Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

January Movie Poll #2

  • Lord of the rings fellowship of the ring 128
  • Fight Club 132
  • 2026-01-12
  • —2026-01-14
  • 260 votes
{'title': 'January Movie Poll #2', 'choices': [{'text': 'Lord of the rings fellowship of the ring', 'votes': 128}, {'text': 'Fight Club', 'votes': 132}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 1, 14, 20, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 1, 12, 21, 21, 7, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 260}

Content

With the poll yesterday showing that over 80% of you think we should NOT include movies Tom has seen before, this will be the final poll for the January movie. Tom has seen the Truman Show before so the poll will be between Lord of the rings fellowship of the ring and Fight Club. Vote for your favorite!!

Comments

Scrumpo

Fellowship is so peak 🙌

DanLand Saga

Im guessing he has already seen Truman show cause it won the poll lol Fight club lets gooooooo!!!

Hyperion

make sure its the directors cut!

Elliot

Everyone has to see Lord of the Rings at least once in their life.

Elliot

I can 100% confirm Tom has seen it. I wont tell you how I know.

griffin(aruto) cofell

I don’t think LOTR fits the mental breakdown super well BUT over fight club? Easiest vote of my life, 🧙‍♂️

Dan

37 hours of my life I'll never get back, but to each his own. I like fantasy as a genre, but I prefer clever characters and good writing. Following bumbling kids who constantly make foolish mistakes is not my idea of a good time. It's why I got a vasectomy.

Charles Brackett

If you read what was posted that would confirm your suspicion

Jordan Habberfield

EXTENDED EDITION PLS. Those scenes are perfect for the character building and all the stuff tom would like

Jake

LOTR without a doubt. Its a masterpiece. Fight club is a classic, but it doesn't come close to LOTR

Snow

Tyler Durden

Kev-la-kill

I'm having trouble picking one, lol, but it has to be Fellowship. Just make sure it's the extended cut.

Ana Saldana

lol goes to show that a lot of people don’t read things completely through.

DanLand Saga

I think thats the point of "im not reading all that" but okay

Amanda

Both? lol! But LOTR first for sure!

####

oh dear, looks like fight club is pulling ahead, LOTR is my fav but for mental health fight club is probably the bigger one to dissect

Jesse James

This will be very close I reckon. Both movies have massive fanbases. I've never watched LOTR all the way through so I'm not sure what mental health there is in it.

Alfred Höttl

it's 50-50 right now, and even though I voted for LOTR, I hope it stays tied. As others have said, the extended edition is absolutely the best route; it's not just fluff like a lot of other movies have in their extended versions, the extra bits in it truly adds value.

Harley

Both please?! if LOTR Fellowship wins, please do the directors cut, and all three movies :D It'll be a long haul but so worth it. Very surprised you haven't already seen it.

Nick

I mean i love Fight Club and would vore for it, but you haven't seen LOTR before!?

thugger

FIGHT CLUB

Reaction Therapy

What are yall doing to me with this vote!!! ITS SO CLOSE!!!👀

Demceez

fight club, easiest decision of my life. I liked lord of the rings when I was a child, tried watching it again a few years ago as an adult.. too long, got bored

Jesse James

Both movies have massive fanbases, personally I'd go Fight Club. I've never been able to watch through a single LOTR movie.

Pekki Taari

Fight club just fits better for therapist reaction. Let’s vote for the other movie later.

Crazy Ralph

I recommend the film Ordinary People if Tom hasn't seen it.

izjah

Fight club

Johnny Garcia

Valentines day (February) movie: “People We Meet on Vacation”

Cyrill_JJK

I've never been so disappointed in this community. Are we fr putting Fight Club in the same league as LORD OF THE RINGS?

trans ben shaprio

Yes, Fight Club is literally about mental health, LOTR, as amazing as a series (i'm a big fantasy fan), there's nothing to get from a therapist's reaction compared to a film like Fight Club.

Cyrill_JJK

at this point i'm just here for Tom's reaction, not therapy Tom. Because remember its not real therapy, it's just Tom breakin down Insert Title

griffin(aruto) cofell

I think fight club might literally be THE most overrated film of all time, and typically the folks who love it are just manosphere drones But I also will always put the mental health first here and LOTR simply has almost nothing to breakdown. It’s an INFINITELY better film than fight club tho for sure

Pekki Taari

I agree that some people love it for the wrong reasons and they don’t get the point at all and take the tyler character as a role model and they think it’s about men reclaiming power, strenght, rebellion, cool charismatic leader (but it’s not about that) It’s about mental health, consumerism, identity, avoidance, freedom vs self-destruction, the risk of following a charismatic leader, nihilism disguised as liberation, conformity.. This happens with many movies. shallow thinkers vs deep thinkers. If manosphere drones like a movie it doesn’t make it bad. <3 <3

Chris Emberley

Wow, he broke the first and second rules of Fight Club already!

trans ben shaprio

I agree with Pekki entirely. The manosphere co-opted it but it's literally a queer story about masculinity written by a gay man. If you're able to love it for the correct reasons, you'll see that the manosphere guys were never meant to understand.

Ryan

That's what I'm saying! I feel like we are missing the point of recommending these shows and movies to him. It's not just so he can see different shows and movies we like but it's so he can dive into the mental health of them. Lord of the rings and quite frankly, fight club too don't really have any mental health in them.

RavenLord

I would kind of disagree about Fight Club, but I see where you're coming from on that. Definitely not LoTR for mental health, nor do I particularly want to sit down for nearly 3 hours watching it again, lol (more if it's the extended version). I'm probably one of the few Tolkien fans who doesn't care for the movies. I try to keep mental health in mind when I'm suggesting movies & shows, but my suggestion didn't make the polls this time around.

Bella Lake

Please consider something wholesome and funny like Ted Lasso on Apple TV 🤗

Arzoden

We need a Hannibal Tv Show reaction!

Demceez

Maybe some of us don't mind seeing Tom himself react occasionally, not just always Tom the therapist. Regardless Fight Club is a psychological thriller; claiming it lacks mental health themes is fundamentally wrong. A simple look at the definition of the genre would clear that up immediately for you pmsl.

David Gessin-McCully

So I’m a manosphere drone cause I like a movie? Go back to watching your cartoons the adults are watching movies.

DanLand Saga

Yes exactly, Griffin is one of those who doesnt understand the movie and hates on it cause he thinks hes better than machismo men. Clearly someone has hurt him and reminded him of that movie

Andrew R

Oh yes of course as if there isn't any mental health in LOTRs. As if there isn't a a character that isn't fully devoted to mental health. Much less the rest of the story. But I hate the movies, but that has nothing to do with my decision not to recommend them. Just take my word on it.

Andrew R

Just because someone disagrees with your opinion doesn't mean they "don't understand" the movie. Then again we can't all be Brad Pitt but we can pretend.

Andrew R

The ironic thing is therapists would find the more cerebral movie more interesting than the fight movie more interesting.

Andrew R

28 of those 37 hours were just you bumbling and stumbling in your own mind. Are you sure you meant vasectomy and not lobotomy?

Andrew R

This is essentially the Breaking Bad vs Better Call Saul argument all over again. Breaking Bad is boom, bang, explode (fight club) versus Better Call Saul's character and writing development (LOTRs). Everyone swore up and down that Tom would hate BCS and why bother but they were wrong. Fight Club is the action man's idea of a deep movie. It's not.