats were best. All but guaranteeing the resistance of everyone present. It was arguably Snape at his most selfish. He wanted what he wanted and he wasn't about to let anyone take his 'vengeance' away from him. More concerned with the feeling of victory than the practical reality of keeping Harry safe. *shakes head*

Hawwah

"I would be amazed if somebody read these chapters and thought Snape is just making a big deal out of nothing." Oh you sweet summer child. (Sorry if that sounded patronizing.) Unfortunately, there are many Marauders fans out there that argue exactly that. They unironically call the full-blown murder attempt "a prank" and claim that Severus is a bad person because he can't just "get over" being nearly slaughtered by a friggin' werewolf. According to them Severus should have just laughed about it and forget it. What an amazing advice to a traumatized crime victim. And the never ending victim-blaming. Oh my god, the victim-blaming. People in all seriousness claim that Severus was a moron because he should have suspected Black was sending him to a death trap!!! According to them only an idiot like Snape would not recognize Black was trying to murder him. (I don't think they realize this is not the great pro-Black argument they think it is.) I love discussing Harry Potter but these people suck out all joy from it like the dementors.

Hawwah

Slim, could you please refrain from commenting in my threads? I don't want your nonsense in my e-mail inbox. Thank you.

Sam-I-Am

@S1lm4r1l no worries! I think an argument can be made that him wanting to call the dementors on Sirius was somewhat justified (I don’t personally agree with this), but it’s indefensible in Lupin’s case. As I said, I think he said it in the heat of the moment, but it’s still awful.

Lisette C.

Mr. Black is absolutely the least fitting name for Sirius imo 😆 He is the least Mr-like person in the books 😅

Hawwah

Thanks, Michelle! I have a feeling Veggie won't be on the Marauders side when we get to SWM.

Hawwah

Darcy's accusation that Severus knew it was Pettigrew and not Black who betrayed the Potters has no basis in the books. Severus thought Black was the person who betrayed Lily to Voldemort and now escaped Azkaban to finish the job by killing Harry. Also, since Darcy refers to Severus' near-death experience and resulting trauma as "a high school grudge" I think there's a possibility s/he might be a bit biased against him.

Katik

Mr Black I should probably start taking notes listening to your reviews. So many things I want to comment about and I start typing my comments, then that gets usually answered a few hours later or someone else beats me to it here. This time around I think nearly everything I was going to comment on got addressed before the end, so I'm just going to say we really appreciate these reviews Veggie, and they always make my day! (and drastically reduce my productivity at work for that day :) )

Jake M

Mr Black. I'm not sure if there's ever been an official answer as to why Pettigrew chose the Weasleys, but I imagined he chose a well-known wizarding family with no connection to the dark arts, so he could keep in the loop but without fear of being recognised (if anyone even knew he was an animagus). I wasn't really aware of how controversial the Marauders were until this book club, but it makes me wonder whether this is the reason the movie barely makes mention of them, in order to avoid a fuss (for wont of a better word)? Going back to the whole 'movie characters must be perfect' ethos they had with Hermione 🙄 can't show Harry's family/role models being bullies, after all!

Methanoutput

Hey Hawwah, I wish I would have thought about this when I wrote my comment for the book club, but since you brought up the 'prank' again, I'm just gonna write this here. But who do you think would be guilty if Snape died? For example, if a child tells another child to stick a fork into a power outlet, is the first child a murderer? I just think there should have been more efforts to keep Lupin away from other students. We know that Dumbledore can draw an age restricting line that keeps anyone away from the inside. Why didn't he do that with the Shrieking Shack? Lupin doesn't get outside, everyone else doesn't get inside. I know it would destroy the plot, but if I had to choose someone who is guilty, then it would be Dumbledore or the staff of Hogwarts that was responsible to keep the other students safe from Lupin.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Sorry I missed commenting on this episode 😢 I was on holiday in Orlando (and yes I went to wizarding world and yes it was amazing) I would have said something about pettigrew being weirdly intimately familiar with Ron 🤣 “I was your rat!”

Hawwah

Hi Jonas, I think your question about the two children isn't worded very well. First problem is how you define "children". Are you talking about two 5-year olds, two 17-year olds or one 5-year old and one 17-year old? My answers would change depending on that. Second problem is did the first child know what would happen or not? Sirius Black was 16 years old when he attempted to murder Severus Snape. He had at least partial criminal responsibility. He also knew perfectly well what he was doing. The Marauders became animagi specifically because they couldn't keep werewolf Lupin company as humans. They knew it wasn't safe. Itsadancething's theory that Black believed the werewolf would just spook Severus but not attack him makes no sense. I completely agree with you about Dumbledore. He was an atrociously bad headmaster. I could rant about his incompetence all day long. That doesn't absolve Black's responsibility, though. If Severus had been killed by werewolf Remus, Black would have been guilty of murder and Dumbedore would have been guilty of public endangerment.

Sam-I-Am

Awww I hope you're able to come around on the marauders! I know it wasn't the best introduction, especially after having just "met" the movie versions of them where their backstories and complexities and flaws were glossed over (never considered how jarring that must be), but I do think they are good to the core. So wish HBO had given us a marauders prequel show These re-reads have really reminded me just how wonderful Lupin truly is. The point about him not being able to hide or run away from his biggest fear was so poignant. Breaks my heart to think about what he must have gone through in the time between the Potters' deaths and coming to Hogwarts as the new DADA professor. Love these reviews! Thanks for all the time you put into them Veggie. Also, really appreciate that you look for the good in all of the characters. So, so, so excited the Goblet of Fire book clubs and reviews to start up as it's my favorite of the whole series (we're almost there)!!!!

Isis Peoples

Yes it may be "Opinion" that James and Sirius are the smartest of their age, however consider. They managered to become Animagus, an extremely difficult task They created the freaking Maarauders Map, a very powerful peice of parchment They might have been arrogant bullies yes, but that doesn't negate their intelligence. One could argue Peter was pretty damn intelligent too, even if he is a rat!

Sam-I-Am

Agreed Dara, it was an extraordinary friendship. Makes it all the more tragic that their trust in Peter led to their downfall.

Annette Elliott

Part of the reason why Pettigrew chose the Weasley family is because Arthur works at the Ministry and he would hear if there was any sign of Voldemort or if someone was looking for him. I believe it's mentioned by Lupin that James went to stop Snape the minute he heard what Sirius had done. In dragging Snape out of the tunnel he very well could have lost his own life or become a werewolf but James didn't hesitate. Was he doing it partly to protect both Sirius and Lupin? Definitely. However, he also didn't want Snape to die. He may have despised Snape and Snape's fascination with dark magic but he didn't wish him dead. I think a tiny part of it too was to make up for how he'd treated Snape before.

Monique

He didn't murder them because he wanted them to have hte kiss, universally known in the wizarding world as a fate worse than death. I'm baffled why you apply such noble intentions to Snape here, or anywhere to be honest. He was treated badly and he has treated badly. No one is innocent in the relationship between him and the marauders or him and the trio. Snape spends 7 books begrudgingly helping Harry while bullying the ever loving heck out of him and his friends. Let's also not forget that the marauders may well have been bullies but Snape was not innocent there. Think back on why Lily ended her friendship with him. He was willingly friends with death eaters and was one himself. His friend group were also bullies. People who think the marauders were faultless are definitely looking at them through rose colored glasses but this insistence that Snape was some long suffering victim is also not realistic when you look at his character as a whole.

Monique

Several times in this book Dumbledore has to be short with Snape to get him to stop with the Lupin hate. He went out of his way to try to out Lupin over and over again during the year and he is the one who flat out tells his entire house about Lupin. He is forced to be civil to and about Lupin numerous times so the idea that he is forced to make the potion for him is a completely reasonable inference.

Jake M

Off-topic but your last comment got me thinking, I'm amazed how far out of the Potterverse the concept of Dementors have spread! I was watching snooker a few weeks ago (sport, very hard to explain its appeal 😂) and one of the commentators said the players sucked all motivation out of his opponents "like a dementor" 😂 It was so out of the blue, and makes me wonder what other Potter concepts are well known by the average person.

Hawwah

Victim blaming, reprimanding misbehaving students is bullying, more victim blaming, yada yada yada. Always the same old boring stuff. Next time come up with something fresh and original.

Hawwah

That IS amazing!

Hawwah

"I do think they are good to the core." You wouldn't think that if you were their victim.

Sam-I-Am

@Hawwah same could be said for Neville, Hermione, and other students Snape has treated awfully. To be clear, I'm not saying Snape's bullying (I know you don't see it that way, but I and other fans do and there is basis for that) is comparable to Sirius's awful "prank," but they're victims nonetheless. I've said multiple times I don't condone what the marauders did, it was wrong and dangerous. Snape has every right to dislike, distrust, and never forgive them. But that doesn't mean that they're bad, irredeemable people. Like every other character, they're flawed.

Sam-I-Am

@Monique wish I could insert an applause gif here lol. Perfectly stated in my opinion! 👏👏👏 As JK Rowling herself said: "Snape is all grey. You can't make him a saint: he was vindictive & bullying. You can't make him a devil: he died to save the wizarding world"

Kunzite Blossom

I don't think I could ever think of Sirius as "Mr. Black" It's just too weird. I don't think any first reader would connect the pieces with Crookshanks UNTIL the explanation. I grew up on the movies, having struggled with reading early in my life. Even though I enjoy reading now, I find it hard to read a book after seeing the movie so the audio books really were a life saver for me. The first time I listened, I was so amazed at Crookshanks. It really makes all the re-reads (or re-listenes in my case) more fun when you can connect the pieces. It's like "oh! That makes sense now!" Absolutely love it.

Kunzite Blossom

Oh! I just loved their channel! It's always fun watching fan films! Too soon now, as Veggie hasn't met a character yet (even though shes minor) but "Sisters of House Black" from Kelsey Ellison would also make a great watch eventually.

Kunzite Blossom

100% James would save Snape to protect his friends from any serious trouble. Sirius could have been in so much trouble if it was found out he caused Snape to go down there and let Lupin kill Snape. Not sure Lupin would have been in trouble, as he couldn't help himself when transformed. But I do like the idea that part of him would want to save Snape anyway. I do agree that as much as James despised him and bullied him, he would never wish death on anyone. I think it just depends. I can't remember if it's said but when did this "prank" happen in comparison to when Snape called Lily the M word? I would think prior, James would save Snape out of respect for Lily as Snape was her friend. If it's after, I can't see why James would care. He probably would be mad at Snape for being rude to Lily like that. I don't think James would do it to make up for how he treated Snape at that point.

Josh Z

But James from my memory is shown to care a great deal about what Lilly thinks of him, so I think he would still save Snape, first to show Lilly his maturity and then because it was the noble thing to do.

S1lm4r1l

Hawwah, You're one of the very few people that thinks they should be able to spout their headcanons without contradiction. If anyone disagrees with you, you insist they don't talk to you. You've done this with other people and not just me. If you disagree with what I've got to say, then explain your views instead of placing ever more irritating restrictions on me. "Don't reply to me. Don't reply to other people replying to comments I make. Don't reply to me because I don't want to receive e-mail notifications." Don't want to receive e-mail notifications? TURN THEM OFF. I'm genuinely at a loss for how you can possibly think that Snape was not willing to commit murder. It's right there in the text. "Give me a reason and I'll do it, I swear I will." The Marauders were bullies, but at least they bullied their peers, their equals. Snape bullies his students, and he actively picks on students that aren't as well liked in his classes. Neville, Hermione and Harry. If Dumbledore didn't need him, I don't think he'd allow Snape to teach there.

S1lm4r1l

> "I can't remember if it's said but when did this "prank" happen in comparison to when Snape called Lily the M word?" The 'prank' occurred before the Mudblood incident. I'm 99% sure James and Sirius were already Animagi by the time of the Mudblood incident.

S1lm4r1l

If Snape can be a good person, despite being a bully. It logically follows that the Marauders can be too. What is good for the goose, is good for the gander. Harry manages to overcome his feelings about Snape and recognise his contribution to the betterment of the Wizarding World.

Michelle Linardis

Anytime, Hawaah! Oh yes, especially when he discovers that SWM happened after the werewolf incident. And all the hints we see of Severus looking out for Harry...There is a lot the movies didn't show, which is a shame. The limits in the films further fuel the Snape-hate. With Veggie knowing Severus' true loyalties, I should expect he'd be able to see Severus' scenes differently.

Michelle Linardis

[Remus Lupin] "You're the cleverest witch of your age I've ever met, Hermione." "I'm not," Hermione whispered. "If I'd been a bit cleverer, I'd have told everyone what you are!" [CH17] "What sort of animal --?" Harry began, but Hermione cut him off. "That was still really dangerous! Running around in the dark with a werewolf! What if you'd given the others the slip, and bitten somebody?" "A thought that still haunts me," said Lupin heavily. "And there were near misses, many of them. We laughed about them afterwards. We were young, thoughtless -- carried away with our own cleverness." "I sometimes felt guilty about betraying Dumbledore's trust, of course...he had admitted me to Hogwarts when no other headmaster would have done so, and he had no idea I was breaking the rules he had set down for my own and others' safety. He never knew I had led three fellow students into becoming Animagi illegally. But I always managed to forget my guilty feelings every time we sat down to plan our next month's adventure. And I haven't changed..." [CH18] +++ Severus has every right to his disdain against Lupin, and Hermione has the same prejudice, too. But somehow people are willing to have a laugh over Severus close to being murdered/injured/turned back at school and wonder why adult Severus is still angry about it. One of his bullies is a werewolf, and one of his other bullies (as the rest of the wizarding world believed) is a convicted murderer. And he was more in his right to call upon the dementors - the guards of Azkaban. Because from Severus' POV, Sirius was still a murderer of those Muggles/sold out the Potters, and Lupin helped said convicted murderer. Instead of mocking Severus and poking the bull, or dismissing his horrific ordeal, Lupin and Sirius should have approached it differently instead of invalidating it. That made Severus more angry, and he is allowed to be.

Sam-I-Am

How is this showing Hermione to be prejudice? It being dangerous for James, Peter, and Sirius to run around at night with a werewolf is quite literally a fact that even Lupin acknowledges. And to compare Hermione's reaction to how Snape treats Lupin kinda seems like a stretch. Yes, Snape has every right to dislike and distrust Lupin. But that doesn't make his prejudice against Lupin okay. And while he may have had a right to call the dementors on Sirius, it's completely out of line where Lupin is concerned. First, because that's not his decision to make. Second, he has no proof that Lupin actually helped Sirius. Third, even if he had helped Sirius - the dementor's kiss is worse than death, I don't think think they would have given Lupin that sentence. Absolutely nobody here is laughing at Snape being nearly murdered/injured/turned. Maybe other Potterheads have in other forums, which is absolutely wrong, but I haven't seen any comments on here doing that. All comments have condemned what Sirius did and the bullying of Snape at the hands of the marauders. I understand why Snape fans get defensive, but it's incredibly disingenuous and frustrating to see the constant downplaying of Snape's own faults. He is not faultless and his intentions aren't always noble/great. JK Rowling herself has stated that Snape too was a bully and vindictive. And you know what, that's okay. No character is perfect, just as no person is perfect. That doesn't erase the good that he did, just adds to the complexity and tragedy of his character

Michelle Linardis

Hermione whispered. "If I'd been a bit cleverer, I'd have told everyone what you are!" [CH17] Need I repeat it? Yes, Hermione was prejudiced. 'What you are'. But people will condemn Severus for it, and not Hermione. Severus intended to call the dementors - no one said anything about the dementors sucking out his soul then and there. The dementors would have captured him and subdued him until they brought him back to Azkaban. It would have been Fudge's decision - which it was - and will soon be known to Veggie. Remus was keeping secrets from Dumbledore - pieces of information that would have resolved this far earlier. As far as everyone else was concerned, they assumed he may have been protecting Black. And Severus is rightfully allowed to think that way. I see many Snape bashers here in Veggies comments happily condemning away without the entire context and blinded by bias. In fact, there are people who blame Snape for the werewolf incident and wish he had died there or say that he deserved to be bullied. It is Snape bashers who are unreasonable and condemn him for things beyond Severus' control. And they don't bother with logic or fact, only who is more fun to hate. Severus is flawed like everyone else - I see him as human with very real, human emotions - but turning him into the devil incarnate in every scene is in is unwarranted. Double-standards. The childish hate and vilifying of a character such as Severus is tiresome to see. I never once see him as faultless. I place blame where blame is actually warranted and logical. The difference here is that Severus KNEW his faults and his mistakes, and spent the rest of his dismal life trying to atone for them. And yet still people view him as the devil incarnate. People only want to see superficially and not deeper. Snape fans see deeper.

Sam-I-Am

Tbh most of the double standards and vilifying I've seen on here has actually been by Snape defenders. I've seen multiple people here use both logic and facts to point out that Snape often times didn't have the most noble intentions. While some people are obviously biased, I haven't seen anyone blinded by it or ignoring context. People are allowed to dislike and condemn Snape for bullying students just as people are allowed to dislike and condemn the marauders for bullying Snape. ETA: I don't see Hermione saying "what you are" as proof that she's prejudice. She is not saying it in a derogatory way, but literally just stating that she should have told everyone what he is...a werewolf. Another huge difference and factor is that Hermione is a 13 year old girl in a confusing, scary, and heightened situation. Snape is an adult. After this one instance, we never hear or see anything that would indicate Hermione's prejudice against Lupin. The same can't be said for Snape

Michelle Linardis

If you are going to condemn a character, condemn him for what they actually did, not what you assume he did, or wish he did. Condemn him with facts, not headcanon or opinions. Hate for a fictional character is tiresome. Allow people to like who they like, and stop criticising people for it. That is where Snape bashers get it wrong. Every single time, and the reason the HP fandom can be so toxic and hostile. Your opinion is your own. I am not required to follow it.

Sam-I-Am

Same could be said for a lot of Snape defenders in the comments here. I've seen a lot of twisting of facts and incredible reaches to paint Snape out to be the most noble character. It's your right to view Snape through rose-colored glasses, but others are allowed to voice their opinions and disagreements. I don't see that as "bashing" or being toxic, hostile. What fun would it be if everyone had the same viewpoint or opinion? This is an interactive discussion forum. As far as I've seen, everyone here has been incredibly respectful ETA: Nobody is criticizing Snape fans for liking Snape (everyone is allowed their favorites). People are criticizing the twisting of facts and the downplaying of his faults.

Monique

Hawah, Your responses to nearly everyone, but those who agree with you, are exceedingly upleasant and, in many cases, downright rude. Clearly no real discussion or debate with you is possible. As a result, I will no longer address your comments directly after this and would appreciate it if you would do the same for any comment I make. As you felt it was appropriate let me mirror your words back to you. "I don't want your nonsense in my e-mail inbox."

Monique

I always wondered if he did it partly for Lily. I'm sure James didn't get to that point without knowing lily and Snape had been friends and good friends at that and it would cause her pain if he were killed or hurt. +

Michelle Linardis

I don't see Severus through rose-colored glasses. I see him with logical ones. The only ones twisting facts are those determined to hate him no matter what the book text tells us. The amount of BS I can debunk with comments under Veggie's videos alone is far too much to warrant a discussion. People will stay seeped in their hate, and try and feed Veggie with incorrect information. Every single time. No one's asking to all adopt the same opinion. But the constant vilifying of a character is so irritating, and childish, IS toxic. People should keep their negativity to themselves and let people enjoy things, reactors included. I hate James with a passion, but I don't go around to pro-James comments on every other social media and tell them what a horrible person James is, just to purposely ignite a heated debate. Snape bashers should learn this lesson, but instead, they like to attack Snape fans for liking the character they do. We have factual reasons why we like him, and it's a shame people are so obsessed with their hate and headcanon to see reason.

Sam-I-Am

Nobody is feeding Veggie incorrect information. I'm sorry you feel that way. Not liking Snape and pushing back on the narrative that Snape was always noble/right/justified does not equal bashing.

Kevin Morris

Mr. Black I always interpreted the statement about werewolves only being a danger to people to mean that a werewolf could only pass on lycanthropy (werewolfism) to a human being. Like Lupin as a werewolf could bite James or Sirius in their Animagus form and hurt them but they wouldn't be at risk of becoming werewolves because they were animals at the time. As far as Sirius being able to communicate with Crookshanks, I always assumed that it was a case of when he's an animal he could communicate with other animals almost empathically. It would make sense for the Marauders because it would be a way for them to communicate amongst themselves when on their adventures in their animal forms since they wouldn't be capable of talking.

Michelle Linardis

I see it all the time in the comments Veggie receives for both the book club and the general comments. Hell, even the chapter summaries are obviously anti-Snape. You can hate a character - but don't plaster it all over a social media forum where fans are present, and reactors are trying to formulate their own opinions (I'm saying this for everyone). And then wonder why Snape fans get defensive. You would be too, if I go to tear down your favorite character, without using facts as to why. I'm just saying - maybe see things from the other POV. We just want to have our comment and shed light on where things get easily misinterpreted or misread. Instead, we can't enjoy forums like this where many comments are so anti, it's repulsive. I like human characters and ones who are flawed and relatable. Why condemn someone for it? I like characters with a dark past, yet still found a way to push through it and do the right thing in the end. I like characters who admit to their mistakes - it's factual that we know this of Severus when Lily was targeted/died. I like characters with growth and human relatability. I like characters who get angry for very real reasons, where people expect them to be kind and patient. Severus was abused and used for all his life. It's almost like Snape bashers get frustrated that we don't demonise him enough to their liking.

Monique

Thanks Sam. I find it so odd when either side insists almost anyone in these books is all good or all bad. That seems to me to be one of the constant threads and overarching lessons in this entire series. People are fallible and human. It's why JK gave her heroes faults and her villians redeeming moments. No doubt , Snape is supposed to be a villian who willingly fought for Voldy but does some admirable things, often because forced but he does do them. He stood by his word to Dumbledore which is no small thing. That said, he was forced into that through is own actions which ulitmately killed the woman he loved. There is really no redeeming that. Unlike Sirius, someone did die because of Snape's actions. Multiple someones so this insistence that he can be redeemed but no one else can be just makes no sense to me at all. No doubt, James is supposed to be a hero. He died for his wife and son as well as because he fought against Voldy. He did a stupid, mean thing as a child but when push came to shove he chose not to be a death eater, not to allow Snape to be attacked by Lupin, not to allow Lupin to live with the emotional toll that would have taken on him. We get a grand total of one real instance of James being awful to Snape and people start throwing around how they hate him. A character we have no real backstory on and who is dead. Dead becaue of the actions of the man whose life he saved. Sirius was an outcast in his own family who was left to go live at a friends house once the rejection of those who should have loved him became too much. In no world would anyone look at a teenager forced to do that as anything other than an abused child. He was an angry, disaffected boy who knew that some dark-magic loving death eater to be had been doing whatever he could to find a way to get them expelled and he lashed out. It was wrong. It was stupid. It was human. He then spent 12 years in prison, guarded by some of the most feared creatures in the world. He more than paid the price for what he did to Snape. Sirius, for all intents and purposes, lost his life the day that Pettigrew set him up. He spent the rest of his life locked up or on the run for something he didn't do. I appreciate that people apply aspects of the story to their own lives and have favorites but objective reality means that aside from Umbridge and Vernon who are 100% evil and Lily who is 100% good, there isn't any character who escapes the moral gray area of being a human being.

Harry Savill

You mentioned the James publicly humiliating snape scene … there may or may not be an entire chapter dedicated to it in order of the pheonix

Janie

Mr. Black! I just wanted to say, that I never realised that the movies never said that James was an Animagus. I knew the Marauders story was never explained but I always somehow assumed that it was obvious that James was an Animagus. That means that the movies failed more than I'd thought. Speaking about James, I think that he saved Snape mostly because he wanted to avoid being expelled or getting Sirius in trouble. And of course, because he didn't want Lupin to be a killer. But I also think he would have saved him anyway. Sirius clearly didn't care whether Snape would be hurt or killed, but he was raised by a family that loved dark arts. His views of what was right or wrong might have been a little distorted. James on the other hand grew up in a loving family that hated dark arts. He knew what was right and wrong. I think he just realised that what Sirius had done was over the line.

S1lm4r1l

@Monique The way I'd describe it is this: James was a good person who occasionally did terrible things. Snape was a bad person who occasionally did good things. Sirius's childhood and youth represent a blueprint for creating an adult death eater. He's pure blood. He's rich. His family prided themselves on being Slytherins. They even decorated their house in the colours of Green and Silver. His family owned a variety of dark artefacts and presumably knew a lot of dark magic. He was disaffected, emotionally distant from his entire family, he had a disregard for life he didn't value (like Snape) and was fully prepared to play dangerous tricks on people that might result in their deaths. He was clever, gifted, talented and angry. Voldemort couldn't dream of a better candidate to recruit than Sirius. Despite that, he never became a Death Eater, never wanted to become a Death Eater. He fought Voldemort right from the start. Invariably, it seems like what people like in the Marauders they excuse in Snape, and vice versa.

Dara Jeeling

Monique - I think I am also one of those people who sees more good then bad in Snape, so let me try... For me - yes it's Snapes fault that Voldemore learned about the prophecy - BUT he pleasdy with Voldemort (at least at Lilys behalf) AND he is not the one who breaks the Fidelius charm. Yes, he is responsible for the Potters being under it - but for me the one who is the reason they die is Pettigrew. Also for me ( and this is only my headcanon and I just want to share it) - Snape was sort of coerced into the Death Eaters - since due to the incessant bullying by the Marauders he had little to no choice as to which people would be willing to be seen with him. As stated, I was bullyied in school and it got that far, that whoever tried to be civil with me was also bullied. So it was hard to find people who were willing to put up with that. That's how I see Snapes situation. A group of talented and beloved fellow students bullied him - and I am sure almost all of Gryffindor (maybe except Lily) was not wiling to go against that. Also not sure how many other students would sort of risk being targets as well. I do not say Snape was just a lovely boy -I thin he gave as good as he got - but still it was almost always 4 on 1 So for me the only people who would be willing to be seen with him would have been his own house - which made his situation with Lily worse. I think Snape has some redeeming actions - but I will gladly accept he is not a good teacher (probably he never even wante to teach - I have gone to explain that in lenght before. He did not have a choice, Dumbledore made him teach after safing him from Azkaban) As for the Marauders - I admire their bond of school friendship and the lenght they go to to be with Remus. For me James is better then Sirius - at leas as we learn he turned into a decend enough being that Lily thought he was worth her love. nonetheless he was a bully to Snape, just because he wanted Lily to be in Slytherin (that's what started it all). I do see that he did good things later on. (I am not a fan o Lily - for how she treated Snape. The M word is a bad thing, still I think a long lasting friendship and Snape trying to apologize shoud ahve meant something. Also one should take into account the situation). Again I am not saying Snape is lovely and I believe he called other the M word as well. Still I think it's so not fun to be humiliated and stripped before the person you love. Teenagers can lash out. You say, you think it's unfair to give Snape redeeming actions - but believe me after 20 yearsof always hearing the same 3 things about why Sape is such a bad person - one can et fed up. I am totally okay with Snape being grey (in fact that's what makes him that interesting) but then - I also think James and Sirius are grey characters as well (and so is Dumbledore, Ms Weasley, hell even Lupin and Hermione) You argue, that Sirius was a abused child, but so was Snape and Snape did not have the luxury of a)money b) a place he could escape to (as Sirisús had with James). So if you get the moment of doubt towards Sirius - please give it to Sape as well. For me Sapes backstory is tragic. He was abused as a child and had no loving parents and no oneto look out for him (apart from child Lily) - he is always described as scrawny / to thin - so I think it's not a stretch to think his whole childhood was misery. Also excuse me... The Marauders had been bullying Snape for years - so I think he had a right to try and protect himself with whatever way he could fine - even trying to get them expelled. Not that it would have worked - because Dunderbore... and it' stated that they always ever went on 4/1 on him - so not matter what - that is also really dark grey I am not okay, for Sirius being in Azkaban for 12 years - but I do not think that redeems his "prank". Because if that doe it, then surely Snape living in misery because of his actions shoudl also redeem him... and I do disagree on Lily being 100% good - if she was, she would have stood by Snape (for me). So for me even Lily has her flaws - minor ones - but she has them. Again - I see the flaws in almost all characters and I am one who is NOT a MOlly Weasley fan for what she will put Hermione trough. But then... I am usually willing to argue and see reason in other peoples points. I am just not really happy with people who do not take other peoples ideas in account and stay in their corner like forever.

S1lm4r1l

I don't think he did it for Lily, but if he played up his heroics later on, it was to impress her.

Dara Jeeling

I should have stated that differently, sorry. The Marauders school friendship - although even then I do not think Peter was being as appreciated as the others

S1lm4r1l

+1 Janie. That's pretty much what I think too.

Dara Jeeling

at SamIAm can I disagree with you? for me (maybe Lupin) the Marauders are not good to the core. They are amazing friends for each other (whilst being in school - although I think Peter was probably not as appreciated as he would have loved to be), but I think they were also bad people for teaming up 4/1 on another student (and sorry for that - I do not believe it was only Snape they did that to - bullies never do). I can accept, that James gew up to be a decend person and Lupin for sure was a good person (even if he tried to abandon his pregnant wife). I think Sirius never really grew up and missed his Hogwarts time - carefree and fun for him. BUT he tried to be decend for Harry. I still think it would not be fun to be in Snapes class, if you are not Slytherin but he never wanted to be a teacher - he was forced into teaching by Dumbledore, after he safed him from Azkaban. For me, being a teach means to have passion for people and be fair - not matter what your personal feelings ( being professional) so yeah... I hope that makes sense.

Sam-I-Am

@Dara you could totally disagree with me! I see what you’re saying, but as far as we know Snape was the only person they bullied. Yes, it was horrible of them. But should that one thing define them for the rest of their lives? Are they irredeemable, bad people? I personally don’t think so, obviously lol. See, this is where it gets a tad frustrating - Snape treats some of his students horribly, relayed information that led to the death of 2 people, made the choice to become a Death Eater. Yet Snape fans find ways to excuse and justify his actions. That he’s ultimately a good person. But James, Sirius, and Lupin are forever bad people because they bullied Snape (who wasn’t faultless) as teenagers? It just seems a tad hypocritical

Anniinii

Really love these in depth reviews on the books, Veggie! Talking about the "prank" on Snape I have to say, neither Sirius nor Snape is entirely innocent. Sirius wouldn't even have the opportunity to lure Severus like this, if it wasn't for him trying to find out where Lupin was going every month. And let's be honest here, if he would have found out, he would have told everyone at school, which probably would have let to Lupin leaving Hogwarts. Severus only kept quite, cause Dumbledore told him to. And Sirius, no need to defend him here. What he did was horrible and could have ended in Severus dying - if that was his intent or not. Speaking in general about the character of Snape - One can feel sorry for the teenage Snape and still see that his behaviour as an adult towards student's was horrible.

Lili

Hi Veggie, long time no comment, but I've been dutifully watching every video and loving every second of them 🙂 Sirius is one of my absolute favourite characters, he is so wonderfully complex. He was definitely an arrogant ass in a lot of ways in school, and some of his actions are totally indefensible - I mean, he should have been at least expelled for the Whomping Willow incident. He was an often rash and careless individual. Yet, he was also a fiercely loyal friend, and was willing to risk his life to fight against Voldemort and the ideals of blood purity at such a young age. He is to his core a morally grey character, as all the most interesting characters are, and I see his life as an extremely sad one in most respects. I mean, he grew up in an insanely messed up and I can imagine miserable, abusive environment, feeling repulsed by the majority of his family, then he went to Hogwarts and found belonging, only to leave school and join the Order, lose all of his best friends in one fell swoop, have the entire wizarding community believe he was a murderer and Death Eater, and live with the guilt of feeling responsible for James' death while being tortured by dementors for 12 years, not to mention his life once he escapes. Just like with Snape, I can see where his flaws stem from. I also have to give kudos to him for the fact that despite the fact his upbringing (surrounded by Dark Arts and a family that loved them) would have made most people turn to the "dark side" and join Voldemort, he never once developed a hatred of muggles or a desire to become a Death Eater. I do sometimes think that the way people talk about Snape and the Marauders time in school can become a bit one sided. As awful as many of the actions of the Marauders were, Snape was no angel either, and did himself hang around with known bullies (the group who would go on to become Death Eaters), found humour in their bullying, and had no qualms with delving deep into the Dark Arts, to the point of inventing a spell as dangerous and dark as Sectumsempra while a student. I do see some cognitive dissonance with people who can recognise how bad bullying is when it comes from the Marauders, but will excuse Snape for his bullying, especially the bullying he inflicts on his students as an adult. Bullying is wrong, end of. Don't get me wrong, I have a lot of sympathy for Snape in many ways, especially when it comes to his homelife as a child and any bullying he endured, but he was no saint either, and was not some shrinking violet in school (imo). But anyway, that's just my 2 cents :) apologies for the novel!

Monique

Yes, I've seen you say these things already. I understand your affection for Snape and derision for the marauders. I simply disagree but thanks for expressing your opinion about it. I never said I don't think it's fair to apply any redemption to Snape, but I do not think being responsible for the death of Lily and James is redeemable. Not at all. For me his trying to protect only Lily and being willing to throw her husband and a literal baby to Voldemort is repugnant and he gets zero credit for that from me. Let's not forget that Snape, as a very young child, was nasty about Petunia who was also a child left behind in a state of envious jealousy. Snape always had a nasty streak so we can't blame his tendency towards nastiness on being bullied at school. That argument falls apart in the face of his tendencies before ever setting foot in Hogwarts. I do think expecting Lily to stand by anyone who would willingly call her a mudblood to pacify his friends (talk about bullies and bullying) is an ask too far. She wasn't cruel to him and after his behavior towards her, that is all that could be asked of her. In the 12 years Siruis was in Azkaban being tortured, Snape had the freedom and opportunity to improve as a human being. Nothing indicates he actually did other than following through on his agreement with Dumbledore. Your reference to Dumbledore as Dunderboreis where I will stop responding to your comment. I'm not into that sort of name changing to insult, thanks though.

Monique

I basically agree. I've always found it so interesting that people forgive Draco and laud him for not, at heart, being into the dark ways and only is awful because of his families influence. At the same there is this demonization of Sirius who was raised by the same family with the same biases and preferences. Truth be told, Sirius isn't anywhere near my favorite character. He's rash, irresponsible and a terrible role model for Harry, in the books especially, Nearly every decision he ever made in his life was wrong and people were hurt. He paid the price. 12 years of it, in Azkaban ;-)

Hawwah

Why is reprimanding a misbehaving student "bullying" only when Snape does it, but not when it's McGonagall?

Hawwah

Yes, protecting students is horrible. He should have been more like Hagrid and constantly put their lives at risk, that would have made him a good person in the fandom's eyes.

Anniinii

You can protect a student without being mean to them, with compassion, for example. Which would have made it a lot easier for students he needed to protect to trust him. I'm not saying he didn't protect them, I'm saying the way he did it wasn't necessary :)

Lili

Hi Hawwah. I think Snapes treatment of his students often goes far beyond simple reprimanding, personally. I mean, take for example his reaction to Hermione when she is hit by the engorgement charm in GoF - "I see no difference". Under no circumstances should a grown adult, let alone one with authority, mock the appearance of a teenage girl. Imo that is reprehensible, and definite bullying.

Hawwah

Monique, you realize it was you who started this conversation, by replying to my comment, right? I will respect your wish and not comment on your posts from now on. In return I expect the same from you regarding my posts. I think it's only fair.

Hawwah

Do you really think Severus could have afforded to express concern for a muggleborn student in front of at least 4 children of Death Eaters? Especially since he knew that Voldemort was getting stronger every day and that very soon he will have to convince him he remained a loyal Death Eater?

Lili

Even if that was the case, would you not agree that there is a difference between showing a lack of concern and outright mocking/taunting her for her looks? That was a very pointed personal attack on a young girl for her physical appearance, which I personally find vindictive and uncalled for under any circumstances... I mean, he's a grown man.

itsanursething

Mr. Black. Also…JUSTICE FOR NEVILLE!!! Going to preface this by saying I haven’t read anyone else’s comment on the video, so if I’m repeating information please forgive me :) People aren't born animagi. I don't think the process is fully explained in the books, but it takes months of prep work and potions and spells and trials to even ATTEMPT to become one. And even then a lot of people aren't successful. It's extremely advanced magic. There's a step-by-step on how to become an animagus on the wizarding world website. But don't look at it until after you read Goblet of Fire! And you're right, as far as I'm aware, you don't get to choose what animal you turn into. It just happens. Regarding the illegality of animagi, it's only if you DON'T register that it becomes illegal. If someone is successful in their transformation, they MUST register with the Ministry. Anyone can try, but again, it's super difficult so most people are likely to be unsuccessful. Considering how advanced the magic is to become an animagus AND the fact that they literally invented the Marauder's Map...I'd say James and Sirius were pretty dang smart! Smartest in the school...I don't know. That may just be Lupin's opinion of the two of them. Interesting question about McGonagall’s opinion of Lupin in that scene in the shack! My mind immediately goes to Philosopher’s Stone and the troll. In the movie, she bursts in and says, “explain yourselves!” In the books, she just asks questions (e.g. what were you thinking?). I think McGonagall is level headed enough to see that no one is in immediate danger and would demand an explanation.

itsanursething

@Hawwah you misinterpreted what I said. I never theorized that werewolf Lupin would just scare Snape and not attack. What I meant was, I think Sirius assumed Snape would follow the tunnel to the shack, SEE Lupin transformed without Lupin seeing him and that in and of itself would scare him. I never said he thought Lupin wouldn't attack. Did Sirius think about how Snape would get out? Or if he would get out safely? No, obviously not. He was a dumb teenage boy. They don't tend to think things through. I questioned in a comment if Sirius and Peter were already in the shack in animagus form and could then try to prevent an attack (we don't know if this was true, but maybe that's why Sirius was less concerned). Again, I'm just questioning because we don't get the FULL story. A lot of my comments are theories and questions that pop into my head as I read. I'm allowed to say "what if" about things. But please don't put words in my mouth and please don't call me out in a comment unless it's directly replying to me. It feels very much like the bullying attacks you condemn so much.

Hawwah

If I misinterpreted your theory, I'm very sorry. I didn’t do it on purpose. I'm afraid I still don't understand your theory, though. It seems we both agree Black KNEW that werewolf Lupin was going to attack Severus. If that's the case I don’t see how it was *not* a murder attempt, then.

John Phillips

I'm just going to say that the "Great Snape Debate" that's going on in the comments right now is so exhausting and it's only going to get worse as we get to the later books. I love the books, but I really don't like the fandom and this is one of the reasons why. I do think one side of the Snape debate is far worse than the other though. Those who have read my comments and replies can probably guess which side I'm talking about.

VEGGIE GAMER

Hi guys. It breaks my heart to have to put out a message like this, but I have had multiple messages from people saying they feel uncomfortable leaving comments here because of aggressive replies they are getting. This is NOT why I started this channel. I wanted to create a place where everyone is welcome. From what I am hearing, people feel they are getting shut down just for having a DIFFERENT OPINION. Please, stop looking for arguments and just let people have their own opinion. I have a lot of life struggles right now and having to mediate this is REALLY not ok right now. LET OTHER PEOPLE HAVE THEIR OPINIONS. None of this matters and it is honestly making me unwell with stress.

Kunzite Blossom

Thank you for this Veggie. It's totally understandable people will have different views, and it should be a free space to really discuss it, not argue and just turn people down for their views.

Kunzite Blossom

Thank you! I honestly could not remember the exact time line for the two events. I had a feeling it was before, but not being sure I wanted to give takes on both.

Hawwah

I agree with Michelle. Severus Snape is one of the few HP characters who actually admitted they had done something wrong and atoned for it.

Michelle Linardis

It is completely tiresome to deal with the frequent hate comments every time I intend to write a comment to you. It makes these threads hostile, and some of us can't write a simple comment without being attacked for it every single time. If I could block, I would without a second thought. If people can stop hating and enjoy the story for what it is and what we've been shown, the world would be a happier place. It's now no longer a safe space for some of us, and that is very disheartening. People need to let others have their opinion, and not condemn them for it.

Michelle Linardis

And yet people demonise him and make him out to be worse than Voldemort sometimes. I mean, they assume he abused and beat those kids on a daily or something. What a world we live in, when a teacher is called a bully for reprimanding a student who breaks the rules, risks the lives and safety of others, and talks out of turn. The amount of Snape fans I know who are teachers are absolutely appalled by this vilifying mindset. I daresay in the real world, they would not be calling a teacher like that, a bully. The negativity on these anti-comments are horrendous. They have such superficial views, and so it makes me wonder how they even enjoy these stories at all. We are accused of 'downplaying' or 'justifying' Severus, when all we do is point out the flaws in their 'logic', correct their 'facts', highlight the double-standards, and see Severus with a very human, empathetic view.

Monique

Yes and it was clearly a mistake I won't be repeating. Since it's clearly a mutual feeling, all will now be good.

Monique

Neville is such a sweet kid. Really just a kind hearted boy. I always appreciated that when Harry found out he spent time reflecting on the injustice that had been done to Neville and felt that he got sympathy that Neville deserved. Poor kid.

Monique

Agree with you on McGonagall. I think she would inherently know that Lupin wasn't a threat to Harry. At least in human form.

Monique

Did you get any amazing merch?

Janie

Thank you, Veggie. I decided not to reply to comments that purposefully try to provoke an argument. But I want to assure you that there are really just a few people who do that, most people are nice and respectful.

Hawwah

I agree completely. I had a strict math/physics teacher. When I was 12, I was absolutely terrified of him. He was a robust man, tall and overweight, we heard him thundering towards the classroom from far away. He behaved very confidently in every aspect, talked very loudly etc. I was a shy, timid kid and all this stuff made me feel intimidated. And he was very strict with grading. That was a huge source of anxiety, because my parents expected nothing but the best grades from me (not a healthy approach, but that's for another debate). So yeah, I was terrified of him and his lessons. Today? I'm smiling as I'm typing this. I'm remembering him fondly. I find it amusing that I actually used to be terrified of this man. How I wish a strict teacher had been the worst thing I've ever encountered in my life! As a kid I feared him. As an adult I can clearly see he was one of the best teachers I've ever had. Easily makes it into the top 3. Was he a perfect teacher? No. But that's okay because nobody is perfect. I wasn't a perfect pupil either. People blow Neville's boggart out of proportion. "Neville's worst fear is his teacher, that's horrible!" No, that just means that Neville is a child.

Janie

I completely agree with you, Lili. Snape should have just sent her to the hospital wing, I fail to see how that would blow his cover in front of the children of the death eaters. That's what any normal teacher would do.

Janie

I think McGonagall knew Lupin was a werewolf. She was his teacher when he was a student and Dumbledore's close friend. I'm pretty sure she would ne reasonable but maybe worried that Lupin didn't take the Wolfsbane potion.

Michelle Linardis

I had one much the same, too. I mean, it is common to be afraid of a teacher when you're young, but that does not mean we were abused or bullied by them. I had a teacher that was strict and overbearing - quite bitter and unpleasent at times. Now 20 years later, we bump into each other and chat like old friends. I have so much respect for her, and now with an adult perspective, I see things realistically. So much of these claims against Severus in the comments are so exaggerated, it's almost laughable. They want to hate him so bad for the smallest things, that they are willing to invent anything. It's just so ridiculous. They seriously didn't read the same books. Such a shame. They are missing out on so much.

Hawwah

Veggie, I'm so sorry to hear you're going through life hardships right now! You always seem so cheerful in your videos, I would have never guessed. If you need a break from all this, take all the time you find necessary. I'm sure everyone will understand! You're right that a disagreement over a fantasy book shouldn't really matter, but I feel it's more than that, actually. The thing is, there are people on this forum who experienced bullying. There are people who experienced assault and other traumatizing things. Many of these people relate to Severus Snape because of the bullying he suffered from the Marauders. (We've only scratched the surface in your last video. There's a lot more to come.) So when Marauders' fans defend and downplay their bullying of Severus Snape, for some of us it feels personal. When they suggest the Marauders were in the right, some of us hear "your bullies were in the right". When they suggest Severus deserved to be bullied, some of us hear "you deserved to be bullied". When they're gushing about how awesome the Marauders were, some of us hear just "I love bullies, they're so cool, who cares about their pathetic victims". If you are a victim of bullying, it's very difficult to accept "different opinions" like these. Because it's not just about the book any more. And the victim blaming. That's another hard pill to swallow. I obviously don't know who sent you those messages but I have my suspicions. And if I'm right, these people are being very disingenuous. You can't post inflammatory stuff like this and then act surprised when you receive similarly inflammatory replies. Veggie, I will take your advice and stop discussing with these people. I agree it would just add oil to the fire at this moment. But I must say I find it ironic when people who defend bullying complain about being bullied.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Not really a “merch” guy if I’m honest. Don’t get me wrong, I like cool things, but I just get a little put off by the crazy prices! We did get some Bertie botts beans for my niece and nephew. Plus I had multiple butter beers (Frozen butter beer is the best!)

Karen

Loved watching and hearing your thoughts veggie! I find it interesting also listening to what other people think about the “prank”. I guess I never thought in depth about the situation and always took it as Black not fully thinking through how dangerous the situation would be or even thinking Snape would go. There is also something I would love to point out but it’s a bit spoilery. But just remember Snape was a death eater he was obsessed with the dark arts even while in school. So I understand why Black hates Snape so much, he reminds him of his family who he hates. Voldemort, the death eaters, and the wizarding war is supposed to be an analogy to the Third Reich. I think it’s important to have that in mind because would you be so sympathetic towards Snape if it was real life? Now obviously this is a book and not real life. So I do see the other side too and that Snape isn’t all bad and it’s uncalled for to bully people around. Also I think there’s a lot to be said for Snape turning against Voldemort even if it’s for a creepy reason of loving a girl from high school who you stopped being friends with because you became a death eater. Now Black was an idiot and immature 100% and lets hatred gets the best of him. I believe James honestly saw that this “prank” was way out of line and was brave enough to save Snape, putting himself at risk too. I always thought James of being smarter than Black and being to be more mature. After all Lilly does wind up marrying the guy and you’ll learn more of that later on and her fall out with Snape.

S1lm4r1l

> "Snape was sort of coerced into the Death Eaters - since due to the incessant bullying by the Marauders he had little to no choice as to which people would be willing to be seen with him." I wouldn't say that's true. Lily was happy to be around him when he wasn't hanging around with his Death Eater friends. > "Also not sure how many other students would sort of risk being targets as well." Well Snape is hardly the only person to be on the receiving end of the Marauder's antics. Harry finds dozens of cards with crimes and punishments featuring them during his detentions. > "I am not a fan o Lily - for how she treated Snape. The M word is a bad thing, still I think a long lasting friendship and Snape trying to apologize shoud ahve meant something. Also one should take into account the situation" Controversial opinion: Snape was the bad friend, not Lily. He walked the path that ended in the break-up of their friendship and did very little to prevent it until it was too late. Lily put up with his dark magic, his unsavoury friends, with his slurs for years. I don't blame her for giving up on him. Snape's childhood is tragic. Sirius rose above his whilst at school. Snape took a little longer.

Frederique Gillespie

You and I are very much on the same page here. Since I am replying it to you and not addressing Veggie directly, I will get spoilery. So if anyone else is reading this and doesn't want to get spoiled, this is your warning!!! To me, the way Voldemort welcomes back Snape tells me everything you need to know about what Snape was like right until the moment he realized Voldemort intended to kill Lily. And we also know Snape is the one who rushed to tell Voldemort of the prophecy about Harry, so he was still very much a Death Eater at that point. He then spends 14 years appearing to be in Dumbledore's pocket (from the Death Eater perspective, I mean). Then, as soon as Voldemort comes back, Snape isn't just welcomed back among the masses, he's in the inner circle. The guy who gave the information to Voldemort that led to his "undoing" is welcomed back like a lost, treasured brother. Yes, Snape is as gifted at Occlumency as Voldemort is gifted at Legimency, but the enthusiastic welcome he has tells you that Voldemort has a particular kind of appreciation for Snape. One he doesn't even show for Malfoy, Crabbe, Goyle, Macnair or any of the others who are not nearly as close to Dumbledore as Snape has seemed to be. So what kind of Death Eater do you think Snape was then? Before he turned spy? To be trusted that implicitly by Voldemort when he comes back, he must have shown some sort of reason for Voldemort to appreciate him so much.

Monique

What an interesting thought and idea to explore! I had never thought of that. Also spoilery, I always appreciated the scene in GOF where you know Dumbledore is sending Snape back to Voldemort for the first time and asks him if he's ready. How Harry notes Snape looks more scared than he's ever seen him, or something to that effect. I always assumed it was a reintroduction that Snape would suffer through in some way for his position at Dumbledore's school. Perhaps his position did afford him a smooth reintroduction to his position in the Death Eaters.

Kattie Martin

Mr. Black, I’m glad you are enjoying the books. They were a big part of my life growing up and I find going back and rereading them to be a lovely time. It’s funny that you mentioned how it must have been something reading such a big book at 8/9 years old. POA is considered a 7th grade level book and I was in 4th grade so it was considered impressive to my teachers. Especially considering I almost failed a previous grade because I couldn’t read. I’m 30 now and I’m not sure if dyslexia was commonly known about when I was in elementary school but I do know they were worried that I wouldn’t be able to learn and I couldn’t read until a week before my cutoff date. I don’t have dyslexia, however I struggle to focus so in order to read I sometimes have to use a blank paper to block the lower sentences because they tend to distract me. The book club helps me to take my time and notice things I didn’t before, as well as get different perspectives. My son is currently on book five and I get so happy when he runs into the room to ask me if I knew about something that happened in the books. He has the illustrated versions of books 1-5. Give Woozel (I hope I spelled that right) a scritch for me.

Karen

Great point I wasn’t even thinking about how Snape was welcomed back so easily. I was mainly thinking about how after Snape calls Lilly a Mudblood and he waits outside Gryffindor common room Lilly points out he can’t wait to become a death eater and his friends too. He doesn’t deny this at all. I know that the “prank” is before SWM but from what I searched it’s the same school year. I also will say I think the “prank” is the start of the turning point for James not being an arrogant toe rag and leading Lily to dating him later on. (I forget if they start dating 6th or 7th year)

Monique

How fun! I've never been but can only imagine the prices must be staggering. What fun memories to have and I bet your niece and nephew will enjoy the Bertie Botts. Good to know on the butter beer.

S1lm4r1l

@Monique From what we see, most of the other 'traitorous' Death Eaters aren't tortured or otherwise killed by Voldemort upon his return. I've always assumed that Voldemort did Cruciate all of them a little, because of their disloyalty and his anger at letting Harry slip through his fingers again. Bellatrix being envious of Snape's access to Voldemort and the position of confidence he enjoys is a central reason why she distrusts him.

S1lm4r1l

@Karen I'm pretty sure they say its the 7th year they get together, which makes sense given they're Head Boy and Girl.

Helen

I always assumed that Lupin couldn’t find work because of the limitations he would have as an employee. Not as a prejudice against him being a werewolf. He would need a significant amount of time off build onto his schedule every month due to his transformations with each full moon. It would he extremely difficult for an employer to accommodate such a schedule. Just something to consider…

S1lm4r1l

Lupin does look ill in the days prior and after his transformation. So there's probably 3-4 days every month when he's less than 100% Kinda understandable why most employers wouldn't want to deal with his disability. Especially given the lack of Worker's Rights in the Wizarding World. And that's before you even get to the stigma of Lycanthropy.

Monique

Oh, for sure on Bellatrix. She is so very resentful of Snape. I also assumed the death eaters all got tortured a little as punishment and so assumed Snape would as well but perhaps a bit more for being in Dumbledore's orbit for so long. That said, we see Dumbledore acknowledge that Snape was a death eater but had turned spy for them in GOF when we see his memory of Karkarov snitching in court so Voldemort must have either believed Snape to be a double agent for him already. Or maybe that was the reason Snape gave for being so tight with Dumbledore while Voldemort was in exile. "I was keeping an eye on our enemies for when you eventually returned' sort of thing. So great to find a thread I have never pondered in all the years of reading these.

Janie

This is so interesting! I've never even thought about that. But you're right, Snape must have been very close to Voldemort in the first war for Voldemort to welcome him back so easily. But I wonder why Voldemort wasn't more suspicious of Snape, especially when Snape begged him to spare Lily's life. Either Snape was really that good at Occlumency, or Voldemort just underestimated him and his feelings for Lily. Or both.

itsanursething

Fascinating! I never even thought of that! I think mostly though, it's that people associate werewolves with people like Greenback, so they don't think any of them are good people and are too afraid to hire them. Which completely breaks my heart!

itsanursething

The frozen butter beer is SO good! And yeah, the prices are stupid high, which is disappointing. But the experience is great. I haven't been since 2009, I'm sure it's changed a little since then, but still amazing nonetheless. I'm glad you had fun Garry!!

Kunzite Blossom

@S1lm4r1l I totally agree. Over the last few book clubs I've just avoided saying anything on these topics for that reason. Real life is enough stress, and adding to it through what should be fun, would only ruin these book clubs. Can only imagine what it will be like in later books. Given this is just part of 1 book, and theres 4 more makes me worried about what can happen in the future

emmainkeri

I believe Snape disliked James for the way he was, not only because James fancied Lily. That just made him dislike and despise James more.

emmainkeri

It was Sirius, not Lupin, who called Ron "boy"! 😅

itsanursething

Oh for sure! McGonagall knew he was a werewolf, I'm sure she's known since he first came to Hogwarts as a student. She was his head of house after all. What I meant was, her opinion of him appearing to be helping a convicted criminal. It would probably look a little suspicious to walk into that scene without having heard any of what was being said. So I'm sure she would demand an explanation of what's going on. Does that make sense? :)

Monique

@Janie, I wonder if Voldemort just missed it completely because of his inability to love others. I know that love being a particular blind spot for Voldemort was a recurring theme. Maybe he just didn't even recognize Snapes feelings for what they were when he pleaded for just her and assumed it was misguided loyalty left over for a childhood friend? It's a bit of a fascinating thought experiment though to explore this!

Ashley Morelock

Yes! I’m glad you explained this. It just helps with the symptoms of being a werewolf, but you still turn with the full moon.

Milana

So sorry you’re being involved in this Veggie, sure no one wants you to be stressed over this! On a separate note it baffles me that grown people feel the need to involve third parties. Just don’t respond to comments you find irritating or annoying and move on; what do you expect Veggie to do - block people for having opinions that differ from yours? Ah cop on will ya

Janie

Oh, sorry, I misunderstood. In that case, yes, she would definitely demand an explanation first :)

S1lm4r1l

@Janie Voldemort does not and cannot understand love. He simply thought Snape desired Lily. Snape is probably the most accomplished Occlumens alive. Because Voldemort is the world's best Legilimens and doesn't ever penetrate Snape's mind.

Janie

You both have a point about Voldemort not understanding love. But still, he seems to be very paranoid. I would think that he would be at least a little suspicious of Snape, considering that Snape had spent 13 years around Dumbledore. Yes, being the best Occlumens alive might help Snape to convince him, but if I were Voldemort I still wouldn't trust him completely. But maybe it just means I'm even more paranoid than Voldemort :)

Karen

Very good point. It makes me wonder how Voldemort and Snapes interaction was when Snape went back. Maybe Voldemort only completely trusted Snape after he killed Dumbledore.

Janie

Slim, I think it's pointless to keep arguing with Michelle and Hawwah. They obviously won't change their minds and further arguments will only bring more stress to Veggie. I do agree with all your points but maybe all three of you should just agree to disagree and leave it at that :)

VEGGIE GAMER

Please reread my comment at the top of this chain again before replying to it, guys! 😃 I am now going to try and relax for the evening! Hope your days are all going well!

Starryk

Lets throw another quote in for those who are not able to see any flaw in Snapes behaviour in Ch 19 while most others here are able to see the flaws from the other characters. Snape in CH 19 ""I'll drag the werewolf. Perhaps the dementors will have a kiss for him too --". Everyone has a right to their opinion but to call this justified... is a hard pill to swallow. Lupin has suffered as a werewolf most of his life and now condemn him to a fate worse than death without even a trial. If one is not able to condemn the bad actions of his or her favourite characters then this person is not reasonable anymore. You should always be able to criticise apects of things you like. We don't need any more fanatics in this world.

Q

I think one reason why Sirius (Mr. Black) would suggest and the Potters would have gone with Peter even though Sirius would have died rather than betray them is because at the time, Sirius trusted Peter absolutely. So did James. Sirius now sees Peter as contemptible and weak after 12 years of stewing in Azkaban thinking about everything bad he ever did. But Peter was a real part of this incredibly close group of friends. That's what makes his betrayal so sad in the end. Someone has probably said above or maybe it got clearer during the reaction, but just in case: Animagi are not born. Becoming an animagus is a super complicated, long process of advanced transfiguration. It's not illegal to become one, but it is illegal not to register that you become one. McGonagall registered with the Ministry, but James, Sirius, and Peter did it in secret. "In on the joke" I feel like Harry (like others using similar language) is speaking to how Snape perceives the Marauders' attitudes more than expressing his own bias, but yeah it's definitely not a joke. It's just easier to call it that than to look too deeply and name it something else.

Starryk

I am not a native english speaker but isn't 'to be in on the joke' a kind of saying that can be used even if it is not a literal joke? I don't think it necessarily implies that this is a joke for Harry. Also Snape himself calls it a joke in an earlier chapter when he catches Harry with the Marauder's Map. So i think its unfair to blame Harry for using this word.

Michelle Linardis

Oh yes, because that quote makes him such the devil incarnate. In his eyes, they were criminals and weren't proven otherwise. He has every right to want to call upon the dementors. If I stood around in a room with a convicted murderer and a monster, with three 13 year olds with me, I'd try and call upon the authorities, too. Show me the part where I mention that Snape was perfect or flawless? Show me the part where I mention he was a kind person? You can't, because there is not one instance when I claim him to be faultless. Snape has a right to his anger, but you see, everyone loves to blame him for every little thing, and many people here are blinded by that odd hate and dont see the double standards for the characters they do like. Snape has many flaws, and I love that he does. People here get all twisted because they assume I see him as perfect - I don't, and I wouldn't like him if he was. I love that his anger makes him unhinged, because given what he suffered by Sirius and the near-slaughter by Lupin (which people here happily ignore), Snape's reaction is so very real. But lets all feel sorry for Lupin instead and never hold him accountable for his dishonesty, and risking the lives of children under his care because he forgot to take his wolfsbane. I have a right to see the good in characters that everyone else condemns unfairly - so why should I add to the character's hate? He gets enough false accusations from people like you(and 90% of people here) who only see his bad side, and never the good or positive. And there is plenty there that many refuse to see. Now, this thread is closed. Do not respond to me ever again, or any other Snape basher who have nothing better to do but harass me because I don't demonise him enough. I will be be adding this request from now on.

itsanursething

No worries Janie! I don't always explain myself well. Always happy to try to elaborate and make things more understandable if I can :)

itsanursething

Yeah, it is kind of a figure of speech. I think "in on the plan" would have been better verbiage, but oh well! And not all jokes or pranks (in my opinion) are meant to make the person they're played on laugh. The "victim" (terrible word, but best in this situation I guess) often doesn't find it funny at all.

Jake M

100% itsadancething! A *good* prank should be funny for everyone, but there are sooo many examples of pranks where the definition of 'funny' is stretched even for the audience (hence why a lot of prank YouTubers get cancelled when they go too far!). 'In on the joke' is definitely a bad term of phrase but in the moment I reckon it's an understandable semantic mistake for Harry to make.

Dara Jeeling

I actually do not see Snape as a good person per se. He did the right and brave thing in the end. this does not excuse how he treated people for me. I just think he became a death eater because he had little choice in who was supportive and friendly towards him. Also the Indikation that Snepe was "the favorite victim" of the 4 Marauders makes me think, there were others. But after a 24 hour shift I'd need to dive into SWM and look and frankly I am to tired. for me it's the other way round - all people who do not like Snape have are "he's a bully" and that's why he is bad - for 20 years. So can we aggre that they all has issues? I know I see Snape through a different lense and give him the benefit of the doubt (still not a fan of his attitude towards students). BUT I see him as grey (snd I even tend to see him in a darker grey), but for me he is still the character with the best and most tragic story arc (although Neville is a close second)

Dara Jeeling

I always found it kind of fascinating, when Snape asks Bellatrix in HBP if she thinks he would be here, if he had not been able to have satisfying answers to each and every of Voldemorts questions. I have never really soend tomexwondering what might have occured, when he returned two hours or so later.

Dara Jeeling

Thank you! I also understand your point of view. Over the years I figured it's hard to "change the other side" s view. BUT I always find insights intersting. Sorry for name changing, will not do that again.

Dara Jeeling

actually found it... SWM - Lily cslling out James " you're as bad as he is..... walking down corridors and hexing anyone sho annoys you, just becsuse you can" so for me this dort of confirmed Snape was not the only one James(and the Marauders) hexed and were mean to. But maybevthisexwere isolsted hexings- nothing Constanze.

Sam-I-Am

@Dara I fully agree with you on that - they all had their issues. Thank you for bringing to light direct references to them bothering (possibly to the level of harassing/bullying) other students. Still I find the idea that they are bad people because of their teenage behavior to be a bit extreme. While teenagers are old enough to know right from wrong, they make terrible decisions all the time. Even if we’re to say that Snape was backed into a corner and had no choice but to become a Death Eater (which I personally don’t buy), he still goes to Dumbledore as an adult and asks him to save Lily’s life. At first, he doesn’t care about James and the baby’s (Harry’s) life. That to me is worse than anything the marauders did to Snape as teenagers.

itsanursething

I hope what I'm about to say doesn't come across like I'm bashing Snape, because it's really not meant to. I think he's an incredibly interesting character and the more I reread, the more I learn about him. That being said, I disagree with a couple of things you've said and I'd like to explain why I feel that way. In my opinion, Snape wasn't "nearly slaughtered" by Lupin. He glimpsed Lupin in werewolf form and then James took him out of there. Werewolf Lupin never actually saw him and therefore never tried to attack him. Snape was not hurt in any way. To me, nearly slaughtered would meant Snape was physically injured almost to the point of death. Now, this doesn't mean I think what happened was ok! It was extremely dangerous and very poor judgement on Sirius's part. He should have been punished. I do not condone his idea of a prank. The fact still remains though, Snape was not physically harmed in any way. I'd also like to say, I don't think Lupin deliberately forgot to take his potion. He was watching the map making sure Harry, Ron, and Hermione weren't getting into trouble/were staying safe, and then he saw two of his best friends' names appear. He then immediately went after them to try to protect them/see what was going on. He was trying to protect his students. Something like that would distract me from taking an important medication/potion. I don't blame him for forgetting, because I don't think he sat there and thought to himself, "eh! Forget it tonight! I don't wanna." I do think once they started talking about the fact that he is a werewolf, he should have remembered his potion and said/done something to make sure he took it. But I don't think his intent was malicious in any way. I really hope you can see where I'm coming from on this, even if you don't agree. This in no way is meant as an attack on you as a person, anyone else who feels the way you do about Snape, or Snape himself. I'm really not trying to start an argument. I just want to explain why I see these two things differently to you. :)

Michelle Linardis

I have specifically asked not to be responded to by those who are determined to never see from Snape's POV, because no matter what he does, you are still determined to hate him. I value open-mindedness, not those who will only see the worst of a grey character and anti-hero to a very concerning degree. I've seen your other comments, so a conversation with you is useless. You contradict yourself since I know your negative stance on him, and we obviously have very different opinions on this. Allow me to share the positives about Snape, since 90% of you demonise him anyway. I don't need to add to that, and Veggie doesn't need hate comments with every video. Snape has a dark enough past and life anyway. I don't care if people dislike him, but people need to stop exaggerating, downplaying certain events, and magnifying his faults to make him worse than Umbridge and Voldemort. People who do not allow us to have our opinion, are making this one of the most toxic communities I've ever seen and been in. The childish hate-posts and negativity for a fictional character need to stop, and I am saddened and appalled by the constant attacks against Snape fans. That is terrible and repulsive behavior. And I'm tired of being on the receiving end because I choose not to exaggerate the faults of a grey character as most of you do, and I prefer to highlight the good, logical, and what gets overlooked. There is nothing wrong with that. I don't have the luxury of a block button. So at the very least, please, respect my request and do not respond to me again.

Dara Jeeling

Not saying they are bad people - I personally do not like them as much as other characters. For me the Marauders have issues (as characters) as has Snape and to be honest - Molly, Hermione and others as well. Havvin had to do a bit of psychology for my Social workers masters made me rethink things. LIke I said, I think James grew out of being awful, otherwise Lily would not have deemed him worthy. Black sort of never had the chance to grw up into an resposible adult, since he was locked up in Askaban for 12 years and really wishes things would used to stay like in school - all fun with his buddies. Snape for me has so many issues he would have been a dream come true for a psychiatrist - PTSD, trauma, heartbreak - binding issues and so on. And thre really are incidents (one of thm in Goblet, actually) even I have trouble trying to understand his actions - just because I do not want to make up anything. One of them is him only asking for Lily s life (because... you do not like James, but heck, he safed your ass for whatever reasons - so please consider) and not asking for Baby Harry.. He should have known Lily would not step aside, but then he may not have been blinded enough to ask for Harry s life, since Voldemort had aready made up his mind that he had to die. Still no not okay with not even trying (with both his masters) Also it's just what I experienced. Like I was bullied at an all girls school and literally no one in my class (as well as the other classes in my year) would try o be my friend - because whoever tried got bullied also. So just for me (ot trying to convice people I am right) it made sense for me that Snape only had Slytherin house to be "friendly" with and him being sort of shy and unsure must not be easier. In my eyes it's still not okay to do what you went through to other who are not even your peers - but your students, but then again - if you do not get help I assume it can be hard to be unbiased towards your bullies kids, especially if the look like your bully (and have the eyes of the only person you think you ever loved(cared for you). And also... I am Kindergarten teacher and I had kids of my one time bullies - and one of the "girls" was like "I was suprised my daughter loves you so much - I was sure you'd keep her at arms lenght" - but then for me ... Small kids (Kindergarten and elementary school) do not need over scholarly teachers but affecionate ones. The kids learn because they like their teacher. So I always tried to make everyone feel welcome and safe. (I do that with my old people, now) okay - to much rambling about my ideas - sorry!

Dara Jeeling

@S1lm4r1l I can agree on a few points and I know my personal headcanon is just that. Not trying to convince people - just saying what I think. I know Lily is supposed to be good - and she is - hell she is a great mother, even giving her life for her child (which every mom would do). I am not saying Snape was a great friend - his M world slur should not have happened - no matter what. (actually I think he was really needy and someone who only wants something for his own sake can not be soncidered a great friend - but again, personally I see deeper or empathize more with a person who has had a bad childhood, no true family and no money and perspective) The part with me not liking Lily, because for me friendship means forgiving (again and again) - but again, that's only my personal idea. Not tyring to make anyone agree with that. I would still appreciate it, if you woul stop quoting sentence by sentence - I really am not a fan of that. I have figued out that the two of us have differnt approaches (and I do not say one of our approaches is better) and we probably will never come to a great understanding - BUT some of your insights are sort of interesting and make me reread and consider things. At least this! Also, since this is only my idea - it's not helpful since it's unlikely you will cange my 20 year ideas - no matter what you say. I have changed a bit over those years and believe me I know Snape is all grey (even darker grey) - I do not see him as a good guy. I'd rather think I am on the more moderate part. And I am sure it's not doimg amy favors to keep nitpicking sentences, esecially since on saome days (like today) I cmoe home from an 18 hours shift and even though I am sure I can think and write in english my brain is all fuzzy. So I tend to write what I think and if someone disagrees that is fine - but I eometimes miss the finer parts. Like I said I love the marauders friendship (and I should have said their school friendship)

Kunzite Blossom

As a female gamer who plays a fairly heavy male dominated game, I'm often on the receiving end of many sexist jokes. I can tell you, I never find them funny. Jokes will only be funny to those that find humor in the same thing. Same can be said for pranks. Obviously the one pulling the prank will find it hilarious, but the person it is happening to, most likely won't.

Mordimer

Actually I think, that you are saying strong opinions not necessarily because that's how book is written, but because you saw the movies. The problem is, that movies distorted, changed, ruined a lot of characters, so yes, there is a lot of context you are missing ;) Can't say anything else without spoilers ;) I always try to spread your 2h of talking (I don't stay for book club, some opinions are just too blood boiling and I listen your videos to relax xD) for few days, so waiting for next video feels shorter, that's why I comment quite late ;)

Mordimer

I don't feel sorry neither for teenage, nor for adult Snape. Let's not forget that as a teenage boy he was very into dark magic, inventing spells like sectumsempra, joining magic nazis (death eaters) etc. His rivalry with maruders also was not one sided. We do have information in the books, that Snape "never missed an opportunity to attack James".

Mordimer

@Hawwah Then imagine how people feel when Snape fans downplay his bullying ;) And when it comes to your last sentence, yes, it is ironic in deed ;)

Monique

As a woman who works in the construction industry, I concur heartily about the sexist jokes but then I realized long ago they make those jokes for their male friends, not for me so I'm just a tool they use to get a laugh. Says more about them than about me so...

Monique

@Janie - I legitimately laughed out loud when I read, "But maybe it just means I'm even more paranoid than Voldemort :)" I think that's what made this entire exchange so interesting. Something i haven't pondered deeply so your point is so valid. Why wasn't he more suspicious? I think not knowing the answer to that leaves so much up to the impression people have of Snape. Appreciate the fun back and forth ont his

Monique

It really is an interesting topic to ponder!

Monique

For sure, Dara. New viewpoints can definitely be fascinating and thought provoking!

Janie

I'm glad I made you laugh, Monique :) To be honest, I'd never ever thought about any of that until I read Frederique's comment. That's why I love the book club, it makes me see some of the characters in a different way or perspective.

Christina Brock

I don't think that Hermione thought it was a joke at all, but she was well aware that Sirius (at least at the time) thought it was. More than that, she knew that Snape knew that Sirius (and James too, in Snape's view) thought it was a joke. She wasn't stating her own opinion here; she was pointing out what Snape believed the Marauders' opinion was. It's not, "Wasn't that a funny joke, and by the way, did Snape think James was part of it?" Not at all. It was more like, "How awful that Snape thought James was in on the horrible murder attempt that Sirius clearly thought was hilarious!" Hermione isn't being excessively pro-Marauder; she's trying to be very balanced and logical, and see things from everyone's point of view at once. In particular, she's recognizing James's point of view, as the one who risked his life to stop it as soon as he heard about it, and Snape's point of view, as the one who narrowly escaped death at the hands of two of Marauders (even if Remus honestly couldn't help his part in it, Snape would never fully acknowledge that) and assumed that the Marauder leader was also involved in the plan. Cut Hermione some slack here; she's just trying to sort out the information, as usual. Oh! As soon as I posted this, I went back to listening, and you corrected it from Hermione to Harry. Oops, I should have caught that. But my point still stands: neither Harry when he said it, nor Snape when he agreed with it, actually thought it was a joke. Both of them simply meant that Snape believed that Sirius saw it as a joke, which was obviously true. That's all. Nothing to get upset with Harry about.

Maggie

Ron claiming Scabbers lives 12 years because they took good care of him is ridiculous. A rat who gets the absolute best care won't live more than 2-3 years max. I work at a vet and honestly I've never seen a rat make it to 3 years. One of my colleagues had a bunch of them and they all died around 2-2.5 years old.