Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

In 1916, the stocked P08 Luger with a 32 round trommelmagazin "snail drum" was probably the most advanced personal small arm available. In spite of its alarming complexity, the same drum magazine was used again in the MP18 SMG. Stocked pistols really aren't a thing anymore in the modern era, and while that is often blamed on the NFA, I'm not so sure that's really the reason.

Files

The OG PDW & Why Stocked Pistols Died in WW1

InRange is supported by viewers like you and every $1 helps! https://patreon.com/inrangetv In 1916, the stocked P08 Luger with a 32 round trommelmagazin "snail drum" was probably the most advanced personal small arm available. In spite of its alarming complexity, the same drum magazine was used again in the MP18 SMG. Stocked pistols really aren't a thing anymore in the modern era, and while that is often blamed on the NFA, I'm not so sure that's really the reason. Let's discuss.

Comments

Quacktar the Unforgiven

It's also a pain in the ass to carry >1 drum; they don't stack neatly the way that stick mags do.

Hobie

Very cool. I find the early "experimental" or "intermediate" solutions intersting.

Michael Schumacher

The MP 18 was originally designed with a box magazine, too; at least the variants MP 18/III and MP 18/IV. What led to the adoption of the MP 18/I with the Trommel-Magazin TM 08 was a decision of the Rifle Board: the TM 08 was in (relatively) wide use in the army and its use simplified logistics by not introducing another item into procurement and distribution.

Ghost of Sweden

Obviously the MP-18 was the better weapon, but if you were a stormtrooper with the choice before a trench raid to pick either a stocked artillery luger with snail drum or a stocked C-96 Mauser pistol, which would be better? What about a full auto C-96, they'd have been quite rare I suppose. Does that comparison warrant another video? I'm hoping so, if you have both available.

Ghost of Sweden

All I can come up with is having large cargo-pant size pockets but these are uniform pockets of WW1 standard size so that may not work. A side bag then?

Emily

That'd be an interesting comparison video, so, Karl, if you have the opportunity to make it, the interest is here! The main place I've seen full-auto C-96's is in Warlord-era China, both authentic versions and literal Chinese knockoffs, so I suspect they're pretty rare these days (used hard for a long time in several wars on the other side of the world from the US, after all).

Guido S

almost bought a mainspring housing very similar board stock like it for my 1911 last weekend. but.. 300ish new for something I am everything but sure if I like it at all... . well there are a lots of shoulderstocks in particular for glocks real cheap plastic things out there. hk vp70. if you neeed to arm any warm body if say a "large neighbour" may invade.... people still messing with the idea.

Land Cruiser

WTF! I pay for Inrange Patreon account and when I click on the video I get routed to Youtube where i am asked to "sign in." This is BS!

Michael James Blum

Full-auto pistols and stocked pistols were used in China up through the end of their civil war, due to various international arms embargoes starting just after WW1, restricting various "better" military weapons. "Pistols" weren't on the list of "military arms", and thus for about 10 years floods of semi-auto pistols entered China from Europe.

InRange TV

Youtube decided to age restrict this video. I've uploaded another version here: https://youtu.be/irlokx3o2Es I'm happy to directly upload videos here to Patreon but my experience has been that even patreon supporters don't/won't watch them on the native Patreon platform?

Tony Amaro

I would watch however it was accessible. I can only wish that you and others would take time out to post some of the best content on other platforms. It has proven fruitless so far but we can only hope time will change habits. I do have to remark that the view counts seem artificially low on some other platforms. You would think simple curiosity would have led to more clicks. My 2 cents. I am sure you have studied up on how to try to not trigger AI as much much. Good luck