Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 448818580.mp4

Downloads

Content

We've got an exciting video coming up in the next few days!A video about Noether's Theorem and its impact on physics.We’d love to hear your feedback and suggestions as we wrap up this video! Animations are still in progress and placeholders are used for Derek talking to the camera.Producer Casper has also recorded some temporary lines of voiceover, so you'll hear his voice mixed in where Derek's will eventually be.Is there anything wrong? Any other questions? Anything more you'd like to see? Explanations you think don't do a good enough job or lack depth? Let us know!Thanks everyone!

Files

Comments

Gregor Shapiro

Of course almost all lipsyncs are fubar... At last an intro tease to Gauge theory..

Cameron Hicks

Thank you for telling the story of women in stem.

Lionel Pöffel

14:51 It looks like the second line in green states L=T+V whereas, on the whiteboard, it's L=T-V. Might be the low resolution.

Charles S. Cook

Thank you for doing this one. I have not heard her name before, but I will say her name many times in the future!

Dragon-Tear

Fear this video really is only for the people who have studied those theories before... At least me you lost very early on. Like why does the rock even stop? Is that explained in this video at all? And what about gravity? (am assuming it's not gravity because then the rock would not just stop but "fall" back onto the Astronaut eventually).

Veritasium

I think you're right and this was a typo -- we'll get it fixed. Thank you Lionel! - Casper

Veritasium

When making a video we don't want to assume any detailed knowledge of the theories involved. We hope the main points of the story can be understood by anyone. We do explain what's going on with the rock later on in the video, but there's a whole journey to go on before we can get there. Are there other specific reasons we lost you early on? Things you think we glossed over too quickly or assumed too much knowledge of?

John Murphy

That was fascinating! As it happens I just listened to a podcast on Emmy Noether, so I've been exposed to some of these concepts and was primed for the symmetry discussion, so it flowed pretty well for me. I'm still having trouble, though, with the jump from time symmetry to conservation of energy. The block of math in the middle was a little hard for me to follow, especially since I'm not very familiar with the Lagrangian, and so while I understand the general concept that we've taken part of the equation we've just developed and substituted something else we knew... I was feeling a bit lost by that point and just kind of nodding my head. If I just take it for granted I can follow along with the rest, but I don't feel I have a firm understanding of where that particular consequence comes from.

Tom Schroeder

I like how the simpler math analogies to the actual but more difficult math, like tensors, was used in the presentation. It was fast paced enough that I want to re-watch it, but didn’t feel too lost on first viewing. Some of the presentation by the physicist seemed straightforward at the time, but the simplifications in the derivation would not have been obvious to me upon first exposure. I don’t know to make it clearer, other than to rewatch that segment. Still, the huge impact of Noether came across as intended. Also, the history of how her work intertwined with the unsolved problems of the time was the best part of the video to me. It explains how each person influenced the other.

Veritasium

Glad you enjoyed! Thank you for your feedback

Terry Bollinger

Editor mode: At least on my laptop, the musical score volume was high enough to interfere with hearing some words in the presentation. The music worked fine and sounded good, but perhaps a bit more volume on the voices might help. For content, the idea that the ball stops due to the universe being asymmetric in time was unsatisfying and more like an unwarranted assumption. For example, what if it turns out that we are, after all, in some form of cyclic universe, say Penrose's CCC -- does this assertion about the ball still hold, or hold in the same way? Or (my favorite) we are in a dual universe in which energy _is_ absolutely conserved by the negative energy of our dual? Most of astronomy is still chaotic about the details of cosmic expansion, which also adds messiness to such a sharp conclusion, especially as an intro. For an intro paradox, you expect an indisputable "Aha!" momentum, and a quick wave at "time is not fully symmetric" doesn't feel like that.

Doctor Why

Amazing! I remember the first time I was introduced to the Noether Theorem and it blew my mind. Being born long time ago I assume Noether was male and years later I found out that I was mistaken; who came up with was never as important as the importance of its use. Veritasium is a magnificent Science communications platform I'm hoping you find more topics where women scientist have made monumental contributions (often battling harder against social structures rather than against the frontiers of knowledge). Scientist like Rosalind Franklin, Lise Meitner, Cecila Payne, Henrrieta Leavitt, Chien-Shiung Wu just to name a few.

Terry Bollinger

I just saw the released video. Very nice! If my memory serves me right (it may not), the released version discusses the link between the ball slowing down and expansion as applied to space and photons in more detail. That was just the kind of connection I was looking for! My worries about uncertainties in the universe model itself remain, but the new version made the math connection to Noether's work much clearer and more persuasive. Also, I did _not_ notice the music overpowering the words, which means the level balancing was perfect: No distractions. Good video!