Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

Sounds clickbaity but this is a DM advice video about what makes a good rule and a good house rule, when you should use the rules, and when you should home-brew. THIS is the first of many, MANY DM advice videos coming this year. Stay tuned for an important message. Enjoy. --PDM

Files

Previews only

Mike Mearls

Comments

Bagel-Man

Excited to watch Professor! I honestly think they were a good idea. But maybe you’ll change my mind.

Terra Jones

So I played both a lot of 5e and a lot of baldur's gate 3 and there's a lot of things that baldur's gate 3 does well, as a video game that illustrate why it doesn't work in a tabletop game. Bonus actions work great in baldur's gate 3. One thing about baldur's gate 3 is that you get all the time you want to take your turn and none of the other players going to be annoyed by it because it's a single player game for the most part. So at that point I like to maximize and theorycraft the best approach to do the most damage. In universe my character only has like 6 seconds to make this decision but hey we're taking turns here. There are no other players who are getting impatient and annoyed, they're not checking their phones or stacking guys together waiting for something to happen and then losing focus. On a different topic, baldur's gate 3 also illustrates why attunement is a good mechanic for tabletop even though they don't use it in the video game. If you do it the way baldur's gate 3 did, you'd have a load of magic items on you, and loads of buffs and debuffs that are highly situational that always seem to apply their bonuses because you don't forget about any of them. Because you don't need to remember any of them because the computer does it for you. You don't have that at the table top. This is why attunement is a good idea because limiting magic items to three means there's less cognitive load on you to remember that you have a relevant magic item in a given situation. It's all about limiting cognitive load and speeding things up at the table top because you want everyone engaged.

Filippo Bettoschi

Happy new year, Professor! Thanks for the video and get well soon!

KervyN

Warm black ooze with some cream at a fireplace.. sounds really good. Enjoy it. If you want the ultimate warm chocolate receipt: 1/3 bar of dark chocolate, with sugar and a little bit of salt. Coock it up with some cream (at least 15% fat) and when you have that really thick warm greasy stuff, add some milk until it is the desired consistence and enjoy. Wish you all the best, get well soon.

madcurry

This is the type of advice that made me a follower on YouTube and then a patron. At first I disagreed with you, but followed because I believe in entertaining contrary opinions. Then I started to get it, and my game mastering has only improved since. Thank you so much for all you do. I hope you feel better soon!

Richard Jyles

No exaggeration: Bonus Actions are the main reason why I don't like 5e D&D. I'm glad Mike Mearls brought it up! I'm sorry you don't feel well Professor DungeonMaster. Feel better soon!

Andyjagger

Take care of yourself PDM, the bit about the magic user is spot on 😆

Daniel D. Fox

Great video so far, Dan! Listening now.

Justin Watson

Great video, PDM, enjoy the slow down and a speedy recovery to you

MelodicMethod

Goodness, I hope you heal up soon. This is a gem of a video. I was nodding in agreement with a lot of it.

Angry Ghost

Get some rest Bro, its deserved, Your advice and discussions are always gold

Graham Kane

Great video, Dan. More players and DMs need to learn that the rules are not set in stone. And I’m sorry to hear you’re under the weather. Hot chocolate and mini painting is the ultimate, 1-2 knockout combo for whatever ails ya!

Enishi X

Get better soon and thanks for the video.

David Hoover

Get well, PDM. I look forward to seeing Mike Mearls on the show. We use a d6 initiative rolled each round and i find that is faster and adds unpredictability into the combat.

Drago Russo

Happy New Year and get well. I can't wait to see these upcoming videos. Great stuff.

Jeffkelly

Resting by the fire. Great advice. Feel better soon. Excellent video!

Jeff Jones

A new video idea: Pimp My Deathbringer!

Jay

PDM, in my opinion, this is the video some folks need to hear. I’m looking at the rule’s cultists specifically here. I’m sure many, especially those who’ve been fans of your channel may already know about the rules hacking and why it’s ok and sometimes necessary. Never-the-less, for those who may be new or can’t seem to break free from the idea that changing the rules is somehow cheating might want to reconsider things. I remember playing Monopoly as a kid and having $100 for anyone landing on Free Parking. So, this sort of thing has been happening for years in all kinds of games. All depends on what you and the others in the group agree to as a fun game really. Lots of good stuff in this video. Even though I’ve seen some of this advice in your previous videos, I rather enjoyed revisiting the quick combat hacks. It serves as a simple reminder for some of us who get caught up on the busy job of running the games as a way of simplifying and keeping things moving. Also, I am excited for the upcoming events along with new content. Also, fun fact, most people don’t prioritize their health as much as they do other things in their life that they love or find more interesting. Remember, you can’t take care of anyone or anything else until you ensure you have cared for yourself first. My way of saying your friends, family, and fans are all counting on you to ensure you get well. All this notoriety you have reflects great credit upon you not only as a professional but to those close to you a good man. So please make your health a priority. One last “Oh by-the-way”, you may have already responded by the time I’m making this post, but I will post the link below for those who might be interested. Esper The Bard made a video addressing your last video “YouTube is killing D&D channels. Here's why.” He was very thoughtful in his response. Esper The Bard “An Open Message to Professor DM (Dungeoncraft)” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIW6JG6m2vs

Jim Baird

Sounds like a good day. Get well soon!

Robert Balshaw

Hang in there, Prof. You sound rough, so I'm glad you got some medical attention. Chemo is a beast. Happy painting!

MrGunn

Dear PDM, Feel better soon, don’t skimp on the chicken soup. Great advice, RAW is for sushi 🍣 not D&D. Your loyal patron, MrGunn

Russell Miller

Looking forward to MM on the show. Should be an interesting episode.

Evil Chad

Get well soon, don't forget the marshmallows ;) Thanks as always PDM.

Brent Norton

Hope you feel better soon Dan. Make your Con save and and get some rest.

Cee-Jay

Thinking about you Prof, hope you feel better soon. Looking forward to seeing you and Mearls together.

Michael Hubbard

Get well soon! I feel the same about bonus actions, really, and have thought about just making everything an action and using the three action economy of PF2 in my D&D game. I'm curious, and maybe you've mentioned this before and I just haven't seen it, but what do you do instead of spell slots?

samurguybri

Much love and care PDM. Get well soon and be kind to yourself. Allow yourself to rest and DO NOTHING as much as you as you can. No minis,no projects, just vegging. Animals hide, sit still, eat and drink little until they are well. Human animals have the advantage of resting in safe, nurturing places, but our brains and societal pressure demand that we be productive all the time. Don’t buy the propaganda! REST me man! I’m fighting cancer now and have learned to honor this. I’m more tired, so I don’t need to push myself or drink more coffee, but sleep and sit on the recline and stare out the window. Stoked to hear about Mike Mearls. I would love to hear what his original intention for Bonus Actions was.

Frederic Schmitt

Get well soon! Happy new year. You are awesome! ☺

Steve

You should checkout "Clownfish TV" episode called "Nerd Culture: Post-Mortem." It may help you with your channel.

Jay

PDM, I'm not sure if this Clownfish TV video will help or not but you and your latest latest video are specifically mentioned in this video along with some positive comments toward you. I’m currently watching it while typing this because I listen to everybody then formulate my own opinions. This typically includes channels I may not normally watch because even a broken clock is right twice a day. In this case, I'm only a about a third into the video, I feel some interesting points are being made. Not just about D&D but several franchises in entertainment along with the current fandom culture. I'm not anticipating things get nasty yet (disclaimer) will post a retraction if things change or get bad by the end of the video. Anyway, that’s just what I think. You be the judge. Link listed below. Clownfish TV – YouTube - “Nerd Culture: Post-Mortem” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lo9PqQ_N9KU

Pete Doroshenko

Happy New Year Professor! Great video that really distills the essence of what D&D was always meant to be.... a set of guidelines and ideas to be modified by the DM to suit their own view of the fantasy world they are presenting. Often it is a matter of trial and error to see what works best for the DM and his players. I hope you feel better soon and are back to 100% before PAGE! May all your rolls be 20's!

Scott

Hope you feel better soon PDM, take care of yourself!

Kevin Richmeier

Hope you're feeling better. As a fellow teacher, I know what you mean about working when you're sick. Thanks for the advise on initiative and collecting player actions. I'm going to try in my next session.

Christopher Gauci

hey prof. Many nasty viruses are going around here halfway around the globe in the Mediterranean, too. They can be nasty but self-limiting 99% of the time. Take care of yourself, and let that imagination of yours cook more stuff up... Your students need you... even us, you D&D students :) Get well soon...but enjoy your time off. Hot chocolate time: Take a short rest by the fire, drinking a delicious hot chocolate. Get a +2 to feel good bonus and con saves vs virus. It can be used multiple times a day. You may need to make a diabetes save after the 5th mug (DM's Choice).

Thorne Tanaka

get well soon PDM. And as a healthcare professional I can verify hot chocolate is on the list.

Lee Dunning

Take advantage of the down time, Professor. Just do something you love and don't worry about algorithms, over reactors, or the weather.

Jethro

My favourite Gygax quote is “The secret we should never let the gamemasters know is that they don't need any rules”, it's as true today as it was when he said it and when they all created this wonderful game. As always loving your vids Sir.

Beardy B.

My concern is this: It's easy to think a game works poorly if you haven't read and understood the rules. Game designers did a lot of work to get that rule set out, so Read The Manual, and try RAW first. If it doesn't make sense, try reading again. Then, if you get it, by all means Hack away! The other viewpoint, which can be totally valid, is that if you understand exactly what these rules do, hack immediately. Professor examples make sense. If you don't have some complicated or dependent rules that rely on some peculiarity of combat or initiative, cool. Do cool stuff like side initiative where players go first unless monsters get surprise. That lets the players plan their actions together and as a combo. They will feel more like a team, and encourages them to be creative with each other. I personally love that hack. It also means that any rules or special abilities that affect initiative are useless. That means that certain class advantages are gone. It has other effects. As a result, the game master might need to provide some sort of advantage to a player instead of a class or feat that affected initiative.