Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This week's CRACKPOTS comes from Kate Wagner, the architecture critic at The Nation. I first came across her writing when Road & Track magazine, a publication we all subscribe to, published and then killed her piece on F-1, causing quite a stir. I don't know exactly what happened but I'm guessing it was because she was paid to write a pretty standard profile on the Formula 1 United States Grand Prix and instead they got a not-so subtle critique of the totality of the spectacle. Here:

The driver is the apotheosis of quick-moving prowess, total focus and control. The car is both the most studied piece of human engineering, tuned and devised in lab-like environments and at the same time a variable entity, something that must be wrestled with and pushed. The numbers are crunched, the forms wind-tunneled. And yet some spirit escapes their control, and that spirit is known only by the driver. Yes, we watch this perfect blend of man and machine, but we speak of the machine as though it were not of human origin, as though the machine, being born from science could—eventually, through its iterative processes—sublimate human flaws. The driver, being human, knows this is false. His intimacy with the machine is the necessary missing connection, and even if the machine were perfect, it was made for imperfect hands. But it is never perfect. The gaps in its perfection are where disasters transpire, but also miracles.

I cannot recommend it enough, though you'll have to read it on the wayback machine. Kate's substack is Late-Review. She also writes the blog McMansion Hell. 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In the last few months of my life, I watched as a handful of small but significant social bonds began to fracture and with them, entire ways of living. These bonds, which in many ways did not operate in what my enemies call an “economically rational” fashion held together the inhabitants of the house in which I also rent an apartment. In the greater fields of economics or even urban development, there exists very little data on such bonds, not only because they are interpersonal and granular in nature and thus do not lend themselves to large scale research, but also because they do not serve as good ammunition for many of the present debates around the housing crisis, much of which is market-oriented in outlook.

We live in a capitalist society. The market and its logic are a given, and hence, any solution or understanding of a problem must be viewed primarily through a concept of economics in which people are considered rational economic actors whose rationality is – and this is often explicitly obscured in service to a rhetorical veneer of progressivism – profit-driven. It is profit-driven, though its rationality is overstated. This is true of the crustiest NIMBYs who only care about their property values as it is of the too-online set of property developers who have every gain to make from building housing that primarily serves a very lucrative demographic with a few affordable units thrown in if one is lucky.

What I take issue with is the naturalistic inevitability of market thinking that inherently occludes non-market solutions to rising housing costs, namely landlord regulation, better tenants’ rights, rent control or rent caps, and social housing. These are, unfortunately, not profitable but still necessary to keep huge swaths of people, especially the most vulnerable among us, both alive and materially stable. This is an important social goal that, as is evidenced by a massive increase in homelessness, the market is not solving because, by way of its own logic, it doesn’t have the means to solve it. The more the rent goes up – and it’s gone up a deranged 23% during Biden’s presidency – the more we are going to see widespread displacement, spatial redistributions of wealth in favor of the wealthy at the expense of everyone else, and massive upheavals in countless individual human lives, usually for the worse.

This is an economic reality and it is an ugly one. It sucks and no, it’s not “rational” – it’s barbaric. A great deal of effort goes into transforming people and property into statistics and wonkish policy in order to hide what is undeniably a form of social violence and with it, the faces of real human suffering. To name just one example, relocation is often viewed as a choice when it is not. This idea of choice is often twisted by anti-rent control advocates to say that rent control limits freedom by keeping people who want to move to a specific area out (this is the real grievance) and people who want to leave their units from doing so. (Usually because they can’t afford anything else!) I don’t know where this assumption that everyone wants to move apartments constantly originates – maybe someone can tell me. For many protected by non-market policies, the alternative is often no apartment at all. The obvious solution to this problem of “inequality” is to make rent control so widespread that everyone benefits. Even some of the ur-YIMBYs have come around to the idea that maybe building new units has to be paired with something that keeps people in the units they’re already living in.

This may be politically difficult, sure, everything is, especially now. But the alternative is clearly barbarism. We all catch a glimpse of a possible future that awaits so many of us should we miss a handful of our paychecks every time the cops arrest people for sleeping outside and destroy what few belongings that remain to people who have lost everything. What does it say about the future of housing when vigilantes execute the most vulnerable among us in cold blood and get away with it. The housing crisis has always been a matter of class war. It is in liberals’ best interest to obfuscate that truth in any way they can. Over 80% of Americans do not have any emergency savings. Most of us are closer to a life on the street than we are to the luxury apartment complex complete with dog-wash high life.

It sounds insane to say this because it is obvious, but there is no crime in wanting secure and enriching shelter, in wanting permanence and stability. There is nothing wrong with wishing to stay where one is living especially if one is being forced out against one’s will by market or other forces. If it is truly a matter of voluntary migration, then fine, whatever, but it often isn’t. This element of force is too often minimized. Sometimes, when I’ve talked about my situation – the building I live in sold to a real estate investor and I am about to be economically displaced – I have been called “privileged” or “nativist” or “a revanchist” for wanting to remain in my home and in the community where my networks of social support have been formed over the span of half a decade, which is a long time when you’ve only been a real adult for about eight years.  

Much like with the anti-rent control argument, what is left unsaid here is that people with more money than me have an inherent right to live where I am living because they have “earned it” more than I have. They deserve it and the amenities around it more because they won at life and should be able to exercise their social mobility. There is perhaps nothing more revanchist than the idea that one’s place in the world should be determined by how much one stimulates the economy, hence the repeated need to invoke freedom of movement. No doubt that (all!) people should be able to move cities, but there is something laughable watching people who can afford $3500 per month in rent rebrand themselves as “newcomers” as though they’ve just gotten off the boat at Ellis Island with only a suitcase to their name. But freedom of movement also includes the freedom to not move, to not have one’s life completely uprooted for little other reason than greater profits for one’s landlord. Like it or not, the right to the city includes the poor, working class, and “downwardly mobile gentrifiers” (as people with my “anti-housing” politics are so lovingly called) just as much as it does those who can live wherever they want on a whim.

There is some truth to the pejorative, however. No matter where I am forced to move, I’m sure I’ll also be part of the problem. I’ll take the place of someone who was worse off than me, who was also forced out, and so it will go until eternity, until we’re all on the street. The urban body can be made healthier and more resilient by many of the urbanism sawhorses I agree with: large-scale upzoning, building more housing for all income levels, building code reform, the elimination of parking minimums and the streamlining of the permitting process. But right now that urban body is bleeding badly and no one is doing anything to plug up the wound. Even something as meager as a temporary rent cap would go a long way in an economy devastated by inflation and rising job insecurity. That even this, once a quiet part of Biden’s own election plan, is deemed unfeasible is just another turn of the hurdy-gurdy of “you deserve nothing and should expect nothing from the people in power.”

However, as I intuited at the beginning of this essay, part of fighting against the naturalistic tendencies of a market perspective is acknowledging the edge cases where social forces act seemingly against market ones. No, we are not all grist for the economic mill, and people act all the time in ways that are not “economically” rational but are socially and emotionally so. Housing, at the end of the day, is also a social issue, a human issue. I know this on a first-hand, empirical basis that by all economic indications, a household of my income level should have been priced out of my neighborhood (Logan Square in Chicago) about two to three years ago. The only thing that prevented this from happening is a series of chance encounters and social bonds that were ultimately dissolved in a somewhat non-consensual way, i.e. by economic necessity that rendered continuation of the situation impossible. The market destroyed these bonds perhaps in part because their anti-market nature was untenable.

Our old landlords bought our house 23 years ago. The were an ordinary “middle-class” couple – a white collar guy with a desk job and a public school teacher. When we moved in, we signed two year leases. Our landlords said over and over that they valued tenant stability more than anything else, which at the time was true. The renters downstairs had been living there for nearly a decade and the man who lived in the upstairs unit had been living on the property since the 1970s. The rent was kept low for him out of a social obligation – he was paying rent on a fixed income. Meanwhile, the value of the property skyrocketed from its initial purchase price of around $300,000 to closer to $800,000. A proposed property tax hike would have put us in some (probably survivable) friction with the landlords but ultimately they decided to sell the house for a different, sadder and more American reason: a member of their family needed long-term medical care.

This meant almost certain eviction for our upstairs neighbor who would in no way survive paying market rent. Our landlords felt they owed it to him to help him find another place before the house even sold. They did. But his situation is so vulnerable that it is only a matter of time before the landlord of his current property discovers what others are renting for in the area, or is similarly compelled by the market to sell because the writing is on the wall. The sound of his footsteps has disappeared from our lives, the sound of NFL Sunday. The house was purchased by a small time real estate investor. The literal day after the purchase went through, renovation started on the unit upstairs. For six to eight hours a day the sound of the hammers and drilling (at 84 decibels, harmful to human health) has made our house unlivable, especially since me and my partner both work from home. It is not a question of whether our rent will go up – it is a mathematical inevitability in order to break even on the mortgage – but of how much. I will move and I will be fine and I will survive moving but I am allowed to be sad about it, as this is the longest I have lived in any one place. Housing for me has been so insecure that from the ages of 18 through 28, I moved apartments every single year of my life. My housing politics are less informed by discourse online and more informed by the constant indignity of being forced to move and the fact that I pay 35% of my income on rent, which, with debt and healthcare costs makes it financially impossible to insulate myself from the disaster of a single missed paycheck.

In this last respect, I’ve gotten so very lucky. What has emerged in my situation is an example of how luck, coupled with so-called good landlords, those rare, well-meaning people who did more for us than most would, are nothing against the brutality of the housing market. A series of events and systemic injustices ranging from the commodification of housing, the general failure to provide greater stability to the elderly, the diabolical American healthcare system that bankrupts families, end-stage gentrification, lack of any intervention into housing costs coupled with the same housing shortage we’ve all been fighting about for decades, and a fucking dogshit economy for everyone who isn’t a millionaire have all combined to create a situation in which three households will be uprooted from where they are living. People may roll their eyes when I describe it that way or choose to point to my cultural clout as some kind of insurance against being a real victim of anything but there is no other way to describe it and there is no recourse for me in my situation other than to leave.

But perhaps worse than this inevitable departure was how, during the process of selling the house, realtors and buyers came in whenever they pleased, intruding in our daily lives, kicking us out for twenty-minute intervals that only served to reinforce how disposable we were. We were treated as liabilities to the sale, as less than human, as little more than parasites when the real parasites were the well-groomed people wishing to secure an investment vehicle through Sotheby’s. Now we can’t even live in the house anymore, enjoy our meals or our music, read, or work because of the renovation. What was once the greatest apartment of my life has become a living hell.

Ultimately, this is what capitalism does: it takes a home and renders it not a home. It takes the place in which one dwells, dreams, eats, sleeps, converses, and makes love, and makes it a commodity like any other, and you as something that is exchangeable as a doorknob. It takes what was once a source of security and transforms it into an inescapable anxiety. And the worst part is, we are supposed to accept this as the inevitable way of the world. I won’t. I think it’s bullshit.

Comments

BeanCurd

Thank you so much for this wonderful essay. I lose sleep over the way homelessness is handled in this country. Everywhere you go - especially the wealthiest cities and towns - there are people sleeping in the streets. Our political class not only doesn't care, they actively try to galvanize the shrinking middle class against their neighbors who struggle the most. Watching ultra wealthy Democratic politicians throw homeless people's stuff in the trash makes me physically ill - barbarism is right. I will rant and rave about this to friends and family and still I'm told some nonsense about how the problem is "unsolvable" or (worse) "some people just want to be homeless."

GSpring

Amen fellow American. You are right about Housing. We are fucked. Like with healthcare, housing could be basic right here in rich as fuck USA. But how the fuck is it possible to get there from here? in the land of too big to fails? And too big to reign in with legislation. Luigi Mangione points out the horror of capitalism when it comes to healthcare . Same goes for housing and legal justice systems are utterly whacked, too. And things aren’t getting better anytime soon. wtf?

Norbur

Hell yes Kate Wagner, blessed bike and architecture theologian

Yankee Amerikan Sky Pirate

Another thing element of this that makes my stomach churn is how housing-as-commodity affects rural/gateway communities. Places in the rural southwest are being transformed into pockets of short-term rentals that are hardly occupied during the “off-season” at the expense of people who live and work in the community. Towns with two/three/four generations of history being turned into playgrounds for the rich Silicon Valley freaks who decided they needed a “retreat.” Towns that don’t lack even the barest supportive infrastructure for the homeless.

Nat

thank you kate wagner for detailing chicago landlord renovation hell. i had to deal with a renovation that was supposed to take 2 weeks, turned into 4 months, where i had no bathroom or kitchen. total hell. excited to read the f-1 article

BeanCurd

Same with some areas of the northeast. One of the rural counties I work in is fully divided between ultra wealthy peoples' vacation homes and the working families who serve them.

Carolyn Hodge

Thank you for talking about this - we need more talking and organizing for renters in every part of the US. I live in the BayArea and have been a renter for 23 years. I am financially successful and have been lucky to have the kind landlords you mention - and managed to stay in units for 7+ years at a time. One of the issues with housing planning and development is that only the current landowners show up to planning meetings. The future inhabitants of proposed housing cannot represent themselves - so inevitably they cannot advocate for housing expansion.

ruby

thank you! logan square!!!

jay alan

Related to so much of this. Good shit! 🫡

Jeremy hatrington

This was a great read. Super relatable for Boston area folks. Kate rules.

SF

Heard Kate for the first time on Trillbillys and have loved her ever since. Thanks for sharing her work, this was great.

Monty

Great essay. Also I just learned Kate created one of my favorite sites, McMansion Hell. How is it possible for her to keep giving us so much?