Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Should A Movie Tom Has Already Seen Before Be in A Poll?

  • Yes (Include movies he has seen before in the polls) 30
  • No (Don't include movies he has seen before in the polls) 129
  • 2026-01-12
  • —2026-01-13
  • 159 votes
{'title': 'Should A Movie Tom Has Already Seen Before Be in A Poll?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes (Include movies he has seen before in the polls)', 'votes': 30}, {'text': "No (Don't include movies he has seen before in the polls)", 'votes': 129}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 1, 13, 4, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 1, 12, 23, 33, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 159}

Content

Before the next January movie poll, lets decide if we should include movies Tom has already seen. Let us know by voting yes or no and explain why in the comments below!

Comments

Don Jeff

Honestly depends the movie

Charles Brackett

Unless it was a long time ago and he barely remembers it

Amanda Lower

Agree! Some movies are just great no matter how many times you have watched them

Steven Quinn

I voted yes but it does depend on the movie. Good will hunting will be a great one even though he has seen it.

Jess

Andrew R

IMHO they should be in their own poll/category but are worth revisiting or used live watch-alongs as hangouts rather than reactions

Elliot

Its not really a reaction when the person has already seen the movie. Definite no for me.

MoniLove

I voted yes, only because of the movies in the poll that I’ve seen before, I think a rewatch reaction would still be worthwhile. But I could go either way.

Azarel Landa

That depends if you’ve seen the great Gatsby then yes if not, then still yes just as long as the masses agree to a solid film

Tyler

I think you’re one of the rare reactors who gets a pass on this because of the educational perspective you bring. We all grew up watching the same movies, so overlap is inevitable! No need to preclude things on our behalf.

streaky

It's okay as long as you say in the poll you have, IMO - then it'll probably depend on the movie.

####

i voted no :) i enjoy a rewatch myself but i think the first watch is where the magic happens

RavenLord

I couldn't have said it better myself.

hbk314

Agreed. It should be indicated in the poll. I think that Tom has a fairly unique perspective among reactors, and that definitely would make it worthwhile for me to watch a movie I enjoy with him even if it's not his first view.

Jason L.

only if it's LOTRs lol

Awkbak

I voted yes because I feel like Tom can have more to say about the movie. Could be an interesting idea.

Daniel S

No the joy with reactions is getting the first reactions to characters and scenes, it feels like showing a movie you like to a friend, if that friend had seen that movie it feels like a waste of time imo

Kofu

While there's probably more insight on the characters of the said movie if Tom were to see it again, I think people prefer to see blind reactions more. Same goes here in my opinion. Could always do a kind of a "review reaction" video of a movie you'd seen before too maybe

ruinfox

Honestly, I don’t think it’s worth reacting to something you’ve already seen. I follow a lot of reactors on Patreon and some do non-first-time reactions, but even if you think you’ve forgotten most of a movie, that info is still in your head. As you watch, you start remembering bits, and it just isn’t a true first-time reaction anymore. I know for me personally — and probably for a lot of others too — the appeal is seeing that genuine first-time reaction to a movie, because once you’ve seen it before, you’re no longer discovering it you’re just remembering it.

Ryan

C'mon guys. He's seen Good Will hunting, but it's such a good movie, especially from a mental health point of view. We need to hear his thoughts on it. The main reason for this is to get a glimpse into the mental health of these characters, of these people, not just to see his reaction to movies/shows we like.

Lab

I vote no because it’s no longer a reaction - it’s not raw or real at that point

Craig

I personally think yes, because he might have seen it before, but I haven't seen him watch it before. For me it's not about the immediate reactions but the input Tom could give on the theme or moment in the story.

Jake

Sure, but depends on how long ago and how much you remember... If you know exactly what going to happen the reaction wont be as spontaneous. So I think it's up to Tom.

Lil j

If it’s a breakdown reaction kinda thing then I’d be down for that

Kev-la-kill

Are we gonna do another poll?

Brandon

I voted no, BUT I don’t mind it if it’s really good, like a gem like breaking bad, I’ve never watched it but I loved watching your reactions to it, and finished the series with you! Dexter I couldn’t control myself and got a little ahead lol