Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

[Fixed] New Video Tomorrow! Title/thumbnail selection today

  • A 89
  • B 320
  • 2021-07-09
  • 409 votes
{'title': '[Fixed] New Video Tomorrow! Title/thumbnail selection today', 'choices': [{'text': 'A', 'votes': 89}, {'text': 'B', 'votes': 320}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 7, 9, 7, 11, 18, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 409}

Content

Sorry for the repost - was having trouble with the poll feature revealing results before voting.Which of the above titles and thumbnails are you more likely to click?

Files

Comments

Pietro Ferretti

I still see the results before voting though, not sure if it's only me.

Derek Muller

I created this account to see if I could see it and I still can :(

Ben Kickert

Yup, I see the results before voting, but I made my decision based on the notification email, so it did not sway my vote.

Veritasium

I hope everyone does it that way - we flipped A and B and the winner stayed the same so it looks like we have our launch title unless something dramatic happens to the results.

Sanjeev Binaykia

I did not choose 'Biggest Myth ...' as that feels a bit clickbaity. Always good to have a descriptive title so i can decide at once if it's worth watching.

Abhijeet Krishna

I think it depends on whether you read the video title or thumbnail first - I tend to read the thumbnail first, therefore Option B on this poll reads better.

Richard Kalhöfer

In B the title is too sensational for my liking, but I guess that's what you have to do to reach people on YouTube, and I really like the more natural-looking thumbnail, so I chose B.

Eli

I much prefer A, it has a more punchy thumbnail, and the title actually describes the video, where as with B not so much.

Quasitling

The problem with A is that the sign has a weak impact. It doesn't make much sense unless read after the title, but it appears before the title. For that reason, I'd prefer B even more if it had a title along the lines of "There's no such thing as a [visual/auditory/...] learner".

John D Jones

I'd have gone with the "clickbaity" link. There's a reason why it's called click bait... But you've never going to believe why! Click here to find out ;-) (Derek, I've sent you an email for a potential future project)

Kalabint

My First Choice was the thumbnail with the Blurred Background (without reading anything), but the Title of the unblurred one is better. That swayed my vote to B (in this poll).

Daniel Turner

Agreed the blurred background but title of B

Robert Blum

But I am a visual learner 😃 like all of us … so clearly I’ll click on B.

Marco Trevisan

If I had no access to A, I would not understand well B: is the statement that «you are not a visual learner» a myth (sou you are indeed a visual learner)? Or is it the opposite and the statement (that you aren't) is the debunking?

Marco Trevisan

I had the same feeling. Derek's videos made it through the noise into my life for not being clickbaity, and I don't know what I would think if I didn't know it already. Clickbaity videos get more views, but don't add great value. Getting high quality content presented with sensationalist titles makes it even more difficult to tell what is what. It's like making an ad about shoes for runners with a guy smoking a cigarette.

Peter Genovese

Many look at the thumbnail first and that's what should catch the eye. A is too ambiguous while B explains what the focus of the video is about and makes it, in my opinion, more attractive in that split second decision.

Bill

Everyone has good points. I do not like the sign in A but the title in B isn’t great either. Maybe a different title like “You may see yourself a a visual learner, but you’re wrong”. Maybe that’s too long but you get the idea.

Jerrad Pierce

Many have written this, but it makes no sense. The card on A is much easier to scan quickly than B, and is punchier. The "vagueness" should be enough to get people to view the video (esp. if you know the channel), or read the title. I suppose if you wanted to beat people over the head with it, you could add text graphics at the top of A "Visual Learners..."

John Callahan

I like the sign in B but the title is too sensationalized. It would probably get more clicks but turns me off.

Joel Menken

Blurry background looks better.

Chris Stone

A feels like a glimpse at the video's reveal, where B feels more confrontational (maybe undesirable). Blurry background either way.

Gregory

+1 for blurry background

Gregory

I agree, A breathes more, B too much text.

Andy M

Or maybe “the myth of visual learning”?

Steve Dixon

I can’t wait. I’m starting a training program at work and I’m learning about interleaving vs blocked learning for the first time

Corey Gemme

Isn’t it more accurate to say that “there’s no such thing as a kind of learner.“ Aren’t we all visual learners?. I think it’s an accurate to say that we aren’t visual learners. I think it’s more accurate to say that there’s no such thing as a “kind“ of Lerner. And my phone won’t let me scroll through my above text to proofread so my apologies.

Corey Gemme

And my phone won’t let me scroll through my above text to proofread so my apologies.

Corey Gemme

Oh, sorry to bug you about this, but I’m still waiting for my Shade ball! :-)

Chris Rogan

I like B because I can relate to it and it is contradictory to the common narrative. With A, there a many "no such things," like Abominable Snowman, in my opinion. And I would not find debunking Abominable Snowman as a very interesting topic.

Kimberly Green

Thumbnail B & this for a title: "Learning style - it's more nuanced than you think." Side note: I really appreciate this kind of engagement with your Patrons. Thank you.

Veritasium

I really appreciate the feedback from Patrons.

Natalie Hansen

Just watched the live video! I love the adjustments great work. I also really like the sponsor segment. It feels less out of place and even aimed to teach :)

Rick Fleischer

The broad direction of that discussion makes me very uncomfortable. I would rather see a dozen ways to build a web of understanding plus adaptive testing to "close the loop" of explanation/learning.

Veritasium

Thank goodness they agreed to do it this way. That is my preferred way to do sponsorships but the initial contract insisted on an early integration

Veritasium

Thank you all for your input! I was honestly going to go with A so you changed my mind and I think it was a great decision.

Jonas

Great video, inspires to learn more!

Michael Aichlmayr

If you had encountered me on the street, I would have told you learning modes is rubbish. Learning is about memorization, comprehension, and trust and the more tools you use to get there, the better. Thankfully VARK didn't exist when I was in school. Sadly a school system that accommodates the way some of us learn still doesn't exist.

Kimberly Green

Much better flow & up to your standard. Suitable for passing on when a discussion about learning styles comes up.

Donal Botkin

Ah, Clickbait . . . Personally, I've learned to avoid "New law in your town . . ." taglines, however they still catch attention on the 'net. For your audience, 'B' should work.

Michael Aichlmayr

While I believe VARK is rubbish, there are memorization centric learners, and comprehension centric learners (with a gradient between them).

Daniel Welsh

Now I'm not sure if I should search for "confirmation bias debunked".

リン

Hi veritasium, I watched your video about click bait yesterday. And I don’t, completely feel that your recent videos covers/titles are good. Today your videos and what you talked about kept coming to my head. I am not sure if this comment will reach you, given the sheer number of them. I think your covers will decide what type of “interest” you will arise, and if the audiences, at the time of clicking, are not willing to learn, to know, or to listen, the way you presented the content may not suit them. It’s a “style” problem. If your cover uses a click bait, but the content, as usual, delivers in a 20 minute academic style backed with statistics and research papers, it’s going to bore many of the audiences out. (As they might be interested in the fun and clicked on videos mostly because they’re internet surfing for some or other reasons) I’d call this a “curiosity gap” as well. And I personally think that this is due to two things/problems: 1)as I mentioned above. Audience & style. 2)I think veritasium, your recent videos, some aren’t really good. Or at least, to a single audience who had no previous knowledge on the topic, and has some interest to find out and listen through the most half of it, eventually drop off unfortunately. I will come back to my second point in a second. I personally feel an aversion to the exaggerated words, for instance "biggest myth", "why should you", “genius”, etc. Hence when you showed the covers before and after, I don't think one is definitely"better/superior" than another. I think you can create your own style of videos. And your style will “generate” the audience. Generate the learning environment and atmosphere. Generate affinity towards your style. I agree that it is important to make people click on things, so I think the direction is good, but the way you go around the set-up may not be. Here is what I think a knowledge-based video cover&title may look good with “https://youtu.be/UOaHUqZAeaU”, it both acts as a click bait but also informs the audience the type video, so audiences will be prepared to listen. The title simple utilises a piece of curious information from the interview. It says”how smelly can corpses be? Mortician answered”I cant order aged beef at the restaurant” It arise interest by pointing to a surprise/conflicting belief. So second point. Here I want to reference how my opinion is shaped, it's from this video (I managed to almost finish it), the maths 3x+1 video (half way), and the learning style video (three quarter of the way). Previously the black hole video, the flame and air current video, the plasma video, and many more like the research paper one, I love them. Although I can finish your videos with determination, I am saying these because I want to hint that some may not. To be brief I think the information is too chunky, not concise, and the core/key question is not clear enough. To start with, the maths 3x+1 video framed it as a “problem”, “no one” can solve. But watching around half way of the video I was still quite lost in track what is The “problem”. I certainly have heard about what it is, but why is it a “problem”? What are you trying to find out? Which part makes every mathematician puzzled by it? Secondly the chunky bits, that’s with this video and the learning style one. 20 minutes are simply too long and after around 85% of the video I feel like I am not learning more, or rather, it gives me a feeling that these things can be told in a much shorter time. I quit them because I think that by watching the remaining few minutes, I could not be curioused, interested, or intellectually challenged. So I fast forwarded them. I personally think that the progress of debate and discussion: how much these hypotheses can be backed up or debated from evidence, needs to be more interesting and concise. The cash note one and risk taking video was really interesting though. I have been subscribing to your channel, and clicking on things that interests me from time to time for several years now. I remember you’re in concern about the video attraction before, I’m not sure if it was the millions of black ball videos that you mentioned it.—- okay here I am promoting myself to say that I am familiar to you to some extent, although also not to an extent of a fervent subscriber. I have been a small patron on your channel before, 50% because I want to get the ball, basically; other 50% was genuine support. I also watched your biography, and from there your very very early videos and your journey. I was once surprised to know that you’re Australian because same here. I hope this comment finds you. :) @Veritasium Well I copied my comment from YouTube. I couldn’t find my patreon email so I gave up and signed up for a new one. I am sorry I don’t feel like wanting to be a long term supporter yet… I am still a young student and I am literally surviving.