Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I'm at a loss of what to do. The most recent WW1 Drum video got hit with 18+ age restrictions by the awful YouTube AI bot. This means that the video can only be watched if you're logged into YouTube and they think you're 18+ based on their "algorithm". I have received a few complaints from Patreon supporters about this, and I get it - but I have also directly uploaded content to Patreon in the past and literally no one watched the content natively, so I just started publishing the link to the YouTube version of the content.It feels like I'm caught in a situation that is lose-lose. I'd like to hear from y'all, would you prefer I publish the content here directly going forward again? That would avoid YouTube restrictions for supporters, but then I'm concerned I'll get complaints about:Being unable to download the content via some esoteric script people are using.Difficulty watching the content on non-standard devices or TV apps.Continued loss of views.But honestly, if the Patreons would prefer uncensored content here and are willing to watch it natively here, I'm more than down for that. I stopped because of complaints, even though I think it makes sense.Your input please? Help.

Comments

Adam Mills

I would happily watch them natively here. I have no loyalty to YouTube, and it's just as easy for me to watch a video on patreon as on YouTube.

Panda

I mean, fuck youtube. I know some creators are posting on patreon native + a dropbox (or similar) link to the full video file for people who want to have it locally. Not sure if that would suit everyone, but I'd be fine with that.

Jordan Walsh

My awareness of content posted on YouTube is a lot higher. It's not that I'm not interested in uncensored content, just that it's a lot easier to keep apprised of posts on YouTube, and comparatively more likely that I miss a Patreon notification in my email. This is the only Patreon I support, compared to a plethora of YouTube channels I follow, so I'm just not engaged with Patreon as a website in the same way.

frank irvin

post it here on patreon a dollar a month today is almost nothing

Jim Brown

I suggest you post the full video on Patreon and a short on YouTube. Basically advertising it with anything "offensive" removed, not sure how you can do that, maybe just talk history and point people here.

Sean Smith

I find it weird the number of people that pay to support a creator, then ignore everything the creator posts, and further, complain about it being too much

nitro

Is the youtube bot equally inclined to flag unlisted videos? If not maybe that is a good middle ground, link a unlisted version of the video uploaded to youtube. It keeps the conveniance of youtube. If that does not help, I personally would watch the videos on patreon native, but it would be really nice to be able to keep your videos in the watch later playlist

Craig

I'm totally ignorant to the editing process, but if it is easily "censored" for youtube then I'm sure posting that to YouTube and then the "real" video goes out on here and/or direct link as Panda suggested. YouTube does have the stranglehold on "easy to watch a bunch of stuff in a central location" at the moment. I never watch native videos, but for InRange I'd likely start

Jason Larke

I don't care about YouTube but I overwhelmingly watch video using a Roku streaming box and my TV. If you were publishing somewhere without a Roku "app", I would stop watching.

Scott Gardner

If I see it on You tube, I then go tomy Patreon account.

Bruce Brodnax

Publish a highlights reel as both a short and as real content; then, using a separate account not tied to the computer you use for uploading [you're digitally savvy, I know you can manage this w/o instructions!] go in and comment with the link to the full video uploaded to Rumble. Then go back in as "you" [the owner of the video] and pin the comment to the top. This should neatly avoid the YT-bots' persecution of your guntuber content, while allowing you to make use of their far superior audience-promotion algorithms [vs. Rumble, which basically doesn't have one...] And here on Patreon, you can link to the full video on Rumble directly, so do so. Use YT for your benefit, not just letting them use you for theirs...

Bruce Brodnax

Also, don't say "32 rounds..." or anything like that, since YT has a strict policy against standard cap mags of 30 or more, according to recent reports. You could say something like "3 and 2, just like 1 and 1 equals eleven" so that the 'bot doesn't parse that you're referencing a "high cap" magazine..,

VM Kane

Frankly, I watch YouTube out of laziness and lethargy. If I pick up on the Patreon notification promptly, I'll invariably watch here and prefer the viewing experience. If I don't and forget to go back to the email later, I'm more likely to catch up on YT and resent all the extraneous clutter, but that's a character failing on my part. Heaven knows what use that insight is to you; I suppose it's a vote for Patreon

JB Robak

I would rather watch on patreon. I'd hate to see you have to do the silly youtube self censoring song and dance not calling firearms what they are or referring to historical deaths as "unalivings" and what not.

JohnL

Posting your content here on Patreon poses no issues for me.

A A C

I watch your content both here and on youtube ss I thought that might help in some small way . If you can post it here in full with perhaps a short on youtube if you think the content may upset the youtube overlords . I will be happy to increase my monthly support as I admire your courage in the shitstorm that is the modern media world .

Mr. Metzger

I find YT more convenient, even if the censorship they're enforcing is annoying, to say the least. Still, you have to put *something* on YT to try and gain new supporters, right? So, as has been suggested already, putting a "compliant" version there and the original one here seems like a possible solution to me.

Connor Stone

Until Patreon has a smart TV app, I'd prefer YouTube please. Totally cool with a censored YouTube version and an uncensored Patreon version, though I know that is more edit work for you. That might be the best metric for now: what % of viewers watch your YouTube videos on a TV? They will probably prefer to easily access your (potentially censored) content via YouTube.

Albini family

Other guntubers are making this approach work. When something obviously crosses YouTube's boundaries (full auto fire, for instance) it would be easier to post the spicy bits to Patreon in a neutered version with a teaser on YouTube, but when they hit you out of the blue like this the short is probably the way to go.

Timothy T.

Personally I think the easiest option is an unlisted video linked to patreon, maybe it's the same video and it releases a week early or something or maybe it's entirely separate. I don't have a strong opinion though, but I'll just be honest I'm most likely to engage with the content on YouTube.

Quacktar the Unforgiven

The question is knowing what is compliant and what isn't. YouTube doesn't usually tell you.

Quacktar the Unforgiven

I usually watch through Patreon. Butt, if you know what's triggering YT to list as 18+ *specifically*, I'd either bleep the audio, and/or put big black "censored to be YouTube compliant" boxes over the offending part of the video. If, y'know, that's not a dreadfully tedious process.

Nomp

This particular case doesn't affect me, since I watch logged in, but there will conceivably be more heavyhanded censorship "strikes" in the future, so I'm fine with content being here. Is there a reason you don't dual-upload by default? Does it have an associated cost in Patreon to have a large archive of video? I get that it would seem to be "pointless" previously, but now I think it makes sense as a *backup* against loss of views.

JS

I’ll watch where the link takes me and continue to provide Patreon support.

Robert Glinka

I prefer the YouTube interface, and I pay for YouTube premium so the 18+ isn't a problem for me. If you posted only on Patreon, I'd get the email and watch it on Patreon.

David Hemsath

I dropped my paid YouTube subscription a few months ago in response to its shitty treatment of historical firearms content (you, Cap and Ball, etc.). If the content is available on Patreon without ads, that’s how I watch

Land Cruiser

I only watch InRange on Patreon. YouTube sucks.

Mr. Metzger

True. What would YT and other platforms be without an unhealthy dose of arbitrariness, right? But, I'd expect someone as experienced as Karl to be able to make an educated guess as to what YT might deem problematic, and to have the connections to learn from other content producers.

Aaron McQueen

I have started migrating all my content creator support here. So I am game for patreon

Dennis McNamara

As I understand it, you don't get any money from YT but you do get exposure and so possible future patrons. For me, It hink you should cater to those who pay you. If the YT users who like your content but don't support you finanancially, sorry about that (Not)

Emily

I always watch here on Patreon, so I don't mind. I'd rather you didn't censor yourself. I've had a minor issue with Patreon-native videos in the past, where the video would autoplay (with no sound) even if I had it turned off (fixable by pausing the video and then playing it), but I'd still prefer to watch here on Patreon no matter the format you upload in. As some people have suggested already, maybe YouTube doesn't flag unlisted videos? I honestly don't know myself, but I know some creators that have posted full-auto firing in unlisted YT videos for Patreon, and - at least back then and to the extent of my knowledge (I'm always logged in though) - there didn't seem to be a problem. I really hope you manage to strike a golden balance, Karl

StoneCW

I suggest posting to both. Personally, I'm unlikely to watch anything on Patreon since I watch almost 100% of my videos on a smart TV through the YouTube app.

Hobie

I'm fine with seeing it only here. If it's not too much trouble (I have zero idea*) maybe the "shorts on YouTube" might get you a few more subscribers? *possibly less than zero. Your understanding might decrease just by reading this.

Bill Smithem

I'm likely confused (nothing new) but I was under the impression that what's here is hosted on YT and I can watch it here or on YT. If so, and I click the "Watch on YouTube" link, does that get around the algorithm's age restrictions?

Rusty Gulley

I appreciate that you and other YT content providers that I subscribe to continue to bring exciting and useful videos to the platform. It benefits YT when they demonetize a video, because they still get revenue off of it. That has got to violate antitrust law, but violating trade laws hasn't stopped Amazon, FB, or any other large corporation.

Åmund Breivik

Not a direct answer, but watching the video I immediately went "Uh oh" when that brief clip of you firing an MP18 on full auto came up. YouTube now has very strict rules against anything full auto, and apparently they have an automated system that flags full auto firing for review and possible channel strikes etc. Allegedly, based on what other creators have said, it seems like what flags it as full auto to the algorithm is the audio with a detectable high and steady cyclic rate. Of course, "high capacity" feeding device can also run afoul of their censorship but I was worried about your getting a channel strike or something when that full auto segment showed up.

Jason

Well shit. Youtube's bot's are evil. As others have suggested, a short on YouTube and the full video on Patreon. I'm good with the Patreon video being either unlisted on YouTube or natively on Patreon. I'd watch in either case.

Sascha Schwinkendorf

I have no google account and am not logged in to youtube, but here in germany i could watch the drum video with no age restriction directly on youtube. Don't know what's the difference there. It even got recommended to me as the second thumbnail on the main page. I normaly watch inrange content via patreon anyway, so no problem with that either.

Leonard Heinz

I tend to watch in YouTube, but would happily watch in Patreon as long as I got a notice telling me that the video was available. My own experience had been that Patreon notices of new videos arrive fairly reliably, unlike notices for YouTube videos.

juwara bobrok

I must be dumbing out here. What is the problem with uploading to both YouTube and Patreon? You're already demonetized on YouTube, correct? What does it matter if the 18 plus restriction kicks in. All the 18 and younger people I know are smart enough to see your mentions of Patreon and come on over here, no? Or does this have to do with some kind of three strikes you're out system on YouTube that would exclude you from uploading there or vanish your videos entirely? Serious questions. I don't know.. Personally, I find the shorts clips on YouTube to be generally annoying.. with the exclusion of a few accounts that I just can't resist watching, including yours, Karl. If this is a matter of, for whatever reason, you wanting to maintain a foothold on YouTube, perhaps publishing sanitized shorts continually is a way.. Sorry, verbose.

Alexx

I’ll gladly watch on here. I usually prefer it anyway.

Luci

Unfortunately no video distribution platform does it as well as Youtube does from a purely technical point of view. Patreon's player is not very good, I'm sad to say. That said, what's stopping you from uploading to both platforms? Or at least uploading to Patreon in the cases where you get hit by nonsense on YT?

RGB

YouTube is easy because I'm already there. But perhaps a hybrid approach. - historicals and discussions on YouTube. - gun content on Patreon with a stub & Short on YouTube. If it's available for all on Patreon, let people know. -shorts that are clips of longer videos as advertising. But ultimately I'm all in favor of pateron being the primary site

Paul-Alexander Crystal

Also - you don't want to become too dependent on another algorithm deciding who gets notified and when. That was one of the first shit moves utub did. The bell became the jittery bell and then they just said ah fuck it we are just going to ignore that.

Eric Sammywaifu

Ive watched some C&Rsenal videos here natively so I would probably be fine watching your videos here natively as well. But yeah, I think it might be the case than many YT viewers wont. Sorry Karl, I don't envy your situation. Pretty much a lose/lose. Good luck though man. Your content is awesome and important!

Eric Sammywaifu

Per the gun tuber who shall not be named, (yes gun jesus) he said that Unlisted videos get marked as advertiser-safe even when its the exact same video on his main channel that is normally listed. The normal videos get the flag.

Robert Shafer

I watch videos from Capandball and others on Patreon due to YT's "community guidelines" being subject to change without notice. In the YT version of their videos, they mention that the full version is available on Patreon.

Brian Herzog

Youtube is easier because I frequently check there for new content on multiple channels, including this one. However, inrange is important enough to me that I'll watch content here if you post it here. I tend to miss things if posted to shorts though (well, I'll see it eventually), so a short video announcement letting us know about patreon content would be better for me than a youtube short. Sorry you have to go through all of this.

George William Herbert

If I know I am missing it on YouTube I will come right over here, but with busy days I often read the email and don’t remember to check if video is still up when I get to after work break and can YouTube freely. A short That’s safe and points to Patreon and I will come right over. But I don’t routinely check here on a daily basis. Maybe I should.

George William Herbert

Just to confirm I absolutely want all the content you are posting. It’s how I notice and look for it that’s not optimal right now.

Nick

I can pretty easily watch a fully "uncensored" version on Patreon when I'm at home, but I also like to point friends towards your videos when we're in someone else's home, which is easier to do with YT unfortunately.

xpoliisi

Other creators I support such as Capnball, post an edited video to Youtube and the full video to Patreon. That is more work for you and forces you to proactively censor your content, but that is the environment Youtube has fostered. It's naive to say don't use Youtube. Yeah, Youtube is evil and full of silly restrictions, but they are the 800 lb gorilla. I wish another platform would take off, but Alphabet would either strangle it or buy it. I don't think anyone has the answer. Good luck.

Dan Hay

I was about to suggest publishing your content on Pepperbox but that sits behind a pay-wall. This is not good if your desire is to get your material out to all of us without the additional financial obligation of a subscription to yet another streaming service. Personally, I would be OK with viewing the content directly on Patreon. I would be happy to not have to interact with youtube at all. I also like Jim Brown's suggestion.

TpzBlau

Seems like more work but its probably the optimal solution at the moment. Its just a shame we live in a world where basic knowledge has to have hoops attached to it.

Michael Llaneza

Uncensored here and censored on YouTube seems to have worked for other creators I follow.

Demosthenes-101

Post an edited short or reel on YouTube and Facebook, with the full unedited video on patreon.

Matteo Manino

I think the best option is to have a censored version on YT and the full one on Patreon, like what Queer Armorer is doing.

'General' Dipper

I think you need to clarify your objectives. However, if your long term goal is to remain operating by replacing wastage then you have to post on Youtube. You cannot attract anyone from in here. That said, if that is your goal then I would consider specific lure content. Do collaborations with, say, history channels and travel. I still insist that what you do is not guns so much as integrity. And the algorithm has not banned that yet.

Daniel Falch

I prefer uncensored content. It’s why I pay to support your channel. I watch your content through here in whatever format it’s in before going to YouTube.

Maxx22944

Google often requires you to confirm your age using ID or a photo of your face to watch such videos, an invasion of privacy and far more than simply entering a birthday

Adrian Colwill

As already suggested by many dual posting seems to be the way. I personally always watch on Patreon since I bloody hate the adverts on YT. As also mentioned entry to Patreon is not excessive and since so much viewing now is prepaid..................

Adam Jacob

YT is an unfortunately necessary evil. Thoughtful scripting could ease (not eliminate, but ease) the editing hassle of creating and posting a YT version on their platform and a "Full Feature" version on other platforms. If the content is interesting, and yours is, I'll happily grab the laptop or head to another app to watch. Patreon needs an app for the major streaming devices though. AppleTV, Roku etc. are all on big screens in living rooms across the world. Making a viewer get out another device to watch on a smaller screen is a turn off, and a missed opportunity for Patreon's content builders.

onewhoseeks17

Just being honest, but Youtube is more convenient to watch content on. Others have suggested 2 versions with the uncensored on patreon, but I know that's harder than it sounds. Sorry you're dealing with this Karl. You're the best.

Jay Thirsty

I don't have a Youtube login, but it still diplays the thumbnail on the main page and doesn't tell me it's age restricted when I click on it.

Tony Amaro

Keep trying to build as much interest on platforms outside Youtube as possible I guess. It seems fruitless I know but if you and others were posting build videos or content that Youtube would have a problem with elsewhere it may draw viewership that matters over time. I have been suspicious of the view counts I see on Rumble for some time now, you would think curiosity alone would account for more than that.

joshua barach

I feel the same way but only because I’m a patron but it can take weeks to find the time to sit down and watch. For some it’s just a time and schedule issue. Still appreciated!!

Daniel Gray Webb

A different patreon channel that I watch uses venmo for videos they know won't do well on YouTube but I don't know if that would help you.

SDKI

it would be cool if you still posted on both but I will be making an effort to view more on patreon