Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Bedtime Story Format Question

  • No music, no sound effects, just the story told, like an audiobook. 2
  • A single music bed that continues from beginning to end, like we used to do at the very beginning. 15
  • Music interspersed with quiet, with the music changing with the mood of the story, like This American Life. 28
  • No music, but some sound effects for atmosphere, like Richard did on "The Hell Carrot" animation on Youtube. 5
  • Music and sound effects used for effect, like Levar Burton Reads. 32
  • 2020-06-26
  • 82 votes
{'title': 'Bedtime Story Format Question', 'choices': [{'text': 'No music, no sound effects, just the story told, like an audiobook.', 'votes': 2}, {'text': 'A single music bed that continues from beginning to end, like we used to do at the very beginning.', 'votes': 15}, {'text': 'Music interspersed with quiet, with the music changing with the mood of the story, like This American Life. ', 'votes': 28}, {'text': 'No music, but some sound effects for atmosphere, like Richard did on "The Hell Carrot" animation on Youtube.', 'votes': 5}, {'text': 'Music and sound effects used for effect, like Levar Burton Reads.', 'votes': 32}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2020, 6, 26, 7, 1, 42, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 82}

Content

Okay. So Richard and I have been studying audio production and different things you can do to make a story more immersive or emotional or just relaxing for that matter.

We've learned that Audible (ACX) doesn't want any background music or sound at all because it distracts from the story. They say some listeners really dislike anything other than the reading. 

Then listening around to different podcasts, we found some use a single music bed straight through the piece, some change up the music with moments of silence. Then, of course, there are sounds effects, something like we did on the "Amabie" and "Cursing your Enemies" episodes.

We've got so much in our heads right now, we aren't sure which is the best way to continue with the Bedtime Stories. Most important, though, is we want to make them the way you want to hear them.  

So if you have a minute or two, could you answer the poll? More than one answer is fine, too. Feel free to comment with any ideas, opinions, advice, anything we haven't thought of. 

Thank you!

terrie

Comments

Andy McLellan

Really, I am happy with whatever you choose to do!

Kimberly Reeves

I really liked the Amabie episode and I'd love more stuff like that!

Craig

Perhaps a different type of audio from the list, depending on the story and the effect contemplated.

Korps

I think with the bed time stories they work better with some sort of music and/or sound effects. Having it just be read as is feels like it might not deliver the same ominous feeling as it would with something else sound wise happening.

Roxanne copeland

I like the music throughout mostly, but if you are doing a more guided meditation like story where we are supposed to feel like we are there the sound effects can help with Immersion. I like that your stories don’t always have the same quality.

steve townsend

I voted for a single music bed because I used to like them when they were like that but really I think you should do what suits the story.

Adam Dobay

I understand where Audible is coming from, but what you're doing is not audiobooks. And your main audience isn't people who listen to audiobooks, but people who listen to podcasts. And those who listen to high-end podcasts like TAL or Gimlet stuff are used to more complex audio design. (I personally can't stand it when there's one looping music bed for an entire chapter of an audiobook, it absolutely ruins immersion for me. One reason I don't really listen to audiobooks!) Of course there are tradeoffs in post-production time. More than one music bed requires more music curation and more editing, and the same goes for sound effects. What I would do is experiment with the format while looking at your time spend for each type of production. If you spend 50% more work time on one type of production and that makes things only marginally better, then scale back. You want to find a good pace for produciton, and don't want to burn out in the long run. Hope this helps! :)

Uncanny Japan -- Thersa Matsuura

Adam! I just now saw your reply. Thank you, very good advice. Richard does almost all of the audio design with my input. We listen to all kinds of podcasts and audio dramas and constantly taking notes, comparing what we think works and doesn't. It's all very fascinating. He's getting faster, but definitely spends hours upon hours fiddling with the audio. Right now, not working, gives us the time, and it's enjoyable. But you're very right about burnout. Thank you again for your thoughts. ^^d