Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Wouldn't it be funny if I actually did this though?

-G

Files

Comments

beelypuff

I'll take anything.

Michelle and Quincy

As long as it’s cheesy, I’m sooooo over that song LOL

Karin Wolf

Oh YESSS... !😆🥰

Ellen Reiser

We will love anything you do.

Landon Maxwell

I’m sure you could make it great. Be an interesting oktavist remix.

MJ

If you did I would be surprised

Rosie Boughen

Ha ha ha. Hilarious. DO IT!!! 😃

Beth Comer

I really hope this is your sly way of saying that you actually did it this year!!

Dana

please?

Katherine Powell

Oh. My. Gosh. All I want for Christmas is this to be a real thing.

Huldra Draco

lol, who are you and what have you done with Geoff Castellucci? 🤣🤣

Laura Müller

Well this would be interesting. 👍

ObscureReferenceWoman

Do it! We need a better version of that one !!! Please? Pretty please with marshmallows?

MEGAN FEAR

That would be the best Christmas present ever ❄️☃️🎁🎄🎅🎁

Emily Dion

If anyone could make me like that song, it's probably you

ZAYRAY!

Now.. if you can get me to like this song.. you win everything😂🤣

Karen & Lauren

Might just be the only cover worth listening to. 😊

Carcidon

Somehow I have no doubt that you would make it awesome in your own way 👀😆

Laura

But in original key 😂

Helen Surtees

I no if you did you would smash it as you and the boys are amazing xxxxxx love from the UK xxxxx

Tema Krempley

Well, you singing it would be the only way I’d listen to the song. Otherwise… 😱 And to be honest, I despise Christmas music. I listen to it when you and VP do it. Otherwise all my nope! 😓

María Gabriela

If you are getting the Mariah Carey outfit then, by all means, yes 😆

Gretchen G

It would be hilarious. And amazing. Please do, lol.

Robin P

I just saw this come across my watch, and my first reaction was "please no". I can't stand this overplayed song.

Carol Franklin

It would be different & it can only be better!!!

J

Sounds great , would Love to hear that. Hope in a Stylish costume , like Always 😅👍

Hunter

I have had to listen to this song for an entire MONTH in rehearsals for a dance performance on the 13th. I do not say no to you doing it, but please work your Christmas magic and make it something I don’t wanna cut my ears off to. Humor is always good.

Jessica Lord

Are you trying to break the internet? Because that's how you break the internet.

Sophia McGonigal

Please do! That would be a bazillion times better than Mariah Careys version

Jason Cranford

This would be amazing!!!!! Please please please!

Angie Woollard

PLEASE SAY ITS TRUE!!!!! PLEASE SAY ITS TRUE!!!! 😭 I was literally JUST telling friends that I’d probably bawl like a baby* if you did this song. Michael Bublé’s gentle crooner version of this song (in the key of F#, no less!!!) is so warm and cozy and is something I look forward to every year. *Happy tears…just to be clear.

ZAYRAY!

Can’t wait for those whilst notes!

Katie D

Oh no 😂

Zach Stegenga

I really hope this is your way of telling us “Guys I did this”

Mona Iren Hugaas

It would be great, with another version then the original!

Katie D

Same 🤣

Ashley Evers

I'm trying to decide if it's more likely that you had time to mock up fake album art for a joke, or that you decided to make it a mini for the lols 🤣

Rachael Dizmang

T'would fulfill many of your patrons Christmas wishes, myself included, if you did do it. 🎄 But, no matter what, we all appreciate the time and effort that you put into the music & videos that you do release. 🫶

Sarah Borzelli

I'm SO sure you would make this song sound absolutely amazing!

Jess M

Yes, please do 😂

Filiz E

Why not? 🎅🤣

Michael Webb

As much as I love your work, don't do this song. I just can't stand it after hearing it on the clock in coffee shops for so long

The Lou Crew

If you think you can get into the outfit, go for it. 🤣

Grace Files

This better be true!! It would be the best cover of this song ever😍

Cat

Yes, but do it the creepy way so that it is like a stalker-song. :D

Kaitlyn Wells

If you do it maybe I would be finally able to listen to it and not want to claw my ears out. Geoff versions are better

Lynn M

🥹 please 🙏 pretty please

Natalie Thompson

I too might finally be able to stand the song if given the Geoff touch. Otherwise it does make me want to remove my ears.

Biene

This could be the only version I can stand. Give it a geoffy try!

Leonie Frenkert-Ghazi

In any case!!! Absolutely!!! I'm VERY curious to hear how you interpret it! 🤗🎄🤗🎄🤗

Sarah Reach

I actually like this song, so I'd enjoy it. Just, please, never do "Last Christmas" 🤮

Jacky Friedman

That is a beautiful Christmas song. Yes. Please do it 🙏.

Dorothy Rosenberg

Honestly? I’m not a Mariah Carey fan; and high-pitch female holiday songs are like finger nails across blackboards. Having said that - your vocal range/control/intelligence gives you the potential to create something magical (yet again). I even see an amusing parody as an option (or a deep male torch song?). So? … HAVE FUN!

Sarah Reach

Plot twist, Daryl posted this.

Mikki Fullerton

WOOHOO! I've been hoping for this one from you! I do recall Kathy didn't want you to do it, so I apologize to Kathy for asking for it repeatedly anyways. Can't WAIT to see what you do with it!

Amanda W

As long as it's not in the same octave as Mariah Carey, I'm sure I'd enjoy it. 😆😉

Zena Darling

Arrange it in a minor key, make it creepy!

Randiskye

That's just mean!!!! Please move away from the terror song, slowly!!

Mikki Fullerton

Secondly, why would the album art for a song all about not needing presents have three presents on it? Is it because you enjoy irony, or is it because you are trolling us again? 😂

Rose Arthur

If you make me like this song then you must be a God.

Victoria

You NEED to do this!

Angie Woollard

All I want for Christmas is you. And a new camera and some cookware. 😬

Tara Congo

Oh my gosh, yes 😂

Cloudy Skies

Yes! Stalker-ish. Bwa ha ha.

Amanda Yarbro

Do it!! Do it!! Do it!! Do it!! Do it!!

Celia

Please.........

Amanda Hovendon

Oh dear lord. Who do I have to kill? 🤣🤣

Emma Yadkin

It wouldn't be the first time you and/or Voiceplay got me to like a song I didn't before your arrangement, but I still hope you use your talent for another song.

Dylan

Yaaaasssss

Tine

Oooohh this will be so interesting and lovely! I am very excited to hear this!

Amanda Hovendon

Whose house will I be visiting? 🤣. Who put you up to this? 🤣

Tara Congo

Skimming through the comments now and WOW is that ever a divisive song 🤣🤣

Mythos Myths

Your starting a debate with a conundrum of this magnitude hurts my brain.

DnD Addict

Well now I want this

schlumpfinchen82

I‘m definitivly agree with you. Last christmas is horrible.

Katherine Linkous

I can envision it now. Geoff making Christmas goodies, but burning the cookies, breaking glasses, and tripping under the mistletoe. End song by Cathy bandaging his boo boos and giving him a sweet kiss on the forehead (he's still on the floor from the trip under the mistletoe)...all I want for Christmas is youuuu.

Anja Eder

That's exactly the kick I needed today....should you actually take the title of the song literally?! 😉

Anke Bühler

And as a bonus "last christmas " and I will shoot myself. I hate christmas songs!! And not even if you sing it will change this fact. 🤪🤪🤪

Jennifer DeBroux

How about the Alannah Myles one instead? 😊

Lori Chaslot

I prefer the version by Vince Vance and the Valiants. Mariah makes my ears hurt.

Ethan Kayne

Yes yes yes yes a 1000 times yes times infinity ♾️ plus whipped cream and a cherry on top

Tara Williamson

That would certainly have the fans swooning. ;)

Bonnie Kaupp

To bad Mariah wrecked this song for me. But, I have faith you'll turn me around. 🤗😊

Joanna

Of course you should! 😁

Jay Fritz

This would be awesome, but I'd go for Do You Hear What I Hear.

AmbularD

I could dig it. Just, for the love of all that's holy, please never cover 'The Christmas Shoes.' Anything but that

Jeanette Pencz

That would be wonderful. So YES please 😉😁

Tara Williamson

That song makes me cry. Geoff's version would have me bawling like a baby. Anything but that.

Jill Weimer Koeninger 🐉

You could sing me the phone book and I'd be happy. However, I am looking so forward to this beautiful song! Sing it to me! (I know you're really singing it to Kathy.) ❤️🥰

Janet Wright

No!! The full thing so we have an antidote whenever Mariah starts screeching it

Janet Wright

Please! You managed to turn around that stupid chipmunk song for me. You’re obviously miracle workers.

Annette Corrado

I really hate that song but I have faith you could do something special with it.

Melissa Glyn-Jones

Oh yes please!!! Fix my love hate relationship with this song!!

Shirley B Karr

No, Geoff! Step away from that song! Unless you're going to sing it in a minor key and make it sound stalker-ish. Like that last "you're mine" in I Put A Spell On You. Or wear the same outfit as Mariah...

Donate Zechiel

Maybe I like this song if you sing it 😅. By the way I like all songs if they are interpreted by you!!

Tören Renée

I’m not fond of the song, but I’m sure there are plenty of people who are.

AmbularD

I just think it's a horrible song XD

Jessica Guerrero

I work retail so I visibly cringed when I saw the song title....however I have hope that you will make the song better than its original

Amanda Hovendon

I thank god everyday that my store hasn’t played this song yet. When they do though, I will scream❤️. Geoff, please make this song so much better 🙏🏻🙏🏻. I have total faith in you😅❤️

Agnes EvaR

Funny? Maybe. Great? Definitely. I have nothing against this song.

Veronica Thunander

Well, even if my first reaction to reading this is ”oh no”, the truth is that you have a talent for making everything great, so I guess this would be as well if you or VoicePlay did the arrangement and singing. So yes, you could actually do this one and make it good…

Kristina [Lady Greensleeves33]

At this point you could probably arrange just about anything into greatness. I feel like this would need either full-bodied dedication or full tongue-in-cheek mockery though 😂 Or both. But no in between.

Carl Thomas

As long as you wear the same outfit Mariah did it'll be a thing of legend.

Cécile Roussey

Knowing you, it will be great, I’m sure:-) ... no matter the Christmas songs... Otherwise, little info, I really hope customs won’t refuse my letter for you... because I had an idea for your wife’s hearing loss, Kathy, in case of emergency at night... And if the customs just refuse the letters, I will not know how to do it... because the gifts I made for your 43 years, do not pass... pity... excuse-me if this message has strange turns because I translate with a software... but it is sure that it will be great with the clip etc... I can not wait! ^^

Ann Durham

I think it would be bloody hysterical and I would put it on loop.

Mimi Nator

No! Please no! It's the most overplayed song of the season. 🤦‍♀️

Dee Herrera

Yes, please! It’s a great idea.

Gaisha Ziapour Edwards

It is such a great idea, go for it, I will be listening to it all year round, not just on Christmas. A very Merry Christmas to you and yours ❤️

Alex Walker

Fantastic idea! Yes, please!!

Karin Wolf

For me this would be "Last Christmas"... THERE'S a big nono from me... 🤣

SunnyOutlook

I really can't picture this, especially as a bass cover. However, you have a masterful touch with arrangements. I could see you playing as a slimmed down, young looking Santa. Would he be wearing a redesigned costume utilizing a tank top? LOL! I'm up for anything you do. It would be fun.

Mark Burlingame

I’m sure it would be great. Give it a go! MB

Nic

I just want you to sing live

LaRae

Yes, please. ❤️

Celia

It could be silly fun! Or should I say your kind of DUMB.😂

Celia

Okay! I was so wrong! VoicePlay did your kind of DUMB with Jingle Bell Rock.😳