The High Seas Update is finally out! Well, kinda. Even though this book is currently the same length as the Weird West Update (which, at the time, I thought was a PDF of ungodly length), it's still incomplete, and will take another month to wrap up. Naturally, as our books get grander and more elaborate, they'll also probably get longer, and the time is takes to craft them will also likely swell. This comes with greater risk of delay, of course, as we've seen with High Seas and Dark Matter, but pays dividends with sheer quantity.
But this brings me to an interesting question: what length works best for you all? Do you prefer shorter books that hone in on a more focused topic (a little book that just explores holy spells, or one that provides a number of new undead monsters), or longer books that really flesh out an entire setting or period (like Dark Matter, which is bringing all of the sci-fi to D&D, or High Seas, which is importing an entire genre of adventure to D&D), or something in-between? Do you feel like over a certain length is too long, or is there no such thing?
Do you have any other thoughts on this topic? Feel free to let me know in the comments.
* Note that the options below shouldn't imply a drop in quality, just a difference in release schedule. You can assume that a Short-and-Sweet book will be every bit as good page-for-page as a Comprehensive book, except you waited longer for the latter one.