Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Choose What We Stream On New Show Plus!

  • The Top 20 Tens 326
  • Defusing Giant Bomb - Baby Steps 250
  • Our Old Dating Messages 329
  • Scripted Podcast - The Smash Bros. Movie 60
  • 2026-01-12
  • —2026-01-13
  • 965 votes
{'title': 'Choose What We Stream On New Show Plus!', 'choices': [{'text': 'The Top 20 Tens', 'votes': 326}, {'text': 'Defusing Giant Bomb - Baby Steps', 'votes': 250}, {'text': 'Our Old Dating Messages', 'votes': 329}, {'text': 'Scripted Podcast - The Smash Bros. Movie', 'votes': 60}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 1, 13, 5, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 1, 12, 19, 1, 38, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 965}

Content

Every week New Show Plus lets supporters at the Backstage Pass tier on Patreon vote to choose a new show for us to create, or to continue an older show from a previous week. If you missed the reveal, you can learn more about the format in this quick video.

So check out your options below, and vote to choose the next episode we create for New Show Plus airing Tuesday on Twitch!

The Top 20 Tens - We just can't quit lists. We'll round-up all of the "Perfect 10" games from big sites like Game Informer, IGN, and Gamespot throughout history and pit them against each other to make the ultimate Two Tens Of Tens... This would also be available in the bonus podcast feed.

Defusing Giant Bomb - Baby Steps - As the new Baby Steps master, Jacob Geller would race Baby Steps superfan Jeff Grubb from Giant Bomb in a cross-over to snuff out Giant Bomb's torch once and for all.

Our Old Dating Messages - Based on a conversation from Bonus Pod last week, Ben Hanson and Haley MacLean would read their old, embarassing dating app messages and beyond. Cringe warning. This would also be available in the bonus podcast feed.

Scripted Podcast - The Smash Bros. Movie - You konw what makes a good podcast? A movie! For the next episode of Scripted Podcast, we'd write the script for the perfect version of a Super Smash Bros. movie.

Choose wisely, and may the best show win! Remember you can vote on multiple shows if there are a few you're interested in, and the winner will be back on the poll next week for a potential follow-up episode! Don’t be bummed if your choice doesn’t win the poll, if we hit our New Show Overflow sub goal on Twitch we revive a rejected show for a fun one-off!

We’ll be going live at noon Central on Tuesday, so we’ll see you on Twitch. Feel free to shoot a sub on Twitch our way (you have a free one with Amazon Prime) and you’ll get us one step closer to reviving a rejected idea for New Show Overflow.

https://www.twitch.tv/minnmaxshow

Files

Comments

MassiveScore

Baby Steps Race please and thank you

Volunder

The top 20 tens needs to happen at some point for sure, but my god the dating message cringe was soooo good

September's Wake-up

Baby Steps race but also dating messages next week plz thx

Joebeezer

Oh no! This choice is too hard!

Jesse Eberenz

Putting a baby steps race and reading old dating app messages in the same poll is just cruel!

J.Vaso

Baby steps race where the contestants must rank the top 20 tens while racing and each time they fall someone reads one of their old dating messages

Rosemarythefarmer

Couldn’t bring myself to vote for dating app messages, I respect your parasocial privacy too much. (Just kidding, it’s actually because think the secondhand cringe might kill me lol 💀)

Gabriel Matias

Please, I need more Baby Steps in my life

Leonel Rolando

Two things that define Ben Hanson in my eyes: 1. He uses his real birthday on the internet when asked. 2. He's has owned (or STILL owns) a Coldplay t-shirt that just says COLDPLAY on it.

Jeff D

Just imagining Ben Hanson listening to “Yellow” while texting on Bumble is reason enough to vote against old dating messages.

FierceBrosnan

I want baby steps so bad and voted for it but how can we compete against old dating messages

LawlWorthy

If we get the dating messages from Ben and Haley this week, I would love to hear the opening messages between some of the newly wedded cohorts and their partners next week

TechTurtle

Top 20 tens or defusing giant bomb has my vote

Casey Holloway

love me some cringe. gimme the cringe!!!!

rylander

Wake up people, how is defusing giant bomb not winning????

rogbrte

You can't just stack a single vote like this! You can't! Dating messages!!!

Joebeezer

I hope the two runner-ups show up again

Surells

I'm allergic to second hand embrassment so will have to skip this. Hope the twenty tens shows up again!

Chelsey

Too late to vote this time around but incredibly happy to see dating take the lead. That little glimpse was hilarious last week