Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

New video is in the final draft stage. I'd love to get your thoughts if you don't mind seeing the video before it's polished. There are a couple things in animation that I want to tweak but let me know whatever you spot that could be better. I would also like to get your thoughts in title/thumbnail combos because I don't feel like I have the right one yet.

Thank you for taking the time to offer suggestions!

Derek

https://www.dropbox.com/s/g5t3ib13091ilzx/Kodak.mov?dl=0

Files

(No title)

Comments

OG

Looks like it's done :) Just the white stripes (I guess it's an artificial noise) is a bit distracting. Great work, as always!

David Sherier

Did you originally have two sponsors? At the beginning you say that "this part of the video was sponsored by Raised by Wolves" and then at the end of the video you say something similar. Is there another part of the video that is sponsored by someone else? Fantastic video!

John Callahan

Great story. I think a lot will be new information for people. Good graphics, sound/video editing. Clear information for someone with a little science background. Maybe mention hat alpha particles are vs beta? One thing I noticed in this video and not in your other ones was that I had a hard knowing where you were going. As I watched, I thought it could be about how remote events can significantly affect the environment 1000s of miles away (e.g., smoke from West Coast fires, acid rain), or maybe it was how gov't spread misleading information resulting inaction using legitimate inconclusive science as support (e.g., cancer from tobacco, climate change), or that there are pockets of higher than usual radioactivity in unusual places, or even others. It felt like the video kept veering off from the direction I thought it would go. That critique is on me just as much as on the video!

Aaron Rubin

When you talk about the wine forgeries at about 11:18, are the numbers shown on the wine bottles significant? I thought they were supposed to represent the years the wine was made at first, but then realized they both start with 17--. If it was supposed to represent the years, the second bottle of wine you show as being made "before" the gamma rays is listed as a more recent year than the one with the gamma rays. 75 years ago was 1945, so maybe it would make more sense to have one bottle labeled 1945 and the other any year before that?

Edith Dubiner

very interesting. audio/video not in sync starting at ~10:08 for a couple of minutes. It's hard to select a title, because there are several focus points - as others have pointed out... "Explosive Effects"?

Ken Schwarz

Very interesting and timely. I think the concern was less for the photographic industry and more that the fogging if X-ray film was something that couldn’t be covered up.

Steve A

I agree with Aaron's comment about the years on the bottles, those are confusing. Really interesting, though. And Ken's almost certainly right too... the issue wasn't concern for the photographic industry than it was keeping things secret.

Adam Flareau

Cool video, but it doesn't seem very coherent. It feels like you are trying to fit half-an-hour's worth of content into 10 minutes.

Rich

Very informative. Very intriguing. Very spooky.

Dragi Raos

Very well done and interesting, both the "scientific detective story" aspect and one about blatant disregard for safety of the population. Two nitpicks, though: - Someone already mentioned the numbers (presumably vintage) on wine bottles. They should be better chosen to illustrate the point about radio-dating using isotopes from nuclear test fallout - Around 1:55 you say "Radium glows because it is radioactive", mentioning its use in glowing dials, e.g. in aircraft instrument panels. It is not radium that glows, but fluorescent compound (technically "phosphor", not to be confused with the element), usually zinc sulfide with trace amounts of "activator" metal. (Perhaps mentioning "radium girls" here would be informative.)

Norman Roldan

Great video! I'm thinking a title/thumbnail somewhere along the lines of "How atomic bombs are a part of you, literally."

Kimberly Green

For a title, may I suggest "Something is wrong with this picture ..." . It picks up not only the angle of Kodak film spots, but also Senator Harkin's quote.

Pedro Veloso

It's scary to think that it is not unforeseeable that more nuclear weapons might get used.

Ulf Hermjakob

Super interesting and well done. Thank you very much, Derek! The one detail that confused me a bit at first was at around 11:17 in the video, where the numbers on the wine bottles, 1742 and 1750, suggested vintage years to me, particularly since your narrative actually uses the words "date" and "vintage". But of course those years do not make any sense here, as the years 1742 and 1750 are both before 1945, in the wrong order with respect to the animation, and generally too long ago. But then, what do those prominently displayed numbers mean?

Peter Genovese

Yeah, I'd agree with Ondrej. The artificial white noise lines in the animations are more of a distraction. I'd prefer the animation clean so I can concentrate on what's being shown.

Paul Looyen

Fascinating. Question, is the level of strontium in bones worldwide, or only stateside? Is that worth mentioning? Especially since other nations did test explosions. That begs the question, how uniform is level of strontium in bone tissue worldwide? Agree with Dagri’s comments about radium. I’m a stickler for straightness, I did notice the graph of the rates of. cancer I believe, is slightly crooked. I know it’s a scan. Minor Overall really informative

Patrik Andersson

Love it. Very clever! Perhaps adding a short "-How kodak was the first to detekt nuclear tests" could spark even more interests?

Veritasium

It’s the way wording is requested sometimes so the sponsor doesn’t have liability for things I say in the video

Veritasium

I see what you mean and I wonder if it’s good or bad or neutral that viewers can’t necessarily see where it’s going...

Veritasium

This tweak will be made - good catch!

John Callahan

It's a good video on interesting topics that require some thought. For this particular video, the changing direction may distract a little from what you're saying. Although it could be just me (as a climate scientist) thinking you're going down a certain road that I'm used to reading about.

David Sherier

That makes sense. I am a civil engineer in texas. Let me know if I can ever help in some small way. Your channel is awesome and I'm happy to be a supporter. Keep up the good work!

Jorge Sinde

Hi, I'm Portuguese and I use to understand your speech easily. But this time you talk faster than usual, in my opinion. It's difficult to follow. Is a great video, but if the rythm was not so fast it would be more pleasent. I had to stop and go back sometimes, I got lost.

Student Entrepreneurs

Might check your pronunciation of Wabash River. It's "WAH bash - rhymes with ash.

Gregor Shapiro

The animation at 7:40 should have milk coming through the cows udder.

Michael Aichlmayr

Carl Sagan said we are made of star stuff. Apparently we're also made of bomb stuff. 😅

Jonas

Love this video! Yes definately would be interesting to have comments regarding worldwide "fallout" both on strontium and on effects in general.. And also I have believe it is hard to get metal these days that isn't radioactive, you have to like go dig up sunken ships to get non-radioactive metal - maybe this could be a relevant detail to mention at some point?

Timur Sultanov

Well I think it is worth mentioning that even though Iodine half life is "only 8 days" it doedn't mean that it stays in milk for only 8 days, half of it stays for 8 days, but big enough chunk will stay for longer...

Denver DSouza

Great video - absolutely loved it! Were there any impacts of nuclear testing fallout moving to Canada? Could something be done over other nuclear tests in the world and their fallout reach?

Miklós Boros

Maybe you can tell a little bit about the site where you start the video. How the vegetation and animals are doing? Maybe a tiny STALKER zone there?

Matt Andrews

Can't access it at all. 🤔

C.J. Smith

Unless they request that exact wording, it would probably be less confusing but equivalent to say "Part of this video was sponsored..."

C.J. Smith

Possible title suggestion - something along the lines of, How Kodak Figured Out National Security Secrets

C.J. Smith

Ah, rewatching the beginning, what I said is what you say there, but the end has "this part"

C.J. Smith

Also my gf commented that 0:11 "by myself" was a little odd since you had a small film crew. I don't know if there's a good way to say "without strangers"...

C.J. Smith

Also, just to reiterate what others have said, I also am distracted by the "old" white lines, and I also was feeling at times like the video of you talking was just slightly off from the audio .

Paul Wicker

And some people on bike's in the background. There playfulness detracted from the serious mood of the video.

Aaron Koblin

That kids tooth clip. Oof. So uncomfortable. Perhaps a little bit shorter?

Shawn Van Ness

Agree, need to try to quantify that .. most viewers may know but some may not, the big difference in alpha vs beta radiation .. externally exposed vs ingested This all hits close to home .. my mother was born in Indiana in 1943, and has had thyroid problems most of her life.

Ethan

I love the videos you make, and thoroughly enjoyed this one. if I may pick one nit, the VHS-looking effect on the animated sequences is unpleasant to look at. I have seen animation with a film grain effect (ISO noise) which I think is much nicer on the eyes.

Veritasium

white lines are out. I filmed at 24fps and the timeline was 30fps - that may be the source of the mismatch. I'll try to fix.

Veritasium

I've tried to add some spacers but will do more.

Veritasium

I'm sure there were and less well investigated

Jorge Sinde

Thank you for sending the shade ball, it arrived some days ago. I'm so happy to have one and signed by you. It was a great idea and a very kind thing to do!

Poker Chen

Suggested title: The fallout in our bones? I think a corresponding thumbnail could be a picture of the US map. I think there are bits of the video where you can add a couple more lines to explain how some isotopes emit alpha while others emit beta. The biological parts are pretty well narrated for the general public. A final question would be: Do you want to go into any more detail about how the propaganda actively obfuscated the overall low average versus local concentration? The ecosystem is extremely efficient at concentrating essential nutrients.