CRACKPOTS #13: AND YET... (Patreon)
Content
Happy New Year. Full disclosure: I was supposed to send this last week but, clearly, I did not, for reasons that I won't bore you with. My bad! I kept thinking I could just send something quick with your typical media diet listicle (shame!) or some New Years recommendations (bore), maybe Ins/Outs (dread) or some predictions (barf). I couldn't do it! A good omen of health and resolve for 2025...
Unfortunately, I found myself writing about something pretty grim, which is maybe not the best way to start out of the year, but I just couldn't get the facts of this case out of my head. Just before we went on holiday, Dominique Pelicot and the 50 other men indicted were sentenced in what the papers have called France's Mass Rape Trial. Save for the usual suspects (celebrity influencer instagram stories, the New York Times, Bluesky I assume) there was surprisingly little discourse on my feeds about the case, at least nothing approximating the type of Cultural Reckoning think-piece onslaught that we were accustomed to during the #MeToo moment (RIP 2016-2019ish).
I shouldn't say surprise. In the years since #MeToo and the long tail of woke, the over-documented vibe shift has swung the cultural appetite for anything resembling #Feminism back toward the SpikeTV years. The attention economy has moved on to brighter, more floral things. I don't think we are in the midst of a revanchist moment—at least not an exceptionally revanchist one—I just think people grew sort of tired, maybe a little bored, somewhat indifferent after the fervor of the past ten years. I'm talking about the uses and abuses of the terms patriarchy, misogyny, abuse (there's that word again) and so on. You know what I'm talking about. It came in the form of anonymous confessions, excel docs, viral New York Magazine think-pieces, tweets responding to said think-pieces, podcasts responding to said tweets, thousands of sparkly protest signs and a cottage industry of mugs and totes and t-shirts with, inexplicably, Greta Gerwig's name on them. These have all blurred together in my mind to form a hot pink, hazy blob: the fog of woke.
The Pelicot case brought back a lot of these now unfashionable shibboleths. Like all incidents involving women speaking inappropriately, accusations of hysteria were thrown, especially as French women gathered in the streets outside the courthouse to rally and demand change. In the 1977 essay "Propos sur l'hystérie" Jacques Lacan asks
Where have they gone, the hysterics of yesteryear, those wonderful women, the Anna O.s, or the Emmy von N.s...? They not only played a certain role, certainly a social role, but when Freud started to listen to them, it was they who allowed for the birth of psychoanalysis. By listening to them Freud inaugurated an entirely new mode of human relations. What has replaced the hysterical symptoms of yesteryear? Has hysteria not been displaced to the social field?
The real figure of psychoanalysis was always the hysteric, the female, the one who is consumed with her desire. It's flowing out of her symptoms; it's spilling out of her dreams. She tells us what is beyond our sense of self by speaking the unanswerable questions. We have to hear what she is saying. Language is not just a tool for expression; language invades us, it speaks through us without us realizing; it tortures us as we wrestle with our inability to contain what it continually opens up, namely desire. Can we attend to it? What she desires, as Lacan reminds us, is an entirely new mode of human relations.
In a scene I found particularly revolting, a defense lawyer for one of the men found guilty of sexual assault stood outside the courtroom, facing a dedicated crowd of women who had parked themselves outside the building in solidarity with Gisèle Pelicot. He turned his camera phone on them to film and taunt—his client was found guilty but would walk free with time served—screaming that they were hysterical tricoteuse, a reference to the women who sat to cheer on the executions at the guillotine during the French Revolution. In between beheadings, history books say, they would knit and gossip. Okay. The balding defense lawyer laughed at them and yelled, "my client has a message for you: thank you and fuck off!" It is difficult to ignore the specifically sadistic rhymes of the scene: a man verbally humiliating women on camera, bragging that his client, who was just found guilty of assaulting a woman on camera, will walk free. How else should we understand this? Another defense lawyer, a woman, was forced to apologize after posting an Instagram video lip-synching in her car on her way to court. It was the Wham! song "Wake Me Up Before You Go-Go," an unfortunate slip that many heard as reference to Gisèle’s inability to, you know, wake up during the estimated 1400 rapes she endured in a near-comatose state. What else can we hear?
My paranoid spidey-sense says that no one in this American boom-boom climate really wants to talk about the Pelicot case, with men and women having different though related reasons and probably at least one shared one: it makes plain how inconveniently relevant those unfashionable discourses might be, specifically bargain-bin terms like rape culture, gaslighting, consent and so on, words that everyone had tacitly agreed to put away for the time being. What else do we call it when Dominique Pelicot accompanies his wife to various doctors' appointments for her unexplained blackouts and memory lapses, if not gaslighting? "Her husband supported her through a strange, undiagnosed illness. She was losing her hair, losing weight and, most worryingly, losing memory of some nights and days," the New York Times reported. Gisèle’s three children were convinced she had Alzheimer's and their father took his wife to various specialists for brain scans, holding her hand as she feared a terminal diagnoses that never came. Turns out, he was drugging and raping her. He often joked with her about the inexplicable confusion, teasing, "where were you off to last night?"
This case only became a case by chance when a security guard was alerted to a man behaving strangely in a cosmetics aisle at a small town E.LeClerc store. There the guard found Dominique Pelicot taking upskirt shots of unsuspecting female shoppers with his mobile phone. Alerted to what was going on, one of the victims decided to press charges. After seizing and searching Dominique's phone and then computer and then his USBs, the police called his wife.
Gisèle Pelicot assumed they wanted to talk to her about the upskirt incident; her husband had told her what happened at the store and she had already forgiven him. But they showed her different images, ones they warned would be distressing. When Gisèle looked, she didn't understand. "I did not recognize either the man or the woman asleep in the bed," she testified last fall. "It was unbearable. I was inert, in my bed, and a man was raping me. My world fell apart."
We need to lay out the details to take in the full horror of the case: from July 2011 to October 2020, Dominique drugged his wife Gisèle, raped her and recruited strangers from an internet forum called à son insu (translation: "without her knowledge") to rape her while she was unconscious. He filmed the assaults, filing them away helpfully in folders titled ABUSES, HER RAPISTS and MY SLUT allowing police to seize over 20,000 images and videos of men raping a near-comatose Gisèle, organized like PornHub by specific abuse ("squirt on the ass," "3rd anal," "magnificient close up from behind" and so on). He crushed up 2.5mg of Temesta (google says: Lorazepam, Ativan) and slipped them into after-dinner ice cream or coffee, sometimes mashed potatoes. Gisèle would pass out and wake up with no memory of what happened. She wasn't aware of any of the abuse until police pointed out that the woman in the photos was her.
The police identified 92 incidents of rape by 72 different men, though they were only able to find 50 of them. They were between the ages of 21 and 68 at the time of the rapes, many from the small French village of Mazan where the Pelicots lived, population: 6,000. If this reads like a census, that's the point. Much has been made of how average these men are: truck drivers, carpenters, a plumber, a prison guard, an IT guy, a nurse, a journalist. A lot of them had partners or were married, many had children, including daughters. Gisèle recognized only one, her neighbor: "He came over to check our bikes. I used to see him at the bakery. He was always polite. I had no idea he was coming to rape me." The French media has taken to calling these men "Monsieur tout-le monde" or Mr Everyman (or Mr. Every Man). "Everybody here knows somebody who is involved," a Mazan local told a journalist from The Times. "Even if it's not a friend, it will be the friend of a friend, or someone at the grocery store. Everybody."
In America, we are used to rape cases hinging on consent: who gave what, when and how and what was understood and for how long and under what conditions. Much of the #MeToo moment was spent consciously and unconsciously taking this legal framework (rape as the absence of consent) and smearing it out onto the social scene, applying its logic to a variety of violations and misconduct, including but not limited to: assault, bad manners, various shades of gaslighting, disagreement, date rape, ghosting, sexual harassment in the workplace, unsolicited DMs, cat calling, being a bad boyfriend and so on. Collapsing distinction invited criticism, including from yours truly. But part of what was, for many women, dangerously and therefore understandably electrifying was, as Jamieson Webster and Kyoo Lee wrote, "this subtle, structural disarticulation of will, handing oneself over to the multitude and the heterogenous—yes, these stories are not all the same, yes they are not all rape, and yet..." And yet...
France, like other European countries catching America's cultural tailwinds, did not escape the #MeToo moment though it sparked great debate. Catherine Deneuve and other French women in entertainment famously published a letter in LeMonde decrying the whole thing: "Accidents that can affect a woman's body do not necessarily affect her dignity and must not, as difficult as they can be, necessarily make her a perpetual victim." I agree. So did the French women who rallied around Gisèle Pelicot, the accused hysterics, supporting her insistence on a public trial knowing that the entire world would be privy to the recorded scenes of the nearly ten years of abuse she unknowingly endured. One of the many quirks of the case is that rape trials often risk re-traumatizing the victim as they relive the scenes of their abuse. The doses of Temesta were strong enough to put Gisèle, as a pathologist testified, closer to being in a coma than anything resembling sleep. The trial meant she'd be living all of this for the first time.
Another quirk is that consent is not actually as relevant to rape cases in France as one would think. French criminal law defines rape as a penetrative act or oral sex committed on someone using "violence, coercion, threat or surprise." It does not mention consent or the absence of consent and it means that French prosecutors must prove intent to rape to secure a guilty verdict. Without intent to commit, as the defense would go on to argue, there is no rape. Dominique was arrested on rape and other charges in November 2020 and immediately confessed. It took nearly three years for the state to track down and file a 370-page indictment against 51 men, 49 of which were charged with rape (most with one count, some with multiple, one man with six) while one was charged with attempted rape and another with sexual assault. Those last two were the only men who, presumably upon understanding the full scope of the scene, walked away.
Despite having to prove intent, consent still loomed large over the case. The defense opened typically with the goal of complicating Gisèle's role. They accused her of being an alcoholic, an exhibitionist. They showed the court images that Dominique would send out to potential rapists, images that Gisèle says she has no memory of posing for: in lingerie next to a sex toy, naked with her legs spread out. The defense would point to her eyes being open as aha! proof of her consciousness, as if they were concerned we would, presumably like their clients, mistake her for a doll. This was meant to buttress the claim that the men were not aware of what they were doing, a claim that flies in the face of any reasonable understanding of what was shown on screen. They claimed they were tricked and duped and manipulated by Dominique and that there was therefore no intent to commit and thus no rape. In America we are familiar with the He said-She said dynamics of rape trials; here, these men found themselves in a He said-He said conundrum, often arguing with Dominique about who knew what and when.
It was an odd twist to the case: it wasn't just that the woman's consent was irrelevant to both the act in question and the central legal claim; guilt hinged on whether the men charged with the rape consented to it at all. This was made explicit when one of the accused apologized to Gisèle: "I'm sorry to Madam Pelicot for involuntarily participating in her suffering." An impossible image betrays the cynicism: two people having sex, both involuntarily. One claimed he was brainwashed; another that he had done so "reluctantly." One said yes it was rape but the kind that is accidental. One claimed he couldn't remember a thing, despite being filmed giving two thumbs up to the camera before driving two-and-a-half hours home to Lyon. One after another: it wasn't rape, it wasn't rape and yet ...
Here, some defense testimony from the Mr. Every Man:
[Her husband] told me she was consenting.
I don't accept that I victimised [her]. When you are trapped you are really trapped.
I am as much a victim [as her].
I knew she was unconscious, but not that she wasn't consenting.
I was seduced by the idea of having complete freedom of action.
For me, it wasn't rape.
It wasn't me. It was my doppelgänger.
If I wanted to rape, I would have chosen a pretty one.
It was my body that raped, not my brain.
I never told myself 'I will rape that woman.'
I recognize the facts but not the intention.
I admit, in the excitement and all, I didn't pay attention.
Those last two lines struck me. What does it mean to pay attention? To not recognize your intention? Attention and intention are actually related, both making their way into English from, funny enough, the French. They are both derived from the Latin tendĕre, meaning to tend, to incline or to extend. Tendĕre evokes a soft gesture — imagine a gentle stretch outward toward an expectant hand — which comes to mind easily when you think of the care it takes to tend to something, or when you hear the related word tenderness. In French, tendre means soft or delicate. Attention follows to attend or to turn one's ear toward, to direct one's mind to or, simply put, to listen. This comes from the Latin attendere and what you might recognize in contemporary French as attendre, meaning to wait or to expect. With this comes the fullness that the Latin tendĕre stretches toward: waiting, an expectation, a paused anticipation, a longing for what might come to pass. Intention, meaning purpose or to fix one's attention on, came to English from the Old French entencion, itself related to the contemporary entendre meaning to hear as in to understand, or to attend to something. Intention, attention, to tend, to listen. A double-entendre is when a phrase has dual meaning, an ambiguity, evolving out of the obsolete double entente meaning dual understanding. Entente is still used, mostly in legal contexts, to mean a formal alliance, an agreement, or more softly, a mutual understanding. Do you hear what I am saying? In her moving essay on the trial, Sophie Smith asks "What are we taught not to see? What do we see and are taught not to talk about?" I will push this further and speak more directly, repeating myself: Do you hear what I am saying?
See you next month.
Yours, Liz.