Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 448521332.mp4

Downloads

Content

The much anticipated Least Action 2 Q&A!We had so many insightful and intriguing questions it was hard to choose what to include.There are two subsections in this video, the first part focuses on least action in general and the second on the demonstration that Casper showed us.Thank you so much for all your questions and engagement, it was a pleasure to read through them and we hope you enjoy this video.

Files

Comments

Mmmmm. Cookies!

You missed out on a great “Least action hero” reference with this one. 80s nostalgia is still going strong!

GoreMaker

Regarding the "infinite energy" question, I'm confused about the assertion that a particle "explores" every possible path rather than "tries every possible path". The demonstration that was performed with the laser showed the photons ending up in multiple places at once, assumedly with no reduction in intensity at the main location. I'm not trying to imply that there IS infinite energy anywhere, I'm just trying to understand where the unobserved energy ends up.

DC

100% there is stray light being scattered in all directions from the tip of the laser. This fact was recorded by both cameras in the laser demo at around 29:50 in the video. The fact that the tip of the laser pointer can be seen glowing red by both cameras, even though the laser is not pointed directly at either camera, absolutely shows that there is light scattering in all directions from the tip of the laser pointer. 1. The camera mounted above the mirror (picture-in-picture image) can see red light emanating from the aperture of the laser even even thought the laser is not aimed to reflect directly into this camera (the laser dot on the mirror and the aperture of the laser do not coincide). 2. The camera recording the main scene can see red light at the aperture of the laser, even though this camera is almost 90° angle from the laser beam! This is particularly damning. I agree that doing this with a single photon emitter would be ideal.

psrmeshaan

I don't like the appeal to authority with the professor in response to the stray light question. It's not very convincing to the audience especially when the prof isn't even named. Would still like the demo to be redone in more rigorous conditions

Muhammad Fareed Raza

But from the experiment shown in your video about laser light, we have see that light took all the possible paths not just explored them.

Ricco Lindner

I hope most watchers, as I do, realize that you ARE putting amazing effort to get everything right and triple-checked. Therefore, I strongly believe, your channel is like State-of-art, and for be your content is a real tough benchmark and very reliable! 🙏 But still, there are always a few things that could theoretically done better. To me quantum physic experiments are hard to be put convincingly. There is much stuff out there which is misinterpreted, like about quantum erasing. Please also ask Sabine Hossenfelder for her judgment

MR Laine

I’m not sure. I think it shows that, upon interaction, light knows what the path of least action is - because it explored all possible paths - then takes the “new” path of least action. It’s like if you have a map of your neighborhood in your head, and you always take the same way home - but today there’s construction along your normal route - you would instantly know the path to avoid the construction, and take it. You may never have taken that route before, but your knowledge of the map would tell you where you now needed to go.

MR Laine

The thing that currently blows my mind is that the path of least action describes the entire “lifetime” of these photons from emission through every interaction they could possibly have - not just the initial measurement or interaction - but ALL of them - as these photons may reflect off of surface after surface - all over the universe - to the point of eventual complete absorption. Amazing. #GoCanucks

Lukas

The idea of doing a single photon experiment sounds great, would love to see it!

Veritasium

We've had a ton of internal discussions about this. What it means for a photon/particle to "take" a path. Our internal agreement landed that the wavefunction takes/explores all possible paths. But the trajectory that is observed just ends up being the ones that follow (or are very close to) the path of least action. - Casper

Veritasium

We are still looking into this! - Casper

Veritasium

We are looking into doing this with the single photon emitter ! - Casper

a a

When particle has high energy, it can either preserve it, or loose it, when it is on lower level, it can only stay as it is, unless getting energy from outside. Lower energy is stable

SinistressDreams

Hey, I just subscribed to you here since I was also one who commented on the video regarding the experiment. I really appreciate it a lot that you made this video and I'll continue to follow you here for sure! Regarding the experiment, I'd believe it if it would be in a tube coated with some sort of light absorbing material. None the less, really cool to see that you interact with the community in such a way

Eric Ruth

Would very much love a more rigorous version of the laser demo - I'm quite excited to see what the results would be! It sounds like you're looking into that, so thank you for going the extra mile. Even if you aren't able to make it happen with a single photon emitter, I think it would be compelling to try a version of it where the light scattering from the tip of the laser is hidden somehow (e.g. the laser encased in a box, with the laser beam shooting out of a small hole in the box).

Michal Bachraty

Just adding more notes: laser diode(LD) sources are gaussian light sources, so final dot has been spreading in relative big area - causing reflections we saw as @DC wrote. LD is Gaussian source and needs collimating optics with diameter. Generally size of chip producing coherent light can vary - cheap are thin - 100um + emitting layer is smaller - can cause an obstacle to light producing gaussian image. Also LD optics has coliimatiion angle, so the light is not exactly straight - but with small angle. Depending on our purpose, we must work with this angle. There are some technics to reduce gaussian beam into uniform beam - using diffraction optics (eg. lenslets) - https://www.techbriefs.com/component/content/article/12683-40429-200 So maybe if single photon emitter experiment will be too hard to create, you can look for diffraction optics experts or change to another type of laser eg. - HeNe laser to produce better quality beam. For removing side gaussian light, multiple apertures covered with black - light absorbing material can be used - see example with back body chamber (optional) - https://cad.onshape.com/documents/b1b51ba167136c1c5cd2bb2d/w/f612135b58f9363a2aa73e98/e/b31a6ef8c103790de9c8bd4f?renderMode=0&uiState=67f62a9a581ca625eeea2b59

‎‎‎‎‎ ‎‎‎‎‎

Emitting a single photon at a time would unfortunately not show anything either, because those photons would still be scattered at the end of the laser. There is a simpler experiment - just cover the edges of the laser with some black tube to minimize stray light. I bet you wouldn't see the reflection in that case.

krisztian letai

And what resolutions do you reccomend for the diffraction grating?

Tim Wilkinson

If doing a more rigorous version of the laser experiment (yes please) please also try to get a surface-slivered mirror. Internal reflections in an ordinary mirror confused the observations when I tried this at home.

- -

I tried recreating the demo at home but couldn’t eliminate all the stray light. I really enjoy your videos, and it would be amazing if you could redo this demo in a laser lab or a more controlled setup to satisfy all of us curious commenters!

File

How does the light know where it is supposed to go? If it has to figure out the most effective path of all possibilities between A and B. how can it have the target B when it starts at A?

Axel Marora

The path of least Action is a property of the path that the photon ends up taking. The actual mechanisms driving the photon are things like quantum fields, the shrodinger equation etc. The path of least Action for a photon is always a straight line (in uniform electromagnetic and gravitational fields). Using the langrangian, you can find the path of least Action in the case of non-uniform EM and gravitational fields. It's like the difference between Newtonian and Hamiltonian mechanics: both are true, forces drive the particles but the path ultimately taken must have a certain property (least Action). So it is with quantum field theory (QFT) and least Action: QFT drives the particles but the ultimate path follows the principle of least Action. The principle of least action is a *description*, not a force. The actual position of the particle at target B is determined probabilistically (measurement collapses the wave function, giving you a final position). Least Action is most useful for cases where you already know the final state and you need to figure out the path to get there, while QFT is useful where you don't know the final state and you must determine what it would be (probabilistically). To find the position from the initial conditions (momentum and force field), you would apply the Hamiltonian (used to solve for the path of LA) to quantum states (rather than classical states) and the output would be a probability distribution across space, telling you the likely positions for Target B. That is what the Schrodinger equation effectively does and it is where the "taking all paths" comes from. For classical systems, given an initial state, the Hamiltonian outputs the path and the final position of the particle absolutely (non-probabilistic, no "taking all paths", just one path). While for quantum systems, given an initial quantum state, the Hamiltonian simulates taking all paths and outputs a probability distribution of possible positions and paths, this is where the "taking all paths" comes from. It is a product of the quantization of the principle of least action.

Prathamesh V Patil

I am Prathamesh, a JEE aspirant currently in Class 11. I have been following your videos for the past two years, and I truly appreciate your work. Your explanations have helped me develop intuition in physics and mathematics, making it easier to grasp complex concepts. Your content is benefiting thousands of JEE aspirants like me, and I sincerely thank you for that. I have a few questions that I have been struggling to visualize, and I would love to hear your insights: 1. Path Integral and Infinite Paths – If a particle moves from one point to another, it explores all possible paths. Since there are infinitely many paths, some of these paths would be infinitely long and practically impossible to traverse. This is hard to imagine. Similarly, if light is emitted from a torch, in principle, it should travel across the entire universe, reaching distant galaxies and coming back. How do we make sense of this idea? 2. Connecting Various Theories – How can we conceptually connect De Broglie’s theory, Quantum Field Theory, Schrödinger’s Equation, the Principle of Least Action, and Classical Mechanics? It is difficult to see how they fit together into a unified picture. 3. Light Traveling Through Infinite Paths – If light travels from one point to another via all possible paths, then it must distribute its energy among infinitely many paths. But dividing its total energy into infinite parts seems impossible. How do we reconcile this with reality? Additionally, I would like to request a video on moment of inertia and rotational mechanics. This is a particularly tricky topic for many JEE aspirants, and a clear explanation from you would be immensely helpful. Once again, thank you for your invaluable content. Looking forward to your response!

Terry Bollinger

5:35 Martin H. (MH): How does something have the energy to try every possible path all at once? Wouldn't that require infinite energy? [5:34] 5:43 Derek Muller (DM): Hmm. It's a great question. I think the particle only ends up sort of, eventually, taking some paths. Right? I think we were careful in the script to say, "explores all possible paths" as opposed to "takes all possible paths." If we're talking about a photon or a particle, it starts in one place and ends in one place. So, in that way, you don't have more than one electron or something. But, while the electron is traveling and not interacting with anything, it must be aware of what paths are open to it. So, that's a very weird thing to think about. But I don't think it would break any conservation laws, or say that, "Yeah, we need more electrons or more energy." It just says that the electron we have needs to be aware of all possible paths. So it needs to be kind of exploring all directions. And then, ultimately, action kind of determines where the thing is going to end up. [6:42] 6:43 Casper Mebius (CM): I think that's spot on. I was talking to Dave about this, and he said, "You know, as long as you're still in sort of the quantum space where you're talking about just the wave function, it can do whatever it likes." You know, you can have these virtual particles, for example, that pop into existence, that go out of existence. But as long as in the ultimate reality there's a net zero energy gain or loss, then all of that is fine. But you have to include all of those still in your calculations. [7:09]

Terry Bollinger

Martin H., like Feynman’s double-slit conundrum, your excellent question zeros in on one of the deepest mysteries of quantum mechanics: How can an almost infinitesimal small packet of conserved electromagnetic energy manage to “be aware” of _every_ possible path that it travels, particularly in cases such as large Einstein lenses where “every path” may encompass a sizable fraction of the entire universe’s volume? For anyone who has worked or thought about any form of electromagnetic information transfer, the classical version of “being aware” of those paths has energy and bandwidth implications: You cannot hear a radio station that lacks enough energy, and you cannot encode vast amounts of energy onto an AM signal. You need _both_ more energy (to get the result in a finite time) and more frequency (to add more information) to capture that awareness of where the photon traveled. Being aware of the structure and shape of the _entire_ Einstein lens — all of its matter and dark matter and the exact distributions of that matter, since otherwise the photon cannot know exactly where it needs to go — is even more daunting. And that destination could be a single focal point with an almost 100% arrival probability! And yet, to a photon, the task of focusing across most of the universe seems no more and no less complicated than the same photon traveling through a camera lens with its version of vast complexity in the form of atoms. Thus, your excellent question: How does “awareness” work in the quantum world? How can it handle such incredible scaling feats using almost infinitesimal energies? What is the deeper nature of this remarkably energy-efficient quantum version of the classical concept of information? The maths do not help, since they only transform the same observation and question into a far more cryptic form: A “wave function” that _itself_ requires infinite energy and infinite disregard for the lightspeed restrictions of classical information. Where is the path to resolution? Did you know wave functions _do_ have physical properties, and can you trivially detect and partially reduce such wavefronts without involving individual atoms? When an experimentally meaningful quantum wave function — a photon or Schrödinger wave — arrives at a reflective surface, it deposits a tiny but measurable bit of momentum there. This deposition is no small issue in astrophysics since, for example, it is how the Pillars of Creation formed, and how similar processes once formed our sun. NASA uses the momentum of individual photons on solar sails to accelerate probes through space. Yet when the photons deposit this momentum, they _only_ deposit as waves that lap evenly against the _entire_ surface of a dust particle or NASA solar sail. The photon never “sees” the detail of that particle or sail, only its broad shape. From that one hint, Martin H., I can add to this discussion a hint towards the deeper answer you seek, but nothing more than a hint: A photon traveling through an Einstein lens does not “see” those galaxies in any more detail than it “sees” the atoms in a focusing lens. The deeper physics hiding beneath classical waves and classical particles is scale-free, meaning the photon is only “aware” of an incredibly tiny fraction of the complexity of those galaxies — and even there, only in the sense of gathering an extremely small bit of their complexity in the form of momentum as its wave front form passes through them. The nature of the transfer is neither mysterious nor unknowable, but a real change we see in the shaping and shifting of the photon front. Linear momentum — acceleration, really — scales in remarkable ways that energy cannot, and through that scaling shapes and transforms the wavefront path of the traveling photon. This extreme non-linearity of linear momentum is at the heart of your mystery, although by itself, it is far from a complete solution to the mystery of choice and rescaling.

Terry Bollinger

One more addendum: 11:59 Albert Einstein (AE) in 1905: “... phenomena involving the emission or conversion of light can be better understood [if] energy is not continuously distributed over an ever increasing volume, but ... consists of a finite number of energy quanta, localised in space, which move without being divided and which can be absorbed or emitted only as a whole.” Thank you! I’ve had Einstein’s photon paper for a long time, but never noticed this line. I’ve been giving him slightly too much credit by emphasizing that he only focused on quantized _reception._ This sentence points out that Einstein genuinely believed in point-like photons. Especially coming from him, that explicit hypothesis no doubt helped create the non-physical continuum-math noise that plagues so much of modern physics. In real-universe experimentation, point-like photons are as much of an energetic impossibility as point-like electrons. In both cases, actual, experimentally meaningful diameters in non-destructive phenomena (e.g., photon reflection versus absorption) are wavelength limited. That means you need infinite energy costs to compress photons or electrons into true points. The point approximation is a concept confined to one inertial frame material instance at a time, so the idea is neither fundamental nor reachable. But what an approximation! The ability of the universe to create functionally useful _approximations_ of point particles is the very foundation of both classical physics and information. This inattention to Planck energy reciprocity makes four minor but consequential errors I’ve encountered in Einstein’s 1905, 1907, and 1911 papers. He must have been a bit better at bluffing than folks realized. But what papers, and what a mind! Compared to Einstein, Minkowski was a minnow swimming beside a leviathan. Minkowski set up pretty but needlessly cryptic and mostly non-predictive mixed-signature equations that did nothing but sidetrack everyone’s attention away from the difficult and more important real-universe problems of how time and acceleration work. Einstein should have stuck with Euclidean 4D space, even if it made his work uncomfortably (for him) reminiscent of his predecessor Lorentz.

Peter Becher

You don't need anything fancy, just set up the same experiment and put a short black tube over the end of the laser to block the stray light. Problem fixed, Negative result.

File

Thanks for the helpfull explanation. But what I, as a non-physicist, just don't understand is this: If you want to rescue your friend out of the water you see him as the target and figure out the fastest way. But how does a photon have a target in the first place. And if it doesn't have a target how can it figure out the path of least action to a target that it doesn't have?

WolframConda

An issue I take with the demo from the main video is saying that "it's just interference/diffraction". interference is a property that derives from the hamiltonian principle and does in fact show exactly what you say it should. For the same reason the laser case shouldn't work. For a reasonably collimated gaussian beam, the action outside the beam should grow very very fast (much closer to a massive object than a spherical wave from the lamp case). So the phase winding that is supposedly broken by the diffraction grating is much faster than the line frequency of the grating and would still cause destructive interference. (this would otherwise also probably break most laser experiments, which very often use similar gratings. And having worked in a laser lab, gratings do not usually reflect light if you miss the grating (which is equivalent to blocking the mirror in the demo))

Donkey Monkey

There is no audio. Can you help please?

Max Karpushko

If it is exploring all possible paths, does that mean in some way the path of least action is being calculated and all paths are being simulated in some sense? Otherwise how is it exploring all paths if they are not simulated? My current thinking is that it sounds like this principle might point to some form of quantum simulation that happens in the background and our physical reality comes from a certain set of rules (the laws of physics) being applied to this simulation?

MiceCube

It is incredibly obvious that it was just a reflection from the glowing tip of the laser. It's honestly shocking that this was released to the public and that it's still up and you're still standing by your incorrect explanation.

SYED BADIUDDIN ANAS

It's nice to see that you mentioned my dust particle doubt. What brings me there is that lasers focus light to a tight spot, and only due to atmospheric reflections do we see its path. So, for me, conceiving that experiment is possible only when it's done in a vacuum.

Jazsajral

why choose patreon not YouTube?

Michiel Nugteren

I’d like to share a theory that’s been on my mind for a while. At first, I dismissed it as just a foolish thought—but then I came across this video about the principle of least action, and suddenly, something clicked. The principle of least action is known to apply to light, but what if it applies to all matter? Maybe it’s not such a wild idea after all. What if every particle of matter is not only following the path of least action, but also simultaneously exploring all other possible paths—just not in ways we can directly observe? Here’s where it gets interesting: perhaps those alternate paths are being taken in dimensions we can't perceive. As individuals, we only experience one version of reality, the one where our particles follow a specific path. So—bear with me—what if the reality we're experiencing right now is the "dimension of least action"? If that’s the case, then every possible version of ourselves could be exploring different paths through different dimensions simultaneously. Among them, there might be one path that is more "efficient" or "optimal"—the one where the path of least action dominates. That would be the version of ourselves we’re most likely to experience: the one that lives the longest, progresses the furthest, and makes the decisions that move us forward most effectively. Let’s call this reality the Dimension of Least Action. But what about others—people who seem to have been tragically cut short in this dimension? It might be that they're not experiencing their dimension of least action here. In your dimension, they could be taking a less optimal path, while in their own dimension of least action, you might be the one on a suboptimal course. Everyone could be navigating their own version of the universe, with different people playing different roles depending on whose optimal path is being followed. So, the big question is: how could this ever be proven?

Jude Nash

The issue with this is it then differentiates living things with inanimate objects. Since we are all made of matter we should follow the same laws as a ball for example and this theory would state that living things have an entirely artificial property that supersedes matter in general. This also assumes that right now there are other dimensions that can be tapped into. Our understanding of dimensions is very small but scientists currently believe that the universe is in 3 dimensions due to it being the most stable on the quantum level and at the big bang there were many dimensions that didn't "make it". Whatever you believe about dimensions, the fact that our universe is in 3 highlights the fact it's probably the only way anything can exist (bit like how a pyramid is the most optimal shape in nature and a bee uses hexagonal shapes for a hive as it is most optimal). Optimisation is a driving force that may have been the reason our universe works so well and hasn't just collapsed in on itself. Basically in full, your theory can be comforting to those who do believe humans have this separate special quality that means that the "experience" of life being cut short is not simply just the human body breaking down but a "soul" dying that can maybe just be a possible path. I personally don't believe this, I believe we are a very articulate and beautiful result of math that allows a system, our universe, to simulate what's happening because if we weren't able to do that the universe would just be and no one would ever know.

Michiel Nugteren

Thanks for your reaction! This theory actually wouldnt differentiate between animate and non animate objects, we would just experience this dimension because it is a dimension where all matter would follow paths closest to this "least action", and therefore would be stable. Interesting you would mention that this is a stable dimension, and in the beginning there would be a lot of other unstable dimensions. This sounds a lot like the theory of least action! So all other paths would be taken by all matter, resulting in a lot of destructive dimensions, but the paths that are close to the path of least action would bring forth stable rules of physics and living beings etc. And on all those paths that are close to the least action required there would be different versions of our selfs taking different paths through life, and really just experience a dimension where all matter just takes a slightly different path. So this theory of least action would also explain why all of our universe seems to be governed by so beautiful physical rules, which seem too perfect to be made up, and just exist for no reason. Only it just seems that way, because we experience only this stable dimension of least action , where all matter is actually just traveling every path and in the paths of least action form these stable dimensions with stable physical rules.

Jude Nash

Makes more sense to me now thank you for explaining. Couple things: The thing about dimensions would then mean even in our universe it was not initially the universe of least action as it started unstable and those other dimensions did not spatially expand. This means that a universe NOT taking the path of least action could technically survive under more dire conditions. In essence if our universe was not stable (which was clear due to sketchy results of calculations done for the initial seconds of the universe) to start with, then at what point would it have "become" the path of least action. Least action is also very much a result of probability like they said in the video in the quantum level the action is so small that the spread of possibilities is much larger. For matter of a ball for example this is when the really improbable scenarios aren't very different from what will most likely happen. A universe is massive, which bodes the question maybe this is just how the universe is meant to be since it has such immense action that it is completely improbable for any other universe to exist. It's a thinker though haha

Kat Seibert

If you repeat the laser experiment 2 thoughts, use a first surface mirror and make sure you use the correct diffraction grating but on second though better still make sure to read Gratings as dispersive elements from wikipedia to make sure this is not what the experiment shows.