Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1cXESAaWJB9SIwV89ixsywoYMXDN_GoNP/view?usp=sharing

WARNING! - I don't usually do trigger warnings on these, but I just want to put a warning on this one as it features an abusive relationship that could upset some viewers.

####### EPISODE SPOILER REVIEW BELOW! APPARENTLY SOME OF YOU ARE WATCHING FOR THE FIRST TIME ALONG SIDE ME, SO PLEASE DON'T READ BEYOND THIS POINT UNTIL YOU HAVE SEEN THE EPISODE YOURSELF! ######

------

So yeah, this one had an effect on me I wasn't expecting.  Brilliantly done, but I felt my blood boiling during several scenes.  Loved the Angel stuff and the fact he remembers her name after it all is adorable!  Can't wait to see where they go next with him!

As for the main story this week, it was very affective.  This is the first time I have felt the need to put a trigger warning on an episode (though we have previously discussed how Ted was another episode that some can't rewatch).  I know the vast majority of you have already watched this episode, but didn't feel ok with putting this out without a warning.

Love you, guys! Hope you have a great weekend!

As always, if you click the video just after this post, you may need to  download it first.  This should be fixed in a couple of hours!

Files

Buffy Redirect - Check out the Link in the Patreon Post!

Comments

The Ginger Historian

I really appreciate the trigger warning (I mean, I’ve seen the episode several times, but on principle). Thank you for always being such a thoughtful and considerate creator!

VEGGIE GAMER

Just watching this back and it looks like I am looking at my notes during a crucial bit, I promise I wasn't, it just with the angle of my hat it may look like I am. XD Thought I would bring it up just so you know I was paying attention! XD OH! And on the review after, I accidentally say Willow instead of Oz when describing the Werewolf outfit! XD

Frederique Gillespie

Agreed. I know this episode very well and, if there's an episode that needs a tigger warning... well, I there will be a few more ahead, but we'll get there... and this one certainly deserves a trigger warning.

Giorgia M

Just wanted to jump in with comment as the resident Buffy defender to say that I really do not like how Buffy acts towards Debbie in this episode. It is very victim blaming type rhetoric which still plagues many victims in real life who are so twisted up and confused, they don’t even know what they are doing. I don’t know if it reflects Buffy’s own issues with Angel etc, her own trauma or if she’s forgotten what it feels like to be defenceless or maybe it’s another case of a majority adult male writers room writing a teenage girls perspective and getting it wrong but whatever it is, I will call Buffy out when she is wrong. She was so horrible and insensitive to Debbie and her issues/struggles and treating her like she was stupid for “letting” someone hurt her and not helping to stop him, was so irritating. Buffy can be hard headed and practical/black and white to the point of insensitivity like in “I only have eyes for you” but I do feel that was more projection than this is. I’m disappointed with her choice to act this way every time I watch, otherwise a great episode but not a favourite. Maybe 7.5/10

VEGGIE GAMER

This is an excellent point, Giorgia! It did feel like Buffy wasn't talking in an appropriate way to Debbie in that scene, maybe it is because she was in full "where is Pete" mode, but she definitely does make Debbie out to be 'stupid' for letting him treat her like that. So true!

Giorgia M

Thanks Veg! Yes, I agree it may just have been tunnel vision to the situation at hand. To be fair, maybe if I was still her age, I probably wouldn’t have been as understanding of domestic abuse as I am now, able to understand how abuse really affects the victim and why they don’t “just leave.” But still. She needs to work on her empathy!! Bad Buffy!!!

FandomReferenceHere

I totally agree, Giorgia. C'mon, Buffy, we don't tell domestic violence victims to "not get hit." I understand her and Willow's frustration, but Willow channels it better -- girl, you have GOT to ask us for help or you're gonna end up dead.

FandomReferenceHere

Oof, this is a heavy episode. Thank you, Veggie, for taking the subject matter so seriously! There are a few clunky lines, and I think the Buffyverse will handle partner violence in a more nuanced way in the future. But this episode NAILS the dynamic where Pete beats up Debbie and then manipulates HER into comforting HIM. It's so good and so disturbing.

Tim Pierce

Probably my least favorite episode of the season, but that's like saying vanilla is your least favorite flavor of ice cream (if you like ice cream). This entire season throws the grading curve off so much. One thing that particularly bothered me was that Xander falls asleep and gets yelled at. Buffy does it and it's adorable. Watcher's pet....

Amanda S

Oh, good :D I kept thinking, look up! Look up! haha

Amanda S

Yes, every time I see Buffy waking up and not getting any grief for falling asleep from Giles I'm screaming Double Standards! in my head. Maybe they should be having two people watch Oz since no one can seem to stay awake on their own lol.

Giorgia M

Sorry, forgot to say. Great video!! I understand this one is hard to watch, mostly because it’s a little too real for me. Debbie comforting the man who just hit her is something so real that I imagine an abuse survivor or someone knowledgable in the subject must have been present in the writers room. I hope you are feeling better now Veg. On a lighter note, Giles is so good this season and only gets funnier, in my opinion. Definitely dominating for favourite character this season. I haven’t rewatched in a while and I forget how amazing season 3 is. It was my fav for the longest time!!!

Giorgia M

I always thought that Oz was back to being human when Buffy fell asleep reading. I couldn’t imagine her being as irresponsible with it. But honestly, you are probably right 😂

Amanda S

On the topic of the theme music change, I vaguely recall something about how when they were making the original theme music, they were on a tight budget and asked some local bands for submissions. The one they picked wasn't keeping a proper beat or something, so later on when they had a larger budget, they got the band to rerecord it and clean up the sound.

Temujin

I think we could agree that Buffy would probably have been more sympathetic to Debbie if there wasn't the time pressure of stopping another death. 2 people were already dead so you have the ticking bomb scenario were you may have minutes to stop another death, she didn't have time to be nice so she went brutal.

Tim Pierce

Giles knockout counter: 10 Also, you're right the theme music was tweaked.

Temujin

Veggie you definitely missed the revel of Debbie's body or you wouldn't have said " I hope Debbie survived" a few minutes later lol

VEGGIE GAMER

Hi Stephen, I promise you I did watch it (I never lie about this stuff, in fact usually I apologise for literally everything)! I was looking just under the brim of my hat because I didn't want to see it. When Buffy enters the room, I look down at my notes, but as soon as she says "Oh god", you can see my head slightly raise. The reason I said I hope she survived is BECAUSE I had seen it, hence why when it showed her body again at the end of the scene I didn't react as if it was the first time seeing it. I didn't think the injuries it had shown necessarily meant she was dead (after the state we had saw the councilor was in). My bad though, it really does look like I am staring at my notes, which is something since doing The Lord of the Rings I have definitely tried to avoid!

Jake M

I have to wonder why Sunnydale keeps all its places unlocked at night- the morgue, the school... No wonder the demons are everywhere! And if only Oz had remembered his Wolfsbane potion...then he would have been harmless and not suspected! 😂

Temujin

I apologize then, I really thought you missed it and I just want you to get the full impact of what's happening.

VEGGIE GAMER

Oh, not at all, Stephen! I apologise for how it looks! When I was watching back I was like "wait... I DID watch this bit, what is going on?!" XD

Raven Dark

I always thought Oz was already back to being human too by the time Buffy dropped off. Now, I wonder, though. Double standards indeed. Although, I wonder if it's on purpose, meant to show that Giles can sometimes be harder on Xander than he is on Buffy. If that's the case, then the "Watcher's pet" line is really funny.

Raven Dark

On both points, all I have to say is... LMAO!

RavenLord

Your expression when Giles said, "No need to panic," was hilarious! Yes, when he says that, it's panic-time. As for the abrupt appearance of Debbie & Pete, while the show does have the tendency to introduce new characters without pretext or even much context, this one can be explained. Scott Hope is now in Buffy's life, and Pete and Debbie were *his* friends. I guess the writers didn't want Scott to have been a loner until he met Buffy, lol. They did the counselor dirty by killing him off. I really liked the character and would have enjoyed seeing that develop. Well, the actor did a masterful job of projecting a personality without much screen time, at least.

Raven Dark

I don't blame you for being as angry and bloodthirsty over Pete as you were, Veggie. I was too, when I first saw this one. A lot of people don't like this episode, I think, and my take is that, it's at least partly because of the way the confrontation between Buffy and Debbie and Willow is handled. Buffy's response is all wrong. Still, I do like the episode and I'm glad you did too. I'm sorry it triggered you, though. It had the same effect on me the first few times I saw it. Matter of fact, so did the episode Ted. John Ritter did a great job portraying the psycho father figure, and Pete did just as a good a job here playing the abusive boyfriend. I have to say, I love the scene with Angel and Buffy at the end as well. A bit random to say this, but I also always thought, when Angel is walking toward Buffy in that last scene, the transition of his vamp face to his normal face looks really good. Very good special effects work, especially for the time this came out.

Ashley Evers

So, interestingly, the thing where Pete doesn't have to keep taking the syrum in order to turn into his Mr. Hyde is actually taken straight from the original story. Dr. Jekyll develops the formula and takes it for a while to intentionally turn into Mr. Hyde, but when he tries to stop, he starts changing without taking it. It's meant to demonstrate how the more you feed your worse nature, the stronger it gets. Also, Dr. Jekyll fully remembers everything that Mr. Hyde does. He created the syrum specifically in order to have anonymity to indulge his 'base desires' without losing his good reputation and status in Victorian society. But we are never told what those base desires are? Given Victorian standards, it could be anything from being a serial killer to partying a little too hard. We do see evidence that Mr. Hyde is careless, violent and unrepentant. Eventually he gets in enough trouble that Dr. Jekyll does try to give up the persona, but by then it is too late, and he can't stop himself from changing.

Frederique Gillespie

Hiya Veggie, I don't think you need to worry about cheering on Buffy as she beats down on Pete. He was a particular kind of toe-rag. And this is, after all, a fictional show. A show that explores very real, human emotions and themes, but wishing the death of a fictional character can't possibly make you a bad person. If it can, I need to worry about myself a bit more. I agree that Buffy went at Debbie the wrong way (heck, I'd even go so far as to say she went at her in a harmful way), but I'm not willing to come down on her too hard for it. The best any of us can do is use our abilities to their best. Buffy isn't a psychologist. Heck, as we saw in this very episode, she may need psychological help of her own. In part because she's been drilled into thinking that she cannot rely on anyone but herself, when it comes down to it. I think she's being unfair to her friends by not sharing that Angel is back, but I understand where she's coming from. She knows they won't understand. And she probably understands that they would be correct in not understanding, too. So she keeps it to herself... I think she's wrong, but I get it. I do take issue (very tiny bit of an issue) with your saying that they're "all" responsible for Oz potentially escaping at the start of the episode. Oz voluntarily puts himself in the cage because he has no control over his wereworlf side. Willow was on watch, but had to go away for school reasons. So she did the responsible thing and found a replacement. Xander never spent a single second trying to hold up his end of the bargain. He went straight to sleep. If that was his plan, he should have been said no when Willow asked him. Oz wasn't the cold-blooded jelly monster in the end, but if he had been... I'd blame Xander. And I also noticed (possibly for the first time) that Xander once again shirked the responsibility of his actions there. He wasn't just being unhelpful, at no point did he own up to his part in what was happening to Oz. Anyway, I loved watching your reaction. I especially enjoy the moment of what I'll call "wrestler fan glee" when Mr-Hyde-Pete and wolfed out Oz went at it. :) 6.5/10 Freddie

tvshrine

Giles was my favorite character for most all of the series. I still have his action figures!! There is something about the straight man doing comedy that makes it even funnier. Currently he plays a "villain" on the AppleTV show Ted Lasso and is soooo good.

Catalina Saturnus

Not a favorite episode, but it's always interesting to watch these things from the eyes of a new viewer like yourself :)  Usually the show takes classic teenage tropes and spins them on their head, but the writers were a little on the nose with the monster metaphor this time IMO.  I enjoy the scene where Oz hulks out and fights the boyfriend. It's nice to have Angel back in the mix. But still, I don't love the abuse storyline.   RIP to the nice guidance counselor Platt, and Debby. They deserved better.

Hanneli Norrgard

The counselor smoking in the school gets my goat. Smoking in a school would have been illegal at that time in CA, and it was not socially acceptable for it to really be seen as OK. This episode is probably a 5/10 for me. Buffy is obnoxious, but we all know how I feel about her. The storyline does have some issues, but I think it's too much of a topic to do justice to in a single episode, especially with everything else going on. As someone who was in an abusive marriage, this doesn't trigger me at all, but I'm sure it does some people. Media portrayals of abuse never do, but I think it's because they never come at it from the angle that affected me. They usually come at it from the angle of the victim thinking it's her (almost always a female) fault and that she needs to do things to make it change or even to comfort the man (almost always a man). With me, it was just because I grew up in an abusive home and thought that it was normal. Angel was my favorite character (for doing the deed), and the card catalogue is a close second (I love me a good card catalogue).

Maggie

It's so interesting to me what triggers certain people, for instance I was abused (more psychologically though) my whole childhood/teenage years, and I have PTSD, and episodes of a tv show would never trigger me. I just know it's not real, even though there totally are people like this. I could hear a story like this on the radio though, and start crying. It is sad that Debbie died. I feel even worse for Scott though, he just lost his 2 best friends. I lost my 2 only friends when I was 18, and not in a natural way, hence my own trauma. The only positive relationships I had. His reaction of being a little sad but all "I'll be ok" is not realistic to me.

Shiby23

Toe Knee Head.... Holy friggen Veggie..... :D

SapientButterfly

Over here for the orange Jelly! This episode is definitely hard to watch, but I think so important not to skip unless you really can't stand to watch it at all because it's so triggering. I highly recommend Merlin for more Tony Head, although his character is so very un-Giles, he is great in that.

Jake M

Here's another question: since his return Angel has been living bestially, running wild, right? So where did he get trousers from and how was he able to put them on adeptly!?

Diego Zenhäusern

I mean, to me his reaction totaly felt like saying that you're okay when you'reabsolutely not. So it felt realistic🤔. But I guess I'll have to see whetherthe show does anything more with him or whether this actually was supposed to "resolve" the issue🤔

Luci Love (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-20 18:00 OMG, Veggie!! I just saw Garth M's Darkplace for the first time like two days before I watched this! I can't believe I finally got one of your British comedy references XD I'll have to keep watching for the monkey episode. haha I gotta say I liked this episode for all the monster on monster fights. Not just slayer v. monster as usual but werewolf v. Hyde AND vampire v. Hyde. So awesome. And great reaction <3
2023-06-05 23:30 OMG, Veggie!! I just saw Garth M's Darkplace for the first time like two days before I watched this! I can't believe I finally got one of your British comedy references XD I'll have to keep watching for the monkey episode. haha I gotta say I liked this episode for all the monster on monster fights. Not just slayer v. monster as usual but werewolf v. Hyde AND vampire v. Hyde. So awesome. And great reaction <3

OMG, Veggie!! I just saw Garth M's Darkplace for the first time like two days before I watched this! I can't believe I finally got one of your British comedy references XD I'll have to keep watching for the monkey episode. haha I gotta say I liked this episode for all the monster on monster fights. Not just slayer v. monster as usual but werewolf v. Hyde AND vampire v. Hyde. So awesome. And great reaction <3

VEGGIE GAMER

Haha that is amazing, Christa! There are only 6 episodes, so shouldn't take too long! XD (It is great, but probably good it was a short series XD)

Thom Purdy

I wouldn't say that Xander is useless. He has saved Giles' life once(The Puppet Show) and the world twice!(Prophecy Girl and Innocence).

chris allen

if anything Willow is far more useless than Xander apart from the odd bit of hacking

Captain Hammer

It always bothered me that Giles found Buffy asleep on her watch shift of Oz and didn't get angry at her like he did at Xander (which was rightly deserved)

Captain Hammer

He also basically saved the entire gang in Halloween and was patrolling and slaying when Buffy left town.

Elizabeth Rose

I hardly skip any episodes when rewatching, but this one I usually either skip or skim through. It’s not a bad episode, I think it’s well done, and it’s not a trigger for me, but I just find it so unrelentingly bleak. Between the abusive relationship that ends in pure tragedy, Buffy’s trauma at Angel’s return, Angel’s whole traumatized state, Oz suffering through thinking he killed someone, the immediate and brutal death of Platt (as happens to practically any adult who shows kindness and support to Buffy)… I just find it a miserable episode. I still enjoyed watching your reaction and commentary on it, though! :)

Todd Bolton

Also, on the third night, they all go off to do various things and leave Oz unattended. Just a very poorly written episode, all around.

Todd Bolton

I think you're right, Veggie, but I don't think they cared enough about Debbie to ever make it plain. It took me several viewings to finally figure it out.

Todd Bolton

By the way, you can’t blame this one on a male writing room. Marti Noxon’s name is on the script. (Noxon, in many ways, is responsible for some of the best things in Buffy – she was the showrunner for season six! – and some of the worst, this being the prime example.) Buffy not recognizing her own relation to Debbie and Pete, considering her relation to Angel, cannot be put down to her age, or the writers would have left some clue. They were oblivious. The disregard for Debbie in this episode is incredible. The reason Veggie was uncertain if she had died is that the episode didn’t give a damn about it. Reveal the villain two-thirds through the episode, just so we can have somebody to hate. If it were well done, I might hate the villain; as it is, I just hate the episode. Victim-shaming and poorly constructed. (At the first, we are to believe they thought that Oz got out and then quietly slipped back in the open window? The police are not the only ones in Sunnydale who are deeply stupid. The therapist gets pureed and yet is still holding his cigarette?) The only episode of Buffy I dislike (which is too weak a word for it). Go Fish and one other (season four and beer), I find relatively boring but I don’t hate. The only two things I really like in this one are Giles getting shot and Willow pulling Oz’s tail.

Todd Bolton

he saved Buffy, last season, when Theresa had her pinned down.

Todd Bolton

This episode is nothing like Stevenson’s Jekyll and Hyde, except in the external monster stuff. Jekyll and Hyde, one of my favorite stories ever, is one of the most compassionate stories ever written. “Beauty and the Beasts” has no compassion whatsoever, not for the victimizer and not even for the victim.