Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 267167221.mp4

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 video, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Throughout the 80's and 90's, there was a church war over worship music! Contemporary seems to have come out as the winner, but how?

Throughout the 80's and 90's, there was a church war over worship music! Contemporary seems to have come out as the winner, but how? And did we leave too much behind? Kaitlyn breaks down the different schools of thought about worship music. 

Recommended Resources

Ancient Future Worship: Proclaiming and Enacting God’s Narrative: https://a.co/d/38Q6klg

The People of the Truth: The Power of the Worshipping Community in the Modern World: https://a.co/d/35d6TiF

A History of Contemporary Praise & Worship: Understanding the Ideas That Reshaped the Protestant Church: https://a.co/d/6CtLYJ3

Files

Previews only

Comments

Aaron SirLemming

Such a big topic with many dimensions to it -- instruments, musical style, lyrical style... I roll my eyes at a good chunk of the modern worship songs with clunky lyrics, un-followable melodies, and pointless choruses. Yet I also don't think I could go back to all hymns all the time. As someone who really finds a lot of meaning through art, I can't possibly have a cutoff point for either content or style. But I also can't abide crappy art. My ideal worship service would have*at least* 50% focus on congregational singing, with some room for more performance-oriented songs, and possibly even some instrumental music. I wish more churches made that distinction. I often get the sense that they don't really know which one they're doing at a given time. One song that comes to mind as an instructive example, a time that I really felt something during a service, is "The Anthem" by Planetshakers. It's clearly modern, but also easy to sing along to, really just one short chorus sung over and over. Theologically it's pretty sound (one would hope, considering how few lyrics there are). It really only works with a full band and electric guitars, though, because a lot of the power comes from the dynamics, as it slowly builds to a crescendo, preferably accented by a guitar solo. Clearly not every church is equipped for this and I don't think they all should be... But it's one expression that is very non-traditional but also very valuable. Once in a while, anyway. But I think we all know that can't be our main diet. I'm just glad we can have room for dessert once in a while.

Sarah Ferrante

I’m struggling to believe that Skye and Katelyn really believe that there is a place in the Christian life for individualized, personal, emotional worship music. If we say something shouldn’t hold such an outsized role in our communal worship (and I wholeheartedly agree), then we need to be *very* specific about what role we think such music should be given, rather than just generally suggesting it’s kind of bad but then coming around and saying “well, it’s okay to have feelings and love Jesus and express yourself that way, I guess.” While Katelyn tried hard to not throw people who have had intense emotional experiences in modern worship settings under the bus, this discussion still number one on by never naming the role such music should play.

Barry Ward

There are divergent gifts and manifestations of gifts, the gift of music and hymns are formative when the surrounding culture is unable to read, or wanting to read, currently does the contemporary worship open the door for people to enter into a relationship with God. There will always be people stopping at the door, not allowing the fullness of the experience to change them, the song service is not the whole thing any more than the sermon. It’s simply the presence of God in all those things, including the difficult neighbor & us looking for Him, seeing Him in it. Not perfect or perfectly done because I’m there but I’m wanting to see Him working in all those areas.

Christina Smith

I never have been a hymn fan. But to each his own. I think worship is such an individualized thing and for me a personal thing

Caroline Grout

I would argue that worship in church can't be an individualized thing though--it is all of us as one body worshiping together. Worshiping well, worshiping in a God-fearing fashion is critical.

Caroline Grout

Skye be gettin' spicy at the 24:00 minute mark! :p

Rochelle Zecher

Can we please put this on YouTube so I can share it with "worship" pastor friends?

Fidelina Tan

Hmm what I heard is that in a church gathering the issue is not music but whether the songs we are singing are purely emotive or have Theological value to help us understand God. In a church setting, songs shouldn't be about what I feel primarily instead about who God is (imo).

Ericka Iverson

and they GOT INTO IT. like even pointing out the racism that is present in this kind of war

David Kilborn

I've been playing music in church since I was 14 (and I'm a few years older than Skye now). I've seen so much over the years in different churches and different denominations. I've been very uncomfortable with music in a few situations and very comfortable in others. I could write a whole chapter on all this, but just want to say that these last 8-10 years I've really struggled with a lot of the contemporary music that I just don't feel has much substance to it. The words are often repetitive, many of them are essentially the same song with a little different melody but many of the basic same phrases over and over. I don't want to criticize the writers, but so many songs feel like they are just trying to churn out songs that sound like other songs people like instead of writing songs that have strong theological messages. I will say, though, that I find Keith and Krysten Getty some of the best in modern Christian music that I've heard.

Beth Prather

My church sings some great contemporary songs but then they switch to the newer ones abd we don't here even some of the great contemporary songs we sang 5 years ago ever again?? With hymns u do sing over and over . We have been singing about 1 to 2 hymns each week now along with some awesome new songs too. I think it is up to us to make sure the next generation does learn and know some if the greatest hymns. If not they will be lost in the next generation. There are some old hymns with some , Idk lyrics..But mostly great. If your church continues to sing contemporary songs or any that are not sound Bibical truth. We need to call those out.. Those of us in Christ. Not in a mean way, but if lyrics are incorrect Bibically.. Then we really do need to say something for the newer or younger believers...

Beth Prather

I actually can't think of a song now in contemporary music that is not truth. Bibical. The repeat over and over is a praise. Ok some.. But if lyrics are not true.. or concern we need to say something or ask.