Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

THIS PART OF THE BOOK CLUB IS NOW COMPLETE!  SEE YOU NEXT TIME! :)

Here is a chance to get your comment read out in the next Book review video!

If you are reading along with the reviews, we are covering chapters "The Dememtor's Kiss" and "Hermione's Secret"! So if you have any thoughts, opinions, comparisons or questions regarding these, please leave a comment below!

I do have to ask, try to keep them fairly short, like 4 or 5 sentences.  That way I can cover more when making the video.  Also try to keep them on subject and not referencing anything that we are yet to cover. Ideally, keep it to 1 comment each if you can (if you have more to say after commenting, you can edit it and add to it! :) ).  These are just rough guidelines rather than rules, I want to be able to fit in as many of you as possible! :)

NEW FEATURE!! - As some of you may want to make a comment, but not have it replied to by others, you can now Message me your thoughts on the chapters by DM'ing me on here.  If you do, please follow all the above rules, especially avoiding mentioning things in future chapters or books!  Oh and please start your DM message with "Book Club -"!

To anyone that does reply to comments below, please make sure you are being friendly and respectful!  A lot of tone and meaning can be lost in text, after all!  If you disagree with someone on something, keep it polite and remember the golden rule in life - Sometimes you have to just agree to disagree! :)

Thanks, guys!! :)

Files

Comments

Mate

Thanks for the reviews Veggie!! Love these chapters. Perfect chapters outlining Harry’s natural leadership and courage and Hermione’s cleverness. No need to give her lines from other characters or make her some flawless hero. Her character is fascinating as it is in the books and it shows how harry over the years earns the right to become leader of Dumbledores army. In the movies that seemed a bit un earned if that makes sense. And of course Rons character in the book. Street smart courageous and a truly good friend.

Jake M

Pedantry time! Lupin says he must take the Wolfsbane potion every day in the week leading up to the full moon. In which case, does he really need to take it on the night *of* the full moon? Even if he does...as someone who semi -regularly misses doses of his non-werewolf medication, I'm not sure missing one out of seven doses should really be as bad as if he'd taken none 🤔 I wonder how exactly Dementors communicate with humans? We keep hearing about conversations between them and Fudge, but all Harry ever sees them doing before passing out is pointing and attempting to kiss people (which makes them sound like an adult film actor XD) I also love how amused Dumbledore is with Buckbeak's escape when the others in Hagrid's Hut are just baffled. It's almost like he knew the plan already! As Hagrid says, "Knows everything, Dumbledore." One last thing...I was watching your Chamber reaction last night...Do you recall calling Dobby a prick several times, and Hermione a psychopath? Has your opinion of either changed? 🤣🤣🤣

Marianne

Hi Veggie! Okay nothing to do with these chapters but here is my take on Squibs. Squibs are people who are born to wizarding parents, but who have no magical abilities of their own. The author said they have to have at least 1 magical parent to become a squib. She also states that muggle-born wizards were believed to have descended from a squib who married a muggle. This means the magic gene is still passed on generations later in the same family. So, I don’t think your theory of 2 muggles having a squib child can be correct. However, I shall use your own words ‘Sometimes you have to just agree to disagree!’. I love how much you are fascinated with Squibs! I find them interesting too as even though they get to know about both the magical and the muggle world, they never fit in properly anywhere. I would love a more in-depth story about Filch’s childhood and what he experienced after realising he wouldn’t get his Hogwarts letter at age 11.

Jake M

I always wondered if they get their Hogwarts letter, but then discover during classes how unfortunately inept they are? Either way it must be crushing! I was heartbroken when I didn't get my owl aged 11, I thought it might be real 😂😭

Marianne

I think that squibs would never receive a hogwarts letter as they book of admittance and quill of acceptance needs proof of magical ability before selecting them for hogwarts. However, maybe they get a letter explaining to the magical parents that their child has no magic so can't be accepted. Must be devastating for them!

Lisette C.

A thing to remember about the Black vs. Snape discussion is that the books were written for children. That only really started to change during the 4th and 5th book. JKR had invested hard into making Snape an unlikable character and imagining him dunking his head against the ceiling as payback for all of his antagonism is funny to children - as it certainly was to me, when I read this book at age 10 or 11. As an adult analyzing the situation, I find it appaling, but I honestly think that many of the horrible depictions in these chapters were written for pure comedic effect without knowing that her books would ever be as popular as they ended up being. Doesn’t excuse Sirius’ actions, but I doubt JKR meant him to be unlikable at all in these chapters. And he is one of my favorites too - along with Snape ;) In my opinion, Snape is driven by fear in these scenes. I honestly think that he has been feeling unsafe this entire year and that it is all culminating for him here. He is afraid of Lupin - which he has been since seeing him in werewolf form as a child. Not only is he forced to be around him this year, but his would-be murderer - who he fears even more - is now on the loose AND heading to Hogwarts, where his dangerous werewolf friend is ready to help him past security. And nobody has been willing to listen to his warnings. Lets also not forget that he thinks that Black is coming to kill Harry - who Snape is keeping alive in honor of Lily. I doubt Snape has slept well the entire year. Not to mention that the dementors’ presence at the school certainly would affect Snape at least as powerfully as they affect Harry, since his past is way darker than Harry’s. I know that he can conjure a patronus to spare himself, but I doubt that he wants to do it if he doesn’t have to, as it would remind him of Lily.

Michelle Linardis

I really love the Snape/Sirius parallel here in these chapters. Sirius moves an unconscious Snape in a tunnel (After Hermione reminds them that they couldn’t leave him there), not caring about knocking his head/feet against the tunnel and making no effort to prevent it. Yet later when we see Harry and Hermione travel back, we see Snape lifting Sirius on a stretcher with the others to take them back to Hogwarts. As soon as he regains consciousness. Despite Snape's anger and hatred for Sirius, he is doing this without knowing he is being observed. And he doesn't hurt him when he has the perfect opportunity. A nice little detail.

Dara Jeeling

as always yout timing is impeccable. Just finished the last Beast item (so I hope I can post on friday) and made sure David keeps his foot calm... First day off after 14 days of 12 hour shifts... Let's start with Hermione s secret. Fudge also does not really believe the story (I know he only believes what is convenient for him) - but honestly it sounds sort of weird, does it? Also.... what do you think about Snapes part of the story being ignored by Dumbledore? (I know his version is not the correct one - still... ) I am sure it was written that way to show early where the characters stand. Fudge believein in the more "reasonable" story of a rown up wizard - Dumbledore going with his own decission and listening and believing 3 13 year olds over others. Also, shout out to Pomfrey - I could do with this enormous chocolate bar, please!

Dara Jeeling

for me ( and I just love potions in HP - I find it facinating) it always meant that the full effect only can take place if you take all your doses - and being able to stay sane would be only possible if each odse would be taken.

Janie

That's interesting. I have to admit I never really looked at it from Snape's POV. It makes some of his actions in this book more understandable. Thank you for pointing it out :)

Lisette C.

You are very welcome 🤗 That is the amazing thing about these books, if you ask me. That all of the characters are flawed and with their own motivations ❤️ JKR did an amazing job in that regard

Janie

I wonder why no one thought of giving Sirius the Veritaserum so he could prove his innocence. I sort of get it when he was first arrested - there were witnesses and he never really denied that he'd killed James and Lily - but now Harry, Ron and Hermione saw what happened. I know it was said that they're just kids and their word means nothing but I think it's unfair that something like this (giving someone the Dementor's kiss) can be decided by one man, even though it's the Minister himself. Also, it's interesting to see how Hermione panics in dangerous or unexpected situations, while Harry keeps a cool head and immediately knows what to do.

Josh Z

I really appreciate how much the books let big moments breathe, the movies don't and I know they have to keep moving but it diminishes the impact of such moments. I'm optimistic that a tv series will do this story much more justice because they can take their time with it.

S1lm4r1l

Sirius immediately stepping up to the Godfather plate. Offering Harry the one thing he's wanted all his life. A loving home. Notice too that it was Sirius that protected the Trio. Not Snape. Not only that, he actively tries to pull Lupin away from Ron and Pettigrew. Dunno why the movie chose to alter this and give Snape a hero moment. Nor do I think Snape should receive praise for taking everyone safely up to the Castle in the aftermath. That's the bare minimum we should expect from a Hogwarts Teacher. Sirius would never make a mailman though, his delivery of Snape's body out of the tunnel was less than kind, despite Snape's constant desire to see Sirius receive the Dementor's kiss. Did you enjoy the time travel aspect? Was it what you expected? Madame Pomfrey for President!!! Sending you good feelings. Loving your Lord of the Rings Appendices reactions btw. The Audio Commentaries for the films by the cast are utterly hilarious. (Might edit this later)

S1lm4r1l

They compliment each other really well.

Rebecca May

I'm pretty sure that Severus letting slip about Lupin's condition is covered in the final chapter, "Owl Post Again", and not either of the two in this book club.

Rebecca May

Thanks for pointing this out. <3 I was going to mention it myself if no-one else did!

S1lm4r1l

My bad. The Dementor's kiss is such a short chapter that I was convinced he'd finish up with POA.

Michelle Linardis

Thank you! It seems like such a small thing, but speaks volumes 💚

Sandra

Hi Veggie :) This chapter makes me want to start a Madam Pomfrey appreciation club. She gives me Mrs Weasley vibes when it comes to caring for people. - Having chocolate the size of a boulder - Breaking it with a hammer 'briskly' - Almost choking Harry by shoving chocolate down his throat, when he stops shouting at Fudge and Snape for a millisecond - Spluttering hysterically at anything that doesn't come under the Healer code of conduct Dementor communication interests me. When Fudge is 'telling' the Dementors to go back to Azkaban, how does he do that? It could mean a spoken thing, or a gesture. Maybe they can only follow commands from whoever controls them (Minister of Magic, then Voldemort). Edited: P.S. I had forgotten that Lupin told the Dementor to leave on the train at the start until I was re-listening your Book Club video haha. Same with Dumbledore telling them to FO during Flight of the Fat Lady. Still interesting to me! Have a nice day! :)

Karen

Hi Veggie! I want to start off saying that I’m not a Snape fan or hater, he’s a middle character for me. The movies in my option do make Snape a more likable character, like when he shields Harry and Hermione from werewolf Lupin. You can’t say for sure that book Snape would have done that too because the situation never arises, one could only hope. I feel in Chapter 21 Snape’s flaw is he allows hatred to cloud his judgement to an extent. It’s frustrated me that neither Snape or Fudge listen to Harry or Hermione. My biggest question is why Dumbledore trust Sirius? Even Dumbledore mentioned Sirius hasn’t done a great job of making himself look innocent, attacking the fat lady. Dumbledore always seems to know everything going on. Last thing. There are few things that the movies add that aren’t in the books that I really love. In this it would be the visual hints of the time traveling, like Hermione throwing the rocks, and her howling. I think it adds so much for being such a little detail.

itsanursething

I always thought Harry and Hermione should have ended up together...

Karen

Wow that’s such a great point, I never noticed that little detail.

Hawwah

In one of my first Book Clubs I wrote this about Professor Snape: The thing that characterizes book Snape is that he's verbally harsh but physically gentle. Now we have a perfect example. When Severus Snape had his arch-enemy Sirius Black at his mercy, the man he hated the most in the whole world, what did he do? He conjured a stretcher for him. He could do anything he wanted. Murder him, torture him, you name it. He didn't. Because that's not who he is. Severus Snape is not a violent man. Readers who accuse him of being a sadist fundamentally misunderstand his character. Severus doesn't seek to hurt people. On the contrary, he's consistently portrayed as the character most concerned with other people's physical safety. That's literally the opposite of a sadist. Severus' gentlessness starkly contrasts with Black's brutality. Both men found themselves in the same situation. Having their unconscious enemy at their mercy. But the way they treated them couldn't be more different. I think it tells us everything we need to know about these two characters. The contrast between them is striking and I think Rowling is too good of a writer for it to be unintentional. Severus' non-violent nature is among the top reasons why I love this character so much. It was also one of the reasons why I never believed he was a bad guy after HBP came out. Murdering Dumbledore seemed so much out of his character that I simply knew there had to be more to it. And it was.

Kunzite Blossom

It's interesting how much Harry cares for Sirius. When he found out the fake truth about Sirius he hated the man, but learning the actual truth, that hate turned to pure love. He chased after Sirius to make sure he was safe, was willing to leave the Dursleys to live with him, willing to go back in time to save Sirius. If we really stop to think about it, even learning the truth, Harry still barely knew Sirius. He was still a stranger to Harry. Knew him just a few hours at most. At least the books give so many details the movies left out to make it less weird, but both book and film it's such a weird concept. I love the hospital scene so much, Snape and the Minister being there with Harry and Hermione trying to convince them rather then JUST Dumbledore is amazing.

Janie

Well, I'm happy Hermione ended up with Ron. She and Harry always seemed more likes siblings to me.

Jacqueline Chaiton

"Black's gaunt face broke into the first true smile Harry had seen upon it. The difference it made was startling, as though a person ten years younger were shining though the starved mask; for a moment, he was recognizable as the man who had laughed at Harry's parents' wedding." Such a nice, but heartbreaking moment. Also the description of Lupin's transformation sounds absolutely horrible, it breaks my heart that he has to go through that every month even with wolfsbane to keep him sane. On a lighter note Dumbledore cracks me up every time in the time travel sequence, both in the book and the movie. This is also what I meant by the movie time travel being my personal canon up to just after the dementors, rescuing Sirius makes more sense in the book. There was no need for her to blast the door open, also there realistically wasn't nearly enough time for the conversation between Sirius and Harry that happens in the movie.

John Phillips

In the movie, Snape did protect Harry, Ron, and Hermione from Werewolf Lupin. While that didn't happen in the book, you have to remember that he was still unconscious during all of this so he wasn't able to do anything. I think if he had been conscious, he would have protected them just like he did in the movie.

Josh Z

I think people forget that Harry in the books is not attracted to Hermione, like at all. In fact if I remember correctly the highest compliment that he has concerning her looks is that she is “not ugly” On the list of things I hate that the movies did, it’s twisting Harry and Hermione’s relationship into something more than siblings that tops anything else

S1lm4r1l

> "My biggest question is why Dumbledore trust Sirius?" If I had to guess? Legilimency. Alternatively Dumbledore extracts Sirius' memories and views them with the Pensieve. I'm more inclined towards Legilimency though.

John Phillips

Snape was knocked out in the book, he couldn't do anything. If he was conscious he would have done something.

itsanursething

I know what I’m about to say is going to get a lot of hate, so I’m going to get it out of the way first. WHAT IF…Sirius WASN’T bumping Snape’s head and feet on purpose. Hear me out! Sirius has spent the last 12 years in prison without a wand, unable to do/practice any magic. And he’s now doing a hovering charm with a wand that is not his own. He’s extremely out of practice and using a wand that probably doesn’t like him. He may be struggling a bit to do the charm correctly. On that same note, I’d like to defend Sirius a bit over the last few chapters. He’s spent the last more than a decade in prison as a convicted murderer and blames himself for the death of basically his only family. I’m sure the reason he’s lost all sense of a moral compass is due to the fact that he’s convinced he’s still going to spend the rest of his life in Azkaban anyway, because who would believe his story? He already thinks of himself as a bad guy, so why not BE a bad guy? That’s not to say that I agree with what he did that was questionable, but I can kind of see where he’s coming from. I’m sure you noticed that Snape was unconscious when they all came out of the Whomping Willow and was not awake to try to protect the kids when Lupin transformed. I had honestly forgotten that was not in the book until I reread, and I’m a little sad it wasn’t. I can totally see that being something Snape would do. I’m glad the movie added that little bit in. Same with what Sirius said to Harry and Hermione before he took off on Buckbeak. I wish that conversation was actually in the books. I love that Hermione went with Harry to go after Sirius by the lake and that Harry asked for her help with the patronus charm. I love that little extra bit! Just shows how great of a friend Hermione is. Ok, I’ve rambled enough. I’m gonna go hide now.

S1lm4r1l

Personally, I think it'd have been better if the 3 had just remained life-long friends and each of them finding love elsewhere. I think that would've been much more unexpected and human.

itsanursething

I got my letter 10 years late. Don't forget! According to MuggleNet: "The theory goes that Voldemort, in his second rise to power, destroyed all the records of Muggle-born witches and wizards who hadn’t yet hit 11 years of age, thus eliminating their chance of receiving a Hogwarts acceptance letter. Voldemort gained (again) peak power during the years 1997 and 1998. If our calculations are correct, then the last set of 11-year-olds to receive their letters would have been born in 1983 and 1984. It is conceivable then, knowing his hatred for mixed blood, that Voldemort had the remaining Muggle-born records deleted – records from 1985 through 1998 when he fell. He could have done it too; he controlled the media and the Ministry. This means that anyone born between the years of 1985 and 1998 could, theoretically, be of magical blood."

itsanursething

I think Dumbledore tends to give most people the benefit of the doubt, or at the very least, lets them explain before he passes any sort of judgement. He doesn't do what Fudge did and just assume because he's a convicted killer. Dumbledore hears everyone out first.

Karen

The main purpose of my comment is just to show that the movie purposefully adds scenes to make Snape more likable compared to the book version. Also take out scenes where he is crueler, such as when Hermione teeth grow. When I first read the books, which was before DH part 2 came out. I was pretty surprised about how different the two Snape’s were, he is a bit more mean in the books compared to the movies. Don’t get me wrong I enjoy his character in both.

Darcy

These chapters are so frustrating to me. I cannot stand when people won’t believe the main characters! To this day, I still don’t understand why Sirius (or any of the other characters present) could not consent to taking Veritaserum or having their memories put in the Pensieve. This is the wizarding world and yet there is somehow no possible way to prove Sirius’s innocence. I’ve read these books so many times for years and I am still so mad about this.

Darcy

This hit too close to home bc last week I took my medication a day late and I've been suffering the consequences ever since so... not too far fetched he would still turn lol

itsanursething

Right?? Just because Harry and Hermione are 3rd years, they're incapable of telling the truth? Or MUST have been confunded? What??

Jake M

Very sorry to hear that! Hope you are okay. As I understand it, he would still turn, he just wouldn't be as mindless. So to act as wildly as if he's not had it at all, when he's had it in his system for the last six days, seems just a little far-fetched to me, was my point.

Monique

Agree totally. I think if I were Sirius I'd be offering to take Veritaserum or offering my memories to anyone willing to put them in a Pensieve. For that matter, is it not an option for your own defense when you're being tried?That said, Sirius never even got a trial so no opportunity to even offer I suppose.

Jake M

Dumbledore can't have had much fun around the Dementors that year, either, as he's had arguably more trauma than Harry & Snape combined what with him believing he killed his own sister... It seems like the Ministry didn't really think of the consequences, they just wanted to be seen doing something, and the students, Hogsmeade residents and staff all had to suffer because of it.

Jake M

My only thought is he must have used legilimency on Harry and Hermione (and maybe Sirius) to see that they at the very least *think* they are telling the truth? Whereas Snape, as a skilled occlumens, would not have been an easy mind to read, even if he had been conscious for most of the evening. Ah, if only veritaserum had been invented a book earlier...

Jake M

She's definitely a consummate professional. Have to wonder what she'd have thought of Arthur's stitches in book 5?

Jake M

It's also worth remembering that by book 7, Harry literally has to *crawl* in the tunnel, since he's grown so much, so I've no idea how everyone manages to walk in this one, unless it shrinks over time. So I definitely don't think Sirius was going out of his way to cause Snape harm at that point, he just wasn't too bothered about *not* hurting him. Like sending a glass vase in the post without bubble wrap.

S1lm4r1l

> "I know what I’m about to say is going to get a lot of hate, so I’m going to get it out of the way first. WHAT IF…Sirius WASN’T bumping Snape’s head and feet on purpose. Hear me out! Sirius has spent the last 12 years in prison without a wand, unable to do/practice any magic. And he’s now doing a hovering charm with a wand that is not his own. He’s extremely out of practice and using a wand that probably doesn’t like him. He may be struggling a bit to do the charm correctly." I think it more likely he's thinking about how to tell Harry that he is his godfather. And that if Harry wanted to live with him after his name is cleared, he could do. That's a big distraction and just because Harry notices, doesn't mean Sirius does. But I like the idea that Sirius was doing it deliberately.

S1lm4r1l

Memories can be altered. Legilimency is not fool-proof Veritaserum has antidotes. Both can be resisted with enough mind power.

S1lm4r1l

The movies actively try and make Snape less unlikeable. But they do the same with other characters too. Harry, Hermione, Sirius, Dumbledore.

Jake M

Although Slim, what is the likelihood of a prison escapee who doesn't even have a wand, having an antidote to veritaserum on his person? Given that even the meticulously prepared Moody/Crouch Jr didn't have any, I doubt a man spending most of the book as a dog would XD

Michelle Linardis

I love the details that people tend to overlook because it is so important to his character and gives those rare glimpses of the real Severus. The one we don't see in public (Or do, because not many pay attention to them).

itsanursething

Both very interesting points! Thanks for sharing!

Karen

Yes and why not check the last spells of the wands? It’s so frustrating and to me this is the beginning of Fudge being horrible at his job.

Jacob sparks

All school year harry has believed Black wants to kill him. Thinks Black even broke into there rooms and got the wrong bed. But straight after seeing the truth and really knowing nothing about Black other than he wants to kill wormtail. Harry is happy to move in with him? Dursleys really are that bad then.

Josh Z

The real world answer is because these things hadn't been introduced to the universe at the time of writing

Kristen Campbell

Hi Veggie! On the theory of Squibs, They can see magical creatures/places. example dementors (Mrs. Figg saw them) and Hogwarts (Flitch) they just down have any magical powers and they can give birth to a witch/wizard because the have the gene. I believe a squib can only be born from magical parents but wizards/witches can be born from anyone that has a magical gene in their blood line. For the chapters, I always thought the fact that they had so much time to talk to Sirius in the movie didn't make sense because they were running on a time limit. The book does it better. They wouldn't have time to talk. Dumbledore wouldn't of let Harry live with Sirius but it would of been nice to see him pop up at the Dursleys to see Harry

Maria

In the last video, you remarked on how many people said that Sirius was their favorite character and said you were curious about why he was such a favorite. Sirius is definitely one of my favorite characters, and, although I don't remember exactly when and why I started liking him, I think it probably started with the scene in chapter 20 where he offers Harry a chance to come and live with him. It's such a little moment, but it's so great and so well written. I remember reading this part as a kid and being so excited for Harry and just so happy for him. Before the other books in the series came out, I just assumed that Harry would eventually go and live with Sirius. I really enjoyed imagining what that would be like for Harry, where they would live, and the things they would do together. It's all very heartbreaking in retrospect, but it's so great to see the bond that Harry and Sirius start to form in these chapters. Also, I find the conversation Snape and Fudge have in the hospital very entertaining. These chapters are just so great!

Kevin Morris

Hey Veggie! Wanted to comment on this much earlier when you were discussing the Dementors showing up to the Quidditch game and their strange attraction to Harry, but I figured that this was a much more appropriate chapter to bring it up. The interactions between Harry and the Dementors and their fascination with him is one of the most amazing bits of foreshadowing in the entire series with hindsight. The Dementor's Kiss sucks out your soul. Now, what do we know about Harry that would make him so much more appealing than anyone else to a creature that feeds on souls?

itsanursething

OMG!!!! I never put that together!!! Amazing!

Dara Jeeling

I think that might have been a "Alan Rickman" thing. He knew some tiny bit of information behind his character and as we learnerd in the Reunion he used it to do certain things and when people (the director asked) all he said was "you'll know sooner or later" Also, Alan was known to change things with his characters - I mean look at the Sherrif of Nottingham in Kevin costners Robin Hood - almost all the good lines came from Alan... He was known to question his roles and add...

Janie

@ Josh - Exactly! That's why I never liked the scene in the 7th movie when Harry and Hermione are dancing in the tent.

Marianne

I was born in 1998 so I've still got a chance! That's a cool theory 😃

Starryk

Hi Veggie, i finally decided that its time for my first comment here. I really enjoy the Book Club and this community. Sometimes there are really great interpretations coming up here that i hadn't thought of before. These 2 chapters are really bittersweet. I really had my hopes up when Sirius offers Harry to live with him from now on and to leave the Dursleys for good. But then it all goes south and this hope is destroyed again. Not completely as Sirius can escape alive but for the largest part. I am really enjoying Time travel stories or what if scenarios so i liked the part with the time turner. It is handled in a clever way as it gets clear that nothing really changed; the trio just misinterpreted stuff before. This book really is the one i enjoy the most mainly because of Lupin and The Marauders story. Yeah a Marauders TV show written from Lupins perspective would be awesome. Now we get close to the 4th book and one that has been robbed of a lot of great and funny scenes in the movie. I will be back once we reached the first major scene.

Mel

Hi veggie ! How are you ? Okay, I know it's probably wrong what I'm about to say, but it's always crossed my mind. Up until now, Dumbledore wasn't supposed to know about Sirius' innocence... but rereading the chapter, he seems totally in the know. Even in the film. When Buck is beheaded, he already seems to know that he must be planning to divert the Minister's attention so that Hermione and Harry can hide Buck, then use him to help Sirius escape. Except that at this point in the book/movie, no one yet knows Sirius's story. Let's imagine that the Dumbledore from the day of Buck's sentencing is in fact a Dumbledore from the future, who knows the end of the story? I always thought that Dumbledore never helped the trio outside the idea of going back in time, but maybe he did... after all, Dumbledore is omniscient, but at this point in the book/film, Sirius is still guilty as hell for everyone. What could Dumbledore have known or understood at that moment to decide that buck would be useful for a future escape? By the time Buck was beheaded, had Remus already seen Peter's name on the map? I don't think so… I think it was later on. So smart that Dumbledore… One scene that touched me was when Harry discovers his patronus... We see less of this emotion in the film... the phrase, « it stared at harry, with its large, silver eyes. Slowly, it bowed its antlered head. And harry realizes… « prongs » he whispered » " he has a moment of encounter with his patronus, which is not his father, but he totally sees his father in it... it's almost a father-son moment. Metaphorically, Harry enters into communication with his father, as if it were his father looking at him with his silver eyes. On first reading, I even wondered if it wasn't his father at the time. And he becomes a stag, like his father, and therefore becomes a man. I find this moment symbolic. In the film, I find the discussion he has with Hermione, on buck's back, rather rushed. Fun fact: Do you know the origin of the dementors? this isn't a spoiler, it doesn't appear in the books, it's a side content that was explained by JKR. The anecdote is long, so I'll summarize it :) In the fifteenth century, the dark mage « Ekrizdis » (no need to read it, the name is too complicated) lived on the island of azkaban in his fortress. He would deliberately lure Muggle sailors to his island to kill them and perform somewhat dubious experiments on them. These experiments went awry, resulting in the dementors, Ekrizdis died and the dementors stayed. When the Ministry discovered the island, it was already infested with dementors who reproduced, but they feared destroying the fortress because the dementors were indestructible and seemed attached to the island. The ministry was afraid of reprisals if they fired the dementors. A succession of ministers followed, including Rowle, who decided to build the prison and collaborate with them. Love from france xx

S1lm4r1l

@Jake Whilst all that is true, it explains why the Ministry might not put at much stock in Veritaserum as the rest of us think they should.

S1lm4r1l

Dinner and Dessert!? Lovely. - Every Dementor that comes within 100 metres of Harry Potter.

S1lm4r1l

Dumbledore was clearly planning on using Hermione's time turner to save Buckbeak. All his attempts to delay and provide more time indicate that. After he realizes that Sirius is innocent, he changes the plan to enable them to escape together.

Benjamin Hütz

There is one thing that always bothers me: it was Sirious' goal from the beginning to kill peter pattigrew... because he knew the true story. After this book he goes into hiding? I mean what really changed? Peter is still free, sirious is still innocent, the whole wizarding world still thinks he is guilty (except for harry, ron, hermione, lupin and dumbledore). Why does he now leave? Yes i know that peter is not in hogwarts anymore and sirious has no idea where he went... but what would be the ministrys explanation for why sirious left hogwarts? For them he was always after harry and harry is still there. I hope this makes any sense to you, sorry my english really is not that great xD

Will

The relationship between Harry and Sirius has to be one of my favorites. Now that Harry knows that Sirius is innocent, he immediately sees him as a father figure. And my take on why that is. Sirius is James's best friend. I think Harry sees his father to be a part of Sirius. Through him, he could have a parent again.

S1lm4r1l

Dementors have mouths and hands. They probably have some sort of language or sign language maybe.

Dara Jeeling

What is the wording? Innocent until proved guilty and we can't prove Sirius is guilty of doing it on purpose. It makes sense he is doing it on purpose, but I have to get credit to your thinking. also.. short thing - you defend Sirius because he (not quoting but using own words) he is in a bad shape because of Azkaban and becuase he feels guilty for being partly responsible for James/Lily s deaths So maybe consider (just consider) Snape also feels guilty that the love of his live dies for at least as long as Sirius (winks) @Jake - IF I remember correctly the tunnel caved in in between, but I am not sure and to tired to look it up

Jake M

@Dara the only cave-ins mentioned in the books are of other passageways into Hogsmeade, but I guess that could have happened 😅 the wording in book 7 is "It was a much tighter squeeze than it had been the last time they had entered it. The tunnel was low-​ceilinged: they had had to double up to move through it nearly four years previously; now there was nothing for it but to crawl." which to me implies he's grown , but it's possible it caved in naturally in the meantime 🤷‍♂️

itsanursething

@Dara oh absolutely! I'm sure Snape feels guilty about what he did, I never assumed he didn't. Although, more than likely, he only feels guilty about Lily's death. (He REALLY hated James.) I just wanted to defend Sirius because it felt like people were just dumping on him and basically saying that he's a terrible human. To me, he's a human that terrible things have happened to and he's just lost all hope that anyone can see him as anything other than a criminal. That was all I was trying to get across :) Hope that makes sense.

itsanursething

I have a question then S1im...why was Umbridge so gung-ho about using Veritaserum when she came to Hogwarts to question students? She was all about the ministry and put her absolute faith in it. Wouldn't she have thought Veritaserum questionable?

Charlotte

omg thank you!! i’ve been trying to put into words that at this point in the book, snape is quite literally written to be annoying & disliked by the child audience, whatever people’s interpretations of him may be. i’m not even sure that at this point jkr was even planning a redemption arc for snape, i think she decided that when alan rickman was cast. sirius and the marauders’ antics and the “prank” aren’t supposed to be looked into as much as they are being done in these discussions, i know i didn’t question it as a kid. but of course as we get older we question these things and that’s fine

Lisette C.

@Charlotte I agree that they weren't supposed to be looked into as much as we are... but it is still fun :) And JKR wrote these characters so well that it makes for interesting discussion no matter what she planned and didn't :) Also, I am almost certain that JKR confirmed that she had planned the entire series out before starting to write, so I am pretty sure she knew about the Snape redemption :) But the tone definitely changed along the way and I don't think she anticipated that :)

S1lm4r1l

Well. It forces the drinker to tell the truth right? But if the drinker is ignorant, or deranged, they might tell what they believe to be the truth. But isn't. The wizarding world thinks Black is mad. Back to Umbridge: Students would have a harder time resisting Veritaserum and they are much more unlikely to have the antidote to it. I think it really stems from Umbridge's ignorance and arrogance. She puts stock in the potion. She gives it to Harry believing that he'd be forced to tell her where Sirius Black is. She arrogantly believes that you just give someone the potion and that's all there is to it. Note the questions she asks Harry: "Where is Albus Dumbledore / Sirius Black?" Now, Sirius Black is protected by a Fidelius Charm on 12 Grimmauld Place. Harry knows where Sirius is, but is magically prohibited from telling the truth, because he's not the secret keeper. A wiser wizard would ask "Do you know where Sirius Black is?" We learn later that Snape has been feeding her unreliable Veritaserum. But the reality is that Harry was never in any danger of revealing where Sirius is. (Unless Umbridge asked more questions.) Rita Skeeter was not bloviating when she said extracting information about the Dumbledores from Bathilda Bagshot required all her skills as an investigative journalist despite using Veritaserum. JKR specifically addresses Sirius and Veritaserum. "works best upon the unsuspecting, the vulnerable and those insufficiently skilled (in one way or another) to protect themselves against it... just like every other kind of magic within the books, Veritaserum is not infallible." For his many faults. Black is a powerful, capable wizard. The idea that he could resist Veritaserum is not beyond the bounds of possibility. And it requires careful questioning. There's a reason why the usage of Veritaserum is strictly controlled by the Ministry. Because it is very easy to screw up its use. Umbridge, in her ignorance and arrogance does not understand these limitations and believes she can use Veritaserum to its fullest extent.

Jake M

"Pottermania" didn't really hit until Goblet of Fire, so it's definitely possible JKR saw the first three as little more than run of the mill children's/YA books with simplified caricatures ("the hero", "the evil one", "the bully") without realising how wide an audience she'd get or how deeply people like us would read into every character? They definitely become more nuanced characters as the series progresses. Like, there are myriad other literature series that probably don't have as incisive and controversial book clubs for them as HP!

Giorgia M

I think maybe now he has something to lose so that’s why he goes into hiding until they can clear his name. Before he was on a mad mission to kill Peter, even if it meant he could die or get captured again, he didn’t care, he had nothing but his hate and his mission left to live for. Everyone hated him. Now that he is being accepted by Harry, Lupin etc, he doesn’t want to die, he has hope for a future, shown by his conversation with Harry about him coming to live with him. Does that make sense? I hope I explained it okay. This is just what I got from the book.

itsanursething

I was trying to figure out how to word exactly that Giorgia! Thank you! Yeah, he's FINALLY starting to feel human again (I think) and now cares if he gets caught.

Monique

@S1lm - agree. That's always been my take on it. He was trying to figure out how to approach Harry about being his godfather and offering him a home.

Monique

Hi Veggie! Chpt 20 - I found it so creepy that the dementor positioned Harry's face for the kiss. As we know in the movies they just sort of swoop in at them so it seemed less personal, for lack of a better word. I'm sure it will come up so I wanted to just note that I've always wondered if Sirius' casual disregard for Snape bumping into things as he moves him to be intentional or if it was because he was getting ready to approach Harry with the fact he is his Godfather and invite him to live with him. Sirius was clearly so insecure in that moment. I mean, he was offering everything he had to Harry and I felt like he was terrified of being rejected. Chpt 21 - The initial portion of the exchange between Snape and Fudge - Snape does this thing where he will 'defend' Harry and then immediately give the 'but'. Here he says they've been bewitched and then follows up with all the things for which Harry should be suspended. He did the same in Chamber of Secrets with the whole 'wrong place wrong time but'. In this case it accomplishes numerous things, it allows Snape to appear reasonable while planting the seed of Harry being bad and needing punishment while also immediately discrediting the truth from being believed by suggesting that the only reason they would say it is because they were bewitched by Sirius. Snape makes sure that there is NO chance that the trio, Sirius or Lupin will be believed with that one conversation. I think the moment when Dumbledore quietly shuts a more and more unhinged Snape down a very interesting and telling moment in the Snape-Dumbledore relationship. I do believe the movies made this relationship more 'friendly' than it may have been. I think there is respect there but I've never really noted any affection between the two. I think Dumbledore's refusal to give Snape the DADA teaching position is a clear indication of this. There is a brief exchange between Snape and Umbridge in OOTP that will tie into this so I'll say no more. I love that Harry is the one who figures out what Dumbledore wants them to do with the time turner, not Hermione. It feels more in line with the fact that Harry has a much more developed relationship with Dumbledore than Hermione so the idea that he would understand Dumbledore's motivation more than she would just made sense.

itsanursething

I noticed the dementors grabbing Harry by the neck too! So creepy!!

Monique

Yes. Very much so!

Dara Jeeling

I have always been confused by the film "relationship" of Snape and Dumbledore. as you said, it looks like friendship. The books never gave the feeling of them being friends - it always gave the feeling of Dumbledore putting his thumb on Snape to make him do what he felt was needed (like brewing Wolfsbane) I've always felt, that the only good thing Dumbledore did for Snape was to keep him out of Azkaban. I am not sure if he likes him - or if he just knows he will need Snapes abilities again in the future. For me I always thought that Snape did not get a lot to say as to where his way would go, after chaning sides. Dumbledore made sure he had him under "control" - havong him live at the school and teach ( I think given that Snape was extraordinary at potions - he could also have persued a job in being self imployed potioneer. Which I think would have suited his personality more). And let's not forget Potions isn't even his best subject - that would be DaDA... ( and yes theposition is cursed, so he can not have it. Also still do not think teaching is something for Snape no matter the subject) already said it - we can't prove Sirius lets Snape bump his head on purpose (although I think he does) but then the argument of him being insecure and distracted is believable. So until prooven guilty, innocent...

Monique

@Dara - I agree that Snape is just not well suited to teaching. He's proficient at, it if he doesn't hate the student, but that's not really enough. I think Snape would have been a very successful potion maker and it might have given him a shot at a life that wasn't defined by resentment and hatred. Sadly, he struck his bargain sealing his own fate. I think Dumbledore trusted Snape but I always got the impression, in the books, it wasn't blind trust. I also don't think DD liked Snape at all. I think he respects that Snape has lived up to his promise but that's about it and I think that was also mutual. The books give us many instances of Snape being pissed at DD. Since I know Veggie doesn't read comments under the posts I'll refer to that moment when Umbridge was inspecting Snape's class. He admits that he has applied for the DADA position every time it has been open. That means that DD opted to let Fudge appoint Umbridge rather than let Snape have the DADA position. That speaks volumes but it's immediately overshadowed by the 'obviously' moment. DD knows better than anyone else that Snape spends the majority of the books punishing a child for the sins of his father. It's particularly vindictive considering the kid has already spent 10 years being abused as a result of Snape's own actions. It felt like Snape would love nothing more than for Harry to continue to suffer the entire time he is at Hogwarts. Any humiliation or harsh punitive action is perfectly fine just so long as Harry doesn't actually die since that was the price DD demanded of Snape but aside from that, anything goes. Wanting to make an abused orphan's life harder is just such an awful goal it's hard to stomach. I feel like DD should have required the same double agent activity of Snape but he shouldn't have inflicted Harry and Snape on each other. The hatred is mutual once Harry realizes that there is nothing he could ever do to have a different relationship with Snape. That choice of DD's made both Harry and Snape's lives exponentially worse. As to how DD feels about Snape, I always go back to the exchange when Snape was begging DD to hide Lily. When Snape admitted he'd already asked Voldy to spare her but not James or Harry and DD tells Snape, "You disgust me" That's the absolute harshest language I recall DD ever uttering. I aways figured DD had some way to be sure Snape was controlled but honestly have never come up with how. What is not in any doubt is that he had Snape by the short hairs for sure. I concede that it's entirly possible Sirius was bumping Snape on purpose! There was definitely enough hate between them for that to be more than feasible. I just always got the impression he was distracted more than petty at that particular moment.

Hairy Pothead

Place this in a reply to Monique (press little chat bubble below comment) since most of this hasn't been covered in the books at this point.

Dara Jeeling

@Monique I totally agree with you on DD never liking Snae (for reasons) - even as a child. Maybe he realized something in Snape that made him connect him to his younger (more selfish and dark self). But then again, it's just my way of looking at the characters. I know that nothing annoys me more then to see my own flaws in someone else (like my oldest daughter)... For me ( just my head canon) most of the really powerful witches and wizard in the Wizarding World are versed in bot light and dark magic. So for me, being good at Dark Arts/defence against it is nothing someone should hold against a with or wizard. Dumbledore in his youth was even greyer then he was as "wise old head of school". McGonagall and Moody both are able to use Dark Arts as well and are at least not unknowing. Actually as much as I really love the character Snape - there are some actions I can not really defend (as much as I tend to defend him - because I feel he is one of the characters with the worst cildhood story). Also - eah I was not happy with him only asking for Lily s live, since if he was even a bit more empathic he would have known Lily would never step aside to let someone harm her child. But maybe he did not dare ask for Harry s live, since Voldemort had already decided he would kill Harry - no matter what. As for the DaDA job, I always though since Dumbledore could not predict what would befall the teacher (hurt, dissapearance, death) he could not let Snape teach - no matter how much more qualified he was for the job then say Gilderoy, Lockhart or Umbridge... since DD was sure he would need Snape again - once Voldemort returns. Also for me the reason Harry has to live with the Dursleys is just a result of a tiny thing Snape heard. DD decides where he places Harry (despite McGonagall warning him off) - and the reason Voldemort could reach Harry is Pettigrew s fault for me. BUt yes, Snape set the whole chain in motion

Logan

This is where fudge really became one of my most disliked character, I think he’s up there with umbridge. Fudges only motivation is to maintain power and do what is easy instead of what is right. If this was the muggle world and they had just caught a serial killer then there would be weeks worth of court cases and the gathering of all evidence. Even though I think they would struggle to prove the innocence of Sirius with Peter running away, it’s the right thing to do.

S1lm4r1l

If Dumbledore had contempt for Snape it was probably because Snape reminded him of himself. Dumbledore constantly nudges Snape in the right direction, I think Dumbledore would've seen a lot in Snape that he disliked in himself, or himself when he was younger. And just like Dumbledore and the situation with Ariana. Lily's death was not enough for Snape to suddenly change the less savoury aspects of himself. Dumbledore consciously refused to exercise those muscles that had led him astray, and I think he nudged Snape in the right direction a lot of the time. Snape is clearly at his worst when Dumbledore's influence is absent.

H

When re-reading these chapters, I had completely forgotten that Snape was still unconscious when Lupin turned into the wolf, because of the whole thing from the movie where he arrived just after and then started protecting the trio. I had also forgotten that Hermione howling was a film thing! And also that she was down by the lake with Sirius and Harry. I think the changes in this part of the story is fine, though. I love what the patronus – «"Prongs," he whispered» – means to Harry now when he's heard the story about the Marauders. Suddenly it's a connection to his father, in the same way that Sirius also is that for Harry.

Dara Jeeling

I agree with the "childrens book" part. I have to admit I was reading them when they were released BUT I was already older (my oldest dauhter is born in 1999 - I am born in 1976) so for me even in book 1 it was clear Snape was NOT the bad guy (not a pleasant teacher but not the main villain) because it's described in detail how Quirel is knocked over. Why do that if it was enough to break Snape s eye contact? I will not go so far as to say I was sure Snape was not bad - BUT I can tell you I was sort of put down for my interpretation at the end of the HBP - because for me the "Severus, PLease" (not sure how it's said in the book) for me always menat, that he intended for Snape to kill him. He was not begging to be safed, but begged for death. And that (with the Pensieve Memory in Goblet) was more then enough for me to believe Snape has always been on DD s side (which was not true - but yeah). That was also the reason I may not like the adult Marauders as much and do not like the bulying part of the "kid" Marauders as well. I always made sure to talk about the things whenever my kids came up with questions (without spoiling, but I made sure my kids understand that bullying is a BAD thing). But yes, it's so great to see other interpretations!

Lisette C.

I completely understand! While waiting for Deathly Hallows I only found one (ONE!) other person who believed as I did that Snape was a good guy and that Dumbledore had arranged for Snape to kill him. And let me tell you, it wasn't for lack of trying either x) I discussed it with everybody who wanted to :) Just as you said, the "Severus, please" was enough for me too :) But it is certainly good that it wasn't clear to everybody :) Or it would have been a lousy plot twist! ;)

Gothic Llama

Couple of my thoughts on these two chapters: - I wonder if Snape had a mad headache after all that scraping and bumping in the tunnel - I love Sirius timidly asking Harry to live with him. That would've been awesome! And to be honest I prefer the film version, it's more heartwarming. - "Personally I try to treat him like any other student" Are you sure about that Snape? - Why did Harry and Hermione appear in the Entrance Hall after using the Time Turner in the Hospital Wing? Does it also teleport you? Now the two major things I very confused about: 1. I've read the series countless times as a child and it never occured to me - why didn't Sirius turn into a werewolf? Now hear me out. After he fights Lupin in his dog form, we are informed that he is bitten and scratched, which would normally turn a person into a werewolf like it happened with Lupin as a child. Maybe Sirius wasn't turned because he was in his animagus form? But then we have to take Pettigrew into account - if you get injured as a human, those injuries transfer to your animal form as is with his missing finger. We could then argue that the same happens the other way - the injuries you sustain as an animal transfer to your human form... but then again, we didn't get any description of injured Sirius by the lake with Dementors nor during the rescue, so maybe it doesn't transfer animal form to human? Or is there a natural law that you can't be an Animagus and a werewolf at the same time? 2. If Lupin turned into a werewolf only when the full moon was shining on him, does it mean he can avoid turning if he stays in a completely dark room or a cellar? What about if there's a heavy storm? I mean he was fine when it was cloudy. Also, does it mean he can turn during the day in summer when you can see the moon in broad daylight? It just bothers me that it is now established or at least heavily hinted that a werewolf turns only when the moon is visible and to me it's just a bit of a weak storytelling or trying really hard to just think of something to move the plot further. What are your thoughts on this, Veggie?

Kattie Martin

One of the few things the movie did better was that night's time travel foreshadowing. I'm curious on why they didn't show that Hermione was trying to help Harry fight off the dementors, were they afraid to show her failing or was it because they felt it unnecessary. Also, is it just me or did that dementor attack sound more terrifying than in the movie.

S1lm4r1l

> "Are you sure about that Snape?" Doesn't try very hard perhaps. :D > "Maybe Sirius wasn't turned because he was in his animagus form?" Animagi are immune to Lycanthropy, its unclear how they interact however. > "But then we have to take Pettigrew into account - if you get injured as a human, those injuries transfer to your animal form as is with his missing finger. We could then argue that the same happens the other way - the injuries you sustain as an animal transfer to your human form... but then again, we didn't get any description of injured Sirius by the lake with Dementors nor during the rescue, so maybe it doesn't transfer animal form to human?" Lycanthropy isn't a physical injury though, its a disease/condition. > "If Lupin turned into a werewolf only when the full moon was shining on him, does it mean he can avoid turning if he stays in a completely dark room or a cellar? What about if there's a heavy storm? I mean he was fine when it was cloudy. Also, does it mean he can turn during the day in summer when you can see the moon in broad daylight? It just bothers me that it is now established or at least heavily hinted that a werewolf turns only when the moon is visible and to me it's just a bit of a weak storytelling or trying really hard to just think of something to move the plot further." It's implied that Lupin gets sick in the days before and after the full moon. It is an inconsistency, there must be any number of ways to conceal a Werewolf from the moon, but it only takes a second to trigger the transformation. Maybe they do try and hide from the Moon.

Garry (Not Jerry)

The only way I can see this working is if both parents are squibs, and they have other children who are magical. Imagine you are a squib and you marry another squib. You expect your children to be witches/wizards. The first two are, the third one is a muggle. In that situation, I can imagine that you may refer to them as a squib.

Garry (Not Jerry)

I pretty sure dementors can talk. You just never see them doing it.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Nah…Mes Figg couldn’t see the dementors she was just making it up. Bad plan in my opinion. Would’ve been more believable if she was honest. She could feel them though. Filch can presumably see Hogwarts because he lives there. If he was viewing it from the afar he would need a wizard to guide him in order to get there in the first place.

Garry (Not Jerry)

I notice that in the movie Pettigrew uses his wand to turn back into a rat, but the whole point of being an animagus as that you can turn into an animal at will, without needing a wand. It plays out a little differently in the book, but why do you think Peter didn’t turn into a rat earlier? My theory is that the spell to force him to turn into a human has a grace period, so he can’t turn back for at least a few minutes.

Sandra

Ah cheers- that's what was confusing me!

Marianne

Yes that would work but I guess they would all be considered Squibs instead of muggles due to having magical ancestors

Diego Zenhäusern

I just wanted to say, that I feel kinda bad, that you apologized so profusely to Hermione for laying Harry's words into her mouth, just for her to call "Sirius' (inadvertent) murder attempt" a "trick" in this chapter. (I had completely forgotten about that myself🙈🤔.) In her defense I would say that she is trying to prevent the "murder" of an innocent man an therefore is in a panick. But it still is a poor choice of words. But hey, live would be boring if we were to be perfect all the time, so I personally will forgive her this misjudgement🤔🙂

Garfnob

Greetings. First time in the book club. Have posted to several YouTube videos. Enjoying your videos, and thought. first series that has prompted me to patronize someone. Chapter 19 (but i think it still has merit to actions in 20) -Pettigrew is a Gryffindor? what traits does Peter have that put him in Gryffindor? "Gryffindor are courage, chivalry, and determination." this also puts the lie to all wizards that went bad are in Slytherin. well "Slytherin are ambition, resourcefulness, determination, and cleverness." Peter sounds more like a Slytherin to me. Chapter 20 -Herry went from you are a murder and I want to kill you to ya I will go live with you in short order. Kids. Chapter 21 - Snape has a point about the threes opinion of themselves and they lenience they get. -so Snape, where they consorting with or trying to catch Black. You cannot have it both ways. That is a common problem with people. Trying to have things both ways, but with how much attention to detail you need to be to be good at positions, I would have expected better of Snape. -Dumbledore “I do not have the power to make other men see the truth." Too bad truth potions has not been invented yet (by the author). Would have cleared everything up, and as wizards do not seem to care about protecting the innocent on trial I doubt there is the right not to incriminate yourself, or the innocent could volunteer to take the potion. All you would need for any trial is some truth potion and someone who know the right questions to ask, wording of the questions would be of great important. -how does the time turner decide where to drop you off? It is not at the place you left from in a different time or the place you were at the first time in the destination time. -why must you not be seen? In this case you are doing “crime” so should not be seen in any case time travel or not. Hermione has been seen by others when time traveling all year at least 2 whole classes at a time. The only problem is the same person seeing two of you at the same time. One example, Hagrid seeing them get the cloak from the tree would be no problem he would just think they did not go directly back to the castle (witch they didn't in ether time line). The part about not seeing your self is only a problem if you go back to a point before you knew you could time travel. So, in this case Harry should not see Harry, but the only problem with Hermione seeing Hermione is past Hermione may wonder why she went back in time in this case, as class and test are over and there should be not reason. -how does Buckbeak hover. The hummingbird is the only bird that can hover. Raptor wings attached to a horse definitely could not. at least in the movie Buckbeak lands on the tower. P.S. You will have to live with my bad spelling, I do. :) (dyslexia , and other problems with how English "works")

Garfnob

sorry for the second post but i feel this is vary important. i want the message to get to everyone it can and i know many will not go back to an old video and see it. the short version. (long version in the 18-19 video) a sufferer of PTSD has no control of what will tiger an episode or when. not letting it effect them because of X is not an option. sorry if this comes across the wrong way but PTSD is not something to down play or even imply the sufferer has ANY control over. too many people think PSTD is not an excuse to have problems with basic tasks like holding a job and the sufferer just wants handouts. depending on the severity and triggers it can be any ware from inconvenient to debilitating. thank you for your time and consideration. i will do my best not to make social commentary this topic is just so important to me and i got so worked up over your comment.

Grace S

Hi Veggie! First time on Patreon here and it feels good to break out the old books. First of all, one of my favorite moments is in chapter 20, that got cut off in the movie. Sirius asks Harry to live with him and they get to finish their conversation! It always made me happy that Sirius got to smile at least once in this book. I find it interesting that in the movie they gave the protector role to Snape. It was really Sirius who stood in front of the kids, and Sirius who shoved them out of danger's way. As for the second chapter, I have never really liked Snape but in this chapter he is downright nasty, he knows that Sirius is doomed and he is trying to get all that he can out of it. Sirius is my favorite character so I might be biased but I really think Snape steps out of line here, especially when he yells at Hermione. Speaking of, now you can yell at her properly since she called the prank a stupid trick. Have a lovely rest of your day and I can't wait to hear your thoughts on my uber long comment. Also, I've noticed that you would like a show about the marauders from the perspective of lupin! I personally recommend reading all the young dudes, it's a very famous fanfiction that a lot of Harry Potter fans know. It includes all of the marauders years at Hogwarts up until after the battle of Hogwarts. I was surprised to find how well written it was, and I'm sure you can find an audio version on YouTube as well.(after you finish the books of course, since this is not canon, just something I think you might enjoy, like a very Potter musical.)

Grace S

I believe that Dumbledore did know about Sirius, which is what makes me so angry that he would let Sirius go to Azkaban, if he already knew.

Grace S

True, however we can't forget that Snape is taking him to where he will receive the dementor's kiss...

Michelle Linardis

He's rightfully taking him to the authorities as he has no reason to believe of his innocence, because he did not see Peter. But he did not torture or even attempt to hurt Sirius' body when he was knocked out, despite the perfect opportunity to do so. Sirius actually did take the opportunity to hurt Severus when he was knocked out.

Garfnob

Squibs can see dementors it would be a ridiculous lie as it would not be hard to confirm, and Dumbledore not make a mistake like that. he used to be the hi mugwump after all. Mes Figg is just nervous in front of the highest court. i do not know where you live, but say you are called to testify in front of the supreme court and the president is there questioning you as well. most people would be nervous. so, Filch cant go to town without getting help to get back. there is no mention of the anti muggle charms extending to Hogsmed.

Garfnob

sure a Squibs can give birth to a wizard so can a muggle. the question is can 2 muggles give birth to Squibs (someone that can see the magic world and anti muggle protections do not work on). i would say yes Squibs have some of the powers but not to manifest magic. noware does it mention it is a genetic thing but that would make seance a recessive trait. i do think you hit on the difference Squibs can see the magic world and muggles cannot.

Michelle Linardis

100%! Actions speak louder than words. And yet we're still so early into this series, that we still have more examples of this yet to happen.

PumpkinSparks

Hi Veggie! I've been a long time youtube watcher and short time patreon person, but I wanted to catch up on my reading before commenting. I have A LOT of opinions on several topics that were brought up in the last couple of months (Hermoine, the whole quidditch/broom stick debacle, the very flawed school system, the ramification of being muggle born vs statue of secrecy, so so many illogicalities - is that a word? - with the wizarding world...) but I don't want to take over the comment section. So I will limit myself to mention one of them for now, and one thing about these chapters that really struck me since I was a child, and might discuss the others by-and-by in the next couple of book clubs, if that is okay. I totally understand if you want to keep the comments focused on the chapters, and will limit myself accordingly, BUT my autistic ADD brain gets excited easily and wants to share all the informations ;) Speaking of which, that brings me to Hermoine and the whole emotions vs logic thing with her. I have always read her as being on the spectrum. She tackles emotional situations with pure logic, which is something I can absolutely relate to. In school I was often called stone cold, because I wouldn't really get emotional (upset, but not like emotional about it) and my idea of soothing someone who is upset, is breaking the situation down in its logical parts and looking at them from all sides. Intellectually I understand how that might not help a neurotypical person, but that is my first instinct when I'm upset. I also tend to take too many classes and having an interest in pretty much everything there is to learn. Hermoine tends to do the same. She is incredibly book smart, logics her way out of situations, sometimes has troubles with emotional intelligence, and (no spoilers) in the next book she gets consumed with a special interest. All of that reads neurodivergent to me. The situation with Lavenders rabbit is a perfect example. First, when she was only upset about the rabbit, Hermoine said what we learned we're supposed to say "I'm really sorry". Then, when Parvati pointed out the Trelawney thing and Lavender got even more upset, THAT is something we can address. We can tackle that problem logically, realize that Trelawney is full of shit, and find that we don't have to be upset about that part - surely that makes us feel better! Obviously, that is not the only way to read Hermoine (and I am 99.5% sure that the author didn't intend to write her as being on the spectrum), but that is how I always interpreted her and I feel that she presents a lot of autistic traits. As for these chapters (actually it is a bit more chapter 19, but still relevant here): I never understood why Peter was part of the friend group. I understand why he wanted to be - he absolutely idolized especially James and Sirius, as we're being told by several different people - but why would they include him into their clique? The way he was described, he was a fanboy following his idols like a puppy. The equivalent would be if the trio would decide to include Colin Creevey. It just does not make sense! Also, the whole animagus thing. I might not understand it correctly, but the way I read it the wizard chooses the form they will take when becoming an animagus. And once it's set, it's set. They certainly imply, that James and Sirius decided that a big animal will be the most useful with keeping a werewolf in check. If it wasn't the case that you have a choice, they truly gambled with a huge disadvantage on their chances. The probability of becoming a small animal is WAAAAAY higher than a big one! But then WHY did Peter become a rat? They say it was so he could press the willow button, but they could have used a stick like everyone else. I think it's one of the many instances of the author not thinking further than the two sentences on the page and not planning for the implication that has for the story and world she is building. But it just bothers me... I'm really sorry this got so long and rambly... I try editing it down to be slightly more concise - I did not achieve it. Lastly, to achieve my goal of giving love to all the puppers, please give Woozle some scritchy-scratchies from this german Hufflepuff :)

Milana

The part about Bill Weasley is a spoiler, you might want to remove it as Veggie consistently asks for no spoilers / any information related to any events of future books

Janie

I think you wanted to reply to PumpkinSparks' comment. You can do so by clicking on the little bubble icon right right under the original comment.

Kate Bogd

Hi Veggie! As I missed last book club I need to add some fuel to the fire here 😁 I think saying Snape has PTSD is a major stretch. People read too deeply into each chapter to find excuses for him, but PTSD is not something to plop on any character on a whim. There’s not enough evidence to suggest PTSD, at least not in how JKR wrote it. She wrote him as a prideful and selfish character, whose pride was deeply hurt and who now seeks revenge. He is somewhat justified in his actions, but let’s not pretend he is innocent and perfectly righteous. And I also want to give praise to the movie: I really love how they did the time traveling sequence. The stone throwing and Hermione’s howling tie the time loop into a bow so beautifully. It is more satisfying than the book. I also like the dementors part in the movie, it is very scary as it should be. If only they took time ahead of it to explain that full-fledged patronus takes shape of an animal, it would be perfect.

John Phillips

You're looking way too much into it. If you're gonna be so negative about the books, then why are you even here? Plus you've already used a couple of spoilers. Veggie doesn't know much about "truth potions" and he doesn't know anything about Bill Weasley. Edit your comments and delete the spoilers.

Dara Jeeling

I actually hope Veggie finishes the books, be fore he delves into some sort of always biased fan fiction. That being said, I never read any fanfiction (and yes, that includes the cursed child) but then I can not imagine the school years being unbiased towards the Marauders behaviour twards Snape (or others hte picked upon). So I really hope Veggie stay in the book and finishes them before doing anthing. As for the film giving the protector role - I see this differntly, especially after the reunification. For me this was one of Alan Rickman s decision. He was well known for doing things his way and in the reunification Danile stated that he did things and when people asked he was just like "you'll know later why" (sort of). So I always thought that was one of those instances. Would sort of fit Also... I do not really like that scene. I woukd have prefered to have the film being more accurate especially in that instance (and the shrieking shack and the backup story about the "prank") And I can understand why Snape is doing what he is doing with Fudge. For him the Marauders ( especially Sirius) is the person who tried to kill him as a teen. It's not a nice character trait and it's not very grown up either, My Great Grandmother always told us as children "if you need to yell, you're in the wrong" and that is what I think about, when Snape yells. Also, welcome to the book club where you will find the ever present discussion about Snape/Marauders and Snape in especially. (and yes, I am usually one who defends Snape, but we now come up to some of the actions I have trouble defending, especially with what will come up in GOblet)

Dara Jeeling

Hi PumpkinSparks if I am not mistaken you can not choose your animagi form. It's unpredictable. It is almost always the same as your patrouns (unless it changed it's form like Tonks one did when she fell in love with Lupin). What is also stated by JK is that werwolfes only attac humans (and can only transfer thir condition to humans). So for me the decision to become animagi would still make sense, because the others wanted to keep Remus company. As for Peter being included in the group - I havean idea, I am willing to share and you do not have to like it, but give it a thought. I do not think Peter was really that bad at magic. He probably was not as good as James/Remus/Sirius - but I still think he must have been decent. He was able to get the Potion done that revived Voldemort and because I am really interetsed in the Potion part (having studied to be a Chemistry teacher, before deciding to go for Kindergarten) this can not have bee an easy potion. We know it invoved venom from Nagini... For me - James and Sirius including him tells me, the were far more keen on being adored the Harry will ever be. It does not make sense - but there are people who crave attention and maybe if he was not all the untalented - why not include him, get a bit of hero worship on the side as well (?) Yes, that shows you I do not look favorably on the Marauders (especially the young one who bully people at school). For me that way it would make sense. As said, thats's just what I think. I am fine if anyone sees this differntly.

Dara Jeeling

I am fine with that. But then, please do not give the credit of the doubt to other characters. I have stated it before, I am a huge fan of Snape (and I was one of the people who always told Veggie he is meaner in the books) - but I am also sure I still see him as as flawed as he is. However since I got this since 20 years... Someday you just get sort of tired to hear that he is a nasty bully (and that is why he is a bad character/person). And let's not forget even Harry stated at the end "he was the bravest man I ever knew" - not the nicest or friendliest one. Yes, his youthfull pride was deeply urt and now he is out for revenge. But then the same would apply to Sirius - would it not (in regards to Pettigrew)? And people are always like "poor Sirius, he was cast out from his family" and yes that is awfull, but he had the Potters to go to and to support him. People overlook that Snaoe has been described as (and no I did not look it up - so this may not be totally correct) as scrawny/thin/uncared for and in second hand robes. So his childhood/teen years were no joyride either I guess. I am totally fine if people do not want to go with the PTSD for him. And for me (and yes I needed a few semsters of psychology for my mastery) the known backstory (child abuse/unloving family / school bullying/near deatch experience) are enough things to sort of assume he MIGHT have had PTSD. Especially with the dementors all around who suck all your happy thoughts out of you (but again, other characters would have been affected as well) - so I do not count that one for this year. Also that being sad, PTSD could also be used for a lot of other characters - Sirius, Remus, Harry, Hermione (being petrified and such), Draco and so on. So I do not use that as an excuse, just a reminder that things might not bee what they seem. But then I am fine with people who see him as just selfish and nasty.

PumpkinSparks

Absolutely agree! Sirius was always one of my favourite characters. I - no lie - had a huge crush on book Sirius. I always saw him as somewhat rock'n'roll. When you read these chapters as a young teen (and the many times I've read them since until my mid-twenties) you get infected with the giddieness Harry felt. Finally leaving the Dursleys. Finally having a real family. Finally feeling as close to his parents as he could. Finally being happy and safe. And all of that with this cool badass uncle. How could we not like him? Reading these chapters now, however, after not picking up the books for about a decade and being in my mid-thirties, they really hit differently. His comment, that it wouldn't have been so bad if Severus would have died or turned from his 'prank' doesn't feel cute and sarcastic, but absolutely unremoresful and negligent. When Snapes head keeps bopping against the ceiling it doesn't feel funny and cool, but like an arsehole move and really? that's the rolemodel you wanna be to your godson? Don't get me wrong, I still absolutely love him. But I now see A LOT of problems with him. Which - granted - makes him a better character in my book. People are complicated. But it certainly makes him problematic. And I can already imagine several instances in future books, that probably feel just the same...

PumpkinSparks

That is an interesting read on the whole Peter situation. I do agree, that Peter was a better wizard than people give him credit for. He seemed insufficient because he surrounded himself with what can only described as prodigies. I didn't think it weird on that part. I always found it strange, because the others seem to look down on him even as a "friend". Why include him into their clique? Granted, I didn't consider James and Siriuses God complexes. Which they certainly had. I love the Maurauders, but they are very very flawed! It still doesn't feel right thoguh. I feel like they would have surrounded themselves with him, but wouldn't have been as close as it is suggested. But I will jot it down as one of the many inconsistencies from the author, where she didn't think further than the two sentences on the page...

PumpkinSparks

I do not agree that this is being negative. You can be (and should be, imo) critical about the media you consume. There are a lot of problems and inconsistencies within the books. You can call them out and still enjoy the books! But I do agree that this is quite spoilery for Veggie. So you might want to edit your comment and leave out the whole Bill/shell-cottage part - which truly does not make sense, I agree ;)

John Phillips

But that is just nitpicking the smallest stuff. I don't have to be critical of anything I consume. You can be critical if you want, but it really comes off as negative and petty if you're nitpicking.

Methanoutput

Hey Veggie, right now i have many things to do irl, so i Just wanted to leave a comment here, saying thanks for taking so much of your time, to talk about these books. Can't wait to hear your thoughts and the different opinions from other comments. The hours i can hear you talk about this stuff, always means relaxing from a stressful life for me right now.

Raider Max

I just want to take this time to give you some much deserved and well earned praise. The work you put in to do this kind of review as well as your other stuff does not go unrecognized. You may call us Veggie Knights but we are indeed fans of yours. It is an honor and privilege to help you with these summaries. Us Potterheads love talking Harry Potter and I am grateful to see this community come together and share their thoughts with you as you experience them for the first time and as we again relive the books. Thank you Veggie.

Raider Max

Man again we have back to back comments and this time we had the same thought process hahahaha.

Monique

Thanks Hairy! Have been away and didn't see anything so thanks. I'd hate to be responsible for discussion that spoiled anything!

Monique

@S1lm - I just typed out a great big reply and lost it! Let me sum up - I agree completely. Dumbledore knew his failings and I think he saw those same failings in both Snape and Sirius, just different aspects of his failings and as a result gave each man more chances than anyone else would have. The fact that the movies just seemed to basically skip the entire aspect of Dumbledore being such a troubled young man and why was awful. Finding out about this was such a huge challenge for Harry emotionally. Everything he thought he knew about everyone he had admired, loved or had been mentored by had been challenged and every one of them was now dead. That left Harry to find his peace with their flaws and come out the other side knowing he could love them and acknowledge they had made mistakes.

Monique

I agree! I think they had to keep Hermione perfect in the movies and the dementor attack was so much creepier in the book. It felt personal in the book. The dementors enjoyment of the process felt more visceral int he book rather than just a 'duty' they had in the film. Ya know?

Hairy Pothead

Rewatched the movie and noticed that Snape is basically the hero who's trying to catch Black and then randomly gets attacked by Harry without the trio even saying a word, then knocked out by a werewolf, then disappears for the rest of the movie, poor guy! :D It's interesting how book Snape still seems to be focused on revenge over truth, even hours after the events in the Shrieking Shack. He tries to discredit the trio instead of telling Fudge or Dumbledore about the things he heard Lupin explain, or that he saw the rat (when the book makes the rat a center piece of the scene with how Black is staring it down and how 'the only sound apart from Lupin's voice was Scabbers's frightened squeaking'). It seems unlikely that Snape would actually think that Black could fool Dumbledore with a complete lie, so it seems to me like his conversation with Dumbledore is based on feelings rather than rational thinking.

Hawwah

You know perfectly well that Severus had no way of knowing that Pettigrew was the real traitor, that he was still alive and that he was disguised as Ron's rat. He was knocked out cold before Pettigrew was forced to show himself and when he regained consciousness, Pettigrew was already gone. Severus never saw Pettigrew that evening.

Hawwah

"selfish character" Severus consistently puts his own life at risk to protect others. That's literally the exact opposite of "selfish".

Hawwah

@Lisette That's interesting. When I first read HBP, I thought it was obvious that Snape was a good guy. It was only after I joined a HP discussion when I found out that many people actually believed he had been on Voldemort's side all along. The discussion forum I attended was divided roughly 50/50 though.

Hawwah

When Harry believed Black was responsible for his parents' deaths, he wanted him to recieve the dementor's kiss. Fandom: Understandable. Black and Lupin wanted to take the law in their own hands and straight up murder the person responsible for the Potters' deaths. Fandom: Understandable. Severus Snape decides to turn Black, the person he sincerely believes is a mass murderer who betrayed Lily to her death, to authorities. Fandom: WHAT AN EVIL GUY!!! Double standards. Double standards everywhere.

Hawwah

Facts! For me personally this scene was the exact moment when I was definitely convinced Severus was a good person at heart. (Edit: I decided to shorten my comment and by doing so I deleted the part you were reacting to. But I'm sure it will come up again in same future Book Club!)

Lisette C.

@Hawwah It was obvious to me too 🙂 But I also found it obvious that we weren't supposed to find it obvious 😅 Snape was the "obvious bad guy" set up to be semi antagonistic throughout the entire series imo 🙂

Grace S

Let's try to keep it civil here.

itz_Cherise

Regarding why Peter is in Gryffindor, it isn’t always about the traits you have, but the traits you value. For example, Hermione believes that friendship and bravery are more important that cleverness and knowledge, and although being clever and knowledgeable are key traits Hermione has, she doesn’t place them in the highest value, so she isn’t a Ravenclaw. It’s probably similar for Peter. He values people who are bravery and loyalty because he wants people with those traits to protect him lol.

emmainkeri

Hey Veggie! I made it in time!! Phew! Sirius being happy about the possibility of Harry moving in, do you think it's because of wanting to provide for Harry and genuinely stepping in as a godfather, or is he excited about getting a piece of James back? I think it might be a bit of both. But I truly believe he cares about Harry just for Harry, it's not always about James. Sirius had already been in Harry's life actively for a full year before Lily and James died. I also love the description of Sirius' first real smile: "The difference it made was startling, as though a person ten years younger was shining through the starved mask; for a moment, he was recognisable as the man who had laughed at Harry's parents' wedding." The last time Harry looked at that photograph, he still believed Sirius was a murderer and almost didn't recognise him as the man from the wanted posters. I'd like to know what you think of the werewolf design in the movie vs the book! In the book they look a lot like regular wolves. This is rare coming from me, but I actually love the design they ended up with, even though it's not an accurate portrayal. I know a lot of book fans hated it. I think the scene where the dementors attack feels much worse in the books, much more emotional and desperate. There's a dementor that is actually about to kiss Harry, and the way the book describes that moment, and the dementor lowering its hood, is chilling. In the movie Harry just kind of sits there, lol. Chapter 13, Gryffindor versus Ravenclaw, Harry casting a Patronus at Malfoy: "Something silver white, something enormous, erupted from the end of his wand. He knew it had shot directly at the dementors but didn't pause to watch -" And after Harry catches the snitch: "'That was quite some Patronus,' said a voice in Harry's ear." I think Lupin realized there, that Harry's Patronus was a stag. Imagine how he must've felt :) I can't wait to hear what your reaction to Snape yelling in chapter 21 was. All I'm going to say about that right now is, he was WAAAAYYY out of line. I'm sorry my comment is getting really long, but don't you think it was an odd choice to have Ron have a cast on his leg in the movie? According to herself, Madam Pomfrey can fix broken bones in a heartbeat (she literally REGREW Harry's overnight). In the book Pettigrew's spell was a bigger concern to Harry and Hermione than the broken leg, and I think it's also why Ron was still unconscious. Also, I love how the first thing Sirius did while he was getting rescued, was ask about Ron. Thank you again for what I'm going to assume is another excellent 5 hour video. Thank you ❤️ ps. that "change my mind meme" is effing amazing. Perfectly edited.

Simon audsley

" Anything can happen in the next half...er..five hours" "Ullo" Sorry to see you didn't get my officer crabtree greeting from last time, 80'sitcoms not your thing. Have to say that the dementors kiss chapter is far superior to the film much more chaotic having Ron chained to lupin really ups the stakes and I feel the dementors are better herethan the movie having them more human makes them a lot more unnerving and creepy than the specters in the film and the fact they can clearly reason is also an added bonus. Hermione's secret is also a lot more reflective in tone than the film and I think I prefer it there always seems to be a tendency in film to add action for action sake rather than giving us all a breather. Well not long now till you get to the book I've been waiting for. Also a Muggle born squib would be a Muggle. Ta Ta for now

emmainkeri

I also 100% believe Figg saw the dementors. She ran towards Harry yelling "Dementors!! In Little Whinging!" Also squibs like Filch can see Hogwarts and other places protected by magic that muggles can't.

emmainkeri

While it's true they wanted to make Hermione flawless, I think in this case, they didn't include her because they wanted to make it Harry's moment. He failed alone and later succeeded alone. It also allowed them to focus the camera on him and Sirius, and their relationship alone.

emmainkeri

I don't think Pettigrew uses the wand to turn back into a rat in the movie, he just picks it up because it's a literal magic wand and he currently doesn't have one in his possession. The wand even gets expelliarmused out of his hand and THEN he turns into a rat. That's how I've always seen it anyway :)

Garry (Not Jerry)

Interesting. I’ll re-watch the scene, but it looked to me like he picks up the wand, points it at himself and performs a spell to turn into rat. Then it gets expelliarmused but it’s too late.

Garry (Not Jerry)

I thought the same at first, but I don’t think this was ever JKRs intention. She can “see” them, in the sense of feeling their presence, and obviously recognises what they are, being a squib she will be familiar with what they are, and likely even encountered them before. But in the hearing, even Harry thinks that it sounded like Mrs Figg had never actually seen one (“big” and “cloaked”), but she certainly described the feeling accurately, and that’s what convinced the wizengamot. Being magical was only ever supposed to be binary. The “pure blood” stuff is clearly nonsense. Neville says that he is “almost a squib” but this is proven to be wrong later in the books as he gains more confidence, and starts performing more advanced magic. So there aren’t different levels of magical ability. You’ve either got it or you haven’t. Mrs Figg is a Squib and therefore non-magic and therefore a muggle. And muggles can’t see dementors. That’s how I understand it anyway, obviously you are free to have your own opinion.

Garry (Not Jerry)

With Filch I’m assuming he can see hogwarts because he lives there, but he would need to be directed by a wizard in order to find it in the first place.

Garfnob

but in that example Hermione has traits of both houses so her values would be the tie breaker. Peter lacks most of the positive taters of all the houses. the traits he has most are ambition (he strives to get more power, on the back of others), resourcefulness (he is willing to do what it takes to achieve his goals. even if it must be in non conventional means). i do not recall if Peter was a pure blood that might disqualify him from Slytherin. if he is disqualified from Slytherin Hufflepuff (patience, and a propensity for hard) might work. he is patent he was biding his time for over a decade. as he was not so bright he need to work hard at the magic. he is lacking in justice and loyalty.

Chorafini (Luiz)

Hi Veggie, hope you're doing well, can't wait to hear your thoughts on these chapters. I always liked the fact that Sirius's dog version is WAY bigger in the books, it compares him to a small bear. Makes more sense that he would help James holding Lupin back when he's in his werewolf form. Not gonna lie, I got a little emotional when Harry realized why James was called Prongs, the movies never mentioned any of it Edit: I thought that Harry's Patronus became a stag after learning that his dad was an animagus, but like emmainkeri mentioned in the replies, his Patronus was already described as something big and silver white coming from the end of his wand during the Quidditch match against Draco, so I was probably wrong. Now back to the original comment Since we're nearly finishing book 3, do you have a Top 3 favorite characters? I always struggle with this types of lists, but mine would probably be Dumbledore, Lupin and Harry. Just one more chapter and we'll be heading into the "DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIRE?!", said Dumbledore with borh his hand on Harry's neck.

itsanursething

Snape and Tom Riddle were both not pureblood and in Slytherin.

Garfnob

good point about Snape. Riddle could be an expected exception being a descendant of Slytherin. was just going on one (apparently) list of Slytherin traits that had it added. did not know if it was something JKR stated in a Q&A or something.

S1lm4r1l

> "I just typed out a great big reply and lost it! Let me sum up - I agree completely." I hate when this happens. It's why I constantly edit and add to my comments and replies. > "The fact that the movies just seemed to basically skip the entire aspect of Dumbledore being such a troubled young man and why was awful. Finding out about this was such a huge challenge for Harry emotionally. Everything he thought he knew about everyone he had admired, loved or had been mentored by had been challenged and every one of them was now dead." There's a great deal that the movies just skip over, but that's probably the most egregious. Harry's anger at Dumbledore is almost entirely absent from the last two films.

S1lm4r1l (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-20 18:00 &gt; "It seems unlikely that Snape would actually think that Black could fool Dumbledore with a complete lie, so it seems to me like his conversation with Dumbledore is based on feelings rather than rational thinking." Not only that, he spends a long time playing up his own part in the capture of Black in order to receive an Order of Merlin. And spends time trying to make sure Fudge didn't get cold feet about subjecting Black to the Dementor's Kiss. Whilst casually throwing Harry, Hermione and Ron under the bus, all because it would make Snape's life easier if Harry had some of his school privileges revoked.
2023-06-19 19:20 > "It seems unlikely that Snape would actually think that Black could fool Dumbledore with a complete lie, so it seems to me like his conversation with Dumbledore is based on feelings rather than rational thinking." Not only that, he spends a long time playing up his own part in the capture of Black in order to receive an Order of Merlin. And spends time trying to make sure Fudge didn't get cold feet about subjecting Black to the Dementor's Kiss. Whilst casually throwing Harry, Hermione and Ron under the bus, all because it would make Snape's life easier if Harry had some of his school privileges revoked.

> "It seems unlikely that Snape would actually think that Black could fool Dumbledore with a complete lie, so it seems to me like his conversation with Dumbledore is based on feelings rather than rational thinking." Not only that, he spends a long time playing up his own part in the capture of Black in order to receive an Order of Merlin. And spends time trying to make sure Fudge didn't get cold feet about subjecting Black to the Dementor's Kiss. Whilst casually throwing Harry, Hermione and Ron under the bus, all because it would make Snape's life easier if Harry had some of his school privileges revoked.

emmainkeri

Can't wait for that chapter!! Hahaha

emmainkeri

I think Harry's patronus was a stag before that night! It's basically a projection of his soul, I don't think hearing about his dad affected its form. But either way, during the quidditch match when he casts the patronus, the book says "Something silver white, something enormous, erupted from the end of his wand. He knew it had shot directly at the dementors but didn't pause to watch -" and also Lupin comes to congratulate him and says "That was quite some Patronus." I think Lupin realized there, that Harry's Patronus was a stag :)

Annette Elliott

The biggest problem I have with this movie is the way they butchered some of these last few chapters. We already touched on the whole Marauder's backstory they left out. A lot of people who've only seen the movies don't understand why mist book readers detest Snape because they did stuff like changing Snape still being unconscious to him putting himself between the kids and a werewolf making him seem protective and heroic. Yes what we discover later makes him a hero but he is in no way likeable or a "good" person. Meanwhile they robbed Sirius of being the protective one. They also kept lines that make no sense without the book context. Like Sirius asking Lupin if he'd taken his potion that day with no past reference to any potion anywhere in the movie.

Martin Wilson

Sirius is one of my favourite and one of the most complex characters, can't really tell you why without spoilers. Him bumping snape's unconscious head deliberately against the top of the tunnel in this chapter might be understandable given snape had just tried to get him 'kissed' by a dementor. Can't help feeling just leaving him in a locked office with a window was a bit careless given they thought he was a powerful dark wizard who had escaped azkaban. But presumably it was on Dumbledore's orders. Would have given a lot to see Sirius' expression when he saw Harry and Hermione at the window if it had been in the film.

Katik

Hi Veggie, Happy Summer Solstice! Others have already pointed out the difference from the movie where Pettigrew uses a wand to transform himself back to a rat - while in the book a wand is obviously not necessary (otherwise how would Sirius transform in Azkaban?) But still in the book Pettigrew's first impulse, as the confusion starts, is to dive for Lupin's dropped wand! He only transforms after Harry manages to disarm him. Now I can't decide if Peter's actual intent behind it was to attack his captors, defend himself from Lupin, or he simply wanted to have a wand with him when he escaped. (I always though of being a witch/wizard without a wand feels something like us muggles when we lose our smartphones) Btw how do you think it works with the possessions an Animagus has on them as they transform into an animal? The clothes obviously transform with them: as we have seen Pettigrew and Sirius and previously McGonagall NOT being naked when turning back. But does it extend to anything people have in their pockets? Holding in their hand? If yes, could one grab a hold of any large object (like a car or something) when transforming and that would go with them into their animal form? Sorry, I'll stop, my head hurts. I'll just add that this concept of time-travel, where going back in time does not change the past but everything you do has already happened, is my absolutely favourite of all the versions of time travel in fiction. I was giddy with excitement when reading the book for the first time as everything came together so beautifully!

Chorafini (Luiz)

Oh yeah, I forgot about that description during the Quidditch match, I'll edit my comment SPOILERS - I probably thought that because we know from later books that your Patronus can change because of your emotions, just like it happened with Tonks - SPOILERS

Alchemist

Hello Veggie, I wonder how many hours will have passed by the time you get to this comment, but I wish you much endurance! ;) So in the book Sirius is locked up in Flitwick's office. Do you remember the (very different) location where he is locked up in the movie? I hope you'll continue playing Hogwarts Legacy and discover the Easter Egg there that solves this discrepancy between the different media... :)

Thunderbird

I think the same of apparating. I mean we know from the African school that it is possible to do magic without a wand - it is just kind of a conductor/amplifier of your powers. So then why do you need a wand to apparate?

Thunderbird

Hi Veggie, I hope I’m not too late for this – I haven’t really found time to comment until now. First of all, I can’t believe how many people wrote about how nice the scene was where Sirius asks Harry to live with him (I definitely agree) but haven’t mentioned the line «…what would happen when he told the Dursleys he was going to live with the convict they’d seen on television». I mean just imagine the Dursley’s faces. That would be hilarious to see! I also agree with the people who wrote about the difference between movie Snape and book Snape. As for me, I really like movie Snape and think he is a good person who protects the students. However, book Snape is a horrible person in my opinion. Snape's tantrum in chapter 21 gives a lot of reasons why. But the main reason for me not liking Snape will come much much later in the books so I’ll shut up now. 😊 And lastly we finally get to know exactly how McGonagall got the timeturner for Hermione. Which is why we know now that Hermione didn’t keep it and that all the timeturner-stuff is ministry regulated. I always want to scream this at YouTube reactors who are asking in later movies “well why don’t they just use Hermione’s timeturner”. 😄 I hope you aren’t completely exhausted by now and wish you a lovely day.

Shira

you got there somthing wrong.. 1. Lupin explains why Harry is so vulnerable to the dementors. 2. the container of a horcrux must be destroyed for the horcrux to be destroyed. It is unknown whether dementors have the ability to destroy a horcrux. but for the attraction that is not the reason why harry is so vulnerable.