Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

Mann Shorts and How to Be a Great DM are gone., RIP.. The rest of the Dungeontubers--including me--are living on borrowed time. I explain why. Cheers.

--PDM

Files

Previews only

How to be a Great GM

Comments

Ron F.

I knew you'd cover this!

Bryan Stephens

YouTube was built by people like you. Now they have money they want to ditch you.

SJBehindtheScreen

channels, like tv and movies, come and go. But as long as you're on YT, or if you move to some other platform for whatever reason, I'm tuning in.

Enishi X

Time make fools of us all. Time moves marches forward and you need to move with it or be left behind.

A Name Apart

I don't know about the YT business so this is just my perspective on the broader world. I HATE HATE HATE clickbait and commercials. I pay for YT so I don't get the regular commercials. I buy lots of products even if they have horrible commercials. I also support quite a few creators on Patreon and substack. So my experience is that I will pay for content that is good and will do a lot to avoid clickbait stuff. So my wants from YT people is similar to other products/services I will pay for your stuff it is a good and I don't care if you also do clickbait stuff as long as I can avoid seeing it. How creators might view my perspective is that there are different types of customer, some small number willing to pay and some much larger number not willing to pay and less anti-clickbait. I view clickbait as a really offensive form of attacking/hacking my brain, but I am a minority. Happy new year PDM and everyone else

Gordon

You must market yourself to stay relevant, in any free market customers have many choices for their limited resources.

MrGunn

Dear PDM, Firstly, I hope you are remaining healthy. Secondly, thanks for this excellent analysis. You highlight the main issue with all of these "social media" companies, they rely on the creative works of others so they can parley viewership into advertising monies, which they only begrudgingly share, and then work hard to claw back through algorithm changes, policy updates, and other sleazy tactics. Every one of these platforms continues to squeeze more and more of the excess value generated by the hard working content creators into their own pockets. Worse they offer creatives little input into the process or how the platform is managed. These platforms can change the rules at anytime they want, e.g change terms of service, claim ownership of a creator's IP, and a myriad of other schemes to reduce the content creator's profits. Some would say; "Duh! That is just how capitalism works, if you don't like it start your own platform."; of course this always easier said than done. Instead of constantly being squeezed by the likes of Tik-Tok, Google, X, Patreon, Snapchat, Insta, et al, what the the world needs is a not-for-profit or cooperative social media channel, so creatives and ordinary people can have greater transparency and input into the management of the platform, and can receive a greater portion of the value they create. Waiting for that day. Have fun at PAGE, it sounds like a fantastic convention. Best wishes for your continued health and success in the new year. Your devoted patron, MrGunn! PS Can anyone pinpoint the exact date Google went from; 'Don't be evil', to MUHAHAHA 😈?

MrGunn

Where is the Bagel-Man 🥯? 🤣

John Doe

I would love to see PDM run a channel that was solely devoted to monsters and what tactics DMs can use to deploy them. Basically a YouTube channel version of the outstanding book, "The Monsters Know What They're Doing." Epiaode one could be 20min on Deathbringers background lore and how he can most effectively do terrible things to the Party.

Ross Y

Professor, as always I am amazed by how much information you pack into each vidoe (let alone each sentence) and how well you deliver it. But forgive me for noting that the Caves of Carnage series, while maybe not technically as adept as The Lost City video series, was much more fun for me. While I am sure YouTube has the best analytics, data can't explain what makes art great and the Carnage series is great art! And you should absolutely do Teachercraft.

Bryan Stephens

Gini D has more than just a bubly personality. That has to count.

Adrian Webster

The lack of promotion by youtube is a choice and not an inevitability. They could just as easily not focus so heavily on the first hour/day views and take a longer term approach and it would make money because they would support it. But then again, I am not positive youtube itself will be around long. chasing short term dollars doesnt make for a lasting business.

Megatron

I love this channel! I will support you whatever direction you decide to go PDM.

Scott

Watch more Dungeon Craft! I have slowly watched the dungeontubers disappear or slow down. Only a few (like yourself) continue to put out regular, good content that I enjoy. I hope you can weather the youtube storm and keep going for many more years!

Jeff Jones

Maybe if your rpg channel ends, you could do a James Bond channel. ;)

Clint Sharp

Great Matthew Colville impression.

Rufus Lynks

So then, YT will push channels if their viewers were to run acripts on a "spare" computer that views videos automatically when they come out? Does this already exist? Consider the range of options with such a tool.

Daniel Defazio

Lol. I love the Bond Experience Channel but I cannot compete with Dave Zaritsky. The dude OWNS an Astin Martin.

Daniel Defazio

I considered separating the advice and crafting. But it would mean I have to double my production. I can't do it. I am sick right now, and continuing to work on content.

Jeff Krus

I see this is woodworking channles as well. I saw one YTuber say I a forest full of evergreen trees 🌲 its hard or little room for new seedlings to grow.... I will always support PDM and Deathbringer!!!

MrGunn

@Rufus Lynks I am sure some where outside of Shenzhen or Hyderabad armies of peoples stand poised to click for profits. 🖱💲 😁😃

Firstspear

Honestly, as long as I can see your content here, YT can go **** themselves.

Dungeon Matron

If you recall the round table breakfast discussion at Mythic Con, these are a few of the reasons I hesitant to launch my own YouTube channel.

Evil Chad

Keep up the amazing work... As you can see from the above comments .. We all love ya. Thanks again PDM

Jay

PDM, yes! This is big news. I saw Guy's last video when it hit YouTube. By-the-Way, he put links to his 2 New YouTube Channels in the description of his last video for those interested. I also knew you would see it and cover it, and ya didn't disappoint. This subject has been something I've anticipated for quite some time and have absolutely ZERO joy that it's happening to our favorite creators. As your video stated, all things change even more overtly in the entertainment industry. Westerns were once very popular on TV, and they went by the wayside just like Star Trek, Game of Thrones, Marvel, James Bond, and Star Wars seems to be. So, it seems only logical that channels covering TTRPG's would eventually cover almost everything about the game and move on to related subject matter if not entirely new channels. Tick Tock… Mr. Dungeon Master… Tick Tock… 2026 is centuries away! Now get back to work on Deathbringer so you can take my Kickstarter Money! I mean who needs sleep anyway. Right? One last “Oh, by-the-way,” I’m don’t watch much Critical Role, yet I came upon this short clip of Matt Mercer talking about his new Grim Dark, Soles like campaign setting called “The Age of Umbra.” It might be worth a look. Anyway, here is the LINK for those interested, it's very short. https://www.youtube.com/shorts/PgK5FH1lz_A

John Doe

Ah sorry to hear you are not feeling well! I hipenit passes soon for you.

Agile Monk

Thank you, Dan (PDM) for speaking up about this. And appreciate the extra updates as well. I’ll be keeping with you sir.

Pyram King

I create content and use my YouTube channel primarily for long-form instructions and walkthroughs. While I don’t have a huge audience (around 6,000 subscribers), my main source of revenue comes from Ko-Fi subscribers, and I’ve chosen to keep YouTube ads off. I’ve never been too focused on ad revenue from YouTube, as my priority has always been growing my Ko-Fi subscriber base through consistent, engaging content. I’m a big fan of your channel and often revisit your older content—it’s been incredibly helpful and inspiring! Question: Do you think creating more narrowly focused content, like your adventures or crafting, would be better on a separate channel? Would splitting it into niche channels improve their performance or visibility, or could it negatively impact your main channel in terms of how YouTube promotes your content overall?

Joshua Slavin

I have loved your content from the start of the channel and go back and watch or listen to a lot of the earlier content repeatedly. I think the advice and content there has a lot more longevity; even if it doesn't have as much first hour punch as reviews and other algorithm fluff. The news and the most clickbaity content has a much more limited shelf life as even the best of it is tied to a singular moment. As such on your core content that that I love I try to comment and view asap, rinse and repeat. The ones that are of less interest like "Clickbait destroyed my channel" I don't watch at all because I don't want the algorithm to encourage that. In my opinion (which with that and a $1.25 you might get a soda from the vending machine) Guy's "How to be a great GM!" content started to be repetitive and he really struggled to come up with a new angles, despite new graphics, or other new presentation tricks. Yes all kinds of content are repetitive; procedural "who dunnit" cop shows like CSI or NCIS wouldn't have half a dozen spinoffs if they didn't work. I'm sure your state rubrics for teaching don't vary wildly from year to year. But as an instructor you have to keep it fresh for you and your students (audience). I believe Guy was also an english/language arts instructor but I never get the sense of him changing up lesson plans very often.

Daniel Defazio

Pyram King! Good question. I think it would kill both channels, actually. Or me. I barely have time to do one channel, let alone two!

Andyjagger

Another great video, just watched the old caves of carnage and they are all great! Keep up the good work PDM

Frederic Schmitt

Thank you for the video. I liked How to be a great GM a lot. Guy brought me back into gaming 7 years ago.

madcurry

I really enjoy the behind the scenes of a YouTube channel info. Though I don’t plan to start a channel, the business of it is very interesting. I personally found the DungeonTube community while looking for GM advice, but I enjoy the other videos as well. I look forward to your PAGE panels!

Daniel Defazio

Thank you. I work really hard on all my videos. Voicing your support really helps. That panel--BTW--will be AWESOME!

Lee Dunning

All of your upcoming content sounds amazing, and I look forward to it. These past couple of weeks I've been doing a deep dive into your older stuff. I watched the Caves of Carnage videos and YouTube started pushing your videos from 5-7 years ago, so they're recognizing that I'm enjoying your older stuff.

Saltheart

I have seen so many Content Creators talking about how much the "Algorithm" has changed for Youtube... I cannot imagine how much time and energy (and skill) goes into creating content... then to have Youtube get in the way of people seeing it..... must be Frustrating, for sure! You are certainly appreciated! Thank You!

Tim Ford

Wow Matt Colville's videos get a lot of views, consistently. Almost as popular as Ginny Di. Professor, would you be interested in doing a deep dive on why these channels might be so popular? They're quite different from each other, so I could see that being an interesting topic.

Brad F

PDM, you put in a crazy amount of work. I appreciate all of it.