Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Here is my next video, in which I try to make liquid nitrogen from scratch:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/quznd0pbbxmfunc/LiNi%20Wed%20night.mp4?dl=0

The video is sponsored so it gives me another chance to 'get it right'. I think this one is significantly better in that the sponsored sections are clearly delineated and most of the video obviously has very little to do with the brand.

Please only provide feedback here and don't share this link or any comments publicly.

Thank you!

Derek

Files

Comments

Bahadir Celik

Hi Derek, thanks for the video. I think the video looks very reasonable, well explained both by you and Alan. It is so nice it's a dull sponsored video, looks like you truly liked the science behind the drink. Appriceated

Smidt

I like that there is a clearer cut between the parts refering to the sponser, and the parts you made youself. But i found the two parts sort of disconected from each other. The making on liquid nitrogen, was super cool, but the connection to starbucks is missing, maybe if possible, show how starbuck makes their nytrogen on-site.

Sebastian Pontow

I agree, the sponsored sections are not distracting from the (awesome) content. Although I really hate these "*tries product* Hm, thats delicious" kind of ads :D Here in Germany those are not quite as present^^

Mark Tea

That was fun :) It was a little unclear why your first attempt yielded 100+ ml. While the second much harder setup yielded what looked like a tiny amount. Maybe mention the second yield? Also maybe point out that the first one had oxygen and nitrogen so the second one was pure by comparasion. Also is there anything wrong with liquid oxygen? Is there a reason to avoid it comparatively to the liquid nitrogen? Is it just the flame risk?

Chris27208

The video on making the ice cream is noticeably lower quality. Is that by accident? You mentioned Starbucks makes nitrogen out of the air in the stores and infuses inline? Can you show a basic diagram of what a commercial unit would look like for this? I don’t think that’s very well known so cool it know more about. Very cool video!

Matze Bob

Hey Derek, my general thought on patreon is that people want to support you for your work, sponsorships should be not considered as an interference. If I'd meet you in person, I might buy you a coffee, even though you would have no financial issue to buy it yourself. I see Patreon as this kind of personal way to say: thank you for your great work. Content wise a sponsored video should IMHO contain some reflection, pointing out disadvantages and negatives of the presented content if given. (See this as a raw 1.0 thought, not a definite answer)

Uri Rothschild

hey derek. cool video. maybe a bit long (though i'm not sure where/what to cut). no issues reg. sponsorship etc. a clear and unbiased statement at the start and at the end and the rest of the video is neutral. actually it's cool to se an actual connection between the science and the sponsor. enjoyed it a lot

Adam Colgan

Looks great! I'd love to know more about what Starbucks does with their production on-site. I don't mind at all the clearly marked sponsor stuff. It's tricky dealing with sponsorships, but this was handled really well. And incorporating science in with the sponsor, makes it more seamless and watchable.

Andy Brown

#3485 checking in! Not a comment related to the sponsership but that alarm on the Oxygen sensor went right through me! Maybe a pre warning or sound reduction on that would be sensible...

James Hoopes

I thought this was terrific! I learned a great deal, which is why I watch your videos. The sponsorship didn’t detract from the learning content. My vote is for more like this!

Mark Tea

I agree that thing went on for what felt like an eternity :D

Riley Willis

Significant improvement, the line between the sponsor element and content was far clearer. And nitrogen bubble hypnosis always helps.

LodeRock

I agree that the this video is definitely an improvement on the last in terms of sponsorships. I think it helps that there is one specific aspect of the sponsoring product that the video focuses on and dives into detail about rather than listing every reason why it's the best (which is what I think the BMW video got a lot of flack from). Great video, very enjoyable.

Charlie Spiers

I wish you explained more about how liquid nitrogen is made commercially and what its uses are before starting making it yourself. I also wish you explained more about how Starbucks does it, maybe with an illustration. I also really liked the explanation of how CO2 and nitrogen affect drinks differently.

Gary D

Great stuff! I've always been curious about that. It would be interesting to also see this scale. Does Starbucks pull from the air right at each store? That would be cool to see. There's a lot of meat here and the sponsor spot doesn't get in the way. I appreciate your transparency in finding the right balance between substance and what pays the bills.

Casper Leeberg

Very good video but missing how nitrogen is produced on an industrial scale!

Dim Simo

First of all, when the 3 hours of waiting for the liquid nitrogen happened the camera on you... was very blurry idk if you noticed that but i did, i dont remember the timestamp but its there, i think thats a great video to post it really give you a perspective on how far starbucks will go for just a coffee, im not a coffee person so i wont be having it so hope you thought it was great, also hope that patreon has given you enough money through supporters that you can pay off the 100 dollars you lost through the betting xD

Veritasium

apologies to all! We cut a lot of it but it's still very prevalent...

Veritasium

Thank you! I believe at most stores they get it from the air - it's cheaper and easier than using tanks

Adrien Eynaud

Today I learned something. I definitely liked the way you portrayed the sponsor this time. It felt like I was watching the good ol' Derek, and not some advertisement promoter. This time I could see the passion in your eyes, and the amazement on your face. It came across as more.. real! The oxygen alarm was slightly annoying, but you quickly forget that it ever happened. It would have been nice to see how the air condenses on the tip of the condenser. Maybe using a diagram? Same for how Nitrogen is condensed on an industrial scale. Thank you again!

Thein Lin Aung

This is a great video! The sponsored content and message just blend into the explanation. I wonder how you got all those machines :).

Raffaele Carotenuto

Hi Derek, as already pointed out I'd add more info on how Starbucks makes it at each store. Regarding the sponsorship aspects, it is well balanced.

Niko

i really enjoyed the video! it was interesting and funny. but from where did you get the cooler? can you just buy it at a hardware store or did you buy it used? i was wondering that because you just had it and used for your DIY project.

Appoxo (Moritz)

Wouldn't this mean, that the LN may be contaminated in crowded cities?

Ben Vlasto

This was great - you really got the balance between sponsorship and content so that it felt very authentic all the way through, especially because the adverts are clearly adverts. Thank you for the vid!

Dlaynee

I definitely liked this video more than the BMW video for a couple of reasons. But first, I feel like sponsorship videos are a necessary “evil” in the sense that you have to have money to make great content. I don’t feel like you have struggled (with inconsistencies) to bring great content so therefore it doesn’t bug me to see you take sponsorships. Your quality of content is very high and well produced. I think what you did better with this video compared to BMW was bringing more of the sponsorship into a learnable concept. I have dealt with Liquid Nitrogen, In the service industry, for 5 years now, and seeing how it can be made is really cool, plus knowing why a drink has the nitrogen bubbles falling is awesome. Always have wondered why it looked like that. Anyway, the other reason I enjoyed the video better was it is longer and more in line with what you normally do. The notes I would have with this video is tying how you made LiNi at home compared to how Starbucks does it. And if that was proprietary information, I think making some connection to how it is done commercially would suffice. Overall though, the video is great and what I have come to expect. Cheers friend! Thanks for being awesome!

Michiel Ladenius

I quite like the pacing and duration of this video. If he were to add that it would probably take too long or everything would be rushed. But at the same time I do agree with you. I think this would make for a great follow-up video.

Michiel Ladenius

I think this one is significantly better in that the sponsored sections are clearly delineated and most of the video obviously has very little to do with the brand. (I know this comment is plagiarism, but it's exactly how I felt about it.)

Greig Burges

I got a Shade ball today dude, #6122? ~Thanks

Nando

Just joining the chorus: great job, that's the right way to do it. Oh, and thanks for the shadeball #6202 :)

Jim Cruwys

I think you have done much better with this video as far as the sponsorship goes. I think this one works a lot better because it is clearly a sponsored video but I think the key with the sponsored videos is to allow your motive and that of the sponsor to be clear. Your motive in this video was to talk about making liquid nitrogen and Starbucks was to talk about and sell their Nitro coffee. From the audience this is much better because the sponsorship is obvious, but separate from your goal. I think the primary concern for the audience is where the motives of the creator and the sponsor are not clearly defined, and where they may be aligned in a way that may bias the message. I believe that this is what happened with the BMW video. Your message and the message of BMW were too similar, even though your message was noble, it looked too much like you were saying buy "BMW electric cars" even though your view was "Electric cars are the future". I think the best way to have these kinds of videos in future is to have not aligned but complementary goals for the video of yourself and the sponsor. Just like this one, you are talking about liquid nitrogen in an interesting way, like you always do, and Starbucks are in there with their message of “check this out, our drink has liquid nitrogen in it” and that alignment works.

Pieter Gosselink

Mute the sound, but add the beeps as subtitle :)

Pieter Gosselink

Good sponsor/content/sponsor sandwich. Most comment match already my feedback.

Pieter Gosselink

Got my shade ball, but I am on vacation, so it is waiting for me at the office. They are wondering what I ordered, as it it sloshing.

Leon Schutte

Where did you get the stirling type coldhead and how much did it cost? I am searching one for ages now to being able to afford experiments with liquid nitrogen. In germany its extremely hard to get your hands on liquid nitrogen...

Paul Looyen

Video was cool (ha). Curious as to how Starbuck generates the nitrogen, same principal but on a larger scale? They must go through a lot and probably need to generate or than 500ml or so in 12 hours. Agree with above, produce placement is clearly delineated. And thanks for the ball, it arrived yesterday (#4085)

arun

hi, i am a huge fan of your channel . As a suggestion i think using a green screen and removing/arranging the less useful objects in the room might be a good idea.. (PS: i dont know if it is possible.. but i always thought your videos looked neat and this one had so much material lying in the background)

crysal

I liked that you put a clearly visible 'warning' that the sponsored content was coming up.

Brooke Wilkin

great video!! i found it super interesting, and loved the touches of humour

Dragi Raos

This one is excellent. Two very minor quips: - Although you have "don't try this at home" warning, perhaps an additional warning of dangers of liquid oxygen (e.g. contact with grease) was in order - Few more words on how is this done on industrial scale would be useful. I hope that the sponsorship suffices to cover all bets you lost :-D

Veritasium

They only need to generate nitrogen gas, which I could do at a reasonable flow-rate. It was pumping the heat out that made my production very slow... thanks for the comments!

Jonathan Doyle

I'm not sure if the sponsership is so much of the problem but rather the focus of what seems to me a shift in presenation style. These last two videos feel a bit more like 'other youtube channels' rather than your usual brand of challenging a common misconception to activate slow brain (etc etc, as per your thesis and Kahneman video). Answering your question more directly: I didn't mind the sponsership in either video, but making a clear distinction may help (as you have done). The connection between the sections felt a bit forced, but I can't suggest how to do it better ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Veritasium

I bought mine off eBay... but I might be in the market to sell one soon ;)

Danil Tkachenko

I liked it! And yeah I am now curious to try that Starbucks brew :-) Though I am not a coffee-fan. BTW what effect does adding gas to coffee in terms of human metabolism? Does it speed up the caffeine intake? Just makes tickling sensation on your mouth? Anything else? Does the reaction of CO2 makes any difference? Since for e.g. alcohol they say it does have some effects other then some slight sour taste... I also +1 for the comments on the industrial side of nitrogen liquefaction and possible uses and dangers of having liquid nitrogen at home etc. Thanks for the shade ball! Got mine a few days ago. Should I send you a photo with some local landmark on a background?

Ian Beeblebrox

Wow, I didn't realize a cold head device existed, how much power does it use? I'm more curious about the process and device. Perhaps a video on the cold head and a video on you making ice cream from the product and the Starbucks cold brew (that I will try) but I didn't like the betting aspect. I enjoyed the video, thanks.

kukukachu

I thought is was pretty slick how you advertised for them, but the flow didn't feel affected in the video at all. Kudos.

Light ReLeaf

Great point! I'm wondering how this is collected for Starbucks; how economies of scale play into it. Surely they don't have this slower garage system? Who knows? I recon Derek does!

Light ReLeaf

Yeah I noticed Derek's style in this video has become a lot more mainstream and vloggy. This might not be a bad thing overall for his channel, but it's certainly less engaging for me, and possibly many other science-inclined folks who watch the channel.

Dragi Raos

Derek very clearly said at the very beginning that the video was sponsored by Starbucks. I don't think that anything more is necessary.

Dragi Raos

" feel a more like 'other youtube channels' " I agree. More like one of those many "DYI" channels - nothing wrong with them, but Derek is unique.

Mark R

0:20 through 0:30 seemed utterly cringeworthy. The science and creation part was exactly the kind of content I think we expect and value from you. 12:00 - Not all that interested in watching glam footage of a drink. If they're sponsoring the video perhaps they would have been kind enough to give you access to the systems they use to extract nitrogen to use as B roll. For the final sponsored spot, kinda get the feeling that "unique texture" was on the talking points list. Is it a personal endorsement you're giving and if so shouldn't you be displaying a notice that it's sponsored over that particulat section? All in all, the science and engineering part was solid. I'm no legal schollar, but shouldn't you also be mentioning the sponsorship *before* talking about the product for the first time?

Jozef Uhľár

If there is at least 90% of science and 10% of sponsorship in video that's still acceptable. Don't be afraid of sponsored video. People complaining has never been doing anything for money probably. They are going to work everyday for free :) ... Just be careful to not cross thin line between science and full advertisement because behind that line there is world you don't want to live in. Trust me.

Sam O

I'm sorry, but you have very bad ideas, a border around the whole video? Seriously?

Leon Schutte

Ebay is the place where i look most of the time :) that definitely sounds good! I'll be waiting for updates on this :D

FlamingFossa

I love the mad scientist vibes from this video. The sponsorship is fine. My one complaint that can't be fixed now but please try to fix in the future: Focus. The camera is out of focus a lot. Really enjoyable non the less.

Sigurd sonne

I haven't watched the video yet as im on mobile, but i think an important part of sponsored content is transparency, a good example is eric from commentiquette. Mention the sponsorship in tthe beginning, perhaps with a blurb that it gave you the oportunity or, excuse to do some engineering.

Nigel Cammann

I tend to agree with Mark Randall. The construction and science behind the concept was good. A little concerned over the lack of safety warnings and perhaps gloves. If that stuff touches your skin, that is going to hurt. Side note: Guiness has been using this system for years.

Rich Murphy

I thought it was well done. The sponsorship part was very subtle yet framed the whole thing at the same time. FWIW, it inspired me to get a nitro-coffee at SBUX this morning, not too bad.

Pattmyn

I haven't even watched this yet but my first thought was "Who the hell did he manage to get to sponsor this?!" since I can't imagine it's the safest activity on the planet. Looking forward to watching it now lol

muh

Regarding your safty warnings: It depends on what you're doing with liquid nitrogen, but as long as you don't pool it on your skin you can pour it over your skin without hurting yourself. If you get it on cloth where it can soak into it will hurt though. I think the "Do not attempt at home." warning should suffice, if anything I'd make it bigger and maybe even put it into the middle of the screen for the few seconds it's visible.

muh

Overall I'm quite alright with the way the video is structured. I also feel like some people are more critical than necessary just because it is sponsored especially about the parts that are clearly about the sponsor. I certainly want to try a nitrogen cold brew in the future now. I'm not positive on american law, but I think I remember from some other YouTubers and streamers that they're required in some way to state in the title of their video/stream that it is sponsored content for as long as it is actually sponsored. You could also put a slighly transparent SPONSORED in a corner of the video at least for the parts that are actually sponsored if it's not the entirety of the video. I know you've put a "Sponsored Content" overlay at around the 12 minute mark, but was it just that B-roll scene or from 12 minutes onward?

Korie Danz

The sponsored parts frame the video well. I really appreciate that you teamed up with Allen Pan in this video, I think it would be cool to see you do more collabs in the future :)

Kimberly Green

For your sponsored videos, use sponsor bumpers ... a broadcasting technique from times past. That way, you can dispense with the "sponsored content" text overlays and such. "Today's episode is brought to you by Starbucks brand Nitro Cold Brew in exchange for certain considerations. Nitro Cold Brew is produced by liquid nitrogen, straight from the air, to give you a unique coffee experience. But how do they get the nitrogen, and can I do it too? Let's find out!"

wolph

The sponsored bit of tasting the drink for the first time... that part felt really forced (probably because it is to a certain degree). If allowed I would try to move the tasting part further towards the end of the video. Somewhat in this order: 1. Keep the first part of the video the same, introduction, etc. 2. Tell that it's being sponsored and that you'll explain what it has to do with Starbucks later 3. The interesting part of the video of how you're creating liquid air. 4. At the end segue into the Starbucks part and do the first tasting.

Alejandro Lorente Pons

Good things: - Clear division between sponsored/non-sponsored content - The video shows the science nicely and the animations are good - Your friend is quite fun to watch Bad things: - When you taste the drink is a bit cringey - Sometimes the video quality drops suddenly - The beeping sound is a bit too much!

wolph

Specifically, add a little talk with the segue to the sponsored at 12:00 roughly. It would probably feel a lot less forced than immediately tasting it.

wolph

I would personally find it really cool (no pun intended) to see the setup that Starbucks uses to get the liquid nitrogen. That's probably much too late for this video, but I think it's something that would appeal to most of your viewers.

Zak Fuhrman

I agree with Alejandro that the beeping from the O2 meter is a bit too much. Mayhaps low pass or notch filter the audio in that section to help decrease the volume. Also, the video felt a little rushed at the end. After getting the new Dewar Flask, it felt like you were crunched for run time. That said, all in all it was another great video. Definitely made me want some cold brew. Guess I know what I'm doing before work.

Tony Charlton

Really enjoyed it, good to see Allen as have been a fan since seeing on MB and he is a good fit for a collaboration. I was a little worried at the start seeing it was a paid promo but then once the science started it fell into the veritasium I subbed for. The coffee tasting did come across a little too enjoyable but maybe you really did like it? :-) I will keep watching for sure if this is the standard to expect. Keep it up.

KB42

I like it. The sponsoring was not intrusive and I didn't feel the sponsor was pushing an agenda other than me knowing about the product. After just having watched the video I don't even remember if a starbucks logo was shown at all. I also like the collaboration with Alan very much. It really came across the both of you really had fun.

Bob Vogel

Better than the BMW one, which (to me) sounded like an 'Ad'. In the perfect world I'd rather not see sponsored videos... but sponsors provide money which allow expenses not otherwise practical.... :-(

Charles Bosse

First, this was 10x better than the BMW sponsored video. Much more doing things and talking science, and the end didn't feel nearly as forced or cliche. It would be interesting to do a nitro to carbonation (you could maybe get plain cold brew or let one sit and then soda stream it?) comparison, but nbd that you don't. It could be cool to break up the flow of the chilling and separating with some more science, or with some discussions of other refrigeration and cryo-liquification techniques (like high pressure jet, centrifugal air seperation, etc.) Also, you should clarify whether helium or just (heat) energy passes between the two sides of the cooler unit, and talk a little more about how expanding the gas once the unit has equalized cools the gas. By the way, gas coming out of a compressor is usually cooler for this reason and CO2 fire extinguishers can actually be used to make dry ice simply by using the right kind of bag to catch the output.

Charles Bosse

Oh, and a note on the Starbucks tasting. If you make less of a note of "enjoying" it, but keep the "flavor analysis" I think people will find it more genuine and actually be more interested in trying it themselves. I don't know if you have time but you can also talk about cryo-separation and why you ended up with (I am guessing) a higher percent oxygen in your first attempt than the atmospheric level.

Thongchai Kolyutsakul

I really enjoy it! I think it would be easier to understand if you can animate or illustrate why it work or didn't work (when you use the big gallon to trap the liquid nitrogen). I actually have a video idea suggestion. "Does drinking cold water good for you?".

Scott Lowe

Certainly not your best work, Derek. Sorry. I think there is no chance of this going viral. This is fine of course, as not every video can be your best and not every video is going to have many millions of views. (But you did say you were going to be going more "click-baity" and trying to feed the YouTube algorithm...? I guess you have two new modes of video production? Either a passion project you try to take viral, or a sponsored video?) I'm sorry, but I'm a harsh critic. I don't normally give harsh criticism to my friends, but if they ask for criticism, I'll give it to them. Anyway, let's see if we can patch up this video... What you need is to give more of a science motivation to the video. Yes, mention at the beginning that the video is sponsored by Starbucks. But we need to *feel* your motivation for making liquid nitrogen. The question that is not adressed is: Why do you want to make liquid nitrogen? And because you don't include it, it feels like you're making liquid nitrogen because of Starbucks. Think about what this video would look like if Starbucks hadn't sponsored it. You would open by saying: - liquid nitrogen is really cool - you see it in cool science experiments where you fast-freeze things [talk over a few seconds of a muted clip from your own video playing with playing with liquid N2, or if you don't have one perhaps to a video by Physics Girl, Sixty Symbols, Smarter Every Day, etc] - its also used in real science research [possible stock footage with video or stills] - and engineering that requires cold temperatures such as the superconducting magnets used in MRI scanners and the LHC [possible stock footage with video or stills] - whether it is hard to make liquid nitrogen - what motivated you to make your own liquid nitrogen Instead, we get some facts about nitrogen being in the air, 78% of it, and in the bubbles of Starbucks's new drink. This is quite a contrast! Maybe you wouldn't have made this video if you hadn't been sponsored to do it, and you're just being honest that its only being made because a sponsor asked you to? That's the feeling I get at the moment, and its not a good one. And yet I'm sure you were excited to make your own liquid nitrogen! But it doesn't come across in the opening of the video. So I think you need to throw away the first 40s and shoot a completely new intro to the video. I hope your contract with Starbucks doesn't require you to show their product at both the start and the end of the video, because if the cringe-worthy bit where you "take your first sip" of the N2 beverage is going anywhere, it should be at the end. The introduction sets the state-of-mind for the rest of the video, and at the moment the intro is failing at its job. Instead, show the intro you would make if Starbucks were nothing to do with the project, which I think would look similar to how I outlined above. But modify it slightly so that after the background section on liquid nitrogen, you can say either that you wanted to make your own and then Starbucks challenged you to do it, or (if you didn't want to make liquid N2 anyway) just that Starbucks challenged you to do it. You can show the Starbucks logo on screen when you mention their name. Then say, "so in this video, sponsored by Starbucks, I'm going to see if I can make my own liquid nitrogen" Make me feel like you made a cool video for your own reasons and a sponsor happens to be attached to it, and not that you made a video because a sponsor asked you to. Other things that are missing: - How does the way you are making liquid N2 compare to how it is done at industrial scale? Other things to change: - Text saying "do not try at home" etc, needs to be larger. I recommend swapping this to a sans-serif font (warning signs etc are in sans-serif). - Clarify that Starbucks's drink doesn't contain liquid N2. I think the advertisement content at the end of the video was fine, and you can leave it as-is. If you are contractually required to include the bit where you taste the drink, try to add it to the end segment. If you don't need to include it, just cut it.

Corey Strable

I enjoyed this very much. We need more videos of you losing $50 bets.

Rafe

Zee beeping iz intenze. 🤯 Otherwise, excellent video! I want to try the cold brew now, too. 😂

katgod

I suspect I am not the only one who would like to know where you can get a cyro-cooler like you used and how much it costs. You also could explain why you used the variac although I realize it is not directly related to your talk. Good subject and well done, liked the explanation on the bubble movement.

Marco Trevisan

Derek, this is so much different, compared to the BMW sponsorship! Things I liked * you talked about the science that is behind it, provoking thought; * you made something real out of it, you have got your hands "dirty"; * you used the opportunity to make a collaboration out of it; * you didn't try to "convince" that something is "good" just giving some facts, but you gave the whole big picture of the problem; * in general, the sponsorship was not too intrusive, it didn't look like an ad. Instead, it kept you style 100%, it is what we would expect out of your channel. Ways to improve (perhaps too late, but...) * as someone else said already, it would be nice to get a hint (not too much, just a hint) about the way Starbucks gets this liquid nitrogen, focusing on the differences and similarities with your setup; * I'm not sure if it's overkill, but safety policy at my laboratory stated that we needed to wear safety glasses when working with liquid nitrogen. If you consider it's overkill, you should say why. If it's not, you should write a note saying that you should have used safety glasses, but didn't consider it at the moment.

Max V

The longer length helped with making it feel less like an "ad" and the sponsorship was a lot more explicit too. I think it would've been neat to include a "taste test" difference between a drink you brewed yourself with NO2 and position it right next to the SBux drink you had at the beginning of the episode. I think the longer you wait in the video to say how much you like the product & include your thoughts on it the more positive the sponsorship would be received.

Conor Floyd

Hey Derek, really like this kind of sponsored video. Making it collaborative and having it be more clearly laid out into ad and non-ad sections made the whole video feel more generic/free. Keep it up!

Randy B

Just curious -- Could you make ice cream with the liquid air?

Tim Ternstrom

Liquid N is nothing to mess with. It can cause severe burns. You should always observe some form of safety protocol. Doing this on your living room floor without gloves and safety glasses made me cringe.

Kaliko Jakson

An interesting watch - kept me hooked. Well put together overall, just a couple of things - 9:50 It's not super clear on why the smaller cooler reduced the temperature of the nitrogen coming into the cryocooler, it seems like it just happened to work. 11:46 The video seems almost horizontally compressed, could just be the angle though. Thanks for another informative vid!

Guardian 452 Bob

Grant Thompson, The King of Random has an old video series on how he makes his own liquid nitrogen.

Jana Simmons

Please note how dangerous liquid oxygen is! I know you had a disclaimer, but that could be explosive.

Robert Emery

I like the video, but was distracted by the lack of safety gear, especially goggles. Perhaps a disclaimer? You might also consider editing in reshot pouring scenes wearing at least goggles and gloves. Maybe use dry ice to get the vapor effect more economically?

Shawn Van Ness

+1 on slightly freaked out by the lack of safety gloves, and goggles.

matt wuchter

You can never go wrong doing science experiments. The experiments may go wrong, but the entertainment value only goes up.

Jonas

Questions I was left thinking about @ 8:40 in the video: why will the nitrogen push the remaining air out of the tank? Won't' it just mix? Or do you trust the cooling unit will cool the nitrogen to liquid before that happens and thus drip directly to the bottom of the tank without mixing? Did you verify that the liquid did not contain any oxygen? Thanks for a great video!

Simon Vacker

The content is much better separated from the sponsorship in this video, nice!

Shawn Van Ness

On the topic of sponsorship, I think it's (slightly) still too heavy-handed in approach. I think the unique value prop you provide Starbucks is that you are so highly trusted and well liked. Just the shot of you sitting in front of their store, enjoying that particular beverage, and zooming in to talk about the use of nitrogen.. should be enough. And just a verbal mention to thank Starbucks for sponsoring the video -- I don't think you need to overlay a "warning" label on the segment. But yeah +1 to wanting to learn more about how they produce the N2 in stores.. I'd just assumed they bought bottles of compressed gas, from local food and beverage suppliers.

Adam J

This video was awesome, we got to 'discover' right along with you! The sponsor content made perfect sense and it was very clear that it did not impact the substance of the video.

Martijn Coppoolse

Interesting video! I found the section on extracting nitrogen without oxygen a tad chaotic, perhaps because the audio is less clear. The beeping noise of the oxygen alarm is annoying(ly loud), and makes it difficult to understand what you're saying. The ads are very well done; clearly recognizable as such, yet interesting enough that I kept watching. :-)

Veritasium

making nitrogen gas like I did with a membrane and compressor is much more cost efficient...

Veritasium

there was a significant positive pressure of nitrogen (too much it seems in retrospect) so it would in fact flood the tank with nitrogen leaving no room for O2

Veritasium

quite possibly, I think the risk is the liquid oxygen reacting with the cream...

Andreas Lindhé

Overall good, I think. The product integration is a bit of a mixed bag. Slight cringe in the beginning, but exemplary in other places. Cringe/bad: * "They challenged me to..." nah, that's overplaying it. I would have much preferred hearing "Let's see how LiNi can be made from air!" or something like that. * The part where you drink and explain is not interesting. It gives off the impression that you got told to do just that. It's fine, but not great. * 12:14 Unique texture? Really? Sounds like another tick-mark in a box in your contract. Examples of great: * 12:24 Having the product be the frame for explaining that the nitrogen won't react and create acids is great. The fact is not _that_ interesting, but the drink gives it enough context to stick with me. The product placement made this factoid better! * 11:58 Hearing that the stores to basically the same process you have just demonstrated is surprising (in a good way). I think it was the right choice to put that out there after you showed it, rather than revealing it in the beginning. * 13:00 Seeing the bubbles flow downwards made for a nice shot, and again I think that the product contributed to the discussion around that rather than distract. Made me want to try the drink, just to feel the things you talked about.

Andreas Lindhé

11:46 Yeah, the ratio is certainly wonky there.

Andreas Lindhé

I assumed that even in gas form it is heavier than air, and would (just like when water is poured into a beaker) push out the air. But I agree that it's not obvious, because in hindsight I'm not sure about that assumption without checking Wikipedia first.

Veritasium

I think they wouldn't permit it, but I suspect it was similar to my setup (except note they don't have to liquefy it - they just use dry nitrogen gas from the air so only the compressed air - nitrogen membrane step)

Veritasium

nice writing! They don't actually use liquid nitrogen to make the drink. They just infuse the gas...

Veritasium

This is an important thread and the point I would make is the channel has always had variation. From straight walk and talks to interviews of experts, to interviews of people on the street, to entirely animated videos, to video essays etc. I don't think this video is particularly similar to the BMW video in style or tone and I also don't think it forms a trend. There is variation, that is the only constant.

Veritasium

yes please do! Tweeting it is probably easiest for me but send however you can.

Veritasium

about 150W when running at full power

Veritasium

There are certain FTC guidelines and the video is reviewed by their legal team so I follow their guidance.

Jonathan Doyle

Absolutely, I certainly don't expect you to not evolve. That is your proagative and also my expectation (and desire) as a consumer and fan. Something does feel a bit differnet with these videos and I was simply proposing that it might not have been the direct fault of the sponsership. I also wasn't suggesting a trend, just a subjective opinion based on contextual observation. I have a lot of respect for you, what you do, and the integrity you present (presumably have), my comments weren't meant in distrust or disrespect!

Ben Michels

That was a cool video! I agree with others the plug was a bit cringeworthy but honestly I think most sponsorship videos are in some way unless it’s super specific and subtle (like a tool manufacturer on a wood working channel with just a note saying it’s sponsored by such and such)

Ben Michels

You need to stop making bets with your mate you have a low rate of success :P

Pamela Wissenbach

Around the 9 minute mark the camera was a bit out of focus and some of the hand held filming was a bit jiggly but otherwise a fun and interesting video. I honestly thought Starbuck's Nitro coffee was just lots of extra caffeine added had no idea it was nitrogen.

Florian Linscheid

I have the same points about the mixed-feelings intro and the severe lack of safety precautions. Otherwise I think that your narration isn't superior but you make your point well enough and there is a lot of science in it. What I wondered about, was, why there is so little surface area on that cold finger. Is it because there would be too much heat flow and the power of the cryocooler wouldn't keep up? Because I think it's no surprise that it takes so many hours to liquify the nitrogen if there's only the surface area of a cylinder. You waste most of the gaseous N2 there. All in all I's say the crowd wouldn't be nearly as mad to you as in the BMW video, but I personally prefer the non-sponsored videos a lot over those ones. But I'm fine to watch them if it helps you to make good content otherwise.

Maeby

Good stuff, the sponsorship did not get in the way in this video. Minimal cringe at the start and the end is totally palatable when it doesn't impact the regular content much.

Kimberly Green

Thanks 😊. Happy to write up future copy for you if you want me to. Gratis. DM me.

Jakub Korczyc

Cool stuff with the cryocooler. I am wondering what interesting things you can make with the liquid oxygen thou. I like coffee end science so I do not mind a sponsored video on this topic:)

Brooke Wilkin

same with the loving of coffee and science here!

Josh Grossman

Nice! I think you have a winner here. This reminds me of physics-girl in the way you are performing experiments educationally. That is one of the types of videos you make that I very much enjoy. You have a couple of other types which also work well and I think I personally prefer, like the less experimental approach of shade balls or the new kilogram standard, where you discover and explain something. I personally would like to see more technical stuff such as CRISPR or upcoming NASA missions.

Ralm

Well, I commented on Dropbox to notice that I should have done it here lol So here is my take on the video: I liked most of the video. Just felt that the transition at the end was too harsh. It went from doing Nitrogen in a fun way to you can make ice cream with Nitrogen which is smooth to a very serious "Starbucks also makes Nitrogen out of the air". Honestly I couldn't care less where they make the Nitrogen, we got it, is from the air, you shown how to make it. The sponsored part I would scratch the clear talking points provided by Startbucks and focused more on Nitrogen + Coffee, not focusing too much on the Startbucks variant and overusing their video segment of pooring. Maybe make it more personal, it would maybe feel less corporate if you filmed your self getting it instead of b-roll.

Ora Storms

That was a fun video, and I think it had a pretty good balance of Oooh neat science things and then explaining how it's relevant to your sponsor. Also, I appreciate how you didn't give an opinion on the product they were pushing - just the facts. It has tiny bubbles. Tiny bubbles make it feel different. Not good or bad, just different in this way.

Megan Fleischman

First thoughts are: what is going on in that room?! It’s like a scienceplosion in there. I like the fun you guys are having It feels very much like a stay-up-all-night slumber party. All that’s missing are the frozen underpants! I don’t mind the Starbucks plug at the beginning, but there was not enough delay in your reaction to “tasting it for the first time”. Had me thinking that wasn’t exactly the first take. Video diagrams are awesome. I couldn’t follow why a slower flow rate from the cryocooler would result in colder output 🤔.

David Xia

Great video. Was blurry in a few places briefly but otherwise it was awesome.

Ramiro Sierra

Great Video I think as long as you don't let the sponsors dictate your videos then its all good more power to you. I have always enjoyed your videos if I could I would give more on this Patreon but we cant all be Scientist's or Doctors I know I'm not. although I've heard Scientist dont make that much hehe. Well keep doing your thing and keep making cool videos like this.

James Austin

Yes! I think you managed to perfectly articulate what I was feeling as well! (The challenging misconceptions thing).

Daniel Toll

Very nice and entertaining video, very clear that it was sponsored with the announcement in the beginning. Also, I like the text-"reminder" that the last part was sponsored... ...and the sponsored (part) content was also interesting and enjoyable... spot on!

Tony Charlton

Did you delete it? I went back to give the cheese a second look and i couldn't find it. If I was right in where it was then the cut works really well and removes any suspicion of overly pushing the brand... with or without the cheese. Great work.

paercebal

Awesome. The technical parts (building a liquid nitrogen generator out of air) is very interesting, and amusing to see (you seem to have had fun with Allen while building that stuff, and overcoming the challenges). I found it interesting, and I can't wait for the public version of this video so I can share it. I agree the sponsored parts were clearly delineated, and the first part ("Starbucks challenged me") had already won me over: I mean, of course, it's sponsored, but that gave me a positive impression of the brand (even if I'll never use it, as I don't like coffee), which is the point, I believe. And the last part, on how they use nitrogen for their beverage is even better: We saw part of the process used at Starbucks to create unique flavor, and what. And it's both creative and technical. So, yeah, I love it all. :-) Thanks for the work you put in it. :-)

Scott Lowe

Did you forget about the bit at the beginning, where Derek tastes the drink, says he likes it and describes the texture and flavor?

Scott Lowe

TLDR; - Consider how the video was impacted by having a sponsor vs what it would be if you made the topic without sponsorship. - Did you cede too much editorial control? - Current intro is not good and portrays bad motivations. Viewers will feel like you are a sell out. - Make viewers feel like you made the video you wanted to (and because you wanted to), and not sponsored content (and because it was sponsored). - Replace intro with one much closer to what you would do if the video was not sponsored. - Warning text needs to be clearer (sans-serif, larger font).

Luke Kearney

The sponsor makes sense. Really enjoyed it.. I am curious though how the sensor works, to ensure that it really is nitrogen. How does the sensor detect the oxygen levels? I understand that majority of the air we breath, 78% I think, is Nitrogen, thus in theroy, removing the oxygen would leave us with basically pure Nitrogen. Surely there would be other gases, for example, Carbon Dioxide? Would that play a role in the making of the liquid nitrogen?

Ora Storms

He said: Sweet Cold Frothy That was it. I double-checked. He didn't give any indication of it's flavor, just the three qualities that are actually relevant to the liquid nitrogen being involved.

Patrick M. Bradley

The sponsorship did not distract from the video, and the content was excellent. I think part of the problem with the BMW add was that the actual content was not particularly original. There was nothing that causes me to think: "Wow, that is so cool, I never knew/thought about that before." Almost every angle about electric cars has already been done, and they are being advertised all of the time. So short of taking the vehicle apart, I doubt I would have learned much new about it. Small things that I would have liked to see in the video: 1. A full schematic diagram of the system. 2. An energy usage estimate for running the system.

Ryan Meyer

Could you explain during the video why it was so much more difficult to produce the liquid nitrogen than it was to produce the liquid air?

Matt Dunlap

He speculatively did, he had the flow rate on the N2 too high, so he was pumping heat in fast enough that the cooler couldn't get the system below -200

Matt Dunlap

I liked this video a lot. It seemed closer to Mythbusters than you in that the focus was the build rather than the theory, but that didn't seem like a bad thing, merely different. I wouldn't necessarily want you to go the Mythbusters route in general (despite also really loving that show), but as an occasional "oh and btw here's some behind the scenes process of how I do stuff" sort of thing it was fun and interesting. I think the only thing I learned was that somehow you had never had nitro cold brew before.

Ryan Meyer

Yes, but that was his first try. On the second, he insulated better and I presume slowed down the flow, but there still wasn't very much liquid nitrogen after a long time.

Uwe

maybe put a quick refresher about the composition of air at the beginning and what's the temperature needed to liquify each element

Michael Aichlmayr

One suggestion. It seems clear that a lot of people are misunderstanding that Starbucks uses non-liquefied nitrogen gas extracted from the air, whereas in your challenge, you are taking it a step further. Maybe where you mention the challenge, something like, "Starbucks uses nitrogen gas concentrated from the air, they've challenged me to take it one step further, and liquify nitrogen gas from the air."

thomas

i think this is a good format for an ad on your channel

Daniel Turner

Perhaps, given it imparts a difference in the texture of the beverage, a brief comment to explain why nitrogen bubbles are smaller than those formed by carbon dioxide could be a useful addition?

Fionera

Nice Video now I have to find a Cryocooler :P

Elinor Strickland

I liked the video. But the advertisement is still feels quite separate from the video. Perhaps getting a look on how Starbucks extracts nitrogen/ integrates nitrogen into their product. Then compare that with what you have done. (if that is possible)

Ottis Francis

Great video, should make LN2 for linus tech tips so he can finally do some LN2 over clocking