Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The video I've linked shows your shade ball's life story. There are behind-the-scenes shots, things I cut from the video and some clips from the original video. I've really enjoyed this project so I hope you have too! I have a few hundred extra shade balls and I will mail them out this month to people who missed out the first time around. Please make sure your address is correctly entered in Patreon.com/pledges if you want to receive a shade ball.

*****

When I started on Patreon, it was clear to me that 'per video' was the best structure. That way patrons aren't charged if I'm off for a month or more doing other things or if I do a sponsored video (as I launched today with BMW): https://youtu.be/GATuMWAFBUA

This video hasn't been received well by a significant fraction of the audience so it raises the question: should I even do sponsorships anymore? The perception seems to be that the reason to do sponsorships is greed, but I disagree.

More than anything, I want to be able to keep making videos that are in depth, high quality, and on subjects I'm passionate about. As we've seen over the years, YouTubers' careers are precarious. You never know when you may experience a downturn you'll never recover from. Sponsorships bring in significant revenue that can keep you going in a rough patch, enable you to hire employees and freelancers (as I have recently done), and take bigger risks like traveling to the Nevada Nuclear Test Site or investing thousands of dollars in scientific equipment.

These benefits must be weighed against the obvious detriment that some content on the channel is of a commercial nature and not free from bias. My sense though is that most of the audience is savvy enough to see these videos for what they are. I always try to make the best, most accurate videos I can and push for complete editorial control. (The videos are also free, identified as sponsored content, and no one is forcing anyone to watch them). But I would like to know your thoughts so please leave them in the comments below.

I have come to see you as a thoughtful board of advisors so it is your opinions that matter the most to me.

Thank you!

Derek

Files

Your shade ball's life story

Here's a little insight into how your shade ball was made and its journey to you. I have more balls so more will be sent out this month to new patrons and anyone for whom there was a mishap the first time around.

Comments

Mike Lambrakis

There are always going to be “haters” whenever money is involved but I think they are ignorant. You nailed it on the head when you said it is free content that is clearly marked as sponsored. I would prefer to see videos like this from time to time rather than have you break up your other videos with plugs for skillshare or whatever. As long as there is a healthy ratio of content to sponsor-driven videos I don’t think there is an issue.

Reversal

The problem with the last video, in my opinion, was that there was not opposition to the points you were making. I have no problem whatsoever with you having sponsors, as they are fantastic for earning money. However, I am not a huge fan of a sponsor which does not allow you to give your own personal opinion and view of the downsides of such technology. Nearly everything you stated in the video about electric cars showed that they were better, I agree that they are better, but there are still glaring issues with them, which you did not mention very much. Please continue to get sponsors as it will keep the quality of the content up, but I simply ask that you act as unbiased as you possibly can, even if you strongly believe in one side. After all, this is a very scientific community bias can be viewed as one of the evils of such a community. Thank you.

Heath Wolfeld

I have no problem with the sponsored videos as long as they are clearly identified as being sponsored, don’t impact the content of non-sponsored videos, and Patreons aren’t charged.

Michael Wenske

I don’t see any problem with sponsorship. Money for interesting, engaging and entertaining content doesn’t come from thin air, especially when you want to go big. I think having commercial partners is totally appropriate. Thanks for the great content!

SkaveRat

"to see these videos for what they are" - so long uncritical ads? The video was fine, but basically just that. and compared to the other content on the channel, it feels really subpar and like you read a script given by BMW.

Andrew Lazenby

I do not understand why folks are against you (or any YouTuber) seizing the opportunity to make a good living while providing to us, content that we all enjoy. You have built a successful channel that educates and entertains millions, I cannot imagine the blood, sweat, and tears that went into its creation and growth. Patreon is an awesome way to raise income for a creator. Sponsorships, are ALSO a great way to raise income for your content. While yeah yeah yeah, I’m sure there is always the ‘spector’ of bias..... but in the years I have enjoyed your content I have never seen anything that would lead me to believe that it would become and issue. Finally, as a consumer I would like to know of industry or businesses that support your mission.

Jeffrey K Shulenburg

So, for me at least, I don't mind sponsored videos. Many channels do them and do them well. I think the issue and where you went wrong is that it felt too much like an ad for BMW and not an explanation of electric cars in general. It was too surface. A much better video would have been to do something like recreate CGPgreys non sponsored tesla video. Document yourself living with an electric car... And gawking at it... But also explaining the how's and why's of these technologies.

Terrance Shepherd

For sponsorship I thinks it's just a bit late. I have seen almost the same video from 2-3 other creators but I watched it through cause I want to support you.

Gergely Dezsereczky

Thanks Derek for the shade ball, just received number 2207 today. By the way I really liked the last video, that sponsorship seemed perfectly fine for me.

Daniel Turner

Your being true to yourself is part of the Veritasium brand and so, being as mindful as you are of the potential pitfalls involved, it is simply a matter of taking an approach you're comfortable with.

Jerrad Pierce

The BMW video wasn't quite on par with other videos, but it was fine. I found the facts about "electric did it first" very interesting. I noticed the down votes and interpreted as being people who are for one reason or another (most likely emotional) invested in the status quo (personal ICE-based vehicles than sit idle and lock up lots of resources) rather than displeasure about sponsorship. Weren't the aerogel videos sponsored? Did they not do well? I think you generally tend to a better job than most with sponsored video content being both relevant to the sponsor, and your channel's theme.

Jeffrey K Shulenburg

I think another company that does paid videos well is Linus tech tips. They talk about both pros and cons of the thing. And many of their best paid videos are about cool BTS technologies like supercomputers or manufacturing processes where they can talk about the technology all video and the paid part is name dropping the company in terms of the innovation, not the product

i❤computers

I guess the one criticism I agree with was the content was surface level. Sure you talked about how lithium batteries changed the game, but you didn’t go into the chemistry of those batteries of why they can hold so much energy or whether there are any power storage technologies out there that can hold more charge. That’s why I sub to your vids cause of the deep dives into the physics that isn’t usually explained to a common audience. Nonetheless, I can’t expect the timeline your sponsor hands down to you to give you that much time to go that deep. Despite that, you went into the history, brought up stats on lithium batteries, and listed more benefits about electric cars. Compared to other vids on the same topic, it was really good. I guess the audience was comparing it to your other videos which dive deep into surprising facts about physics.

Nathan Cardinale

I set mine in a way that only allows 1 charge per month. I wish I could’ve set a monthly easier. Easier to factor in the expense of your support (and other Patreons) when i know the amount monthly.

Tom Braider

Happy owner of ball no. 3172 writing from Bulgaria here. Derek, I think you should do what you feel you like doing best. You are a fantastic explainer, a great story teller, and it is only fair that you seek different channels to capitalize on your skill set. YouTube is a merciless partner and I agree you should not rely on them. If getting sponsorships is a good way to achieve creative independence and expand your work, you owe it to yourself to try. About the video itself: I don't know why so many folks reacted negatively because I fail to see how BMW sponsoring this video is different from Skillshare or Brilliant.org sponsoring it. Maybe they just didn't like the interior of the electrical prototypes (I didn't). Or maybe it feels a little short and a little rushed (most of your vids run twice as long on average, right?) But, the bottom line: don't give up just yet! I am sure you will produce many more sponsored videos that will be liked as much as your regular ones. Always upwards & onwards!

Jim361Tx

I just figured out I had to edit my pledge to show him my address. I wish there was a better explanation of how this was done. I have been a patron for a while and had an address on file however didn't realize I had to explicitly share it with each creator. Hopefully I will get one of the few hundred left. If not that is ok too.

Rick Garnett

I’m not too bothered by it but I haven’t seen the video yet. I would encourage you to take a look at what Ok Go does. They are somehow able to balance integrity with the audience and money from sponsors really well!

Bruce Goren

As long as you retain your independence and are true to your mission statement of providing unbiased analysis and commentary, more power to you. The video was clearly represented as sponsored, and I thought you did a good job on its content, assuming you believed it yourself. You may risk turning off some who cannot get beyond the sponsorship, but that only limits them and their access to good content such as yours.

Jerrad Pierce

The top ten list was clearly framed as opinion, not incontrovertible objective fact.

Guardian 452 Bob

I think it isn't that it is a sponsored video so much as pretty much every other science/technology YouTuber has released a BMW sponsored video in the last two months. I watched yours, and three one Linus Tech Tips did a while ago. Yours was great, really cool and informative. I didn't actually learn anything from it, as an automotive enthusiast I already knew all those truth bombs you dropped about electric cars. Silence isn't an advantage by the way, it is a safety issue. Loud engines prevent phone absorbed pedestrians from stepping out in front of you.

God 420

i got my ball the other day it was the left one #4490

David Leschinsky

Uhm, a hard topic for sure. I think it really depends on the individual video. The BMW one was rather subpar and had an uncomfortable ad vibe to it. I was disappointed to see that the problems associated with the battery resources for example were not included, rather just the positive aspects of electric cars, which certainly added to the ad vibe. In general I think it's definitely possible to create high quality sponsored videos, it's just a fine line you need to walk. That being said, I see and understand your reasons, and I'd prefer non-sponsored videos and hope that your patreon supporters are generous enough to avoid the need of sponsored ones. Thank you for letting us in in your thought process and taking our feedback!

Reversal

I disagree, I find that the top ten list portion was a list of all the advantages electric cars had over other cars. This is all fine, except for the fact that there was never a portion alongside this stating that the cars had shortcomings in certain areas against other cars.

W Yoder

Hi, if there are extras, I don't think I received one. The thanks in advance.

Veritasium

Got it! Be warned there is one more video sponsored by Big Coffee coming up, but it has a clearer demarcation between the video and the sponsor parts.

Ben Michels

Mmmm ultimately you are a brand and you want to grow as a brand, your BMW sponsorship was somewhat shallow which is unexpected. Perhaps Sponsors need to understand you work at a different level delivering information to a different ordinance which means you are ultimately going to appeal to a smaller market (but one far more invested) . I agree with putting out sponsored videos and not dipping into Patreon supporters as well . Otherwise keep the credibility high, keep the quality high and wether you are being paid by your Patreon supporters or sponsors keep doing good work.

Ben Michels

I wish that were the case, idiots are going to walk out in front of you even if you are a Mr Whippy van playing your chime. They just aren’t focused on their own safety

Dennis Hakvoort

I get why your taking sponsor deals, I truly do. However, for a channel like yours, one that's (imo) build heavily on giving a neutral and unbiased view various topics, sponsored videos clash with this motive. Even if the sponsor allows you to be completely unbiased (and you manage to actually stay unbiased, regardless of the pay), the viewer won't be able to fully trust the information given in the video. (Just my 2 cents)

Veritasium

thanks for this feedback. I think this was my own myopia. I'm aware that mining for batteries is harmful to the environment, but then again so is mining for the metal to make traditional cars and engines (one could argue the mining for things like lithium and cobalt are worse and they may have a point). I think I failed to have a good sense of what people would want to talk about and that fault is on me rather than the brand.

wolph

Even though the video was sponsored, I don't feel like it was pro BMW or anything. As far as I could tell, everything in that video was truthful and as unbiased as can be so I have no objection.

Veritasium

haha and the sad thing is that was all put together by me and I believe BMW didn't request any changes or get involved in any way in the scripting process. I mean some guys in Munich mentioned the marathon car so that made sense to include. But I think this one was perceived as all positive hence sponsored shill, when it was really I'm just very positive about electric cars because I drive one and love it.

Aaron makes things

I'm against any and all sponsorship, the way trust is gained is by being completely free to speak your mind, a sponsorship is anti-competitive against other companies, and ties an unfair positive spin to the sponsor. The world is becoming less and less scarce over time, the last remaining vestige people will spend their time and money on, is trust. It takes 20 years to build a reputation and five minutes to ruin it. If you think about that, you'll do things differently. You need to stop focusing on the views, and stop focusing on revenue outside of supporters, you need to work on building trust, which means stop focusing on the YouTube algorithm and stop focusing on making clickbait icons and titles. Also quality beats quantity, so I think the monthly payment system is better, i.e. if it takes three months to make a great video, I would rather have that that three lesser quality videos.

Farhang Frank Amini

I personally will watch a sponsored video (maybe less likely to click though). I don’t mind them at all, and I know that YouTubers need them to operate when it comes to other content

Veritasium

Thank you! Thank you for getting it and thanks for your support!

David Perry

It's about knowing your worth. Would the brand tell James Cameron how to make a movie? What would he say if they did? If it feels like it's the brand speaking in your video there's a problem, if it feels like you speaking, your audience will love it. So it's simply up to your agent to be clear that to work with you, 100% of all dialog and storytelling is in your voice, that you can share your opinions. (You can simply offer Veto rights if they HATE it.) If they say no to the request, then they are reminding you that you are a billboard. If you want to be a billboard, lots of brands will work with you, but your audience will hate it. There are plenty of cool brands that understand social media, so you can hold true to who you are. You are a brand just like BMW. If you asked BMW to tell everyone to buy a product of yours, they'd think that's absurd, so should you. Callaborate? Now that's different, that's great, but it must be in your voice. They can always make their own video in their voice, it won't get the lift they hope for, then they will come back to you. :)

David Leschinsky

The last sentence hit the nail on the head, I think. Even if the sponsor is great, you're completely unbiased and have complete editorial control, it may still leave behind an uncomfortable vibe to the video for a significant fraction of the viewers.

Veritasium

haha I've been waiting for the green light on this one for weeks!

Veritasium

but I appreciate you watching anyway

Veritasium

Yeah, this is the heart of the matter.

Gary D

I have no problem with sponsors. You need to get paid. I usually enjoy your videos because I learn something. The BMW video felt rushed and was very surface level. I'm sure many don't know about early electric cars, so that was an interesting tidbit, but I felt like I learned nothing from the video.

Veritasium

thanks! Aerogel videos were not sponsored but it was kind of a 'we'll show you our lab and you can include a link' no money changing hands. I'm glad you think I generally do a good job of it though.

Earthwormia

I mean this is your job and I don't imagine YouTube has an employer-matched 401k. Like the click bait titles and your openness with the algorithm, I think this is just part of the deal. If you stay open with everyone, I feel like people should be able to get over themselves.

Jonathon Wyza

I think the biggest thing for me was the amount of "stock marketing" footage. I also agree that the depth wasn't there the way it usually was.

Sammy Harris

I'm perfectly fine with sponsered videos. I genuinely thought it was a good video and I learned a lot from it too. As long as sponsered videos don't interrupt the normal cycle of your own videos, a sponsered video is a win-win: Extra Veritasium for us and more money in your pocket to keep doing more high quality videos in the future. LinusTechTips actually did a nice segment on one of his livestreams explaining how they go about doing sponsered segments. I think maybe posting a short video talking about how you go about doing sponsered content would be a good idea to clear up people's misconceptions about why you do sponsered videos. Thanks again for your videos and keep up the great work!

Jana Simmons

I don't mind sponsored content.

Daniel Turner

Patreon support is a form of sponsorship and thus Veritasium content is somewhat steered by our feedback, it's just our diversity of views that weight the outcome more favourably than a single donor.

Martin Holeys

in my opinion Patreon is what helps with a steadier income. I don't mind sponsored videos as long as they influence just the topic (meaning the videos are still in an interesting topic and non-biased = mentioning the sponsor is fine, but the information you give should not be of commercial nature) If having patronage monthly rather than per-thing allows you to pick and choose sponsored videos and set your own terms with sponsors, Im happy to pay monthly. But keep in mind I'm a person who loves patron and I support several artists and projects, so paying monthly is normal for me and I don't even really notice if I was paying you this month or not. Also I always cap on 1 payment per month anyway..

Mo Hassan

To be honest, I was beginning to switch off and scrolled down to read the comments, just as the video was ending. I'm sorry. There just wasn't enough substance to the video - I was expecting more, I suppose (your previous videos have been consistently good!). Seemed a bit like an introduction to the next much longer in-depth video on electric cars. You can't please everybody whilst doing what's right for you though. Thanks for the shade ball by the way!

Jerrad Pierce

Yes, but it was top-ten reasons electric cars are the future, not "let's compare the two in great detail." Not that that wouldn't fit the channel, but that's not what it was billed as. Sure, "rare earths" and battery recycling are issues, but I don't think there's any need for people to hyperventilate about them, especially when the counterpoints of petroleum extraction and refining (look up Cancer Alley) are rarely noted. Nor, for that matter, are all of the metals that end up in the air due to braking (diminished with EV) and catalytic converters (which use rare and expensive platinum group elements).

Michael Lloyd

I don't mind the sponsorship, I get it, this is not cheap to do. It takes a lot of time and resources. I chose not to watch it because I don't believe in it. I posted a comment, taking care not to beat you up (it's your channel). I wish you would look into the petrochemical industry from a strictly scientific point of view. Due to patents and legalities that may be harder to do than I imagine. I work for a company that has production and midstream assets (ie feed stock not petrochemical). I'm not afraid of electric cars. I love the idea. But the energy density gap between batteries and hydrocarbon fuels cannot be closed by efficiency differences alone. Battery tech is going to have to drastically improve before electric cars are more than a rich person's toy. The cool thing about that is that battery efficiency drives the industry to make the internal combustion engine more efficient and cleaner.

Stefan Grunspan

I watched the video and read the comments here and on youtube and can't reconcile one with the other. I don't see a problem with sponsorship in general and with this video specifically. It's not like you choose a car manufacturer that has no presence in the electric market. Your videos (in the six years I have been watching them) have monotonically improved. Some videos are an inch deep and mile wide like this one. Others explain how transistors work. I am only sorry that I only discovered patron a few months ago as I would have been supporting your work all along. Keep up the good work.

James McLean

The only thing I would be against would be a failure to communicate truth and to be forthright about the Sponsorship. Otherwise, I have no specific objections to sponsored content. I always felt that your channel has had a good focus on education and this video was no different. shade ball #3714

Srdjan

My first response was going to be that I generally don't mind sponsorships, and so far for your videos it was the case. But then I watched your last video, and it really bothered me. For the entire video I was wondering, what was said because of sponsorship and what was not. It certainly did not help that the video was all about the positives. I mean, the car does not emit CO2 itself but manufacturing of them does and according to Adam Ruins everything's video people should not suddenly all sell their cars in favor of the electric ones. Secondly, gas might be cheaper than electricity now, but if we make the switch, then it won't probably be true anymore. Generally what was missing from the video was the other side, some concerns about the electric car and what would happen if we all switch to them. At the very least more counter arguments to the most common criticisms. I still don't mind sponsorships, but I don't think they should be connected to the topic because that's what makes people wonder, especially if the video is fairly one-note. I don't think anybody would mind if BMW sponsored your shade balls video. Alternatively, product placement may be an additional revenue worth pushing a bit more. If you drive a BMW to get to point X or use specific brand of science equipment. As long as it's unobtrusive, I think it's ok.

Jeremy Schwartzentruber

I have no problem with sponsored videos. I think that comes down to a) I trust *you* to be skeptical and authentic, and b) I trust myself to detect whether sponsorship has made the video into a spin piece. But it's obvious that lots of people feel differently. For example, I'm friends with a well-known scientist who has gotten grants from an organisation with explicit religious ties. Even though he has complete freedom in the research and results, and I trust his integrity, a lot of other scientists think that it's wrong to take that money no matter what. So it comes down to whether you think that sponsorship will allow you to produce better content and to increase your audience, or will alienate too many people. I don't know how much money is involved from either sponsorship or e.g. patreon/Youtube... but I would bet that, assuming you feel that sponsorship isn't truly affecting your integrity, you'll have at least as large and interested an audience if you continue doing sponsored videos. Sponsorship should always be stated up-front, and people will get used to judging for themselves whether they feel the sponsorship has tainted the video in some way.

Appropriately Awkward

Thank you for being so thoughtful towards your viewers. I personally can't stand most ads, which is why I pay for YT premium to support creators instead. As far as sponsored videos go, I usually don't have a problem with them, as long as the content is still entertaining. I will always give a creator a try, and if the sponsored part bothers me, I will just skip part or all of a video, but it generally doesn't come to that if the creator still treats viewers with respect! :D

Leon Schutte

Mine arrived last week :) thank you!

Kevin

One of my favorite educational videos recently was 'The Glass Age' one Jamie & Adam did for Corning

Veritasium

I don't think there was any actual stock marketing footage, but I guess the stuff we shot had that feel to it... And it was a short video so agreed on depth.

Martin Holeys

As far as the bmw video goes: I don't mind that its almost solely about bmw, but that is not how I imagine a non-biased sponsored video. Here is why: 1) While the facts may all be true, they are not in an truthful context. You dont mention a singe downside of batteries or electric vehicles that we are still facing it today. Thus making your video basically a commercial. Which is said. I am all for electric cars but I prefer informed public rather than manipulated. There are CO2 emissions, from making electricity, or manufacturing solar panels, the ecological benefit is mostly less emissions in cities. There isn't as high demand for electric cars so currently the lithium production is way higher than needed to make car batteries. 2) The last line in a speculative video like this should be a question, not a questionable statement 3) While you might be interested in electric cars, the video doesn't show. Its clear to see this was a work for you, not a passion. 4) I dont care that as a patron I didn't have to pay for this video. I think it is unfortunate that it took your time you could spend making something I'd be happy to pay for.

Veritasium

Thanks Aaron, I appreciate you sharing this perspective.

Rimuru

You should take advantage of opportunities to not only make videos you like, and we like. If it still meets your standards, then shill out and get some green man. If you made this video the same as had, but lost money, then that sucks and could hurt your future video production. Making money now from a sponsorship is how that ball keeps on rolling, especially in case of hardship

Veritasium

thank you - this was my perception too

Veritasium

yeah, that's pretty much how I feel about this video. So it's something to consider more deeply.

Michael Aichlmayr

So, most things I would say have already been expressed by others, lack of depth, slight bias towards the product, etc., but I happily watched it. I support you. At the same time a little concern crept into me about the possible impact this might have on the future. Will this mean Veritasuim will never do an in-depth video about battery technology, the pros and cons, the environmental impact, cost of battery replacement and how that impacts this overall price of kilometer/mile. Maybe you'd never do that video anyway, but I worry something like this might take some future videos off the table.

Eric Kennedy

I have no problem with you doing sponsored content occasionally so long as you note that it's a sponsored video and that it conforms to the scope and mission of the channel while never promoting a product or service that goes against your values or against reason (anti-vaccine, flat Earth, etc.). I have no doubt that you would never compromise in this way. Do what you need to do and take advantage of good opportunities when they present themselves. :-)

wolph

One possibility for a future video could be to show the other side of the equation. The environmental footprint of the car production.

Sam O

I dont have a problem with sponsored videos but the BMW didn't feel like a sponsored video it felt like a commercial. It felt like BMW told you what to say and you said it. If it had been a regular veritasium video and maybe the last minute or so was the ad part I wouldn't mind. The head and shoulders video was better I thought

Winston Moy

I like the topic of the electric car video, but I think there are a lot of places where it didn't feel as in depth as you could have made it. 5:39 is way too short to cover your points. I want to see some of BMW's research, or new products, not the lame i3. I want more substance understanding car dynamics, torque. This is a perfect opportunity to collab with Engineering Explained. What about safety, being able to engineer an architecture without compromised for routing a powertrain... (maybe BMW is a terrible partner on this front as they want to modify ICE architectures which will never be as sturdy as a Tesla's frame, and their execs have conflicting narratives on the role of electric in their future...). Anyway, I felt this video lacked the deep-diving quality I've come to expect from you given how rich this topic can be. Sponsorships aren't bad, but this was on a topic that so many people feel passionate about, and you only scratched the surface of the numerous talking points that I already knew most of. I know it's easy for me to say this, but I would have preferred if BMW agreed to sponsor a whole series on this subject.

Strawberry Puptart

I have no problem with sponsored videos, and I absolutely understand the need to have stable income, but I would comment that the BMW video was specifically out of character for Veritasium. If you weren't in it, and providing narration, I would not be able to distinguish it from something an ad company might produce. You're best videos are ones where you explain something novel about the world, or provide insight to something normally hidden. This video told me something I could have learned on BMW's wikipedia page. What would have been better if you could have interviewed some of the engineers and chemist working on electric vehicles, or maybe had done a demonstration of the electric and chemical energy in Lion, and Lipo batteries.

Jase Smith

No problem with sponsors - but yes, this felt like a little bit like an infomercial, not as much depth as you normaly put in. I still enjoyed it though.

Porta

Thanks for the nice gift :) Number 4442 (or regarding on the handwriting 4uuZ) xD Thanks a lot for your work <3

Chris

Echoing what a lot of people had said: I am all for you doing sponsored content that you are really into and dig deep for. Heck, I am happy for you to double-dip and charge me for a sponsored video if it is your usual high quality. Seriously, I want you to make plenty of money, feel secure, and keep doing great work you love. The problem with the BMW video was not its sponsorship, but its content. It just felt flat. :( It was not as in-depth or interesting as a usual Veritasium video. That said, everyone has an off day at work. I look forward to your next video - whether it is sponsored or not!

Christopher Coleman

Sponsorship is fine, but only when it is done with the normal video quality. The reason people are calling this an ad was because it really lacked your personal touch and normal polish. It felt like a commercial you just happened to be a part of.

Josh knauer

I appreciate everything you do on your journey. I like seeing your style of videos change over over time. I loved the shade ball perk as a patron. I’ll support you no matter what you have to do in any way I can. Keep up the awesome work. Thank you!

Shelby Barlet

Totally ok with sponsorships (As long as it's clear in the video that it is sponsored.)

Thom neale

Sponsorships work when they are clearly demarcated from your signature own content. “And now lets take a 2 minute break from nuclear fusion to talk about the best brand of toothpaste.” Or a video “how to blow things up with nothing but toothpaste and dynamite” would actually be pretty hilarious, where all the toothpaste is the sponsor’s brand. In contrast, a whole video “science proves buzz (tm) toothpaste gets teeth whiter” would be an unforgiveable act of content millery. This comment probably wasnt helpful..... to summarize, TAKE THE MONEY YOU FOOL. Then do the toothpaste and dynamite video!

Michael Austin

I am totally fine with sponsorships as long as it's made clear in the video that its sponsored. I have expierienced youtubers in the past overdoing it and it limited the scope and scale of their their content. It's really cool however if/when you get sponsored by a company to go somewhere

Dlaynee

I appreciate you wanting to ask us so directly and quickly after your video went live. As far as what you should do, I think transparency and honesty are what most people want in a content creators. However, there is a lot that factors in managing a YT channel, and with that a lot that people don’t realize. It is very expensive for a science channel of your status and I think with that you do need to protect yourself by taking sponsorships. Being transparent with a sponsor is priority #1, and if it matches the quality of content, plus adds value for your channel down the road (flights, equipment, additional employees) then you need to do it. I would like to think that your core followers and those of us who support you on YT and Patreon are intelligent and empathetic to recognize that. Keep up the great content and do what you need to do to keep your channel as awesome as it is!

francois Gagnon

The problem with that, is the fact than if you wanna talk Against something you were paid for before, your kind of strangled, i love your video for the fact that i like what you say because of all the research you do and you tell pro and cons, but thoses are not objective

Light ReLeaf

Well said, Chris! These are my sentiments also.

Veritasium

OK, I think this is the reason I decline any sponsorship I am explicitly against. My question to car companies has always been 'can we talk about electric cars'. Usually the answer is no. Here the answer was yes, but I think I failed in the execution...

Veritasium

OK, I'll always try to make it clear.

Veritasium

what's funny to me is that it had a lot of polish - the graphs were all custom made. We searched huge data sets with python scripts. The music in places is an original score. Anyway, it's my fault I didn't hit the right tone with it and address the things people really wanted detail about.

Veritasium

Thanks Chris, and let me warn there is another sponsored vid in the works but it has clearer divisions between sponsored sections and content...

francois Gagnon

Actually, i didnt watch the video yet, i understand the need and the help it can give. but maybe you should get some sponsoreship that are not about A beautiful subject as electric car or any subject that we should expect you to talk in the futur.Subject as this one or other where you can have some problem because of some contract that restrain you to talk about. Like , for me, taking sponsorship like a Website, who sells VPN, or more in this context, sells monthly access to libraries of book, of any subject and scientific, kind of ''audible'' and kindle subscription. in that case, i don't see where can be any of those problem. I dont think that being sponsor is bad, just taking more General sponsor. (Sorry , i'm not really great to explain my point in english, still need to enhance my english level ^^)

francois Gagnon

I mean, you can also take some sponsorship of this kind, that would be great, if you got a clause where you can also tells the cons of the technology, telling the sponsor that you public like to have each side of the medal. Know how beautiful is that technology, but you still need to tell what are the actual problematic with it, because it is kind of ''going against the fundament of your channel'' maybe? anyway, i'll continue to look forward your amazing video, watching your documentary that i've baught and be waiting for new knowledge from you! Signed: mister shade ball 526 :)

Veritasium

Here's the thing, I would never make a video about BMW electric cars being better than everyone else's, I would only make a video about electric cars (every brand's) being better than internal combustion engines as a technology. Since this is a technological battle and not a brand one I didn't feel it was too salesy - the points work for all other electric cars too... But this was shortsighted because people clearly interpreted it as all pro BMW.

Veritasium

that's an interesting perspective. I think having a negative experience with this video does make me not want to go near the topic again. On the other hand it makes me want to come back and answer all the criticisms being levelled at me. This is kind of like what happened after my 'climate change is boring video' when I came back with '13 misconceptions about climate change' to address all the specific questions raised...

Veritasium

I think this just comes down to me getting it wrong. BMW gave me free reign to do what I wanted to and this video was it. The point was not to say that BMW is amazing but to say that electric cars are great (and BMW is now making more of them)... Anyway, I clearly failed to deliver the depth that viewers expect.

Michael Krugman

Your integrity, commitment, and the quality of your production are unimpeachable Derek. Be confident in your judgement on what's reasonable and appropriate ... we certainly are. Do whatever you think best to garner as much support as possible through Patreon, partnerships, and sponsorships. You'll make the very best of it, I'm sure, while remaining objective, unbiased, and true to your excellent moral judgement and cause. You have many, many appreciative beneficiaries, and I certainly count myself among them! Much obliged!!

Veritasium

Hmmm... interesting. I think they just wanted some 'influencers' to share images from their event and I was kind of ticking a box for them but I failed on my end of making a compelling video for my audience...

Veritasium

That would have been good! If only we could have arranged something like that

Veritasium

I think a lot of these are good points. I guess the main point of difference is that I didn't see this as a video about bmw. Yes, all the cars in the video are BMW's (except say the lunar rover or original Mercedes gas car) but for me the video was about electric cars, which is why I was comformtable being so positive about them. Because I am genuinely that positive about them. So in a way it wasn't work for me. It was personal, but I missed on delivery and therefore everyone thinks this was the brands influence. I think this was an unfortunate confluence of events...

Veritasium

No problem Mo. Yeah I thought keeping this video short was the right way to go. But in hindsight I should have gone more into depth.

JKB

Martin Holeys

Im happy it was fun for you! ..unfortunately your extreme positiveness made it look a but 'fake' i guess (might be also me watching it knowing it's a sponsored one and thus seeing it that way) Secondly my point about not mentioning any negatives stands. Even if you're passionate about them (and I'm too, I'd like to be one of those people who will only ever own electric (I didn't have a car yet)) but there are still some downsides worth mentioning ;)

Ethan Noyes

Absolutely take the money when the opportunity arises. As you said yourself, this is a very precarious career you’ve found yourself in, one that we all would love to see you do for years to come. At the end of the day, you need bread on the table. Sure, what all of our opinions are do matter, but don’t sacrifice your security and possible wellbeing because a small portion of your fan base gets upset. Those people aren’t your true fans anyways, and will likely be the first to leave should any major changes happen in the future. The true fans will continue to cherish the immense level of dedication and quality you bring to your product.

Eric Kennedy

I’m thrilled that you did a video on electric cars. Please don’t shy away from making another video on them. If anything, it sounds like the majority of patrons wanted MORE on the topic. You said in other replies that you insist on focusing on electric cars in discussions with automakers about sponsorship. You clearly are passionate about them. Run with that. Consider creating a video that goes in-depth on the topic and unabashedly demonstrates that passion. I love your content and your engagement and I’m proud to be a patron.

Hunter Ratliff

Reading through some of your responses to other comments, I think you already have the right approach to sponsorships: Only accept them when they don't require you to go against your own beliefs, can be used to make a video about a more general idea/topic, and aren't a compromise in terms of video/subject matter quality. I think that last part may be the most difficult. I imagine most of your original videos start off as ideas that can be developed and cultivated in whatever direction you see fit. If the idea ultimately doesn’t pan out in a way meeting your own standards or criteria, it can be scrapped/shelved. Sponsored content, like the BMW one today, provides you with a set amount of material from which you must develop a video around. Of course, as was apparent with the electric car video today, you had extensively planned out the video before going on the trip so that you could get all of the shots required for it. Regardless, I still think making it feel as if this constraint is not present at all (as it’s not in your original videos) is remarkably difficult, and viewers can sense whether an idea was formed organically from scratch or was molded around a preexisting topic given to you externally. I thought the electric vehicle video today was good and was certainly pro-electric car rather than just shilling for BMW; I think you did a good job of taking advantage of a sponsorship opportunity without making the whole video a big BMW ad. Though, I can easily see how people could perceive it as a BMW ad given that much of your footage is of BMW electric cars. I also felt that you probably would not had made this video if not for the sponsorship, and that is probably what put off a large number of viewers. Also, I think there are two other things outside of your control that could be contributing to the negative response. First, I think electric versus combustion engine cars is somehow a polarizing/political topic for a large number of people, so this video would’ve really irked the anti-electric people out there. (Though, I would like to believe that your general viewer-base would be pretty heavily skewed in the pro-electric direction.) Second, I think there is some psychology around when people are more or less likely to click the dislike button. If a video already has more dislikes than whatever threshold a viewer perceives as normal, it suddenly becomes much easier for them to hop onto the dislike bandwagon, lowering the bar for what is required to get them to click the dislike button rather than just not rating the video or clicking Like instead. Anyways, thanks for the excellent videos, and keep up the great work!

Kimberly Green

I enjoyed today's electric car video. Yes, it was sponsored & therefore had a shading to it. I'm an adult with critical thinking skills. I can think beyond. And I did! It made me personally ponder ... with all that freed up income (less moving parts to maintain, etc) what impact will that have on the economy & personal finance?

Carolyn K

Please continue making the same quality videos that we all know and love. I think you should continue to have sponsorship as long as it meets your personal standards as outlined in this post. The concern you have shown speaks volumes about your ethics.

Christopher Coleman

Maybe polish isn’t the right word. But it felt “bad” (as in quality, not morality) in some visceral way, not related to it being a sponsored video. Sorry to have that reaction after all the effort you put in

Andres Rosales

I trust your integrity and understand that this is your livelyhood you're talking about. Take these opportunities when they arise and keep making great videos.

Scott Lowe

Hi Derek. I think you are doing the right thing as you are currently. You should only take sponsored videos if you maintain editorial control and do not have to compromise your content. And you should make it clear upfront that the video is sponsored and by whom. Omitting sponsored videos from patreon support is also the right call. If I were to think a creator I was backing was using just as much advertised content with patreon backing as they would without it, I was cancel my pledge. With regards to the BMW video in particular, I wish I had watched it before seeing your message to give unbiased feedback. To my eyes, the content did not appear to have any significant leaning towards BMW. You were not trying to claim it was the best electric car, or state that you were going to buy one, etc. When talking about electirc cars, you had to pick a car to show, so used the one who sponsored the video. All BMW gained was exposure - more people now know BMW is working on new electric cars and maybe they should consider buying one. This may lead to more sales for BMW, so it makes sense for them. But also it may lead to more electric cars being purchased, which I think you would agree is a net positive (cars have a long lifespan and we can't turn renewable electricity into petrol very easily). If you hadn't been sponsored for this video, what would you have done instead? Not made it? Or made it and shown a car from someone who didn't pay you, giving them free advertising? Tesla get an awful lot of free advertising, because the brand is cool and trendy - if the content creator has a free choice of electric car to show, they will pick Tesla for the extra clicks the brand will attract to the video. I'm happy to see a video on electric cars that isn't also a unilaterally given free advert for Tesla for a change! I have a lot of respect for you as a content creator. I trust you to be honest, and to make a prominent correction if you make a meaningful error in your work. You are right to prioritise maintaining the high level of trust your viewers place in you. If you lose that trust, your channel will be negatively effected very quickly. What is the point in watching educational videos if you can't trust the educator? So what should you do? Certainly, don't make most of your videos sponsored content. Not that you were going to anyway. One thing you could do is add a sentence to the preamble pointing out you retained full editorial control over the content. Or if you didn't have full editorial control, indicate what the relationship was. Fact Fiend have made an entire video (actually more than one) explaining how they have never taken sponsorships because companies who approached them wouldn't give them 100% complete editorial control, and I believe this has increased the amount of respect their audience has for them. At the end of the day though, that creator-viewer trust is vital to you. You need to consider what level of risk sponsored content places on it, and what level of risk is acceptable to you. This is obviously what you're currently trying to assess. Good luck!

Michael Aichlmayr

I would love to see that 😊, but please also know that I did enjoy the video, and I'm not against sponsored videos. My issues were slight. I usually wonder things while I'm watching, and you almost always answer my questions like you know I'm wondering, and that didn't really happen so it felt different. I probably just have unrealistic expectations. 😅 Honestly, I almost didn't say anything, but you asked, and I felt I owed it to you to be honest. Your channel is one of the few I always look forward to whenever there's a new video. Do what you need to do to be who you are. I'll be over here making a custom stand for this awesome shade ball someone sent me.

J Garruba

Thanks for the great videos. My prefrence is that you grow the per video subscriber base so that sponsored videos are not neccessary. I understand the realities related to your costs, but I prefer to eliminate the middleman since I think the sponsors influence will tend to ruin a youtuber's credibility over time.

Veritasium

agreed! And if we could do away with parking lots, what could we do with the extra space?

Veritasium

Thanks for your very thoughtful comment - I will take this on board!

Veritasium

Thanks for all these points - the last paragraph echoes some of the thoughts I've been having. I think my personal pro-electric car bias probably gave me some blind spots when I was thinking through the topic...

Veritasium

Thank you Ethan! My personal commitment is to redouble my efforts to make great videos that I can be proud of and will satisfy my core audience and make them feel like sticking with me was worth it.

Veritasium

I agree - thanks for noting. I'll check out the buses piece!

Veritasium

Great video! Wish I had been working with you on the script.

Veritasium

Thanks Michael - I appreciate your support!

Ethan Noyes

That's always the best way forward. There's always going to be people who are critical only to be critical, without any sort of effort to be constructive. Your passion for your work is evident, which alone will keep a sizable portion of your audience watching. Keep up the good work, but also don't work too hard. That's something that's easy to lose track of nowadays.

Veritasium

btw this is a lot to live up to. I will endeavour to earn it.

Josh Grossman

Derek, I love your videos! One of things I love is that you go off in wildly differing directions. The only rule is that you be inspired by the subject matter. I do agree that this video missed the mark. It did have a tone that was less than brand agnostic, but I'm fine with that. However, there just wasn't enough depth to the material. There are SO many angles that are interesting here that it could easily become a series, but do concentrate as you did on the top 10 reasons electric cars are inevitable is also fine. The part of your video that dealt with the top 10 was short for my liking, leaving me wanting more depth. Here are some that I liked on the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VyZOLMeMYnI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RhtiPefVzM

Dragi Raos

I don't mind sponsored videos. While there was nothing wrong with what you said in the BMW-sponsored one, it was a bit, umm, constrained. In "historic intro", you didn't mention the first, hastily killed EV1. You also skipped mentioning the company that dragged everyone else, BMW included, into the third millennium, kicking and screaming, Tesla. No mention of the proliferation of startups, a phenomenon unheard of in modern car industry. No mention of the phenomenon of Norway with 50% EV market penetration. So, your video was correct, but drew far less complete picture than you usually do. I just was another video sponsored by BMW, one on "moral dilemma of autonomous driving" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBjY3QGNdAw), which did not suffer from this shortcoming. You had a simple message (one I wholeheartedly agree with) and delivered it effectively. Sponsorship was not "felt". BTW, more directly vendor-focused videos in another subchannel, like those with Mercesed (I just watched the one on Distronic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jWvOtgQpHuo) are OK, IMO. Not exactly in your vein, but simply a piece of good journalism.

IcyMidnight

I just watched that Electric Cars/BMW video after I saw your Patreon email and you asked for feedback so here's mine :) RE: video feel The video itself does feel a little off of the usual Veristasium flavour, but I don't think it's because of the BMW sponsorship ingredient. E.g. it's one of the shortest of your recent videos (11 out of your last 60 videos are < 6 minutes) and the video seemed less in-depth than I'd expect of the normal Veritasium video, mostly because of the quick top ten list at the end. Did it get made more quickly or with more/different people than usual? I don't think it was a bad video, but it's certainly not your best work. Granted not every video will be your best, and I don't expect that -- I wouldn't normally comment in this direction but you asked. 😜 RE: sponsorship I'm not opposed to sponsorship in general, though this style of sponsorship is a bit more difficult to get right. E.g. in a video about shade balls, a pre-roll ad for an auidobook seller is easy to see as not influencing the content. In a video about electric cars, sponsored by an electric car maker, where the sponsorship and content are fundamentally entwined it's not so easy. At the very least you have to watch the video with a critical eye towards bias. Do I think you appear biased in this video? Nope: you talk about pretty general stuff. Did the sponsorship affect the way that I watched the video? Yep, a little bit. Do I think you shouldn't have done it? I think it's fine. In general, I don't mind sponsored videos (as long as the sponsorship is explicit) and I think that if they make sense to you, you should still consider them. It might take your audience a bit of time to get used to this style of sponsorship. Some of that time might be the audience building trust in you to navigate the different relationship that you have with your audience when an advertiser gets involved. Maybe you could do a video that simply directly addresses your approach to sponsored videos for people to refer to? On the one hand, we patrons are here because we think you should be able to make a living doing this and sponsorships achieve the same goal. On the other hand maybe part of the reason some people want to support you directly is so that you're free from brand influence. Your brand could be summed up as "science and facts" so when you bring corporate influence into the mix, it does kinda dilute things a little. So, yeah. I think that sponsorships are fine as long as it's clear that you're only saying what you want to say, but you combined an introduction to sponsorship (at least I think it's an intro... I don't recall if you've done many sponsored videos before) with a video that didn't work as well as your normal videos do so you're probably dealing with a bit of a skewed reaction.

Cynthia Oude Geerdink

I don't mind the sponsored part, but the part where you said electric cars produce no carbon emission misses a huge part of the chain where it is produced. People are throwing away single use plastic before using it because it's bad. Or they buy package free but then don't bother to check how much packaging was used before the item got to the store.. and they throw away their perfectly good car to get an electric one.

Daniel Harris

I very much agree, not so much an issue with the sponsorship but just with the flow of the video.

Maximilian Radig

I also don't mind sponsored videos but i disliked this one because quite a few of the points you mention are not differentiated. E.g. "you can charge at home" that anoyed me the most. Why? i live in an appartment building, so i have no private parking space. So i couldn't charge at home. I also have a parking space rented in in a different garage, but i don't think that the owner would invest in a electric outlet for charging as i pay only 50€ a month.

Michiel Ladenius

I also didn't like the last video. It did come across as almost pure greed. I know that wasn't your intention though. It felt like that because you only had good things to say about it, and because there was a heavy focus on BMW. It just didn't feel honest anymore. It felt like they prepared a script for you and you had to read it. I think it would've been better if you stated the current positives, the things that aren't positives, ways we could improve those aspects and how those aspects really are when they've overcome those hurdles. Maybe it also would've been better to keep BMW out of the picture during the video. Quickly mention them in the beginning of the video and keep the sponsorship to the end where you tell us what they've been doing in order to save the planet.

amir titi

i just got mine, thank you very much for the awesome content and that little souvenir

Noel Braganza

Hi Derek, first of all I don't think there's anything wrong with doing sponsored videos as long as you are in control of the editorial content. For one, the BMW video was short and sweet, but it was different from you usual videos and story telling. I liked how it started, but then somewhere it became a bit plain. Information I already knew and have read about on various different websites. I think it would have been interesting to also get into the details of the lithium ion battery and how charging, predictive battery data and other challenges will influence the electric car industry. It would have been nice to learn about some crazy stuff being done with this technology not just relevant to BMW, but electric cars on a whole. That being said, please continue to create your own videos as well as doing sponsored content. But I would imagine that you should treat your sponsored videos just like you would treat your own videos. I love how you story tell and i think you should just find an angle even in sponsored content that is new, insightful and thought provoking. I will continue to be your 'patreon' as long as you keep making videos. ♥️ Ps: I've been following your story and your videos from many years back and I think you're one of the best storytellers on YouTube. Thank you for being inclusive, honest and such a great teacher.

Vincent F

Well, why not putting all of this in a public video, explaining why you are sometimes making sponsored videos ? If this can help you doing what you love, who cars ? Haters gonna hates. Let people not look at sponsored videos, maybe by putting it somewhere very readable, and everyone's happy no ? I have to say I went here for the shadeball, but I very like the insight on your work. I keep the subscription ! Thanks for everything, for making the world a better place, for giving and sharing knowledge !

IcyMidnight

The more I think about it, the more I think that quickie top ten list at the end of the video is what did you in. You could have easily done at least 1-2 interesting minutes on each of the items on the list. Also, if you watch it in a certain light, it can read like a marketing checklist even if it isn't actually. The first three and a half minutes are pretty classic Veritasium, but the part that you remember after a viewing is the, less than two minute, Dave Letterman top ten list at the end.

KB42

I wouldn't mind sponsored videos if sponsoring enables you to produce in-depth and differentiated content with no or minimal bias towards the sponsor. In this case I don't feel this was the case. I can truly say I have learned nothing new about electric mobility from watching your video. This may be because was am interested in the topic beforehand but I think you went for low hanging fruits with this one. One major issue I took was that you did not talk about the reasons why we need to switch to electric mobility and another was that you did not talk about the future of electric vehicle technology, meaning what potential energy storage and drive technology are on the horizon. Self-driving cars will surely change our view of transportation but that has not very much to do with their drive technology.

Bram Steenbrink

I really hope to get a shadeball, I had some problems with my PayPal, so my pledge went trough very late. Thank you for the great video's and all the work!

Jean

I wouldn't do sponsored videos where the sponsor is in an industry in the same field as the topic of the video, because the suspicions and risk of bias is very high. Sponsors could just be a completely orthogonal field to the video topic itself, which is what many youtube channels do.

Dániel Horváth

Many of the graphs you show are truncated! This is a type of misleading graph, meaning that the y-axis is does not start at 0. These graphs can create the impression of important change where there is relatively little change. Even the advances that you are showing is amazing, they are not *that* amazing that these graphs try to depict. Avoid using them, especially in ads, since they question the reliability of your whole advertisement.

James Hoopes

I don’t generally have a problem with sponsorships if, as you did, they’re made clear to the viewer. This is your channel and your decision, but if it were me, I would use sponsorships to do something I might not ordinarily be able to do. For example, a five-part series on electric cars. The sponsorship might, pardon the expression, afford you the opportunity to go into a depth on the subject that you might not ordinarily be able to. This video wasn’t that kind of exercise. It felt light to me. So in a sense, it felt like a missed opportunity. In any case, as long as you don’t start producing kitten videos, you’re stuck with me as a viewer and Patreon.

Moritz Latuske

As many have pointed out, sponsorship isn't bad per se, but there's always the risk of leaving an aftertaste (warranted or not) or to get caught up in whatever recent negative turns that sponsor may have taken. I'd say sponsorship is best where it gives you access to places and people you otherwise could not have reached, while being transparent about it. Not doing any, at all, ever, is unrealistic and you can't make everyone happy all the time ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ If people won't take your word for it that a particular sponsor had no editorial control they probably won't trust you with no sponsor attached either. That said, the test screenings you sometimes do here on patreon may have been a good idea in his case.

Jochen Kunz

I am OK with occasional sponsored videos, if they are made to a reasonable balance. I think you got that balance in the BMW video. It is a bit shallow and has its flaws. (Like graphs not starting at 0 which distorts proportions. Charging at home is not possible in an apartment like I live in.) But the flaws are not related to the sponsorship. You did not overly endorse and promote the products of the brand. You clearly stated the sponsorship. You stayed reasonable neutral to the actual topic of the video. Also such sponsorships may give you a peek into the inside of a company, that you may not get otherwise. After all you have to make a living and cover production cost. YouTube and Patreon may not cut it all the time.

Mark Tea

Ohh i did not realize the addresses were per patreon. =O Interesting.

tdh

I thought the video was fine. It stands out compared to your other videos, and you'll probably not gain subscribers from it, but if the money allows you to improve your other videos, then it's a trade-off that may be worth it. You could have put more effort into it to make it seems less like an ad, or you could have put less effort into it and made it obvious that it was an ad, in which case people would probably just skip it. Either way is fine.

Destyrium

My opinion is that you should never post a video that doesn't meet your standards. I watch a video of you around once a month when it is something I am interested in. If that is a sponsored video I don't mind, but don't flash logo's and adds in my face. Just say I made this video together with ... and use their product in your video, but don't highlight it.

Jay Khandelwal

I remember seeing this thumbnail of your BMW video, but I skipped it just because the content didn't look familiar to me, now after watching this post I went back to find it and I can say that there was something wrong with the thumbnail, as at the time of scanning through the videos on my feed I was not able to recognize that the video is from Veritasium. I think this would have happened with most of them. Even when I take a look at your videos tab then this particular video's thumbnail doesn't blend in.

G Medina

Yo. I’m not gonna act like I don’t know that sponsorships might create a bias. That’s on me as the viewer to fact check the info. But this is a natural process of all new science information, sponsored or not. I decided to trust in you before signing on as a patron. Being labeled “commercial” is illogical thinking of nineties music fans. What do they want? “Underground” scientists to live off honor and pride for “sticking it to the man?” C’mon fam. Think. Think! You stay true to yourself. If you need a sponsor, then get a sponsor. I’ll let you know if your sponsors make me lose cool points in front of my trendy friends.

Nando

"I think I failed in the execution..." For what it's worth, I see an important difference compared to a similar video you did not so long ago, about dandruff (of all things). This was sponsored by H&S, but I remember being fascinated by the research, which you did a great job of presenting. And I also recall thinking (1) wow, great Veritasium content, as usual (2) man, if all ads were like that, I wouldn't be using an adblocker. Here with BMW though, we didn't get to see BMW's investments, their passion and commitment, you didn't get to talk to their researchers, or if you did, you didn't show it... Like others have already commented, I don't feel like I learned much. The historical part was interesting, but you could have done that without BMW. In short, I don't mind at all you producing ads, I'd even like it, as long as your sponsor and you get me excited about the science in their products.

João Gouveia

I think it is absolutely fine for you to do sponsorships. You have already the right mindset with it. Try to have control and avoid biased content. I did feel your BMW video was a bit "poor" but I don't think it has necessarily to do with the sponsorship. It was there so people will of course blame it. I felt the video lacked information of the other side. I don't believe there are solutions that just immediately fix all the problems and introduce none. And certainly electric cars aren't without problems. The video didn't discuss these things. It just said hey look EVs are the best, period. No other solution available. I think it makes it seem there's a very easy and obvious choice for everyone and things aren't that simple. In that sense I felt the video lacked discussion and didn't really give a lot of information. It would also be nice to, for example, take the opportunity to discuss hydrogen cars. But please don't think I'm saying it's the worst thing ever or anything. I still think overall you did a good job as always and I'm looking forward to see your future work. :)

Adrian Ritchie

In my mind the sponsorship wasn't a problem with the video. However, as others have said, it did feel somewhat shallow. There were so many avenues left unexplored and it was very one sided. This view is based on the high bar that you have set for yourself in your other non-sponsored videos. You could take this as an opportunity for non-sponsored follow-up videos exploring the areas that people here think need addressing.

Sarah Giavedoni

I've followed you online for several years, and my pledge is a support of your scientific journey, not the videos per se. If sponsorships are a part of your long-term business model, I trust you to manage them ethically and professionally. I appreciate how clearly and openly you handle your sponsorships.

JVDL

Dude, you've been making great content for the past few years, if you need to add in a sponsored video here and there to be able to keep doing that, then go for it! Haters gonna hate, sadly, and for some reason YouTube seems to be a place that makes people feel like they can do that more so than other places. If you don't want to watch sponsored content and you decide that you're going to keep watching a video that in the first 5 seconds states the sponsorship, then that's on you. Like you said, ultimately nobody is making anybody watch videos they don't want to watch.

Nick

I'm a family doctor. In recent years, people have become concerned about doctors taking gifts from pharmaceutical sales reps. Rightfully concerned. Influence is insidious. If they are giving you money, what are they getting? Be sure that you know what you're selling. It may be your good reputation.

Vincent Zalzal

I was about to say the same thing. In a nutshell: the video was too one-sided, but globally, I'm okay with sponsorships as long as it's clearly stated and not overly biased.

thomas

I don't mind Sponsored content. But I would say a more in depth look at how the "sponsor" makes the car self driving, would be more in line with the channel and resonate more with wat your audience expects. That's wat my thought was when I saw the video. Ultimately this is your channel. If you want to do sponsored contend so the next video will have a higher budget. Please go ahead

Candice Sheaffer

If you can find sponsorship for your content, that's great. It is not cheap to make high quality videos like the ones you make. I love your content, that is why I support your channel.I cannot grasp how someone will accept professional athletes who make millions of dollars to play a game have the right to get sponsorships but small business owners, or YouTube content creators, cannot. It makes no sense to me. Keep up the great work and don't listen to the haters.

Maksim Chistov

It would be great if you'd mention somewhere in vode description that patreons don't pay you for sponsored videos :)

Daniel Toll

I think to be clear about what is sponsored by whom is important. That said: I did not mind the sponsored video at all. It did not feel like a "sellout" and it was clear to me that it was sponsored...

Heavy Q

Sponsored videos are totally fine when they make sense. It's when you have something like, a video about dinosaurs, and then the sponsor is a cereal company. It doesn't make sense. I've seen a lot of YT videos that are like that and it sorta boggles my mind. This video was perfectly fine. If people don't want to watch, well then that is their loss. they are missing out on some great content.

Saketh Kasibatla

I wasn't gonna say anything because everyone here already covered my points, but I felt I had to after reading the comments. They were snap reactions, without very much thought. I personally have seen so much journalism on Tesla that it was refreshing to see something about another car manufacturer's EVs. Nothing wrong with sponsorship, and don't worry about those comments.

Orevelos

Having been to the BMW museum in Munich (and liked it!), I recognized a lot of what I saw there in the video, which is "a" history of electric vehicles, but not a complete history or future, so talking about the future of EVs while only talking about and showing BMWs, it's just not the whole picture. As for the criticisms of downsides of EVs, I think doing a video about "Here's the benefits of EVs" while also saying in the future you'll address the downsides of EVs, would go a long way.

Jonathon Wyza

In this case the one area that really felt the most like marketing was the concept cars in what appeared to be a tradeshow of some sort.

killergege

No problem with sponsored content, as long as that it is well disclosed (title, description and at the beginning of the video), and that the contract keep you free to express yourself.

Daniel Wisehart

I have no problem with you doing sponsored videos so long as they are close to the theme of your channel. If you were doing sponsored videos for a commercially interesting product that has nothing to do with an area of science or technology that interests you, then it would not be appropriate, I think. Let someone else cover the latest in women's fashion and make a sponsored video on what real world benefits there are to genome mapping, if that interest you. Full speed ahead.

Steve Ford

Like many others, I have no problem with sponsored vids so long as it is communicated. Which yours was. I'm not sure why there was so much negativity on the youtube comments. Some of the suggestions are good ones and would have added to the value of the video, but IMHO it would not have raised it from poor to good. (I thought it was already good, and the suggestions would have made it a little better.)

Kevin Cable

No issue with sponsored videos as long as it is clearly communicated, as you did. I read through comments on the electric car video and it seemed many were upset that the video didn’t go into the science as much or as in depth as viewers are used to.

Jeremy Hankinson

I don't mind sponsored content. YouTubers have to do what they need to in order to make ends meet, or to allow their channel to grow. You state up front that the content is sponsored, and you still keep on track without trying to essentially do a sales pitch. On the flip side, this isn't a channel that is making a dining room table and as such you are being sponsored by DeWalt for all your tools. This is an exploratory and science based channel, and doing sponsored work has the potential to limit the point of view for the audience. This video was sponsored by BMW, and as a result we didn't see any of the work being done by other companies that are also pushing fast and hard on electric vehicles. Sure, we got a neat little history lesson (would have loved more of that by the way) but the rest of it centered around BMW. This is just speculation, but it feels like you had to leave out a lot just because you couldn't feature other companies and/or brands due to this being sponsored.

Matt Dunlap

As with most of the voices here, I think sponsorship in the way you're already approaching it is fine. One recommendation I'd offer is to revisit your goal statement. "... in depth, high quality, and on subjects I'm passionate about" seems to miss that the content has to be interesting. Perhaps you're implicitly rolling that into "high quality", but I think it warrants calling out. So you're passionate about the subject of EVs, sweet, me too, but why the future of cars is electric is obvious at this point. Sure, I know way more about this particular topic than Joe Schmo, but with Teslas silently zipping around all over the place, and auto pilot famously being misused and killing people it's pretty common knowledge where the industry is headed and why. That you can recharge from solar at home is also pretty old news. That EVs have a long and interesting history is cool, but if that weren't so it wouldn't change the present or the future, so in some sense it's a history lesson instead of a science lesson.

Lukaluke

I'm just flatly opposed to directly sponsored videos. I'd rather have an isolated and cordoned off section of the video about your product than an entire video of product placement. I wouldn't go so far as to call anyone a sellout or immoral for taking a sponsorship, it's money and people gotta eat. I just question how easy it is to segregate the content from the money. Say that electric cars are the future but that the design of the BMW is flawed because the battery housing is near the bottom and thus is susceptible to speed bumps and tend to blow up. Would that information which is technically not about cars in general be brought up? If not, why not? Was it simply outside the scope of the work being done? If so, that’s harder to believe because they are paying you to make the video, so it feels suspect.

Veritasium

Good opinions. Yeah I'm mainly seeing that sponsored or not, I didn't nail it with this video. The fact that it was sponsored led many to suspect that was the reason for the failing. But really it's all on me.

Veritasium

haha yeah, so in a way I was constrained. Specifically BMW wanted shots of their concept cars in the video. And frankly I didn't mind - they are electric cars. But when I was talking about electric cars, I was talking about all of them. I wasn't just talking about BMW. Sure the cars I was showing were BMW's because that's what the sponsor wanted but the positive things I was saying were all more general, which is why I didn't feel it was too branded. Obviously I got it wrong as the message many received was 'BMW's are making lots of great electric cars unlike anybody else' which was not my intention...

Veritasium

Thank you for these thoughts and your support. It's good to be reminded of them. STORYTELLING - I should write it in big letters on my whiteboard...

Veritasium

Thanks for your support! Yeah I've been thinking of addressing this publicly for some time. I may make a video on my second channel (2veritasium) about the dilemmas I face when making videos and why sponsorships are still important.

Veritasium

I hear you. I mean one thing I'm seeing from people is they wanted a different video, ie on a topic that was not the topic of this video... I think some of this reflects the tight time horizon I had for the brand, constraints of what I was allowed to mention (no other car companies), and the lack of access to engineers who could actually talk through the details. My sense was that making something short that delivers on my genuine positive sentiments around electric cars would be the best way to go. But clearly this left a lot of viewers unsatisfied and suspecting there were more nefarious motives behind this short summary video...

Veritasium

You weren't on the first list but if your address is in patreon.com/pledges I can probably mail you out one in the next week or two...

Veritasium

yeah this is a good point. Then you have to decide whether you want many orthogonal sponsors or just a few suspicious sponsors. Personally I feel like some of the sponsored work I've done eg. Head & Shoulders has not been too bad because they gave me access to scientists and labs who are the experts on these topics. I think viewers can make up their own minds about how much to believe people in the video or me in those videos. If something feels wrong to me, I just won't do it.

Veritasium

This is a very good point and one to not for future. The graphs were done by my new editor/animator and I thought they looks beautiful. Plus, in my mind they were just there to show a trend. But you're absolutely right. They should be better scientific graphs...

Veritasium

Thanks James! Now I have to ditch all that kitten material I've been preparing...

Veritasium

definitely would have been a good idea!

Veritasium

Thanks Jochen. I appreciate your understanding. Your perception of the video is the same as mine.

Veritasium

how so? Oh, per pledge. Have you updated yours now?

Veritasium

haha I think a lot of effort was put into it, which in hindsight made it seem like an ad. Because we invested effort in renting a car and drone shots rather than talking about the challenges of lithium mining... Anyway, it will definitely help with making future videos and being financially sustainable for a long while.

Veritasium

Thanks Sarah, and I appreciate the faith you put in me. I will endeavour to earn it.

Veritasium

They are giving me money in exchange for showing their concept cars, and other cars. Mainly I was brought in to film some of their vehicles. They wanted a video about their event. I said 'no, I can't make a video about your event because that's not what I do. But I can make a video about electric cars, which is something I want to talk about and I'll put some of your electric cars in the video.' And there you go, that's what happened. My conclusion is I didn't do a good enough job of making the video and people assume that's because of undue influence but really it's on me...

Veritasium

Thanks Thomas. Yeah I think part of my thinking was, look if people are gonna complain this is an ad, at least make it short. But that was a bad instinct to follow...

Veritasium

Thank you Brian! This is really important to hear right now - I appreciate it!

Veritasium

Thanks Daniel, I feel the same as you, which is why the reaction caught me by surprise

Veritasium

I'll keep this in mind - thank you!

Veritasium

haha yeah, when you're sponsored by a brand, you're explicitly told not to mention or show competitors. Nike is not going to support a creator to feature Adidas. And I get it, and I hope the audience gets it too. Of course there is a bias because that company funded it. At the same time I wrote the script and they didn't interfere with anything I wanted to do.

Mark Tea

Ya I thought just setting it in Patreon was enough. But yes it’s now updated!! :D

Mark Tea

I guess that lets you give your address to people you trust and not just to everyone you pledge to

Marc Selman

To me it really did not feel like a sponsored video. It was an interesting overview of the history and future of electric transportation. You mentioned BMW sometimes but definitely not like a car commercial. I really liked the ten points summarized and the conclusion about sharing vehicles. The topics of the environment and climate etc. are very hot at the moment, everybody has an opinion and not everybody agrees. So I think that's also a reason a video about electric cars that only shows the positive sides could receive some negative comments. If there was a channel that ONLY made sponsored videos and the videos were as interesting as this one for example, I would subscribe. Don't feel bad for making money. You seem to be very thoughtful about everything you do and sometimes thinking too much about something could create unnecessary doubt about things. Keep doing what you do, trust that if you do, people will support you. And thanks for the shadeball!

Niko

I have no problem when you are doing sponsored videos if you can do you script in a way which you a are comfortable with. so if there are not too many limitations from the sponsor. but then i expect the same quality as many of your other videos. indepth and inspiring. i remember when you did a meet and greet in vienna austria where you said that one of your goals for live to make "epic videos". i hope you didnt forget this. because as long as you try really hard to make epic, indepth, philiosphical and inspiring videos i really dont care if there are sponsored. but please try to impress you fans but maybe even better, try to impress yourself with each video! thanks derek !

Dragi Raos

Hopefully, they *sell* their perfectly good (shall we say, still usable) ICE car to buy an EV, displacing a sale of a new ICE car or allowing someone who can't afford any new vehicle to own one. The lifecycle CO2 footprint of ICE vs EV cars has been nicely covered on several channels, taking into consideration factors such as battery size, durability and "second life" use, the source of electricity in particular region etc. (E.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RhtiPefVzM - recommended) But, I agree, it warranted a mention in Derek's video.

Dragi Raos

Thank you, Derek, for taking the time to read all our often repeated comments.

Sven Mueller

The only part of the video where I was thinking that it felt a little bit too much like a commercial was when you listed the BMW plans (leading up to the "23 electric vehicles by 2021" or whatever it was). It felt a bit too much like promotion. Those 10 seconds put aside, the video was mostly what I expect on your channel. At the end you said that when charging your EV via PV, it doesn't produce any CO2. Which seems misleading, given CO2 footprint of their production, of their maintenance (tire replacements, cleaning, ...) etc. - Not too far off, but felt weird, given your usual attention to such details.

Sava Kovalenko

I'm ok with sponsored video as long as you keep the good stuff coming. And obviously make sponsored video close to non-sponsored ones in terms of quality. The BMW sponsored one was nice, but could have been better.

Dániel Horváth

They do look beautiful though! I liked them. Also I received my shade ball which I am very happy for! Thanks for it and the amazing content you create.

Jim Cruwys

Hi Derek, I thought I would show you something that may help you with this decision. Tim Ferris also had a similar test recently but the opposite way to you. He was testing a crowd supported model rather than with sponsors. I think that you could use sponsorship in a good way that can actually add value to your audience if done the right way. Here is his post about it if you are interested. https://tim.blog/2019/07/11/why-im-stopping-the-fan-supported-podcast-experiment/

Michiel Ladenius

Well, I personally didn't feel like the message was 'BMW's are making lots of electric cars unlike anybody else'. To me it sounded more like BMW just told you to say these things regardless of if it were the truth or not. And since you only had positive things to say it all didn't feel honest. I did believe the things I already knew, but I was instantly skeptical about the new information. The heavy focus on BMW throughout the video gave me the impression that you just said what they wanted instead of the truth.. I also want to mention that I really do appreciate your honesty here on Patreon. And in the end you've probably learned a lot from it :)

Nigel Cammann

There is nothing wrong in itself with the occasinal sponsorship. Provided that you are clear and honest, even better if you can retain editorial control. Keep up the quality. Keep the subjects interesting. I remain a patron and am happy to keep supporting your content.

Mr. Hunter Jones

I appreciate that you are sensitive to how sponsorship affects not only your editorial freedom but also the perception of the viewers both actual and potential. It is necessary for you to manage how the channel generates income and you must weigh the benefits and consequences of various methods. In the end you must decide how to balance the content you wish to generate against the money the channel receives. It should be apparent from the large support group through Patreon that your judgement in this matter is trustworthy. I will continue to enjoy and appreciate your work knowing that you are aware and focused on how to balance these things in the future. Hunter

Michael

Sponsored videos are fine as long as the sponsorship is communicated transparently - which you did. So overall there is no problem. However, with the BMW video specifically, I disliked the huge amount of product placement of fancy BMW cars or concept studies throughout the video. An additional issue was the (compared to your other videos) low depth of information. To me, the video felt less like "We sponsor your video for a little name-dropping and you showing our logo" and more like "You make an ad for us and put some filler content in top".

Michael Braun-Boghos

I don't mind sponsored content if it's unrelated to the sponsor's product, for example when Skillshare sponsors your videos. A BMW-sponsored video about dandruff or a Head & Shoulders-sponsored video about electric cars would also be fine. The problem is when the sponsor and the content exactly match, it feels like an ad, and I think you should avoid this in future videos. In this day and age where science is under attack worldwide, we rely on scientists and science communicators like yourself to be the paragons of empiricism, impartiality, and reason.

Andrew Gobsill

Gday Derek. You don't need to defend your decisions mate. I'm a Patreon because I like your videos as I'm not just entertained by them but I also learn from them. Knowledge is invaluable. Ads are everywhere in media. We have to accept them for what they are, revenue raisers. You need money to live and make content. So be it. Thanks for making your vids and keep up the good work.

Veritasium

This is a really important point and a challenge because doing aligned sponsorships generates significantly more revenue than not-aligned. The outcome being, you can do more unaligned sponsorships or fewer aligned sponsorships. In the case of BMW, I really did want to say what I said about electric cars. I wasn't saying it about BMW electric cars, I was saying it about all electric cars. And this topic wasn't even their idea. They just wanted me to show some footage from their launch event...

Veritasium

Thanks Andrew, I appreciate your support and understanding!

Veritasium

My pleasure Marc, and thanks for writing this note. I really do view my Patrons as my board of advisors so it was important for me to check in after what is possibly my worst-received video ever (at least as measured by likes/dislikes). Personally I didn't think the video was that bad. A little short and lacking detail but not overly branded in my opinion. But as you say there are other reasons why people reacted so strongly and I think that helps explain a lot of the reaction. Anyway thanks for your thoughts and ongoing support as I work through this.

Michael Braun-Boghos

I believe you. Doing more unaligned sponsorships seems like a good compromise, as it would allow you to generate more revenue for your fantastic channel while avoiding the uncomfortable feeling of mixing science and direct advertising. With aligned sponsorship, at least some viewers will always have that bad feeling, no matter your good intentions or research into the subject area. In any case, thanks very much for starting this thread and considering all our feedback.

Ivan Gomez

+1. You are free to do what you judge is the best course of action, and you don't need to apologise or defend your decisions (though it is nice to read the reasons behind them). You might be the "survivor bias" definition but I completely trust your decisions. (you always communicate your sponsors, transparency is key for all content creators). For me, being a Patreon is a way to directly support the people that I believe they deserve, and I think we all do. Maybe our opinion as patrons is not in like with the average opinion out there on the internet but I don't mind monetized youtube videos, ads, or sponsored videos, even if I've already contributed in a small % to them. Regards to your family, hope you are all well.

frerk saxen

In general I have no problem with aligned sponsored videos. However, the BMW video lacked a crucial point: The drawbacks of electric cars. I felt puzzled when the video ended because you only mentioned positive points about electric cars and no negative arguments. I suppose this supported the belief of some that you've been bought by BMW.

Cristian Consonni

Hi Derek, first of all let me say that I appreciate your work a lot, what you do is amazing. On the subject of sponsorships, I don't mind sponsorships as long as they are clearly stated and I know you have editorial control. Of course, the problem about this video is one of perception. I think it may help if you can have long-term sponsorships I think it would be better, I can think of two scenarios: * they support you for a long stretch of videos on a variety of subject * they support you for a special project that needs resources or expertise that the company can provide and otherwise it would be impossible to make the video The point is that in both case we see that the company is committed to the channel and to support you in creating content. They are not just "paying for an ad". This may speak to the fact that personally I would like to see something good come out of ads and not just publicity for the sake of it. Even if it not a continuous sponsorship, if think that a recurring one from time to time is better than a one-off for the same reason. On the subject of the video, I am probably biased by my own interests, but I think that you may have misjudged how much this argument is already talked about by the general public. Admittedly, I don't have hard data about this, but I have already seen several videos on the subject even in channels that usually have nothing to do with cars or electric cars, not to mention several articles in well-known outlets. Just to take two examples Wired[1] and The New York Times[2] have an entire category of articles dedicated to EVs. For this reason, your decision of listing "just positive things" even if it was done with a clear goal in mind and wasn't your intention, may have come across as simplistic. [1]: https://www.wired.com/tag/electric-vehicles/ [2]: https://www.nytimes.com/topic/subject/electric-and-hybrid-vehicles

William Campman

I don’t have any problem with the video being sponsored by BMW in theory. The issue I took was with the quality of the video. Most of your videos are 10-13 minutes long and explore a fascinating educational topic. The electric car video was 5 minutes long and didn’t seem to provide an explanation for any of the points it was making. Yes, the brakes on an i3 wear out less because of regenerative braking, but how does regenerative braking work? Electric cars are leading the industry in autonomy, but what advantage is giving them this leg up? What changes in manufacturing and design led to the decline in LiPo costs? Without any science or learning the video just felt like you said “car good” and left it at that. I would have been disappointed in the video regardless if it was sponsored or not, but to have a sudden drop in quality for a directly sponsored video felt like a quick paycheck grab.

Veritasium

Thanks Ivan, I think the people here are the most invested in what I'm making, which is why it's important to me to check in - thanks for your support!

Veritasium

haha yeah, but the truth is I'm not sure BMW really wanted me to make that point. So really it's all me but I get how if people didn't know that they'd think of these as BMW talking points...

Veritasium

Agreed - I definitely misjudged where the audience is at. Thanks for your feedback!

frerk saxen

True, but I think much more important is how much you censor yourself because you want to please your sponsor. Nevertheless, please keep in mind that the internet is not a nice place. If one video hasn't been received that well it's no big deal. You have so much great content. Don't stress yourself, make a pause and do something else before you make any conclusions regarding sponsors.

Erez Atir

You are the best! Just keep doing what you love and feel passionate about. Your video are AWESOME and no sponsorship can affect that!

Ben

In my opinion, sponsored videos are fine and very necessary, but it works better when the sponsorship is aligned with the target audience. I suspect that not many veritasium viewers are in the market for a new car, but things like CuriosityStream and Audible are perfect for this audience as they have content in the same vein. The various home cooking services are another example that has a wider appeal.

Uri Rothschild

first of all thanks a lot for my shade ball. i love it! and so do my kids, and my brother, and my neighbours, and my friends :-) what a feeling to actually hold one. regarding sponsorhips: i'm not gonna lie and the BMW video had sort of a different feel to it and the "bias" as you called it could be felt a little. but it was a great video nevertheless. and i'm sure your existing followers can very well understand the genuine messages and trust you that you would never say something you didn't truly believe in yourself. if a new viewer can make that distinction or have that trust... i don't know. i guess that's part of the deal when you make sponsored videos about a product of the sponsor itself. then again you might find new followers with such topics (e.g. if someone is looking into information whether to buy an electric car or not). so as you said yourself it's always a thin line and sort of a trade off... but the way you are doing it is in my eyes the right one in the long run because in the end you can keep going, invest in equipment etc. so we, the viewers, benefit in the end. the other sponsorhips like "audible" etc are not to worry about in my eyes. they clearly have no affect on the content of the video and everyone who watches such videos on youtube must know the deal by now. after all we are getting great content for free. no one can expect that you just forgo making money with these clips. or better said: everyone who stops to think about it for 10sec will see that they'd rather have these sponsorships than pay for the videos :-) in any case thank a lot for all the great content and regards from sunny switzerland!

Mark

I think sponsors are great and good just if it ties in with the rest of the video :P also Your videos are Amazing :D

Andrew Newhouse

I haven't read all the other comments; not sure if I'm repeating anything. I think people should realize that sponsorship does not imply ownership. Becoming a sponsor allows YOU (as content creator) to do your best at making videos; it doesn't give me (as a sponsor) the right or ability to dictate what you do or how you do it. I understood that when I signed up, and I think your descriptions are clear, but maybe people misunderstand that relationship?

lesto

PSA: is not enough to have your address in patreon, you have to hover on your profile picture (top right) -> my mebership, and select the address for each specific creator. Just found out, hope im not too late to get some fun with the balls ^^'

Veritasium

you probably just missed out for the August shipment (I exported the list yesterday). But there will likely be another in September.

Angus Harms

Hey Derek, I live in Australia and my ball hasn’t arrived.. so maybe I missed out..??

Clayton Reid

I think that you can and should do sponsored videos, but only if you believe the sponsor won't censor you, and I know that you have a strong moral compass, so just create what you want, I love your stuff man!

Andreas Lindhé

Like some others have commented, I have no problem with you doing sponsored videos. I trust you to properly disclose any deals involved, and that you wouldn't tell an outright lie just because you got money to do so. The issue for me was just the content. Having point after point with overly simplified arguments like that, draws the simplification to a point where it feels disingenuous. It almost slides into what I perceive as propaganda. I happen to be of a similar stance as you, when it comes to climate change, EV's, etc. But despite of that, I really do not like it when someone tries to "score a few easy points for the team", so to say. It's fine to have an agenda, and there is no such thing as an unbiased presentation/video/lecture etc. But I expect more of you than simple "top 10-videos" of arguments that are mostly true. The slogan of Veritasium is "an element of truth", and I think it's fair to say that you pitch the channel as an educational channel with it's basis in science. But facts used in arguments for a good cause is not science, even when they in-fact bear an element of truth. And regarding the simplifications... Simplifying to the point of saying "electric car don't produce any CO2 at all, so they don't contribute to climate change" is incorrect. They most certainly do contribute to climate change, and I know that you know this. So why on earth would you say that? That's not helping anyone, that is just trying to sway those who do not know better. I would have loved a video where you explain how emissions are estimated, in a full-chain analysis from primary energy to end-users, looking at the different efficiency that each step has etc. Even a brief elaboration like you did in the comment to the video ("Electric cars produce more CO2 to manufacture than gas cars - but they compensate within 1-5 years by being more efficient and producing less to run") would have been fine. Or something about the inequality issues that makes good EV's inaccessible to anyone but the top 1% of the world's population (and that's not even a topic relating to natural sciences). But we got none of that. Just "electric cars are the best". In part to prove a point, but also in part to give you some concrete ideas, I'd like to just say one short thing about each of the arguments. #1 "More torque." Why? #2 What goes into "better handling"? Take the opportunity that you have when collaborating with an industry leading company, and interview one of their "driving handling"-engineers! #3 Cool, tell me more about control systems! #4 Why are some vehicles so noisy while others are quiet? #5 Why have the long-haul industry not converted to electric yet, if that's the case? #6 This one is, in my opinion, _really_ interesting when you look into the end-to-end efficiency from primary energy to forward motion! #7 Tell me all about power spikes. Or why the grid does not shut down every time someone plugs in a new thing that draws power. #8 Why is regenerative breaking better for the breaks? #9 (Already discussed this above.) #10 Why would electric vehicles have an advantage over combustion engine vehicles for autonomy? One of the videos you have made is the best one you have ever made. Another video is the worst one you have ever made. This, of course, is necessary. So don't worry too much, but listen to what people liked and didn't like, and I'm sure you'll figure out a healthy video format for future videos -- sponsored or not. Thanks for sending me a shade ball. Cheers!

lesto

Nice, thanks for the info! And really thanks for all the great work you are doing, I really think your work will make a difference in the future of our society. Just wait all all those inspired youngling coming out of school and tarting a new golden age. One can always dream, I guess.

Simon Marquardt

I would prefer a strict barrier between content and sponsor advertisement (I actually already do not like native advertising, e.g. when the presenter of a video/podcast also reads the ads, sadly that has become quite normal). Imho it already is problematic, when the sponsor has influence on the topic of a video (or even worse when the sponsor dictates it). But there is a threshold between journalism and advertisement, and the BMW video definitively crossed that. That was an advertisement, not a journalistic piece. (Mentioning the sponsoring and that the sponsor paid travel expenses is an ethical obligation, nothing more.)

Julius Petter Flem

Thank you so much for the shade ball Derek! Ball #513 arrived today in Gold Coast Australia, and I am so happy. In the video you mentioned that you numbered the balls yourself at first, do you have any idea of how many you did? Hope you have a great day! Cheers

Toby Spark

Thank you! Just received ball #3313 that made its way to Russia. :)

Daniel Vaz

I agree almost fully with Andreas, and he did a great job of writing what I felt about the video. I have absolutely no problem with you having sponsors. Actually, I am really glad that a big car company like BMW is willing to sponsor EV content and invest in it. It's a good sign that things are moving in the right way. As to the video, I enjoyed the first part of it: it had some good historical information, and tells us how the technology has progressed. My issue is with the top 10 list: I feel like I didn't learn that much from it, as it was mostly stuff that I already knew, and it was covered at a mostly basic level. There will always be some people that will dislike the videos just because they are sponsored, and I don't think you should really listen to them. Sponsor or no sponsor, if the video is good, people will like it. That is all that matters. Thanks for the sending us the shade balls, and thanks for all of the great videos. Your channel is one of the few that I make sure to follow and keep up-to-date on.

Corin

This is what I came here to say. I've got no problem with well disclosed sponsorship as it was in the video. But the content was just not close to the usual level for Veritasium. Could have been so much more informative.

PETER17$

mine Belgium

infernap12

Just got my shade ball in Adelaide #640

Rex

Got my 3639 ball the other day in Taiwan!

Carlos Valdez

Got my ball #75 in Mexico City. I was arriving home and the post office guy was just leaving it!!!! Thank You!

Tina

This whole shade balls story was an opportunity to reconnect with your channel : ) I could not find you then one day you appeared on trending! 🙌 YouTube is your career and I understand it as such. For you and your channel to grow and flourish you need funds. While patreon is a good platform, who am I to tell you to reject sponsorships. If your sponsorships were misleading, this would be another story but they are not : ) We can clearly see your passion for video and science along with the idea of sharing your knowledge with the public: That's a 10 out of 10 ! I am glad to have finally reconnected with your channel and support you through patreon. Thank you Derek!

DALE HORNE

Derek, first off thanks for the ball. I do not think I have been so happy to see a ball from another guy.

thomas

hey man just watched the starbux ad. this is exactly wat I had in mind. its an ad but still informative. i like it

DALE HORNE

....as for Sponsorships, you have to do it if you want to continue forward. Your audience is pretty sharp. As long as you keep making great videos, people will not care. Sure you will lose some viewers, but you can use that money to make even better videos. Joe Scott on Answer’s with Joe is to me an excellent example on how it should be done. His videos greatly improved when he had extra money from sponsors. Sure Patreon subscribers should drive topics, but they cannot fund everything. Joe’s sponsors allow him to make more live streams and such to stay connected to his viewers. After all without viewers, it’s a moot point. Again, let Patreon help drive topics and let sponsors help drive reach. Thanks

Pandora

I had my address wrong and just fixed it, I hope I wasn't too late @_@

Benjamin Tabb

Love your videos! Thank you for your passion in making engaging, interesting and educational bits! Just added my address, would be honored to get a carbon ball from your swimming pool. If it’s not too late :) Thanks again and shine on.

Kaliko Jakson

<3 You my dude. Ball #6966 arrived in Perth, Austalia. Exciting!

moirail3112

Shade ball #4055 has arrived in Mandurah, South of Perth, Western Australia <3333

Matheus Ferreira

Shade Ball #4128 arrived in São Paulo, Brazil! Thanks, Derek, I'm very happy :D <3

maxime

#4006 From france so happy thanks you so much !

Tyrion Terence

Australia reporting. We have received shade ball #635, over.

Adam759

#8120 arrived today in Bolingbrook, IL! Thank you so much! They are heavier than I expected!

Steven Leung

Still waiting on my shade ball but UPS hasn't been helpful in tracking since the tracking number doesn't work after UPS initially packs the item and hands it over to USPS. Also I think sponsorships are important if they enable the creator to further their goals and to create better content. I only think sponsors would have a negative effect if they don't agree with the creator's ideas.

Veritasium

you'll likely be part of the September mail out

Veritasium

I sent out a ball to you in the first mailing... did you get an email with tracking info? Maybe check your spam

Steven Leung

DFTBA has been very helpful and has agreed to reship the ball. Hopefully it arrives soon. Pretty excited to see one in person :)

Leah Howard

I received my shade ball and absolutely love it! If you’re ever doing a live talk please let us know on Patreon, I’m sure many of us would love to attend! Much love from the UK

Wouter

Just received a shade ball! (#1854) Did not expect it because I joined quite a bit after the project, so was pleasantly surprised! It did not fit in our mailbox so was delivered to our local post-office for pick-up. The lady at the counter was quite confused about it, a ball containing liquid!? :-) The ball will get a nice place at my desk, thanks a lot!

Jiyeon Ryu

Number 1881 arrived in Canada :) Thank you so much!

Stefan Vuckovic

Hey, I was out of the country for 2 weeks and my ball got sent back to sender, would there be any way to resolve this? I would pay shipping and all

Francois Nel

#4505 arrived in Centurion, South Africa!

Andrew

#5229 in Russia!

Michael Ganzer

#(S/4/8)289 arrived in Dresden, Germany. So happy to have a physical connection with one of the 7 billion people in the world I like the most! :)

robert + pug

Anyone got there's in Scotland yet ?

Jon Snow

i got mine and I'm from Australia

Stefan Vanya

I still haven't got the shade ball :-(( Czech Rep.

RaenBoow

I'm from Sweden and I too have not received a shadeball yet, though I'm not sure when it was supposed to be delivered?

Kostia

The ball #8132 received in Ukraine. Thank you very much! How much time does it take to sign all balls?

MadMike

Are there any balls left for little me in Sweden? :)

Daphne Vorbrich

I had forgotten I had requested a ball until I saw my pledge on my credit card statement. If there are any left go ahead and send it my way. By the way, you are doing a wonderful job doing what you apparently love so there is nothing wrong to ask for support. One can only imagine how much time labor and cost it takes as well as a whole lot of personal love. If I were a teacher your videos would be in my classroom for sure even if it would come out of my pay!! Thank you

MadMike

Sure, I'll pay the toll and postage :D How much is it?

Lari Pöhö

Hello, I havent recived my ball to Finland :C

Ilic Sorrentino

I have received mine in Italy, thanks! I didn't believe it!

Jeff B.

I got it #8965 thanks :) loving it...

Gregor Shapiro

November 16: No delivery to me in Sweden yet. Will it come? Or am I out of reach, beyond the Heliopause?

Thomas Jerslund

I have the same question, I also last checked my mailbox 16 November. From Denmark.

Tina

#4531 arrived full and safely : )

Gregor Shapiro

December 2 and so sphere in sight...

Riley Kipp

Anyone from Canada have received their ball? I haven't yet

SunKee Hong

Hello, New Zealand here, I haven't received one yet, still waiting :)

Ruth Barth

Hello! Are you still sending Balls?? I really want one!

Deadly Shaun

Hi Derek, I still haven't recieved mine. Are you still shipping them?