Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Dear Patrons,

I have a final draft of a video that I would love to get your input on. My purpose in making this video is to change minds (or at least introduce doubt) around the utility of learning styles. Does this accomplish that goal? Are there questions you feel the video leaves unanswered? Any other notes?

And thank you for helping me make these videos better. I really appreciate your support and insightful input.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/vt32i5e3sv6r7gg/20210610_VERITASIUM_LEARNING_STYLES_v4.mp4?dl=0

Best,

Derek

Working title: You are not a visual learner

Files

20210610_VERITASIUM_LEARNING_STYLES_v4.mp4

Dropbox is a free service that lets you bring your photos, docs, and videos anywhere and share them easily. Never email yourself a file again!

Comments

SkaveRat

that sponsor segment was... weird. "Use google for this. Look, the result that google parses out of the content for you is wrong" I'm not sure if that would convince me to trust that google feature. If you search for it now, it shows the correct answer, btw

Rishi Gangoly

Although I like SkaveRat's feedback, I think your videos are cool man. Just love the effort you put into making this information available to us mortals. :)

Ruslan Khroma

I agree, but its necessary I suppose in order to continue to be able to make these vids. Also he made it very clear that it was a sponsored piece. I do think that sponsors should come first or last. Middle is...sneaky. BTW the UK advertising standards authority has just issued their first list of 'non-compliant influencers'. Those who repeatedly did not disclose sponsors/ ads in their posts: https://www.asa.org.uk/codes-and-rulings/non-compliant-social-media-influencers.html "this video should have been sponsored by Smarter Every Day™" :D

Shelby Doolittle

While I definitely respect the studies disproving the VARK model, there may still be some truth to different modes of learning. Personally, I learn topics best when presented with the general idea and then one or two specific examples. Obviously that doesn't attach to any of the ideas in VARK, but there may be a different model that actually shows results.

Will Latinette

Kind of a "Mythbusters" video, eh? I wish you could focus more on specific techniques that DO work... maybe another video.

Shelby Doolittle

Agreed. It kind of felt like you were showing how Google is wrong a lot and can't really be relied on for extracting understanding from the amount of data it searches. Which, while true, feels against the spirit of an ad and confused me.

SkaveRat

I don't criticize the sponsorship. Just that it was a weird way to include it and the result was maybe not really something that would make me use it, if I didn't already know it

Aaron Disario

As a Googler, I found your sponsor message hilarious. 🤣

Joel Menken

So in short yes, I believe your goals have been met. I was convinced I was a visual/kinesthetic learner but now with this information I see that may be a preference but not a truth for me. Throwing the Google search in there also puts the trust Google idea on the rocks. You should dig a little deeper into a search query than just going with the first answer that pops up.

Andrew Berg

I agree with above. The sponsor segment was a bit out of place and it kinda showed how ‘googling’ something could be wrong (which I liked generally, because folks need to start believing that everything they read or see online isn’t necessarily true). I don’t believe that it fit with the subject of the video nor with positively portraying the sponsor. The intro to the video was a bit different than your usual. It make the viewer try to figure out what the video is about (yes, even though you explicitly say what it is about), when your normal videos explain also what the video will contain. You do this a bit later, but after the explaination that google is the sponsor which, for me, put greater emphasis on the google section of the video and when it was time for the sponsored segment I paid more attention to it. This is probably good for the sponsor, except it created the issues said above about the content of the ad. Overall I enjoyed the video and was relieved actually because I personally was never able to place myself into one style of learning. I’ve always gained more from multiple styles of content delivery as well as repetition.

Andrew Berg

Please excuse my spelling errors.

Coheed2313

Great job! Love the small homage to the minute physics atom. As for whether it is convincing, I can’t be much help since I already have a baseline against learning styles. That said, I think the second test showing mixed media isn’t helping the case much since the subjects already “practiced” the memory game in the first test. The “practice” counts as practice even if there were different objects because participants performing under average will likely change memory tactics on the next round which would confound the result (unless the test was conducted prior to providing any results).

Dustin Hof

Debunking VARK is certainly okay, but as an alternative you "only" offer is multimodal input. Couldn't you elaborate a bit more on alternatives?

Rich

For the question of "Is this convincing?" I have to say maybe. For me, as an instructor and content creator, it does make me think about how I approach teaching. On the other hand, the idea of learning styles makes sense on an anecdotal level and is hard to shake. As you state in the video, there are clearly different ways to present information, each with their own advantages, so by extension there are different ways to digest that information. Whether this translates to a single way any one person learns is the question I think this video answers quite well.

Christian Broß

I like the content and I think it achieves the target. No improvement ideas from my side.

curt hesher

First impression is that it feels a little light on proof. However, it does resonate. Things have to make sense. I have to be able to link it to something I know already. Multimodal sounds like it probably helps. For me, I just have to be interested. If I could just figure out what combination of chemicals leads to that mental state.

Alexander Johnson

In your Learning Styles video; the only questions I have are about governments response. Are there any discussions going on about replacing the outdated approach to teaching/learning? Great video by the way!

Veritasium

These are all excellent points so thanks for having this conversation with me. I could put the sponsored segment first but that feels like a real turn off. At the moment they won't let me put it at the end. I agree it's not a great promo for a product to show - look it gives you the wrong answer! But the whole point of the campaign is that your first search might not be right, so try a second one or search in a different way.

Felix Thewes

As I understand it, the multimodal approach is not an alternative but a combination of learning-styles. "Real" alternatives would have the same problem as VARK: they are very hard to generalyze and often are not thoruoghly proven. I personally like Bloom's taxonomy for learning. It takes in account that recalling information is much simpler than applying it or to even apply it to a new situation that was not covert in the material. Discussing that in a way people coud actually use would probably take a lot of time though.

Veritasium

I guess the question of learning styles is: is that approach specific to you or does everyone learn better with a general idea and then one or two specific examples? I certainly do. Everyone learns better with multimedia. etc. These are not learning styles, they are effective for all learners.

Veritasium

Yes! I do have a video called the science of thinking, which has more about what works in it.

Veritasium

They are yet to approve it so *fingers crossed*

Ken Schwarz

I’m glad to see this ridiculous myth busted. I have long suspected it was bunk and simply believed that multi-modal instruction worked better for most people than single mode. Your treatment is good but probably could be shorter without losing any key info. (I’m wishing for more of your “advanced” videos; recent ones seem to be directed at a younger/less educated audience and are slower paced. Is this intentional?)

Veritasium

that's the point of the campaign. Maybe we need to frame it a little better.

Veritasium

All good, thanks for your feedback, clearly we've got more work to do to integrate the sponsor segment into the video as a whole.

Veritasium

Absolutely! The memory games with people on the street are not there as evidence but as illustrative examples. But totally take your point about practice.

Veritasium

Yes! Probably not in this video but yes. The reason multimodal is so relevant is that VARK divides people into, for example visual OR auditory. Where for almost everyone visual AND auditory together works better

Felix Thewes

It feels to me the ad could be more integrated with the message of the video. Something along the lines of "don't only try the first result, look at a combination" or "if you want to be on the save side, take several approaches/search terms and compare the results". Obviously these are drastictly abreviated examples.

Pavlo Pravdiukov

The video is great! I'm a little skeptical because in the first study there is only 61 person and you don't mention the two groups were equal. In the second study, there are 4 groups and I still don't know how skewed the groups were. In the animation, I see 4 equal groups, but I don't think they were that equal in reality. If visual learners are the majority, the remaining students might not be enough to get significant results anyway. Also, as for significance. If no significant difference was found, that doesn't mean there's no difference. It's the difference between "we don't know" and "no". Your video implies "no", while researchers usually go with "we don't know". As for the google segment, I like that you show that people should not blindly trust first google results, but try different searches to get to the truth. It's a powerful tool and requires a certain skill to use properly. Programmer here 🙂

Veritasium

Ken, that video about Godel? Or the deep dive on a 33 year bacteria evolution experiment? I would hardly say those are for younger/less educated audiences. But there has been a mix. Downwind faster than the wind is more of a story of the day, which I personally found interesting, plus some physics but it doesn't go too hard on that side. As a creator I must say I've been finding a bit of rhythm in the work, when there is a pause here or there, I think it's easier to follow and enjoy. If you want the rapid fire info, you can always speed up the video 2x if that's your fancy.

Veritasium

Thanks Pavlo! Your points are taken. I think that's why the review studies are so important. The conclusion is "if there is some utility to these ideas, it is yet to be demonstrated"

Jorge Sinde

I think is a great video and your goals have been met :)

Anguel Nikolov

Nice video! I hadn't heard of the different modes of learning to begin with, so I feel like I've been metaphorically vaccinated against this particular myth. I found the Beatles query a good warning against blindly trusting Google Search's various units. However, it didn't really fit in with the rest of the topic. Subtle manipulation of information on the internet could be a great topic for another video, though. For example, I find it very fascinating how Wikipedia manages to have any credible information at all, let alone be the behemoth of a resource that it is, given it's very open editing policy.

Kimberly Green

"Is this convincing?" No. Too much time is spent on a "person on the street" exercise in memorization. Memorization ≠ learning. Truly learning something is comprehension. Personal examples: 1) My company currently is requiring some compulsory learning on compliance. The person who developed the training essentially created a bunch of slides of reading the policy. It is boring the *hell* out of me and I could not recall a single thing I've read after a day. (Empirical evidence supporting that I am not a Read/Write learning style.) 2) Someone once tried to train me on a process that I was to take over. They handed me a few pages of their notes. I did not grasp the process until they walked me through it and I did it myself. (Empirical evidence of the kinesthetic style that I gravitate towards.) 3) I am presently developing training on the Scrum methodology for software development. I've gotten compliments from testers and executive leadership on its easy of comprehension. It uses animation, a spoke script, and a repeat of the spoken script as words on the screen. (Evidence of the effectiveness of multi-modal training delivery.) So, no, showing a memorization example, followed by the information from the studies doesn't convince me. I would have preferred starting with a talk about the possibility of VARK being false, along with your animations. And then run a more convincing, true learning experiment and discussion with the participants to examine their pre-conceived style assumptions vs their experiences learning in the experiment vs their actual results. That, to me, would have introduced more doubt as to the veracity of VARK.

Matthew Gambrell

I would have liked to see a slightly more detailed mention of other learning style paradigms (you suggest with a list of authors that there are many), just a couple for example, and then explain that you're focusing on VARK because of its popularity. Otherwise you can interpret the video as kind of a learning styles strawman for the most popularly cartoonish paradigm. Since I feel pretty convicted that there must be some OTHER learning style paradigms that have some legitimacy, I began the video pretty resistant to your assailing the whole concept. But by the end of it I realized the scope of your criticism was limited. I was skeptical about your on-the-street examples, but you ended up using it well with the memory tricks and multi-modal bits. I feel the idea that the meaning behind the lessons is more important than the surface content of the lessons was a little glossed-over. I connected the dots (between that point and your silly on the street games not really proving anything.. right?), but I don't know if everyone will. The line about 1st year physics demonstrations threw me for a loop. It was too interesting. I was immediately trying to imagine what demonstrations. I don't remember what you said exactly because it boggled my mind so quickly. I didn't pause the video to think about it. Your thesis that we're all multi-modal seemed well-argued but I can't remember why exactly. I think the "well, we would all learn better about music by hearing it and about maps by seeing them" is a pretty feeble argument if you think about it but in the momentum of the presentation must have been effective. I had no strong opinions about VARK in particular to begin with other than that it seemed too mickey-mouse to be very true. With some evidence that it's not and some reasons to believe it, overall I would say I'm convinced to be more aggressively doubtful.

Felix Petersen

Great video! I had learned first about learning styles in a didactics course (in Germany). In this context, we were advised and practiced multimodal teaching to cover the preferences of all students. I think that an underlying factor might be motivation of students. If they are sent to read a textbook, they might not do it at all and just think about other stuff, while if they listen to a teacher, they might pick up more. On the other hand, others (including me) are bored by the slow speed of almost any lecture and can only learn effectively from textbooks or other material that they can consume at their own pace. I think the situation of a test or study might also skew the results significantly in comparison to a regular class. If a study would randomly assign students into going to a class and just reading from a script, this bias could be removed --- but obviously other biases are introduced.

Will Latinette

Great- You should definitely LINK it here...

Felix Petersen

On the memorization example, to me, the message was that the difference between performance was only due to how people remember it and not how they got the information, though I agree that the latter point was not demonstrated.

Ken Schwarz

I'm sorry if I shot from the hip there. More specifically, I generally prefer the presentations where you are doing the talking and explaining rather than you being the reporter/interviewer and having someone else do the explaining. I'm probably over-generalizing because of course much depends on who you are interviewing and how you edit it, but videos like "This equation will change how you see the world (the logistic map)" are denser and more mind-blowing to me than the bacterial experiment. I appreciate that there is no accounting for taste, and, who knows, perhaps "learning style" has something to do with it! :-) To be fair, I also loved your recent ones on Pi computation, the fundamental flaw in math, and (somewhat older) the one about the speed of light. These cannot be played at 2x, at least not by me.

Peter Genovese

At first impulse, I consider myself a visual learner. However, at the 7:37 mark in the video, it immediately made me realize that while I AM great at visual learning (with the way that pump works), the verbal part to learning absolutely increases my understanding and allows me to plug in the details to what I'm seeing visually. It validates what I grasp and understand visually and gives me insight into the details/description of WHY the things are happening the way they are in the visual part. The mind visually understand why things work. The verbal allows me to explain the process, even though I already understand it visually and without words.

Stefan Alenius

Loved it! I have no idea how this can be improved, but I am convinced and I do not think there is any need to change it.

Molly Gallant

I am pretty familiar with Dr. Willingham, and was super excited to see him in this video. I felt like this video presented many of his ideas in a more simple and cohesive way than is available through technical research papers. I do have a question about whether there is a distinction between “learning styles” and “memory styles”. Memorizing facts is certainly a key component for learning, but is not the end goal. But I could see someone having a strong and legitimate preference for example, in memorizing the periodic table in a certain learning mode, (by reading, listening, etc.) while almost everyone would need kinesthetic labs and diagrams to truly understand concepts in chemistry. Maybe “memory styles” would be more helpful for students than for teachers in discovering memory techniques that work for them. Is there room or help in that distinction? Did the techniques used by the high scorers tend to fit in one of the learning modes? Great video- thanks for sharing!

Veritasium

Maybe more popular than VARK is VAK. You 'feel pretty convicted that there must be some OTHER learning style paradigms that have some legitimacy'. Anything in particular? It's all so unconvincing to me (and VAK/VARK are the main ones) so it's hard for me to imagine legitimacy in this area. If I could, maybe I could mount a better counterargument. Thanks for this feedback!

Corey Gemme

Yeah, the Google add seems out of place and kinda suggested that we should not trust Google. Kind of ironic. In general I’m not digging these embedded advertisements particularly the bounty paper towel add in the other. It just increases the chees factor. The video touches on another topic which was sort of glossed over a little bit. How one person’s hypothesis about something decades ago somehow can morph into a seemingly scientific rule! Maybe you could do a video just on that topic! But the intended topic of this video I think is pretty important, and it’s OK to hypothesize as long as it’s presented as such. Maybe there is a best way to learn, but without taking into consideration the variables, asking the question can be kind of ambiguous. Aren’t we are all actually “build a model in our head” learners? Whether memorizing a map or how a transmission is put built, photos and physical objects are going to need the least translation to generate the model in our head. Language, written or spoken, is just one step further removed from our objective. Whereas a detailed enough picture is worth more than a thousand words. If we’re trying to memorize Shakespeare, or Beethoven, aren’t we still building a model in our head of a movie playing out with a script and a plot, or a movie of our walk through the woods to the stream, then the thunderstorm etc.? Oh, and I’m still waiting to hear regarding my shade ball! Thank you :-) :-) :-)

Kyle Nishioka

I'm somewhat biased because I've heard that learning styles have been debunked and this video is just more proof in support of that argument. I think the video and your speech itself is persuasive but it lacks a call to action. If there were a self test, similar to the ones you showed in your video, that the viewer could perform on themself it would do more to convince people.

Veritasium

thanks for this feedback, I'll consider it carefully. And agreed the man on the street bits are not evidence in the same way a randomized control trial would be, absolutely.

amir

its a shame that teachers don't know how people learn! This is a very important video towards improving the learning abilities and I hope, for the audience, that there will be more videos alike. Also, sound+images, i.e. videos, are not the answer, otherwise Coursera et. al. would be a much bigger success. For me (PhD), when I want to learn something new, right after learning it, I must practice and play with it. It is much better if there is a correction phase. i.e, if it’s a simulation or a programming task – that’s great as you can follow the variables in the editor. Else, talking with someone can also help.

Veritasium

that's true too! I should emphasize that more. It's not just visual + auditory together but also kinesthetic and actively working through the material.

Matthew Gambrell

Sorry, I haven't really studied the subject. I only know that there seems to be a dichotomy between specifications and examples where some people are helpless unless they have whichever two of those they need, something about induction vs deduction. I think that's got more explanatory power for the differences of readers vs listeners than VARK. I feel there are more useful insights from VARK if we can discuss them in terms of disabilities rather than preferences. If we're all basically multimodal but have a particular deficiency, that could be important: if my hearing is poor then I am psychologically exhausted just from trying to listen for long. So, in general, I am more interested in whatever teaching styles or even environmental controls can avoid cognitive fatigue, since nobody's going to learn anything when their brain has shut down. This is ranging far afield from learning styles, but I expect things like circadian synergies, nutrition, and motivation to have more impact than the VARK stuff. Even just hating the sound of your teacher's voice is going to make you less receptive to what they're saying. You could argue that grating against your preferred style is what makes you fatigued, but that should only make you ask what other things are fatiguing.

Natalie Hansen

Great video, I have missed this older format of yours. Talking to humans, it really helps make the videos connect. I would generally say that I thought of myself as a lecture learner. By that I mean that paced lessons with note taking often was enough for me to learn to pass a test, while self-driven assignments or reading was less effective. I would agree with the sediment motivation here is key. I often score very high on reading comprehension tests, simply because I know I will be tested on them, not because I am an auditory(text) learner. I had the motivation to pay attention. I would like to comment that the visual "pump" probably makes more sense to most people. Not because we are more/less visual learners but trying to reason about a physical movement is significantly more difficult when presented in a format that "lacks" the ability to convey clearly. A video can show the oscillating nature of the pump and how the flaps block the air. It adds clarity that text takes a long time to explain. Entry level Physics is a topic that is often best done with physical example, the text descriptions and static images fail to convey the real "meat" and potatoes of what is happening. At least at first, images videos can often quickly convey what is happening, but it isn't until you add the text or audio that the deeper meaning of what is being shown can come into focus. If you give somebody a toy car and a slope, they will know that the car rolls down the hill. However, they probably would give you an incorrect explanation as to why the car can stop on the hill. It isn't until the physical/visual is combined that the reason can become clear. I somewhat held the misconception, however during the latter part of my education the "multi-modal" teaching was becoming more of a thing. It was still "preferential" but the use of single modal was not common

Natalie Hansen

I personally find that the man on the street bits, makes the videos feel more relatable. Maybe if you "asked" the YouTube audience to participate they could have gotten an idea about the difficulty of said task. I often connected better to your older videos where you had people try to demonstrate what they thought. More than once I agreed with somebody and they were wrong. It was more effective to me than just hearing it. I think by having another person be there with the same opinion, made it feel easier for me to "join" them in the realization. Instead of filing it away in my brain (dismissing it)

Sam Bebbington

Not feedback, more of a continuation of the Google discussion. I find when people ask me about my strengths, such as in job interviews I say “I’m a very good googler” by which I mean I can find the answer I’m looking for, I know what phrase to search instead of talking to google as a person. This could be due to my background in computer science, but I definitely feel understanding what google is and how to use it is an unknown skill that people should learn. Again with computer science: I find that I am able to find solutions to issues I have with a much higher success rate than some of my colleagues and friends (software engineers survive of Stack Overflow and I’m no exception!). Great video, I’ve always found I’m a hands on learner, which I guess is the type of learner that is multimodal in a way!

Patrick Bobell

Agreed that related videos should be referenced. Call out the link(s) in the description during the video or put a card up at the end linking to it.

Patrick Bobell

That said, The Science of Thinking video feels tangentially related but without sufficient overlapping substance. I'd love to see more evidence/discussion in this video about the research that has demonstrated multimodal instruction is beneficial.

Patrick Bobell

Echoing other calls for more detail/evidence for learning/instructional approaches with significant findings supporting their efficacy. I was confused for a bit when the illustration of the two paragraphs were presented as verbal and visual when both were just text. It became clear when the illustration showed the text definitions vs graphic on mouseover, but it took me out of the flow of the video. FWIW, I didn't find the Google segments disruptive, but the thesis needs clarifying and a stronger connection to the main video subject (if possible at this point) would probably go over better.

Patrick Bobell

Sorry about the lack of line breaks, the mobile interface here isn't letting me avoid the enter-to-submit default.

Marios Douh

So far the evidence is based on learning small quantities, maybe when the quantities of things to learn is larger the results might differ? We might want an experiment to test people's learning limits and see if they are related to the learning type.

Rick Fleischer

I was convinced. I am slightly bothered when remembering is conflated with understanding, and I am left wondering what techniques improve understanding. (I previously read that paced repetition improves remembering and raised the same issue of understanding vs remembering with that author.)

Steven K Knapp

The evidence (or lack thereof) for learning styles was new to me and quite interesting. One of our trainers was a huge advocate and I too always considered myself a "visual learner." Regarding your top-level question, yes, I think the video accomplishes your goal. Personally, I've always advocated for using multiple modes to convey the message. Beyond the classic "learning styles," there are other powerful techniques like model building (real or imagined) and analogy. I've started using your technique of having students explain how they think the world works to understand their preconceived notions and for quick assessment of their current understanding. Sometimes, the results are eye-opening! I'm not sure that the experiment on remembering a list of ten images quite works for me. It's not bad, but it doesn't necessarily prove your point. Memorizing a list isn't necessarily "learning." For pure memorization, there are a variety of "stupid memory tricks," some of which you mentioned. Perhaps in a future video, you can mention the power of data visualization versus a text table. Data presentation, in my humble opinion, is an incredibly important skill in science and engineering communication. Few people, outside of accounting perhaps, instinctively "see" the big picture from a simple data table.

Daniel Haas

It was a decent video, but I'm more of a kinesthetic learner so if you could pair it with an activity I think I'd have retained the information better

David Crawford

Perhaps a follow-up video could video could consider teaching styles and how teaching styles could be linked to learning styles.

Dan Sherman

Liked the video, but not sure the provisional title "You are not a visual learner" is the best in that it will likely "hook" the people who consider that they are visual learners and might be passed over by people who think they are some other type of learner (e.g., I think I learn best from text). Maybe a better title would be "Do you learn the way you think you do?" or something that is provocative and probably is of interest to most people - They'll want to find out what learning styles might be and then be given the info that most people have multiple learning styles (and that effectiveness of different styles depends in part on what of being taught). PS To figure out youngest Beatle, I went to Wikipedia to get to their article on the Beatles, and then clicked on name of each Beatle to create a mental list of birthdays that revealed the youngest Beatle. PPS Really enjoy the range of your videos, the content they contain, and the engaging way you present things. Keep up the good work!!

Sandro Hawke

I was already familiar with the conclusion, that learning styles don't exist. I *was* surprised and a little horrified at how all your subjects claimed to have a learning styles. So I am curious and would like to hear if that's true -- that everyone 16-35 in the US thinks they have a learning style -- or did you just focus on those people? The basics of your demonstration seemed a little off to me, because I tend to think education should be about understanding not memorization, but it made the point clearly enough.

Bob Van Valzah

Yes, it's convincing, but I recall hearing a skeptical perspective on VARK previously. I understand comments that the street interviews didn't seem tied in with the narrative. I believe you said you were conducting an unscientific study. Presumably, that's people's self-reported learning style vs the way you chose to teach. I don't recall you giving results of your study. Unless the study results are there and I missed them, I'd suggest removing the mention of the non-scientific study or adding your results. And perhaps removing mention of the study would clarify the roles of the interviews: 1) Confirm that many have heard of learning styles. 2) As with your cited stats for teachers, person-on-the-street also thinks learning styles theory is credible. 3) Use of mnemonic memory tricks leads to a bimodal distribution on memory performance tests. Finally, you might want to point out that the formal studies assessed each participant to determine their learning style using standardized tests purported to divine their actual learning style. Your person-on-the-street study couldn't take time to do that, so you had to fall back on self-reported learning style. That fact alone could account for any difference in outcome.

Coheed2313

Technically empirical implies experimentation so I would describe examples 1), 2), and 3) as anecdotal evidence.

VenkataSainath Ravikanti

Perfect and awesome. I personally never associated myself strictly with any learning style over the years since I started at School. But sometimes I definitely thought that Reading Style never suited me better because I am lousy at reading reams of paper. But somehow I proved myself wrong when I left the university and started working. The only way I learned anything after the post-grad school is just reading and digesting stuff. There was no multimedia component involved, mostly. But, now and then, whenever I attend any corporate instructor-led training, I was always drawn towards it and remembered and learned better than reading, which again contradicts with my recent theory of learning by reading is also efficient and effective. I was always fuzzy about all the processes and never established a solid understanding of the learning process. I was always confused on why I was better learner as a kid and my learning ability degraded over time. This video explained these lines very well. Thanks, Derek.

VenkataSainath Ravikanti

I suppose better learning is always equipped with better memorization. I have experienced this enough in my life to understand the difference. But you're right too, just memorising stuff is not equal to learning. Deducing, analysing, reflecting, discussing, comparing and practicing the stuff one memorised constitutes to learning. But memorization of the concept at the back of your hand (to some degree) must be there to do all the above, Don't you agree ?

Kimberly Green

@Rudy Deleon ... per a Google search of the definition, and provided by Oxford Languages, empirical is defined as "based on, concerned with, or verifiable by observation or experience rather than theory or pure logic". So, no, my statements are empirical in that the are direct observation and experience.

Henry Liu

It certainly is convincing, but not 100%. The form of presentation does matter a lot. Some material can benefit more from spacial display, some complex concept might be more suitable for a sequential form. Learning is a process for a person to take in the information presented, internalize it, construct a mental model in their head. Some people might be more effective at that process if the information is provided linearly. Another person might prefer to have all information presented all together, she/he can decide in what order to consume that information for more effective reconstruction. In this case, the presentation form can affect how quickly the learn process happen. Over-emphasizing learning style is bad, complete ignoring it might not be wise either. To me, visual learning is more of a learning process with high level of freedom. auditorial learning is more a guided experience. Their effectiveness does matter differently to different people

Thales Martins

Great subject. For me the important is to understand concepts. Memorize is an utility used to get the answer faster. I don't need to memorize the phone book. I use the phone book to get the answer. Also in my case, I'm 95% visual to get my attention for something. If I want to get a deeper understanding I have to get my hands on when possible. The concept of learning styles is something that has to mature. The way those test are being done to verify this ideas may not be the correct one. Something different will come up to help us better understand what seems to be obvious.

Oliver Hendrey

Really like the video, i think the subject and presentation are great. Possibly change the title though. You may end up excluding people who think they are auditory learners for example and won't bother clicking. Possible make it more generalised. Something along the lines of "Do you learn the way you think you do?", or "Your learning style isn't real"

Andrew Abo

I found the video pretty convincing and surprising. In particular, the facts that the original research proposing learning styles was purely anecdotal, and actual data shows no support for the learning style hypothesis. Yes, you said the street trials were unscientific, and luckily it supported your thesis, but it could have gone the other way. That kind of "data" can heavily bias the viewer and should be used with caution. It would have also been interesting to hear from someone in education who felt strongly about the existence of learning styles ask their opinion about studies to the contrary. Totally understand the need for sponsorship, but the Google search bit in the middle felt very out of place. Keep up the awesome work.

Jerrad Pierce

As a former science educator this is a particular bugbear of mine, so I cannot judge the efficacy, but I do like the return to the old man-on-street form, as well as the emphasis on mixed-mode. If using something like "You are not a visual learner" for the title card, I would include an asterisk "You are not a visual learner*" to help caveat the statement, tie it back to to mixed-mode (perhaps with an on-screen footnote referring to the title when discussing this), and also perhaps to draw in some of the astute who notice it on the thumbnail.

Marc Braden

Very good. As a teacher, the presumed existence of learning styles comes up frequently in training and parent meetings. I teach physics, and I can't imagine student success without multiple styles, sometimes because one style is more closely related to the issue (the visual in geography), but also to make repetition (practice) more engaging and beneficial, and to offer more tools for students to make explanations or solve problems.

Marc Braden

I'm not quite sure how this fits in with the discussion, but how well can a teacher say they've succeeded in teaching when a student can only successfully solve problems that are presented to them in a particular style? Is it "not fair" to ask a text-based learner to interpret charts and diagrams?

Dragi Raos

It always seemed to me that VARK is nonsense (and, BTW, Ms. DeVos is simply not a learner of any kind, but I digress), and I think that you argue that well. Perhaps an trivial example or two of, say, how perfect pitch will not help a musician to learn to skateboard or ski would be useful.

Luiz Gonçalves-Ramos

Awesome video! Having been a teacher for more than 30 years, I relate deeply to all that's been said in the video. I also agree that a multimodal approach is the best strategy to learning, based not on the alleged preferred style of each student, but on the type and characteristics of each subject. One thing that could have been addressed in the video is how well (or poor) teachers are at teaching at each style, and how that affects learning. Better teachers would be those who can exploit better each of the teaching/learning modes, applying different approaches complementary. It may be a little more sensitive a topic, but worth debating. Still, as I said before, awesome video!

Definitely Not 3 Dogs In a Trenchcoat

I found the "How many items can you remember" test unconvincing, since remembering isn't at all the same thing as learning. I could regurgitate formulas better when seeing them in one modality, but that doesn't mean I learned the concept better that way. I also don't see how "Learning styles don't exist" follows from "Learning styles don't remain the same across domains". That doesn't disprove that there could be individual learning styles per domain.

Mordecai Glicksman

The video *is* persuasive. I vote that you did make your point convincingly.

Chris Stone

I like the return to your mixed street style. It offers a bit of diversified views, just feels more natural and less fully-scripted. As others said, maybe an asterisk on the "you're not X" bit. I'm convinced, but also suspected as much pre-video, and mostly trust whatever you publish. That said, the referenced studies sound weak. I'm constantly dubious/suspicious of published psychological studies (small groups, oddly-specific cohorts, conclusions based on tenuous extrapolation).

Shad Sterling

I already thought learning styles were nonsense, but I think it would be more convincing to go more into why people might think they have one of these learning styles. I take in information much faster from images than from text or speech, but I'll only understand it right if my mental modeling already includes applicable hints. A lecturer can use tone and cadence to affect the structure of how I connect ideas, both adding clarity and avoiding the "wall of text" blurring effect. But if I need to work through something point-by-point, especially if I don't have someone more knowledgeable on hand to ask, intentionally stepping through a text for each point can add clarity and depth that other "modes" can't match. Interactive tools, like snatoms or on-screen simulations, can be helpful, but are way too expensive to have available for everything, and will be more confusing than helpful for students' whose prior mental model conflicts. I grew up hearing about "good students" and "good teachers", but in my experience as both a student and a teacher that model is a misunderstanding, and what actually happens is that students learn effectively when the presentation is able to connect with and build on their prior mental models. Visual information is easy to take in quickly, so if it connects with with a prior mental model I can learn from it quickly; textual information can be thorough and specific, so if it doesn't connect with a prior mental model I can use text to build a whole new one. I think the idea of learning styles rests on having interests unevenly distributed across domains where different "modes" are more appropriate, and on having experiences where information in the same domain presented in different "modes" had different proximities to prior mental models. To learn things like how an equation relates to a graph relates to a physical phenomenon using only one "mode" is entirely nonsensical.

Mark Lindhout

Love the content, but I have a small remark about the classroom solo scene: It has a noticably high noise floor. I don't know if you could still clear that up, perhaps a bit of noise gate could help.

Pim van Pelt

I can't comment on dropbox (no account), but at 07:54 you narrate "students were randomly assigned" but your visual display is an exact mirror image of red/green students, which was a distraction.

Andrew Dean

Great video and I agree learning styles is a complete red herring, we learn using all of them. One thing I would maybe highlight, a little more is "memory" learning is about how well we can commit information into memory part one, and part two is then comprehension. There is a great book called "moonwalking with einstein" and it looks at memory and memory palaces, are they real and how do they work, etc.

Alexander Schulze

I think a better video title would be a clickbaity "What is your learning style?". Because as far as I understand it, the harm in the VARK approach is done to people who want to learn something. If they believe in it they'll be demotivated if some presentation doesn't match with their supposed style (e.g. if I believe I am a visual learner I'll probably phase out in a lecture without visual presentation because I've internalized the fact that this style doesn't suit me ... same way some girls phase out in math class because someone told them, maths is not for them). From the teacher's perspective I don't think there's such a big problem with VARK as long as people are still taught in large diverse groups. When I had a course about didactic methods a few years back I also learned about learning styles but rather with the take-away being "apply them all to reach as many students as you can". So although I might not realize it I'd be using the multi-modal approach afterwards. At least that's my experience here in Germany, I don't know if clustering by learning style happens in other countries or areas of education.

Anthony B.

I loved the video. It touched on the major peer-reviewed articles on the subject. I especially liked how you raised the question of whether belief in learning styles ends up suppressing the use of more evidence-based teaching and learning strategies (I wonder if anyone's done any experiments in search of such a pattern. Perhaps that could help dispel the learning styles myth). The section on multi-modal learning was nice. You might add mention that your videos are crafted with that in mind. The narrations and animations complement one another well, and I suspect that it requires painstaking work to make that happen.

Boris Petrovchich

I have a question -- perhaps you know the answer or can direct me to a link. In a high-frequency high-voltage transmission line -- how does EM radiation propagates? Ideally with a pictorial illustration. Obviously due to "skin effect" most of the radiation is outside he wire. I sort of understand a dipole antenna but not a long-distance transmission line. Many thank in advance.

Richard Kalhöfer

If you search for “waveguide modes” you will find a lot of material including pictures and animations.