Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Enjoy The Sopranos 6x21 group reaction and uncut!!

Uncut: https://thenormies.com/the-sopranos-pa/

Edited reaction is in the thumbnail aboe!!

Files

THE SERIES FINALE! | The Sopranos - 6x21 Made in America | Group Reaction

Suraj, Navi, Chris and Pat present their review and reaction to season 6 episode 21 of The Sopranos, "Made in America" created by David Chase. In this episode, Tony (James Gandolfini) makes his final move against Phil Leotardo (Frank Vincent) with the help of the FBI, while AJ (Robert Iler) decides what he wants to do with his future. BECOME A Normies Premium or No Fomo MEMBER: Get 6 WEEKS AHEAD on most shows (excluding premier shows), exclusive movies and vote on what we watch: https://www.thenormies.com/ Pick up your Coffee here: "TheNormies" 10% OFF https://www.coincoffee.life/ TokyoTreat: “THENORMIES” to receive $5 off for your first #TokyoTreat box https://team.tokyotreat.com/TheNormies SEND US LETTERS/GIFTS: PO Box 785 Fishers, IN 46038 FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA: linktr.ee/the_normies

Comments

Braavosi

...and on goes this thing of ours

SunnydaleClassof99

#SundayRundown Hated the ending the first time I saw it when it originally aired. I've come around to it in the intervening years. There's several thousand takes on what does happen. They all probably have their own validity & can be backed up by argument, I think that actually makes it a great ending. IMO nothing happens in the diner. Even if he doesn't get hit Tony is going to continue to be miserable. There'll be small fleeting moments of joy like chowing down on some onion rings, that's the most he can expect though. Ultimately because he's in the life there will be a bad ending for him but like the song says the movie won't end, it'll just keep going on & on.

Potsi

Cant believe its over

Telly Phillips Jr

#Sunday rundown, Who do you guys think carried out the hit?

Paul T Hewes

-Agent Harris was boning a different agent or law enforcement agency person to get info and then he immediately passed it onto Tony. Dude had game. -Phil got what he had coming. He was a mess and a dangerous man to have as a boss of a family the size of NY.

Jeffrey W

Paulie totally had Tony killed. When Christopher is shot in season 2 and dies he has a vision of hell. He talks to other mobsters and they tell him to tell Tony and Paulie “3 o’clock” The guy in the Members Only jacket goes to the bathroom to grab a gun just like in Godfather and shoots Tony at his 3 o’clock The cat was looking at Paulie cause it knows he’s a rat

Alexander Sawasdee

And also Patsy who has legitimate beef with Tony for whacking his twin, not to mention the whole uncomfortable scene at Tony’s house in this ep. I think they both most likely went to Butchie to set up the hit as the offer of going to NY was much more attractive than working with a soon-to-be indicted Tony.

Paul T Hewes

Agreed. While I think the end was literally the END of Tony, i loved that it was left up to your own imagination

Jftb 9673

49:24 My Dad watched it week to week, if you were a fly on his wall you would have seen him get up, pound his fist on the cable box, then call the cable company to curse at them, and finally (like many people) cancelled his HBO subscription in protest of how the show ended. It took him years to get over it lol

Jarrod Wild

#SundayRundown What makes the most sense to me is that, while Butch was sincerely okay with them taking Phil out, I think he changed his mind due to HOW Phil was taken out. He was murdered in a public place, with witnesses from a variety of demographics to spread the word, in front of his family, and his head was crushed, really embarrassing and memorable way to go. So New York went for revenge, kill Tony in a public place in front of his family with a lot of witnesses. The last thing Meadow sees as she enters the restaurant is her father being gunned down in front of Carmela and AJ. The guy in the Members Only jacket reminds me of Eugene, and maybe was a family member who maybe blamed Tony for Eugene taking his own life and was motivated to help New York. There are a number of directing and editing choices in this final episode that remind me a lot of Kubrick, especially the end of 2001.

TJ

Georgie

Michael Colorado

How I figured it happened: Tony and his family are sitting together at the booth in Holsten’s. The man in the Members Only jacket exits the restroom, casually drops cash at the counter to cover his check, and walks behind Tony’s table. Before anyone can react, he steps up right beside Tony’s blind spot and fires three shots point-blank into the side of his head. Blood splatters across the table. Meadow lets out a piercing scream. Driven by pure adrenaline, AJ lunges out of the booth and tackles the gunman to the floor. In the chaotic struggle, the shooter fires again, hitting AJ. Both of them bleed out on the diner floor.

SunnydaleClassof99

Loved these reactions & revisiting the show. It might be the greatest rewarchable drama. For every dark or intense moment there's 5 absolutely hysterical lines or scenes. Not to mention the incredibly layered storytelling that gives the viewer so much to interpret themselves.

TCW

Sopranos is the reason for good TV but everything like it that proceeded it is better 🤷🏾‍♂️

Stan the Man

They clearly do not remember Paulie seeing the Virgin Mary.

NICK Luna

As Tony said, "I guess you never hear it coming when it's your turn."

Stan the Man

**Long Comment Warning** Ok. So watching the opening montage to season 6 again? That could be fun. Wink wink.. Think of all the fates of the characters. It lays it out. Right there. Meadow is the Guardian Angel “he she or it, is third man out”. Think back to the coma, whose voice calls to Tony? Meadow? And who would have been there to sit beside Tony, blocking a clear shot? Meadow. My opinion? Meadow probably just found out she was pregnant. She just came from the doctor. It was about birth control. She was flustered parking, runs like mad towards the diner, all to tell her daddy the news he wanted most in the world(he says as much). Tony is going to be a grandpa. But instead of getting to tell her dad the best news of her life, she watches her dad get his head blown in. There’s so many layers to the ending, yall don’t even know. The ending is a literal ice berg where most of it is hidden. I love they chose a song with the lyric “Working to get my fill” or in the shows context “Working hard to get my PHIL”. So the episode draws numerous connections between Tony and Phil. First of all, the music. Tony and Phil are both listening to the same song in the episode (Vanillas Fudges “Keep me hanging on”). Both Tony and Phil had near death experiences last season where they ended up in hospital. During Phil’s ceremony of becoming boss Nancy Sinatra says, out of nowhere, “You two going home together?”( When Tony is in his coma and Steve Buscemi is at that house trying to get Tony to enter the house he says “You’re going home”). Phil doesn’t see his death coming either. And he’s murdered in front of two kids and his wife. Just like Tony. Also, I love the hard on the show has for hating on SUVs. Tony and Adriana get into an accident, then Tony and Chris, AJ has his SUV blown up, Phil has his head crushed by an SUV. The best deep dive into the end and the final season is in a blog written in 2008. Whoever wrote the blog was the first person to “unlock” the ending & the final season as a whole. It goes deep. And time has only proven it right as the shows creator has confirmed almost all of it over the years. The blog is called “Master of the Sopranos, The Definitive Explanation”. It’s all there. All of it. What the coma dream was about, what the opening montage is about, the PoV and editing patterns of the final scene and how we are set up to see Tony’s POV when we see black. The shows creator, David Chase, has been extremely cagey about the ending. He’s all but confirmed Tony dies. Some fans just refuse to go there because we don’t see it happen on screen. But Tony is dead. Personally I think it’s the greatest ending in television history. When you see and understand the thought that went into it? I think the ending works on so many levels. The meta level is almost cruel in that people thought their cable/satelite went out and David Chase KNEW that would be their reaction. That’s what I thought at the time. It’s almost a prank when you think about it. The ending is one of the great artistic statements of our time. It works narratively. It works thematically. It works on a meta level. The sopranos was infamous for how unconventional it was. How no one could guess where the show was going plot wise. So here’s the finale. Everyone is wondering, what will happen to Tony. Will he die? Get arrested? Flip to the fbi. Will the Russian from the woods come back? Or the middle eastern guys? All of that is floating around. So how do you end one of the most groundbreaking shows of all time? How do you make it so the show is talked about and debated for decades after? You deny the audience its need for closure & certainty. The show even name checks Schrödinger’s equation earlier in season 6. And if you know your Schrödinger you know he was famous for a thought experiment using what animal? A cat. See what I mean? How deep it goes. Here’s an ending no one could guess. Where all options are valid. Until you begin to dig. Speaking of which. What is the first image we see of Tony Soprano in season 6? He’s digging. His own grave perhaps?

Aaron

In the first episode of this season when the narrator is speaking over scenes, he mentions a guardian angel when Meadow is on screen. Multiple times Meadow has come across as a guardian angel for Tony. Season 1 when the ex mobster didn't shoot Tony because he saw Meadow. Tony going towards Meadows voice in the hospital instead of towards the light. In this episode Meadow was probably the last thing Tony saw but if she was there a minute earlier she would have been sitting next to Tony and would have blocked the shooter. If he was the guy in the members only jacket that came out of the washroom. I'm sure he still could have and would have shot him but if fun to theorize.

KMun79

Sad to reach the end of this great show. Sopranos and Battlestar Galactica have been peak normies reactions. I know people still argue about Tony's fate at the end, but rewatching the series makes it obvious he died as clues are sprinkled throughout the series. One minor thing I just noticed on this watch is the fact that Meadow never made it into the restaurant. Meadow has sometimes played a guardian angel role for Tony previously and even brought him out of his coma and back to life after he was shot. She wasn't there this time.

Dante Sparda

I just want to thank you guys for reacting to the Sopranos, I joined your patreon when you guys started and now to see you guys reach the end fills me with the same melancholy feeling I had when I finished this show for the first time, so again thank you for that feeling again. But to my last fact about the Sopranos. David Chase has only directed two episodes in the entire show. The Pilot and Series Finale big respect to Chase for starting and finishing this masterclass of a show

Stan the Man

FYI: The Wire came out in 2002. The Sopranos came out in 1999. Sopranos put HBO on the map for original drama shows and literally changed TV forever. Before Sopranos? TV drama was lawyers, doctors, and cops. You’d occasionally have a show like Twin Peaks try something different but it would be very temporary. Sopranos was that rare thing, a phenomenon from the get go. It was like an instant hit. Prior to Sopranos HBO had Oz and some comedy shows but none of them were hits. The sopranos had a couple phases. There was the first 3 season where everyone loving it. Then post 9/11 the show changes big time. No more Tony going to his kids events like soccer, volleyball, football. It’s not as fun hanging out with extremely petty, narcissistic sociopaths. To give you an idea of how groundbreaking this show was, people watch an episode like “College”(season 1 episode 5) where Tony is taking a trip with meadow visiting colleges when he spots a rat he knows and kills him, people watch that episode today and just accept it like it ain’t no thang. They don’t blink. Well back in 1999? That moment was so earth shattering HBO almost didn’t let it happen. I’ll say that again. * HBO* almost didn’t let Tony Sopranos kill a guy. Why? Lead characters didn’t kill people in cold blood back then. It didn’t happen. Ever. Now? Every main character is committing murder left and right. But back in 1999? It’s like going from black and white TV to color. That’s how major it was. Now we have shows like Dexter where all the main character does is kill. But David Chase, the creator and showrunner, had to fight HBO over it. In fact he only ever had two arguments with HBO over content on the show. 1 was Tony killing the rat. Which is crazy to think about.

Stan the Man

“You know who had an Ark? Noah” The show was telling us since season 1

Stan the Man

Oh shout out to the waddling “OH SHIT” extra when Phil is killed. Dude is the GOAT of the show. I love earlier this season Phil says he doesn’t wanna get a bike in case he gets “head trauma”.

Shihi

#SundayRundown I always remember the final shot of Paulie being alone outside of Satriale's. Remember that season finale where everyone was joking around and hanging around outside of there? The agents come out and introduce Tony to a new partner, the lights are bright and colorful, and there's just this lighthearted feeling this'll go on forever. There was still some joy to be found. Now? Paulie's alone, the warmth and color is washed out, and the people he once called friends have all left him. It legit feels like an end to the Mobster way of life, and in a way the show seems to almost spell it out. There's no next generation, everyone's eating each other alive, and the world seems to be moving on from them. What a brilliant ending.

BindingofNack

23:30 Ya it be like that brother brother

PIG

I'm going to miss watching The Sopranos with The Normies and Blindwave. Thank you guys. I'm glad you love it as much as we all do.

Veya

the wind is a motif in the final season. was stated in the comments and some of the past episodes had featured it prominently. this show is worth a rewatch, especially outside of a reaction setting, so the full scope of the themes and a large number of intricate interpersonal and relational connections become clearer. remember the show opened with a monologue about broader america, before narrowing its focus on the family. it's not too dissimilar to the godfather in this way. also recommend reading analysis and reviews of the show to see how much is actually packed into it that a lot of people miss on a first watch. and you guys hit the nail on the head that, yes, you can point to more reasons for why tony dies than he lives, which is more fitting considering what he does for a living. but it really doesn't matter, because the show also gave an out in terms of tony still getting consequences if he doesn't die right then and there. he's likely going to prison. he's going to continue being miserable if he stays in the mob. he might end up like junior. he has not gotten over his mother issues and has become more like livia. it really doesn't matter that much what the immediate aftermath of the diner scene is. he and his organization was heading in a downward spiral the entire time.

Veya

while i agree with pretty much everything you said, and the general critics consensus is pretty much aligned as well, in regards to the artistic achievement and significance of the ending, the dogmatic statement of "some fans refuse to accept it" is still not convincing. people should read the av club review of the episode, it summarizes a lot about the issues of the dogmatic view of the ending and most people who repeat the narrative "that david chase confirms it" don't seem to actually consume as much behind the scenes stuff as some of critics who have interviewed him, or even take into account what some of the other writers on the show have to say about the ending. even if david chase privately views it as tony dies, he is deliberately being cagey about it because it doesn't have to be dogmatic or only up to his particular view. he has admitted other things that people have guessed correctly about the show, so he pretty clearly wants the ending to not be so one note and simply a puzzle to solve that provides a clean answer. the masters of sopranos essay is not infallible even if comprehensive. you could apply a number of different interpretation to some of the arguments, some of which can be pretty loaded with pretty heavy confirmation bias, and to the final pov cut, considering the scene primarily jumped between tony and meadow's viewpoint, so it could be the audience's pov being cut off as well, to list an example. on that note, even if it's likely tony dies, which i lean towards as well, at the end of the day, the artistic power of the ending is that it isn't dogmatic and it aligns with the type of ambiguity that the show has engaged with since the beginning of its run. there's a reason why the show gave us a number of other ways that tony "dies" besides a physical death. he's almost spiritually dead. he can't even remember what he said about "remember the good times", which also comes after his scene with junior. he still hasn't gotten over his mother issues. he isn't likely getting out of the mob which we know makes him miserable. the final scene specifically includes the fact that carlos is testifying against him so he's legally screwed even if he doesn't die at that moment. the technical aspects of the ending should reinforce that tony probably dies at the end because the actual plot reasons for him dying are pretty weak. why is butchie killing a known variable and letting...paulie or patsy take over where they'll likely provide less money given the level of competency the show portrayed them as having. people are so desperate for theories that they're saying paulie killed tony. the same paulie we have seen all series, fucking things up, who also in this very episode expressed a desire to not increase his workload until reluctantly accepting the captain position. the plot reasons are so weak that we pretty much need a lot of the foreshadowing to actually create a sense of dread.

James Finelli

lol, right? Weird cause they all pretty much jumped and were freaked out when it happened

James Finelli

People were legit calling other people like did your shit go out? Lol

Javi

While everyone usually focuses on the meaning of the ending the scene that always gets me is Tony's last meeting with Junior, he ignored him in his later years of life just to end up regretting not being able to have a real conversation with him in seemingly his last days on Earth. Just gut wrenching how Tony says "this thing of ours" and Junior doesn't even believe it 😭

Frank from Vegas

I remember watching the ending with my folks. My dad loves the show. That ending happened and he actually sat through the entire next show that was premiering behind it because he though there might be a hit (that show was John from Cincinnati, David Milch's follow up to Deadwood. Better in idea than execution. The acting was great, but the story was basically California surfers, but everyone talks like they're in Deadwood. Also there's a character that's basically Jesus). As for the show, I never believed Tony died. He already made peace with New York and this isn't the type of universe where Phil hires a hitman who keeps his word and would still do the job after Phil gets killed on principle. I can see an argument where Patsy organized it, but it would be a situation where he does it on his own and sets up New York to take the blame, not as an organized thing. Paulie also just doesn't have the ambition to go for it. The legit panic when he gets offered the Capo spot sold that for me. Most likely, he gets arrested, Carlo testifies against, and he has to cooperate and admit to his crimes while his family finally hears the reality of what he did. David Chase just didn't want to do that and decided to go with something more ambiguous. All the other theories require too much headcanon for me to buy in. Overall, the ending works for me. I don't love it, but I also don't hate or feel indifferent to it. It's great, but I feel it could have been greater. On a related topic, I would love to see how you guys react to The Shield. I rewatched it recently, and it's still an amazing show, even looking at it with a different view on city policing than we did when it first came out. It also had the same issue that The Sopranos had (vague spoilers): a charismatic antihero lead that the audience roots for despite him doing objectively terrible things throughout the series. The big difference is that David Chase would famously get annoyed with his fanbase for rooting for Tony, while Shawn Ryan (The Shield creator) was confused, but nonjudgmental about it. And that show's ending is why I can never bring myself to fully love the Sopranos' ending. Also, since Navi asked: The actor you saw was Martin Sheen (Apocalypse Now, The Departed) and he was nominated for The West Wing (another interesting idea for the future).

Veya

they don't remember a good chunk of the show, even compared to some of the other reaction channels that has covered this show. i suspect because they're reacting to too many different things and have a very busy schedule, because it happens with some of the other shows as well. this is why i suggest a rewatch where they're not concerned about the reaction, to actually catch everything. and also, to read some analysis and breakdowns of episodes. there are running themes and subtext that i don't think i've heard mentioned in a single discussion that has been picked up by a number of reviewers and critics.

Veya

the sopranos was the second hour long drama on hbo, after oz. which meant they were among earliest hour long scripted dramas in general. they were exceedingly rare prior, because a lot of cable channels relied on syndicated reruns and low budget films. the wire and deadwood (and too many other shows to count) basically would not have been able to air without the sopranos show opening up the tv landscape. it's also the first non network tv show to get attention from major awards that were previously dominated by mainstream network shows. this show often ranks number one on critics and publication lists. populist sites and ratings tend to lean more towards shows like breaking bad or occasionally the wire but this show remains a more tvphile show (you can look into how many people in the industry regard it highly) because it sits at the center of the venn diagram of innovation and quality tv. other prestige dramas aren't nearly as influential, and while there are other previous very innovative and groundbreaking shows, they're generally much older and were far more constrained by the networks and so aren't really comparable to modern prestige tv. this is the show that bridged the gap between older tv (which wasn't as respected as an artform) and cinema. cinema was already highly regarded as a much older and developed medium but tv back then were largely structured around ad time. networks were largely concerned with broad appeal and safe writing because they wanted as many people sticking around for the ads. there were still some gems in spite of that, but there's a reason why there's basically a pre and post sopranos era of television. hbo obviously wasn't beholden to ads in the same way and was behind a paid subscription so it had to develop its name on quality programming, and this was the first show that brought widespread prestige to the hbo brand. as mentioned in the discussion, the innovation and influence extends to the characters and not just the structure and writing style. the reason tony soprano has the legacy he does is because outside of him influencing so many other future tv characters, he still remains one of, if not the most, complex and developed character. so much of his life and viewpoints are fleshed out, to the degree that he feels more like a novel character than a traditional television character. the marriage between him and carmela is also one of the most developed and even in the first episode you got a long sense of history between them that felt very natural. most of the villains and minor characters had very memorable and quotable lines. if you remember some of those lines, you're likely going to come across them online.

Stan the Man

I’ve read everything Chase has publicly said about the ending. Im pathetic like that. Starting with his interview with Alan Sepinwall in the Star Ledger, to his comments to the TCA, his interview with VOX where the interviewer claimed Chase said Tony did not die(which Chase released a statement thru his PR rep denying he said that). But it wasn’t until Chase did an interview with the DGA, directors guild, where he goes into the ending shot by shot and confirms EXACTLY what Master of Sopranos laid out. The bell, the editing, the POV. Christ, Master of Soprano even got the “2001 A Space Odyssey” influence. Up until then I use to say some fans who say “Tony lives” have a leg to stand on. But when I read that interview? And successive interviews? in the book “Sopranos sessions” Chase said when he picked Holstens as the final scene he said “Yeah Tony could get it in a place like that”. He said his original intention was always a cut to black, and when referred to his original idea of a cut to black as a “death scene”. He ended up changing it to a diner. Tony Soprano died that night. That is the ending. You can accept that or not. If you want to believe something else? Go ahead. That’s not the intent of the maker but go ahead. I’ve read the AV Club reviews. And she(the writer now identifies as female) falls into the same trap many do regarding the master of sopranos essay. The essay was split into sections. People who discount it look at the sections written “for fun” with the same seriousness as the section about what happens to Tony at the end. So people who discount it say “oh well how do you know the cat represents Adrianna, that’s a huge leap” as if that’s the same as methodically laying out shot by shot why the cut to black=death. No. The writer makes it clear which parts are “maybe important, maybe what Chase was saying” vs “here’s what’s intended”. People who group it all together do it a disservice and it’s intellectually dishonest. Matt Zoller Seitz falls into that same trap. That being said? I do think the ending is up to interpretation, this is art after all. Just because the creator had a certain idea in mind doesn’t mean everyone must agree. But if you want to say, what was the intention of the writer of show? It was to create a sense of dread and anguish in people. But like Chase said in his first interview after it aired: “anyone who wants to look, it’s all there. It’s in that episode and the episode prior to that”. Then Chase references the Jerry Torciano hit. That was in his first interview after the show aired. “It’s all there”. That means there is something to be discovered. And what do we find out over the years? Despite Chase saying there are no esoteric clues, no “Da Vinci code”, he goes into detail about how he edited the final scene. Chase is a contrarian. I don’t think he likes being interpreted correctly. Even when he gives answers he’s weird about it. In the book “Sopranos Sessions” Chase is asked if Ralphie killed Pie Oh My. First he says no he didn’t kill the horse. Or have it killed. Then he says “Wait. What did I tell Joey Pants(the actor)”. Then he goes on to admit Ralphie did kill Pie oh My and mentions the references put in to lead people to that answer but no one ever picked up on them. Those references are devil symbolism. First he mentions how they had him saying lyrics from the song “Sympathy for the devil” but the real discovery was the goat. Pie oh my had a goat friend. And Chase mentions how no one got how this was devil symbolism. (Back in season 2 Paulie mentions goats and goat buds/horns as related to the devil). Also. In the documentary “Wise Guy” Chase says the conversation between AJ and Meadow where AJ says “Black means death” was on his mind. But yeah. I’m obsessive about this shit. There isn’t an interview, podcast or book about this show I haven’t read. That sounds like a “know it all” boast but it’s actually kinda sad lol. Sometimes I think the guy who wrote the “Master of Sopranos” essay may have worked on the show. Chase himself said he read part of it. But there’s just too much that essay got right. Like the bell in the diner being a call back to the bell on the boat dock in Soprano Home Movies, that it’s a reference to Buddhism.

Adam Vialpando

I always like to compare this ending to the ending of season 1. That's when Tony told his family the thing about remembering the times that were good. And Tony doesn't even remember saying it. I love how despite everything seeming to be going well in terms of how many stories like this usually go, you can feel the unease underneath it all. Very few of them are actually happy. And the ones that are happy have hints of other things going on. Like the fact it feels like Meadow is on her way to becoming a criminal lawyer, and I mean CRIMINAL lawyer. Even if Tony wasn't killed, he and his family are pretty screwed in so many different ways. You guys were perceptive by catching the fact the show already showed what it would be like with Tony dead. Another detail you may not have picked up on is that it also has examples of all the ways it could have ended up for Tony. Like Going to prison (Johnny Sack), getting whacked (Phil), or giving up the power and getting out (Little Carmine).

Stan the Man

Also. I said “some fans refuse to go there” which is different from “some fans refuse to accept it”.

Dan R

Probably been mentioned, but I would love to see you react to the David Chase Wiseguy documentary. No reactors have done it yet as far as I can tell

Veya

"That’s not the intent of the maker but go ahead. " my guy, this was my entire point: you can't say that is the definitive intent of the maker when he has so adamantly and repeatedly walked back any attempt to narrow it down to just that single reading. it's also completely contradictory to say "tony dies, that is the ending" and "the ending is up to interpretation". it's either up to interpretation or it's not. with the cut to black and the fact that he again, repeatedly refuses to endorse a single reading, it's up to interpretation. i have even said previously, in different words, that he's basically engaging with "death of the author" as we can fully accept that even if he views it as a death scene, his *intent* is clearly not to have that as the only reading. and i agree btw, that he is wishy-washy. but it doesn't seem to just be out of a need to be a contrarian. even if he can be, it does not mean it's always the case. you mentioned that part about ralphie and the goat in the sopranos session. i read that portion and it does not seem to come across the way you've framed it, as if he changes his tune only because he doesn't want to be caught. in that same interview, he had no issues conceding that he drew a line between the stripper and the horse when it was first brought up by alan. it came across more as, he forgot the details behind his process (and he's forgotten a lot about the show), and then remembered what it was and then expanded on it when matt and alan started asking more questions. it's very clear, from almost all of his interviews, that he values certain themes and vibes surrounding the final scene more than the specific mechanics. why? perhaps because he doesn't want a binary answer for it. regarding the av club, you're saying the av club author fell into a common trap regarding the essay, but you're stating things she never says in the article. she makes no mention of sections in the essay that divided between a for fun and a more serious section. if you read the review, she laid out her general irritation with narrowing down the thematic scope and mystery of the show to one thing, and how it is incongruent with how david chase has handled stuff with ambiguity in the past. i'm going to assume with things like the russian or what exactly tony meant when he's shouting "i get it" while watching the sunrise. she also just makes a very compelling point about the show always being filled with death imagery simply because of the world these characters operate in. and in regards to the dga interview and the masters of sopranos making the same connection regarding the editing. well yes, the make the same connection because it's there in the show. it's like stating two people point out the same special effects, or expressions that actors make on the show. the sequence of the editing is the sequence of the editing, how it's cut is not really disputable. but that's the editing, the interpretation still doesn't just get reduced to one reading, especially when again, his intent can be different than how he personally views the ending. everything about the hints and foreshadowing just leans towards that tony does likely die. but that's it, at the end of the day, there is still that wiggle room. the song he picked is "don't stop believin". he could have picked any other song. the normies have tapped into this as well. we're acknowledging that it's lop-sided, but lop-sided means there is room to go the other way. again, it aligns with how david chase has approach some of the other things in the show.

LucasHolliday

Remember, it's all just a big nothing. What is? Life. That's what Livia said to AJ in the hospital in season 2, and what Tony says to Carmela in bed in the season 2 finale. So, whether or not the Members Only jacket wearing barsitter comes out of the restroom and hits Tony's 3 o'clock with a head shot before Don't Stop Believing is over, the fact is it doesn't actually matter. Both are true: if Ton lives, he lives in hollow emptiness like a golem (he was called that in season 1) and eventual loneliness, likely in prison, or inevitable oblivion just like his dementia ridden Uncle Jun. If he is dead, then it was telegraphed from the beginning. During his first conversation with Melfi, he states "lately I've been feeling like I came in at the end". He's referring to the golden age of La Cosa Nostra, but maybe he doesn't realize that he's saying he is on his last leg in this world, he is nearing the end of his life. Most of the show deals with his near epiphanies about spiritual awakening and soul deep change, intermingled with his utter disregard for life and self centered path of dominance and destruction. And despite his fleeting moments of insight, he waves off others around him as superstitious and remains objectively blind to the bigger picture, shrugging off or making fun of Paulie's fear of the supernatural, or laughing at Chrissy's "dream" of Hell where he was told to tell Ton and Paulie "3 o'clock", i.e. Tony's right side directly facing Holsten's restroom. If you want more clues pointing to his death, the season begins with that William S Burroughs voiceover about the Kemetic Book of the Dead, the seven souls that leave the body at the moment of death. Funny enough, there are around seven significant deaths of members in the Soprano Family and in the New York Family throughout season 6. Raymond Curto, Eugene Pontecorvo, Vito Spatafore, Christopher Moltisanti, Bobby Baccalieri, plus John Sacrimoni, and Phil Leotardo. Remember, that random guy's jacket said Members Only.... So seven souls, and that leads to ultimate death, in this case, the death of the first person whose perspective we view in the pilot, Tony. But even if you focus only on the Soprano Fam, you have Ray, Gene, Vito, Chris, Bobby, and also Burt Gervasi, Carlo's cousin that Sil strangles in his own home. Tony would make the seventh since Sil isn't actually dead. Speaking of perspective, the last scene of the series is filmed largely from the viewpoint and perspective of Tony, except for the Meadow parking cuts, and then right when the doorbell rings and Mead seemingly gets there, Tony looks up for the screen to go black....every other time he looks up, through his eyes we see someone enter the restaurant. Other hints would be the beginning of the episode, where Tony is seen lying in bed, completely still, eyes closed, on a pillow that looks like it could be in a coffin, as organ music plays in the background. Intentional imagery. Also the pilot shows him in bed in the transition to the second scene, still and staring up into nothing. Someone once made a good point about the Egyptian reference specifically about Ba the heart, often treacherous, in death, the human soul goes to confront Anubis and the scales of Ma'at, the soul's heart is placed on one scale and the feather of truth on the other. If the heart is heavier than the feather, it's weighed down by misdeeds and sin, and it will be fed to Ammit, a crocodile headed deity of judgment and death, and the soul will fade into nothingness. All a big nothing that Livia and Tony mentioned a few times? The ultimate punishment in the Egyptian belief system was the threat of non-existence.

Stan the Man

My point about Chase regarding the Ralphie section was that his first inclination is to say NO. And I honestly think he ultimately fessed up because no one had correctly interpreted the goat devil symbolism. So for the DGA interview… you are being incredibly obtuse here. You say “oh well of course he got the 2001 A Space Odyssey Influence, it’s right there in the milieu” but you are only saying that BECAUSE HE WAS RIGHT lol. Thats easy to hand wave away when it’s been confirmed. But the bell and the editing pattern mixed with that? Come on. The AV Club reviews didn’t just refer to Master of Soprano once. It came up numerous times in the “speaking with the fishes” section. And she would constantly do the “oh MOS makes a compelling case for this” but then later discounts it entirely for the other stuff. I could be wrong but it might be in the review where she talks about how she thinks the MOS may have pitched the essay as an article to a few outlets. I don’t want to go thru each essay. I might be confusing her with Matt Zoller Seitz here but one or both of them take issue with the “title” of the essay. That the writer called himself “Master of Sopramos” and says it’s “the definitive explanation”. I mean come on. He wrote a title meant as an attention grabber and you’re going to knock the guy for that? But anyways, you ignore so much that Chase has said. Like he clearly gets caught calling it a “death scene” in the book, then walks it back because it’s not the exact same scenario. The original idea was ALWAYS a cut to black. But because Chase doesn’t want to say it, he does some weak “oh well, it changed”. But to me the response after he’s called on it is everything. “fuck you guys”. He doesn’t even realize he’s done it until they repeat it back to him. So if Chase had ended it his original way, again, same cut to black but different circumstances, you don’t think the exact same arguments would be going on? “Did Tony die?” And do you really think Chase would be any less cagey? You take all of this, “black means death” was on his mind. “2001 a Space Odyssey” was an inspiration(which shows the death and rebirth of Dave). He has called it a death scene. Said “Yeah Tony could get it in a place like that”. Said “it’s all there for anyone who wants to watch” makes a call back to “Maybe you don’t hear it” and the Jerry Torciano hit. Then Chase confirms that he was doing a POV editing. Then you releases a PR statement when a writer says “Tony didn’t die”. He’s done how many interviews before and since. The only time he’s released a statement afterwards was when someone claimed he said Tony lives. He also said he wanted the audience to feel like something was being ripped away from them, and that the ending makes him sad, not because it’s the final scene of the show he created or he misses the cast, but because of what’s happening on screen. It makes him sad. Now. You take all that. It Paints a pretty clear picture doesn’t it? Yes Chase has said other things. Like “it doesmt matter” or “it’s pointless to look for an answer” But they are never as specific. It’s always more mealy mouthed. He has contradicted himself so many times. So again. People can interpret the ending any way they like. It’s art. But in Chases mind? Tony died. There is no doubt. But I did not say “some fans refuse to accept it” I said “some fans won’t go there”. Refusing to accept it means denial. Refusing to go there means they have their own idea of what happened and are just fine with that.