Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I asked this question back when I was a student and I've heard other foreigners ask it throughout the years. A lot of time you'll get uncomfortable laughs or 'no reiigion'. I had a university friend who insisted the answer was 'money'. But I do have a favorite answer that I've heard repeated by Japanese friends and family and others. It's kind of a light-hearted joke, but wonderfully self aware, I think. It goes something like this:

When Japanese are born, they're Shinto; when they marry, they're Christian; and when they die they're Buddhist.

日本人は生まれたときは神道、結婚する時はキリスト教、死ぬ時は仏教.

Of course, this isn't absolutely true, but in general you'll find Shinto rituals followed after the birth of a baby. Also things like visits to the shrine to pray for health and good fortune.

Then when it's time to get married, it's pretty popular to have your ceremony at one of the "christian" churches you'll find everywhere. Christian is in quotes because while there are real churches, a lot of the ones that are very lavish, sometimes to the point of gaudy, hire foreign men to dress up in robes and perform the wedding ceremony. The marriage is registered with the city hall, it's legit, only the whole fancy ceremony of it is just for show. I've known quite a few people who have acted as priests or preachers. I hear it's really good money.

Below is a graph (not sure the year) where dark pink shows the percentage of christian-type weddings (61.8%), not-quite-as-dark pink is Shinto (18.8%), light pink is civil ceremonies (17.9%), and that 0.5% is Buddhist weddings (very rare).

So after your wedding, I guess the next big life event is the funeral.

Below we have your percentages of of people opting for Buddhist funerals (88%), orange is Shinto (3%), red is called "friend ceremony" (3%) and it sounds like it's a funeral where you don't use a Buddhist priest and no posthumous name is give (<-- big deal having one of these. I'll blog about this later. It's quite interesting.), yellow is a Christian funeral (1%), blue is No Religion Ceremony (2%), green is something other (1%), and dark blue is No information (3%).

So overwhelmingly Buddhism when it comes to funerals.

However, times are changing, too, and the number of Buddhist funerals are decreasing a little. There might be other reasons, but one I know for sure is that Japanese funerals are the most expensive in the world (over two million yen/25,000 USD) and as much as I love Buddhism, this is seriously messed up. Also, you have to pay yearly fees to keep the ohaka (grave). Some are very much like rental spaces.

I have a good friend who lost their baby and invited me to the memorial ceremony. I (along with everyone else there) was quite surprised by the altar, not the traditional butsudan.

Here's a basic butsudan (two actually). You can get yours for 398,000 yen (64% off!), around 2,600 USD. Lotsa gold leaf.

Instead they had a Soreidan 祖霊団. This is a big one. My friend's was half this size. Lotsa wood.

Soreidans are different that kamidanas (another post!), by the way. Kamidana house certain Shinto spirits/gods, while the soreidan houses the ancestor(s) who have passed away.

Anyway, he told me that that the new "trend" is Shinto funerals. This was some years ago, mind you, but both he and his wife said the reason is they are much cheaper than Buddhist funerals, not as much fuss, and much brighter.

I find it fascinating the interplay between Shinto and Buddhism through the ages and am now on a quest to find more information on the history from the introduction of Buddhism when the merging of religions was encourages (Shinbutsu Shūgō) to the Meiji Restoration when they were forced apart again in 1886 (Shinbutsu Bunri).

Okay, this idea is from some eagle-eyed patrons who noticed the funeral in Shogun had both Shinto and Buddhist elements. Great show!

XO,

t

Files

Comments

Andy McLellan

Oh, that is interesting! Thank you for sharing, Terrie. It is true that Buddhism is not big on marriage, although maybe we should be as we like people to be aware of suffering! (jk, kinda ;-) ). My Zen teacher often says that a lot of Japanese Buddhism now is a funeral business, and since medieval times people have been expected to pay for annual prayers to keep their ancestors out of the hell realms. Quite how that squares with ideas of rebirth I am not totally sure but apparently doctrine shouldn't get in the way of making money :-/ I don't know if that is still the case or maybe the charge for the grave space has taken over.

Uncanny Japan -- Thersa Matsuura

That sounded like a line from a standup comic. Are there Buddhist stand ups? Wow, even your teacher mentioned it. I didn't even mention all the services and prayers at certain anniversaries of their passing. I just thought it was eye rolling that you pay for a rank of monk and length of time. I think this is what Ikkyu and his ilk were rebelling against, right? Although with Ikkyu I do wonder if his calling out the monasteries wasn't an excuse for him to frequent the pleasure districts. Why can't we all just listen to and read and contemplate those great words and try to become better people? Jeesh. I just read somewhere that Japan's brand of Buddhism doesn't adhere so much to rebirth or reincarnation. Surely something got skewed along the line. Hey! If make them think our prayers are keeping their ancestors out of hell, we can keep making chonky paychecks. Hmmm...controlling by fear. That seems to be theme these days. 😒

Andy McLellan

I don't know if there are Buddhist stand-ups but some Buddhist teachers certainly fancy themselves as comedians and sprinkle their talks with humour. It is okay done sparingly but can get a bit much! The big monasteries like Eiheiji and Sojoji seemed to get by fine with donations and support from the laity, and their practice was also good. It was the regional and rural temples that made a living from people paying for funerals and the safety of their ancestors (that's a nice grandparent you had, be a shame if they fell into the hell realms...) and also selling amulets and charms. It is hard to know how much they believed in it and, as we have mentioned before, until the Meiji Restoration Shinto and Buddhism tended to mix pretty liberally which is probably where the ancestor worship comes from, which is not so prevalent in other Buddhist countries to my knowledge. Zen certainly doesn't worry too much about rebirth but I don't know about the other traditions. You would think that Pure Land would, since their main purpose is chanting in order to be reborn in Amitabha's Pure Land, Sukhavati. It was sad in reading about Buddhist traditions and realising that they have been just as bad at, like you say, controlling by fear, as other religions. I gues human beings are human beings and, yes, it is sad we can't just contemplate the teachings and be better people.

Andy McLellan

Oh, also I don't know if you know about the 'Blood Bowl Sutra' which is a hugely misogynistic piece of work in which women are said to be reborn in the blood bowl hell and forced to drink their own menstrual blood as punishment for 'polluting' the earth with the same blood :-| https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_Bowl_Sutra

Daniel Cook

Very insightful. On a tangent, when compared to America, religion in the UK is a sport and sport is a religion