Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

New video coming tomorrow! Your input requested today.

  • A 340
  • B 243
  • 2021-05-29
  • 583 votes
{'title': 'New video coming tomorrow! Your input requested today.', 'choices': [{'text': 'A', 'votes': 340}, {'text': 'B', 'votes': 243}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 5, 29, 2, 18, 20, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 583}

Content

First, this video is super top secret, please don't share the titles and thumbnails with anyone outside of Patreon. I think it might be one of the best and most fun videos I've ever made.

Second, I saw some feedback on previous polls I've conducted about titles and thumbnails saying 'don't worry so much about the title and thumbnail, quality content will get seen.' That is just not true. Having eye-catching and engaging titles and thumbnails can make a 5x or 10x difference in the viewership of a video. We pour countless hours of work into the tiniest details of these videos, but if we don't get the title and thumbnail right, then many fewer people will see it. That's why your input is so important.

Which of the following thumbnails would you be most likely to click?

Thank you!

Derek and the growing Veritasium Team

Files

Comments

SkaveRat

The image from A, mainly because your face is visible, and B without a logo would drown in my subscription feed. Although I'm not a big fan of the title of A

Andrew Berg

Risking my life to break the laws of physics. Or some combo of the two. Don’t mind my first comment I wrote it up wrong.

Jessi Krupsky

I don't like title A - risking your life may not set the best example for younger viewers!

Andrew Berg

Yea I feel like a combo of the two somehow would be attractive to new viewers.

Sreyleak

Faces totally make a better thumbnail.

CharlieRose

i think A is better because your face is recognizable and seeing a title like that would surprise people. Problem is YouTube might suppress a title like i risk my life. But as a subscriber i would definitely notice it.

Andrew Berg

Idk if there is much going on in the world where one isn’t either being told they are risking their life or you’re actually are risking your life. Personally I would rather my four year old know that doing some activity X is dangerous and should not be emulated. But then again she is four and I am a new ( well 4 years I suppose) parent. Excuse the rant,

Luke

In these polls it would be helpful to have your actual logo in the circle and the channel name instead of "Your Channel". I voted B, as I assume that my initial reaction of "why am I seeing a clip about perpetual motion" would be overruled once I saw the channel name and icon. Regardless, I'm super excited to see the video :)

Ken Schwarz

Neither would get my attention if I didn’t know it was your work. The arrow and the words on the right are are more visually arresting, but sound like nonsense, sad to say. The promise that you risked your life for physics also seems like a cheap headline. So, I hope you have some others to consider. Sorry!

Joey Luther

I have a bias against anything claiming perpetual motion (thanks Electroboom) so I have to choose the thumbnail for A by default. But I think I'd be more apt to click the title for B. Just my $0.02

Stefan Grunspan

A. It’s A. Mr Beast settled this question with all his self referential video titles.

Stefan Grunspan

Also please ensure no physicists were harmed in the making of this video.

Paul Looyen

Agree with a few here already. The text is important but so is your face.

Mateen Kasim

In general, I find that titles with numbers in them (e.g. 70 million shade balls & lots of MrBeast vids) and videos that seem paradoxical (e.g. infinite pattern that never repeats, or "these are the asteroids we need to worry about" when the thumbnail points to the smallest asteroid in the pic) can garner a lot of attention. Hate to say it but the notorious red arrow often helps too. In this case, I would probably only click on Option B.

Shad Sterling

Neither of those would interest me if they weren't on your channel; both sound like clickbait nonsense and don't give any indication of the actual topic

Sam O

Not only would I be more likely to click A but I actually avoid clicking videos that say "perpetual motion machine?" Because I know its BS

Jan Vilhuber

B just sounds too click-baity and as a rule I never click on stuff that sets off my click-bait-radar. Maybe that's just me (obviously click-bait works..). A is marginally better, but also feels click-baity

Sam O

Or maybe Bs title and As thumbnail. The "perpetual motion" part is what kills it for me

Aaron McBride

I'll watch it either way, but I really don't like the clickbait tone. I get that you've got to do what works to promote the video. I just wish it could be something like "Can a car power itself with a wind turbine?" was in the running.

Alex Stern

Honestly both images are fine... One a cute picture, the other has a phrase that sparks interest for anyone who enjoys physics at all.

RayLast

"I barely survived this physics debate"

Alexander Johnson

I chose A but honestly the mere mention of a perpetual motion machine will attract tons of views.

Katerina Richard Wise

I like the thumbnail of B and title of A 😅 "Risking my life..." is very catchy. But the thumbnail has no impact. The other thumbnail with the perpetual motion machine is very intriguing. Can't you combine those?

Aaron Koblin

FWIW I think A will be more compelling to those who know you and B will be more compelling to random YouTube viewers. (Your data sample may be biased... :) )

Veritasium

I mean a title like that would get fewer than half the views. This is the conundrum I'm up against. I don't have a clickbait bone in my body, so I've hired people to help me make these titles and thumbs. They allow the videos to reach a broader more diverse audience and get people interested in STEM who otherwise wouldn't be. In my view it's worth the tradeoff.

Michael Tuvim

With all due respect: unless you know the face of the person you are not going to have a strong impulse to investigate. Thus "B" thumbnail is more catchy in broader market. However the "A" caption is more intriguing.

Robert Blum

Image of A with title from B - I think that’s mostly our consensus also.

Clayton Greenwell

A. But only because the YouTube algorithm leans into more extreme content on watch next. Personally I think B is a better title, but I'm not the watch next algorithm.

Gregor Shapiro

Too "cartoon-like" ( but that might attract some viewers who are not subscribers!)

Molly Gallant

Already been said but cannot echo enough: thumbnail of B, but title of A.

Nadav Goldenberg

I’m personally tired with the “Did I just break the laws of physics?? 😱🤯” kinda title. It’s stupid.

Austin H

Title of A with thumbnail of B!

Pierre Joos

I agree with Austin. I personally like to know what the video is about. Thumbnail B is therefor much better. Regarding the titles: I am not a fan of these type of non-descriptive titles but A is slightly better.

Rens Oliemans

I find it difficult to give constructive feedback on this: I (and I assume nearly everyone that votes here) obviously watch all your video's, but the goal of the thumb+title is to convince others to also watch it. Personally I am not a large fan of clickbait, but I think that it's worth it in this scenario: if the content is the same (good!) and much more people will watch it (that aren't as nerd) then I think you're doing a good job. That's why I became your patreon, you make engineering content super fun to watch for everyone, much like Mark Rober. If I were in your position, I'd use the thumb+titles that generate the most views. Edit: my bad didn't explain correctly, there are a lot of comments disliking clickbait: my point is that clickbait is fine IMO, as long as the content is good: it brings your content to a wider audience.

Klaas Deforche

Maybe something less clickbait-y? Both titles sound childish imo.

Zeus

Certainly title A. Title B is simply a *lie*, which we here should eschew even if it's a deliberate clickbait. (No, not *everyone* will say that. (I'm pretty sure I know what the video is going to be about)). Thumbnails are both OK; I guess B is better for non-subscribers, though I (if I were one) wouldn't click on it ("no, not another one!!!")

Til Boerner

I would definitely not click B, because the answer to "Perpetual Motion Machine?" is clearly no and I don't need to spend 15 minutes of my time to learn that. In fact, I'd feel offended at the clearly click-bait title. Also, I bet that not _everyone_ will say anything breaks the law of physics. Titles like this make me expect low quality, low information density content. For people who don't know what "perpetual motion machine" means, I'm not sure the words by themselves would be interesting enough. Thumbnail B: It's not clear at all what I'm looking at, but it does look a lot like a desk fan. That you're sitting inside it is not immediately obvious, despite the arrorw-thing. Also, I think the face is too obscured, which makes it less interesting. It's also hard to recognize you. I know you and I like your content, so realizing a video is by you makes me likely to click it. This way, I'm not sure I'd pick you out in a wall of thumbnails.

Daniel Wild

Precisely why I voted for B. The selling point of A is that we recognise a familiar face; this may not apply to most non-subscribers.

Dragi Raos

No, the other way around.

Dragi Raos

I am, too, but Derek needs views from people who are attracted by such titles, too.

OldManLink

I would skip over B because of the text, since I already know that perpetual motion machines don’t exist, and I don’t need to waste my time getting it confirmed.

Dragi Raos

I don't think we are such a good "jury" to decide this - this (admittedly pretty large) core body of your viewers does watch everything you do, for the quality of content. FWIW, my favorite Veritasium videos are those where you go more than a bit "philosophical", typically shot while simply walking around. Those give me most material to think. But they don't fuel the channel growth, I guess...

Scott Lowe

It's never a perpetual motion machine.

Daniel Wild

I absolutely agree with Dragi. If the goal is to attract more non-subscribers, your patreons are probably not the best ones to help you decide. The discussion pretty clearly shows that the vast majority here strongly dislikes click-bait and click-baitish means of attracting viewers.

João Gouveia

I would think having a face on it makes it more attention grabber for us humans. We like pictures, especially faces, not text. So I think A beats it. I certainly like it more, likely because of that. Having said that, since the title says "risking my life" it'd be even better if you have a more "OMG" or scared, "about to be in danger face". 😂 I think that would sell it more and take it to the next level. Good luck man! I don't envy these thumbnail nonsense, wish it wasn't so necessary! Looking forward to watching your video ☺️

Oliver Hendrey

I think an issue with B is that one it is clickbaity, which is so prevalent now that i feel people try to avoid it. But more importantly, the idea of perpetual motion machines has been done to death by so many people. People that know your content (like us) that know you'll be a bit different will still watch, but for people that have an interest in science but don't know your channel, i feel will probably see "just another perpetual motion video" and ignore it.

Shawn Van Ness

Yes to both -- either of those 2 criss-cross combos seems better than A or B as presented.

Shawn Van Ness

Physicists hate this one weird trick..

j-beda

I thought that one of the points of Patreon was so that artists did not need to work as hard to feed the capricious maw of whatever algorithm-of-the-day might be pushing them around. What fraction of your team's income comes from Patreon vs YouTube? 4,031 Patreon supporters seems above average for my list of creators, but maybe you would be better served in trying to increase that number rather than directly working on thumbnails and titles? If you convert a tiny fraction of your YouTube subscribers into $1 Patreon supporters, you could be on easy street.

Ken Schwarz

Another comment from me...I think your titles have been consistently excellent and help explain why you have so many views. I looked at them again to seek a pattern, and what I observe is that they arouse my curiosity with a challenge along the lines of, “everything you know is wrong!” Neither of these new examples have that important quality. I think you are better at marketing what you do than these clickbait experts you have hired. Maybe they need more coaching about the core values of your content, but they seem to me to be missing the mark in a fundamental way.

Mateen Kasim

People keep mentioning the face thing, and while it's important sometimes if you have an insanely recognizable face, I don't think it applies to this channel. Just sorting the Veritasium vids by most-watched, I just don't see the correlation between views and having the face in the thumbnail.

Chris Rogan

While a title with "risking my life" in it may be an attention getter as it is a bit shocking on it's surface, I was attracted to your amazing videos because they often question or expound upon many of the basic scientific and mathematical tenants we take for granted. Breaking the laws of physics sounds much more intriguing than risking your life because I watch you for your knowledge, insights and creativity not for death defying feats.

Ludovic Robillard

You are right, but the sub-title "everyone will say..." make it clear enough I feel.

Rick Moore

Your face counts for a lot

Veritasium

We are running tests not only on Patreon but also on other platforms and the titles and thumbnails I pick consistently underperform those of a more "clickbait" variety.

Veritasium

The economics of this is a very important point. And certainly the channel would be sustainable (if not growing and employing multiple people) with around a million people viewing each episode. But if you can bring 10 million into each episode and the cost is not changing the video but altering its packaging, I will take that deal. Ultimately I do what I do to reach people, preferably people who don't know what I'm talking about already, people who will be surprised and delighted by the concepts I discuss. For that kind of reach, you need to be pushing the envelope in some way.

Mark Widmer

I feel the same way about perpetual motion. OTOH maybe it would attract the people who most need to hear about it from someone like Derek.

David Bailey

I chose B over A, but I actually think B without the "Perpetual Motion Machine" text would be even better.

Corey Gemme

That’s because they’re honest!, And while I’m here I thought maybe I would check on the status of my shade ball :-)

Corey Gemme

Your face from a is a visual attention grabber if you could incorporate that with me but short in the text of B to something like “how close to perpetual motion Can we actually get”

Arnau

For me seeing your face makes me want to click. But this might not work if you’re trging to attract new audiences

OftenSane

Strictly speaking, B would probably get more clicks, but it would make me rage and I wouldn't click it just out of spite.

Elizabeth Schneider

I like the title of A, but the visual of B. And I absolutely agree with you that titles and thumbnails can make all the difference in the world as to whether someone will click on the video.

Crated Comments

Definetly wouldn’t use perpetual motion in a title, it instantly causes people to be skeptical.

Crated Comments

I get how this works, but my head can’t process it’s limitations. I’m assuming that there is a threshold at which it cant go any faster, assuming the wind speed remains constant. Or does the vehicle moving forward create a constant vacuum behind itself? Pulling in wind from the sides and continuously speeding up? You were going significantly faster than the wind. Can this be applied to air travel? I feel like it’s possible, but difficult to design.

Vassil Nikov

The different thumbnails will attract different kind of people. The first one will be more familiar and likable to people that already know you and are interested in science facts. The second one will be more appropriate if the target group is people who like conspiracy theories but probably won't be liked that much by people who know that a) there is no perpetual motion machine and b) it is obviously very click bait like title.

Dru Hill

I hate titles that are obviously click bait, with words like "Everyone will say" in the title.

InvestorMainiac

Do both! There is space for the red words AND your face on the left.

Luis

B looks like standard clickbait. I would skip it in a blink. A looks much more interesting.

Cy 'kkm' K'Nelson

Derek, you taught us about our biases too much to ask questions like this. I'd click on any of your videos, even if it had a black rectangle for its thumbnail. Or pink. Or one filled with random color noise. 100% A, 100% B, neither is more likely for me. I understand this is the only place you can ask this question, but the both sad and wonderful truth is, it's the only wrong place to ask this question! :)