Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

New video launching this coming week, I'd love to get your thoughts on what makes sense and doesn't. Is anything wrong or confusing? Which part do you like the most?

And any ideas on titles and thumbnails? I really do value your opinions. They make my videos better. So thank you!

Files

The Pattern That Never Repeats

I'd love to get your feedback on this draft.

Comments

xavie

The bit at 6:05 ish was a bit too fast. I didn't quite understand what the conjecture meant.

Dean Kyfiuk

At 2:34 we need a little more time on Kepler's conjecture to read the slide. It changes too quickly.

Markus Appel

Amazing video, I'm completely in awe of the beauty of those two overlying penrose patterns. Two things I noticed: - the kind of out of place subtitles in the first snowy scene - I don't see any reason why in that shot you need subtitle for something. If it's supposed to be a quote then it shouldn't look like subtitles imo. - When you make the tiling on the floor and say that the pattern won't work but you will only find out if you stack all the way "to here" the viewer actually doesn't see how far "to here" actually is until some moments later when you actually build it. Either skip the "if I tile it to here" part and just show you tiling and finding the defect or at least show where "here" is in that moment. Hope that input is worth something. Love the videos.

Paul Looyen

Great video. And absolutely fascinating. You traveled to Prague just to do a Kepler intro 🤓 Couple of thoughts. The section on Kepler I wonder if it could be trimmed. For example the first point in the platonic models although fascinating seems a little out of place. I guess you are establishing context but wonder if it could be trimmed. Love the laser cut tiling you do and the moire pattern section. The section 11:30 onwards initially seemed a little confusing. Had to watch it a couple of times to get the idea presented. Thumbnail idea should include the different coloured penrose pattern. Mesmerising. Oh I wonder how many takes you did to get the jump into the scene but on to the chair. Love to see the outtakes. 🤣

Richard Sundvall

Love that you've discovered Penrose Tiling. But, you're standing on the shore of one of his other great theories by extension. The non-computable nature of solving the tiling problem (meaning computer algorithms can't actually solve it, but human brains can) to him was evidence that the brain as computer analogy is wrong and evidence for a quantum basis of consciousness. Maybe that would be a great 'mic drop' at the end and lead to another video....? See Matthew Fisher's QuBrain project.

Dragi Raos

I have nothing to contribute. This topic fascinated me since I learned about Penrose tiling (rather soon after he discovered "kite and dart" set), and you cover it here beautifully.

Pamela Wissenbach

Maybe explain Why it was called a conjecture as oppose to anything else.

Veritasium

Believe it or not that was first take, and I don't think I could ever do it that well again haha

Aaron Roberts

As always, fascinating. I know early on you mentioned you were going to tell us 5 things about Kepler. Without repeatedly viewing, I dropped off at the 3rd. One of the things I struggled grasping here was how the 2 dimensional tiling translates into 3d crystal forms. I'm not sure how others would view it, or how important it actually is, but the differences between the 2 stacks of cannon balls was lost on me. I'm wondering if this is the key bit to go from a plane to a solid.

Kimberly Green

11:12 '... regularities, like stars and suns ...' and bunny heads with ears.

Michael Ward

I had trouble seeing the alignment and mismatch patterns when you overlay them with a transparency, so I couldn't much follow what you were saying there.

Robert Blum

Love this, it’s really perfect, especially since my family is from Prague :) At 18:06, it would be nice to mention the 5-fold symmetry of the Bragg diffraction pattern, which is something that regular crystals don’t have. Second comment: I’m not a fan of the hcp fcc animation - you can’t tell the difference. No need to dwell on the subtle differences but a better animation would help. The Moiré sequence could be shortened since the lighting isn’t ideal in some shots, but it’s fine as is in my opinion.

Nick Grant

The moire demonstration works well at the end when you have the 5 lines radiating, but up until that point it was very hard to see anything. I think the very fine pattern constantly changing all over the screen is losing a lot of detail when Youtube compresses it. The compression side-effects might be reduced if the pattern were larger, but I don't know if the final effect would be harder to see in that case.

Student Entrepreneurs

At 12:47 when you present the golden ratio I was stuck wondering: were you counting the tiles in the assembly you just made on your floor? You could have easily added a kite or a dart. What was the constraint aside from the number of each you had to work with?

Ken Schwarz

Perhaps your most challenging video to date. The treatment pays homage to the content: simple at the core yet it radiates in many directions and defies summation. I admired your efforts with the tiles on the floor but wished for a software simulation. If you know of any mention these please and post links. I feel certain it would stimulate many to try this at home.

Shad Sterling

I was going to ask for a link to buy a set of tiles, but I like the software simulation idea better. It's too bad Patreon isn't a federated identity provider so creators can make sites for patrons that use the Patreon login, 'cause that might be the best place to put such a simulation.

DER RÜTTLER

I think the link between repeating geometric shapes and crystals should be more clearly established in the beginning of the video. I'm a literal physicist so I was aware of the link but I think to most people the tiling behavior of geometric shapes seems like a purely mathematical concept. At least I personally find that I am more interested in learning math when I feel that it has some application.

katgod

I found it interesting but I wish you could explain more about the practical applications or behavior in the compound that was found to exhibit this strange symmetry. I also found it a little hard to follow the connections between various parts of the talk but enjoyed it anyway.

jochem

It's not entirely clear to me whether the video is about Johannes Keppler or about tilings. I take it to be about tilings about 5 minutes in :) Then I observe that even though I've programmed an tiling app for islamic patterns myself, I've never understood what causes tilings to be aperiodic and how to prove (or predict) that. Unfortunately the video does not explain that either. So I like the video, it's interesting but it seems the focus can be more on tilings (unless you wanted to make a video on Keppler :) and it would be *very* interesting if you can explain aperiodic tilings in more depth.

Adam Flareau

Really a great video. It was clear, informative, and very interesting. I especially liked the mix of animations and real examples. The one problem I had was the how little you talked about the applications. But one again great video!

Veritasium

valid point - I wonder if it would work in 4k...

Veritasium

I did add a couple darts. The point is it's illustrative of the mathematical relationship we know is there. Large enough patterns will certainly approach this ratio. But it's better to talk about something concrete, rather than just say in the abstract this is where we know it's headed...

Veritasium

We made some code for the video (as you can see in the infinite different tilings section. We'll be releasing it on GitHub with the video. I've got to say you do get some intuition by trying to work with the tiles that you wouldn't get from the code. But it was tedious and I wracked my brains and didn't make nearly the size of tiling I wanted to because I ran into those problems, eg not having a plan and doing everything locally you can get yourself in a bind

Veritasium

I think applications are still in development stage. There are some great stories around finding quasicrystals in nature (the first discovered was in a meteorite) but it's such. good story I didn't want to spoil it.

Veritasium

this is the second hcp fcc animation I had the animator make. It's a tough nut to crack. Yeah I'm sad about Moire - maybe if one watches in 4k

Nick Grant

Very good point, my previous comment was from watching at 1080p. 2160p/4K is wonderfully clear, and 1440p is in between the two as you'd expect. While it's not perfectly clear at lower resolutions, the general effect of the pulsating light/dark patches still comes through, which feels like one of the key points. And once you move to the static pattern with lines it's clear at all resolutions, so that part is fine if you ask me.

Thongchai Kolyutsakul

I think it is still difficult to take in how Penrose pattern tiles up in a non-repeating way. I know it is hard to show because there are pieces that looks similar everywhere. Plus, our human brain is very good at finding "repeating" patterns in what we see and tries to convince us that it is repeating, although as you said, it is not. You have one good visual that breaks this misunderstanding though, which is the Long-Short parallel line spacing. You could add more of evidence like this.

Daniel M. Bensen

Excellent! Excellent excellent! You gave me an idea for a plot point in the sf novel I'm writing :) My only suggestions are a shout-out to Greg Egan's short story "Wang's Carpets" and a shot of your kids playing with those tiles :)

Matt Dunlap

Overall I really liked the video, but more on that in a sec. You got something wrong in a way that could end up causing debilitating injuries to your viewers. You lifted that box of plastic with your back, and not your legs. I realize that this seems like a minor thing, but I'd like to convince you that it is not. People are looking to learn when they watch your videos, and brains aren't really precise enough to do things like "learn from these portions of what this authority figure does, but not these other portions". You can separate aspects intellectually, but motion is typically subconscious, you learn motions by watching others move and by experimentation. So when the authority figure doesn't see a problem with an awkward back based lift it reinforces the hunch that there is no problem. But speaking as someone who has been in pain 24h/day for over a week at this point: there is a problem. For the good of your viewership, please either cut or re-film that scene. Okay, so with that chip on my lower back addressed, the thing I loved so much about this video was its progression. Even compared to your previous videos this one does a great job at asking the questions in a really interesting way, and then giving us time to stew on them. More than once I found myself somewhat bothered by a topic shift, not because it was out of place, but because I had serious unanswered questions... and then eventually you did circle back and answer them. It felt like a smaller form of the "solved the problem for myself" catharsis. Masterful.

daan brinkers

The aspect ratio is quite. Euhm, Anoying. Why haven't you made it 19:6? Like to fill a normal 1080p of 4k screen. Now we have black bars at the side.

RayLast

You always manage to find such interesting topics. I learn a lot from your videos. I did feel like having so many "coincidences" here was a bit tiring, like oh wow, cool, nice, u-huh, hmmm, OK... well at some point math just rounds up on itself, and it became a tad bit less interesting. Could be just me though! Some tightening or trimming like mentioned in other comments may help but I don't know enough to be helpful with specifics...

Michael D Fox

Interesting video topic- well produced and researched! Check 12:10-20 - using the word impossible twice in the explanation doesn’t work (for me). Maybe focus more on known and potential applications?

Mark Widmer

A couple of things are not clear to me from watching what is, overall, another great and engaging video. 1. What is the reason for the added constraint that the curves on adjacent tiles must line up? What would happen if the tiles didn't have those curves and that constraint were lifted? There is no such constraint in the examples of triangular, square, and hexagonal tiles, so why is it here? 2. At 11:12, why is there a change to a different color scheme for the tiles?

Student Entrepreneurs

Perhaps you could add after you say: "Now what if we count up all the kites and darts in this pattern?" - "For any suitably large area like here on my floor. . ."

Marco Trevisan

I'm a bit late to the conversation. But I have to say, it was superb. I was sort of hypnotised from the beginning to the end. I knew already several of the subjects you talk about, but you present them with such a mastery and connect the ideas so well, that I just loved it. I felt like in a magic world for few minutes. Every video you make is more captivating! If there is any contribution I can make, I would say: 1) you jump too fast from one idea to the next. While I'm still deeply thinking about something you said... boom, here comes the golden ratio. Then I'm thinking about the golden ratio and... boom, Fibonacci! And so on. However, this might just be a personal feeling, other people might get bored if you slow it down. 2) I was curious about those tiles you get out of the box. I guess there was a lot of work behind that. The design, the laser cutting, etc. A few seconds describing that process would be very interesting, even getting some five seconds or so where we can see them being cut (if you have this at all). The way you present them looks as if Santa had come to bring them to your doorstep out of an elf factory in Lapland or something. And in fact, those physical tiles are one of the main characters in this video, they deserve a better introduction.

C.J. Smith

My initial impressions from my not-super-careful viewing (which perhaps can be expected from normal viewers): 5:00 - at this point I was confused as to what the hexagon "only" tiling periodically meant. Things later in the video helped, but I wonder if perhaps a change in the order things are mentioned, or an extra sentence earlier, might clear it up before the confusion. 11:53 - the comments starting around here made me wonder something - is this reflected in the idea that if you were to make a tiling yourself, at some points you have a choice for what to do next, and they will both be valid but change the tiling from that point onwards? If not, what's different about it? Could be something relatable to compare all this infinity talk to. I also wonder if if would be useful to have some reference to what it means to be uncountably infinite, either a quick description or pointing people towards a video addressing it.

Tristan Ursell

Paul Stienhardt was also part of a larger expedition to Komchatka Pen. Russia to find naturally occurring quasi-crystals -- that mission, in addition to being a great story, was fully successful, they occur naturally, they found them. That was a bit of a shocker to the physics community :)

Rocco Neil April

Wow, this one is a brain-squeezer. I need more coffee :)

Veritasium

I love the story - even interviewed Steinhardt on Skype but I didn't have room for the story and didn't want to do it half-way

Juveri Setila

Really hard to find anything to improve on this video, since I was just astounded by everything the whole time. But 2 very very minor things: 18:08 make other set of those white dots a different color, so we can see the differences better 18:41 I love that. Take the "boom" out, and add the famous shaky effect to have the maximum impact on viewers. I love the video and the way it progresses. Very fine job once again Derek!

Mark Widmer

I did find out the answer to my note #1 above. Omitting the curves would allow the kite and dart shapes to make a periodic lattice. So, as is stated at 8:31-8:44, adding a rule like matching the curves insures that a set of tiles can only work nonperiodically.

Poker Chen

Nice! I hand built a set of paper Penrose rhombuses for a class of year 3 and 4 students once. They are beautiful. The only problematic part is where you place two oranges onto the four on the table for artistic effect, but that is not a valid 3D tiling. You could potentially trim some of the smaller details such as Fibonacci numbers from the script, which are not central to the 5-fold quasi-crystal storyline.

Poker Chen

I vote for the almost superimposed Penrose tilings as the thumbnail Those parallel lines look very engaging

Boris Petrovchich

If you like geometry – truly fascinating • BTW that was the fifth Platonic ideal body • Worth viewing – from 38’ to 53’ (total of 15 minutes) Lectures from famous Vincent Racaniello -- structure of cupsids – protein shell protecting virus genome – made from protein subunits (symmetry plus self-assembly) • Viruses will never be the same to you after you see that https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jY3axuAm2AA

Axel V.

I love how the aspect ratio of this video (1748x1080) is ~1,6185, that's a really nice touch!

Axel V.

The video currently has an aspect ratio of (1748/1080) about 1,6185, which I feel is pretty neat :)

Mark Widmer

And now Roger Penrose is a Nobel laureate.