Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Unshaken THUMBNAIL POLL (Patreon)

Published:
2024-03-05 19:38:24
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Poll

Unshaken THUMBNAIL POLL

  • Group in Shadow 159
  • Group in Light 39
  • Single Shadow 315
  • 2024-03-05
  • 513 votes
{'title': 'Unshaken THUMBNAIL POLL', 'choices': [{'text': 'Group in Shadow', 'votes': 159}, {'text': 'Group in Light', 'votes': 39}, {'text': 'Single Shadow', 'votes': 315}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 3, 5, 17, 23, 39, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 513}

Content

Lemme know what you think! 

Files

Comments

Tema Krempley

So you decided to trust us with thumbnails again? I feel honored. 😆

Angie Woollard

Hands down, #3 for me, the single shadow. It's very evocative, and immediately brings to mind the video game. You've absolutely nailed that RDR2 font, too.

Robin Carter

As much as i luv Daryl, its still all about you

Ashley Evers

I would probably center the title on the single as well, but that's my favorite.

Carol Franklin

I vote for three. Think it needs to be shadow red for the game & it’s always good to tease possible multiple or solo Geoff!

Janina

They are all really good, but the Singel Shadow picture was the one that got me to finally joine patreon 😊

Jen A AKA Dravengal

Wow, hard choice. I love all of them. It depends what you're going for, I guess. The first one is mysterious and haunting, the second is cool because we get to see the Ghost riders as humans (though we get that in the video), and the third looks like a really awesome book or record (yes, I was around for vinyl) cover.

Steffi Poe

I prefer the single shadow. It's a perfectly balanced picturesk composition 👍

Tara Congo

I love both 1 and 3, but went for 1 - that silhouette is unique, but definitely still brings to mind the game. The single one is awesome for an album cover, though

Tine

Ooh hard choice. Either single or group in the shadow. But that single one looks so striking to me

Tara Congo

Whichever one wins, *please* consider selling prints of the single shot in your store. It's such a cool pic

Jordi S

I second that!

Lenka Z.

We can vote, so you can choose as you like at the end again, regardless what Patrons think? ;) I voted for group in shadow as this is all about multiple versions of Geoff... but single shadow would be ok as well. I guess you are going for some of those two anyway. :) Perhaps for the single shadow as you already used it for the teasers. ;)

Jeanette Pencz

I love the shadow red thumbnails 👍 Solo Geoff or all 4 Riders ? 🤔 I love both but I choose „1“ 🥰

Mythos Myths

😎 I think #3 feels more like the game.

Gretchen G

Either of the shadow ones!

Alyssa Daniels

Group in the light takes away from the mysteriousness. Def 1 or 3, but I like the composition of 1 more.

B Sprak

I chose the single shadow. It will be most easily seen of the two, though either in shadow pic would be great. I love all three, but unless there's a lightening bolt involved in providing the light, shadows fit the song best.

Petra Harwin

I voted 3 but I expect to be ignored so you can pick your favourite!

Shirley B Karr

The lonely guy in shadow looks awesome -- in a bigger picture. In a thumbnail, I think it might be hard to tell what is depicted when someone is scrolling whatever platform. The first time I saw it, it took my brain a moment to recognize it as a person in a hat, head bowed. Group in shadow is instantly recognizable as people. Moody people. Which suits the song. Group in light reminds me of I See Fire.

Sarah Borzelli

are you sure, you wanna trust us again? it's tight between the group shadow shot and the single shot... (they're great) for me the font would work better without the black background (but maybe then it would be too similar to the game?) and for the single shot for my eye it would be even better if you weren't right in the middle but a little more in the golden ratio of the pic... (oh gosh I sound like my artist husband)

Helen Surtees

I think single as it will be a shock to everyone else that the rider's are back xx

kami

I like the single shadow and then group shadow would be my second choice.

Debs Badger

Why do I even bother? 🤣🤣🤣 ETA: I picked the group in shadow since you said it was a favorite shot of yours.

Debs Badger

He's going for whatever will get someone to click on the video.

Lynda Rood

Love all three, but the shadow ones add to the mystery.

Jacky Friedman

I personally like the thumbnail you have for the Patreon premiere video. The lettering and everything is great.

Pat R

I seem to be going against the crowd but I love #2.

Kourtney Frantz

It’s kinda like having a secret..we think it’s just Geoff…but then..SURPRISE!!! So I like the teaser solo shot..since Sir Geoff likes to tease😁

Mythos Myths

Tema, I think G "trusts" us to figure out which one he wants to use.

Mikki Fullerton

I voted the red shadow group since I thought it would stand out the most for a thumbnail. However, for a merch pic (since others brought it up) I'd also prefer the single shot, only since the font is off to the left side of the pic could the cowboy please be further on the right side of the pic to balance it out a bit more? I'm not sure how much extra footage you might have on the side to pull from but hey, it's worth asking...

Tema Krempley

That’s a tall order! Well, at least he has faith in us.

Marie DesJardin

I think Group in Shadow makes the most recognizable thumbnail

Ilona Dever

Much as I love seeing your face, and I know I'm not the only one, I voted for Group Shadow. The rationale?? All of your fans squealing , "The boys are back!!!!!"

Katherine Powell

Well let's see if I get this right this time. 😆 Taking into consideration the cover art for RDR2, I chose a silhouette, and I chose the single version of you because it's obvious you're in a cowboy getup even when it's tiny like a thumbnail. I also know that when you put that up as the teaser pic, someone guessed RDR so it's iconic enough to be associated with that. Plus, if someone didn't know, they could at least immediately guess something Western themed, I think.

Lexy Wolfe (aka Pam)

I like the single shadow because it'll look good in actual thumbnail or full size.

Dorothy Rosenberg

While I love group in light (#2), I believe (#3) single in shadow would be most effective as a thumbnail.

Jen A AKA Dravengal

Well, yeah, that's a given. But it just being a Geoff video will get many people to click it. It seems like everyday I see someone new reacting to him for the first time. I voted for number 1, but I do like them all. Hey! My profile picture is acting like a Gif over here! It doesn't on YouTube anymore.

Japheth Campbell

I’m going with single shadow. Although the RDR2 artwork shows a group shadow, it primarily focuses on a single cowboy character that’s not a shadow. This combines both elements, shadow and single character. I think it is most likely to create a connection for fans of the game.

Riona O'Malley

Single shadow, but I would So Very Much prefer it with centred text. The red/white/black pair are definitely more striking than the full colour images, that's for certain.

Beth Comer

Personally, I like the group silhouette the most, but for the thumbnail I have to concede that the single shadow is the most appropriate.

Hallie Heller

I think you alone is much more impacted. It's a strong powerful image

Cloudy Skies

I like them all; I voted for the group in light, but I have already changed my mind to the single shadow.

Jamie Marcus

I like single you. It reminds me of Willie Nelson , red headed stranger and I love Willie 😉

Angie McDougle-Curl

All in shadow is my fav … But the single silhouette gives more of the vibes of the game, I think.

HGeek

Even though I liked the group silhouette but your individual silhouette gives it a look deserving of the vocals and the video❤️ but something tells me that you have already chosen your favourite of the lot as the thumbnail haven't you Geoff 🤔😎

SunnyOutlook

There's no question for me. It's the single shadow.

Cécile Roussey

I voted the third because it’s more mysterious ^^

Melanie Hobbs

I am honestly torn between the group in shadow and the single in shadow. I think I would like the single in shadow more if it was a little more balanced. With the title on the left, the figure needs to be pushed farther to the right. I didn’t have a chance to look yesterday, and the votes are looking a little lopsided. Just pick the one you eyes keep coming back to.

Suzy Bailey

The single shadow is definitely impactful and more mysterious!

Cynthia Ross

The shadow with the red background is very true to the game’s imagery. I had to pick one, but I think either will draw the eye of people who know the game.

Shirley B Karr

I KNEW you'd change the thumbnail! Hope the group in light gets a lot of click conversions. Single shadow image would look great as a t-shirt graphic. It's a really cool, powerful image ... just needs a larger format to see what's going on.

Gene Skinner

NO bout about it, the single shadow wins it!!