Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

New video incoming! Your feedback appreciated

  • A 79
  • B 415
  • 2021-07-22
  • 494 votes
{'title': 'New video incoming! Your feedback appreciated', 'choices': [{'text': 'A', 'votes': 79}, {'text': 'B', 'votes': 415}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 7, 22, 14, 28, 33, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 494}

Content

Hi All,

This new video should be out in a day or two (all going well) so I'd love to get your opinion on title and thumbnail. If you have other suggestions, please put them in the comments below. Thanks again for your input - whether a video gets seen depends so heavily on this single image and title.

Best,

Derek

Files

Comments

Stefan Grunspan

I think the word “scary” and the phrase “they are already here” would drive the most traffic

Veritasium

It's amazing to me how strong and clear an opinion you have collectively when I feel like I'm flipping a coin

Michael Asaro

It's all about that user testing!

lawrence leavy

Maybe it sounds like clickbait, but maybe some “and it’s scary...” at the end of the title? Or “and you wouldn’t believe how many...”

Raphaël HERVIER

Definitely B. Safety looks like more important to people than scaryness. If it's safe, there is no (or less) reason to be scared. Plus the title of A is too much obvious since the thumbnail shows you inside a driveless car. B title is giving us an information that can raise interest & curiosity to know more about them. I can't wait to watch it!

Jeffrey K Shulenburg

We shouldn't be talking about technology like this as scary. But rather we should be talking about how safe and practical it is. So the second title is far more appropriate to the conversations we should be having

Clayton Greenwell

To me "Scary" just feels like it homogenizes the video. Too click bait-ish..

Andrew Lazenby

I loathe clickbaity titles. (Yet I fully understand their function and need in regard to driving traffic. We monkeys are nothing if not predictable). “Safety” is just enough of a question to pique my interest, yet not come across as too clickbaity.

Nadav Goldenberg

If you aim to get more views, negative words (like scary) tend to get more reactions.

Robert Blum

I find it somewhat surprising how fast you get used to the car driving itself, so it’s definitely not scary. But some cars are not safe - marketed like a L4 even though they are L2+. That’s why B is appropriate and more catching also. On the flip side, humans are terrible drivers, so the bar to get to “safe” isn’t particularly high. But to get people to accept the technology you need orders of magnitude better safety. That’s where imaging Radars and LiDARs come into play.

Richard Green

Option "But officer, I wasn't driving"

Quasitling

I like the image title for B (“How safe…”) but the video title for A (“I rode…”) because it is more personal. But I have a problem with the image. It’s too busy, and the arrow doesn’t convey information well. Is the arrow pointing to the missing driver, your hand, or the entire car? You intended the first, but it takes too long for the brain to process that. And is the arrow pointing from something? Maybe those wispy clouds that look just a little too much like some swirling mass? My suggestion: Replace the arrow with a circle around the missing driver—something that looks like a hand-drawn red marker—and photoshop out those distracting clouds.

Cathy and Terry Nance

Or "Ready to trust your life with them?" I think is the more fundamental and engaging question

Brian Poole

When I read (A) it makes me feel like you're trying to reach more viewers with a clickbait title. When I read (B) it feels more informative/educational and so, it feels more reputable. While I understand the desire for (A), I chose (B) because there's enough clickbait noise on YouTube for (A) to get lost in anyway. I think it's better to stand out with quality and integrity.

Bruce Goren

Sure, the first time I used autodrive, it was certainly unnerving, but the safety of these systems is by far the most important thing. And more data about that needs to be made public. Thus far, all we hear about are the instances where they apparently failed (without any real analysis of what happened), but the critical thing to me is a comparison of accidents/injuries/fatalities per mile driven by auto-drive systems versus the same for human driven systems. I suspect that they are much safer, but that is the data that is necessary. So yes, safety should be your lead.

Luiz Gonçalves-Ramos

Interesting poll. Right off the bat I choose option “B”. I rarely go for click-baits and that’s what option “A” sounds like: pure and simple click-bait. But that’s just me. My wife went for the “scary” option, though she’s not much interested in the topic of self-driven cars, so she’d naturally choose whatever is catchier. Then, as others have mentioned, there’s the question of how we should address the topic. The more sensationalist way would never be my rational choice. Thus, option “B” for me again.

Pamela Wissenbach

If the question is associated with the link title, then A (I rode in a driverless car) should read" How scary WAS it?" If the video is mostly about your specific ride in the car then an altered A is better. If the video is mostly about driverless cars in general then B is the better one.

Kimberly Green

I like B, but maybe "Driverless cars ... How safe are they?" I suggest it for a few reasons: 1. some people read titles 1st & a non-specific title might not pique their interest 2. some people are visually impaired & use screen readers to understand the topic & listen 3. putting "driverless cars" into the title enhances the searchability & feeds the algorithm better.

katgod

O.K. "How safe are they" gets my vote but underneath "Driverless cars are already here" needs to have a question mark

Markus Appel

You could make it even more clickbaity by saying "You won't believe how scary it was!" or something?

Sander Blok

To be honest, I don't like either of them that much. They're not bad, but they don't jump out as much compared to previous ones.

Magnus D. Magnus

I agree that A comes across as a bit too alarmist-for-attention. It's B for me. If suggestions are okay, you could retain some of the intrigue and lose the naffness of thumbnail A by changing "How safe are they?" to "Just how safe are they?", "...but how safe are they?" or something similar. Thanks for letting the patrons in on decisions like this. I think it's really cool.

paercebal

I believe a simple cartoon-like drawing of you on a convertible-style car, with you sleeping (or enjoying the sun) on the back passenger seat, while the car seems driving alone, would be clearer. In your thumbnail, there are a lot of strange details (ex. what's the thing on the roof of your car? Also, what's the deal with the tornado-like clouds on the top-right?). These details distract, and make it difficult to find what's really important (this is why you added the arrow, unless I'm wrong).

Christian Leichsenring

I really like how people here reliably go for the less sensationalist option.

Daniel Varga

I thought "who would EVER go for B, it's sooo boring" and was really surprized by the owerwheIming opinion for B... I still stand by my choice, though: Go for A, it's way better!

Jay Iyengar

A is the one for me because that titlw seems to reflect a personal experience rather than some theoretical discussion/ opinion.

Katerina Richard Wise

I think most people are concerned about safety. Haven't heard anyone saying they're concerned they might be scary.

Ricky Lee

I wonder why my choice is always opposite to what the majority thinks...

Miguel Escudero

It's going to be the future, so why scare people from the beginning? Be positive, I would Suggest "Are they safe enough today?

Fausto

Going through viral videos, the word scary performs better than safe...

Stanley Macdonald

If you were main-stream media then you would sensationalize it and A would be the appropriate choice. If you are an educator then B is the choice.

Chris Stone

I don't know about other people, but I consciously avoid clickbait, and strongly distrust it. It reminds me of 2V's "Anti Social Media" video from two years ago. That video resonated with me possibly more than any of Derik's others. Even the red arrow in these options rubs me the wrong way.

Michael Slade

Suggest you photoshop out the distracting clouds and replace the arrow with a red outline of a person in the driver’s seat.

Aaron Koblin

Thinking fast: A, Thinking slow: B

Rafi Syed

I think we are past the Scary point, just have to understand Safe aspect...!

Dean Kyfiuk

Unfortunately I think better thumbnail text would be "How dangerous are they?" ... Which is really the same question as B but more enticing. Feels a bit Mr. Beast-esque though as I'm sure the final message is that they're safe.

John Trevithick

How about: "Will I Survive?!" That seems the more relevant question... PS: photo of you in the back seat, maybe? Left-hand drive is a bit US-centric. PPS: Keep 'em coming. Love your work!

Kyle Nishioka

People are going to jump to the conclusion without watching the video just because of the title wording. Both of these titles are loaded with judgement. Which one you use is really about whether you are for or against driverless cars.

Rose Andrews

Oh boy. As a former Waymo operator I can’t wait for this one!

Mark Tea

I agree Making them sound unsafe could make it harder to get there in the long run. And i would love to see the technology become the norm so we can save some lives.. Drivers are horrrrible.. and distracted.. and sometimes drunk =(

Peter Genovese

I'd click on B between the two. "Scary" to me sounds more like click bait with lack of ideas and lame content whereas "How Safe" sounds like there's some actual evidence and thought to the video.

Patrick Kennedy

Those demand two completely different answers... Whether or not something is scary has no impact on whether it's safe. Self-driving cars aren't scary, but they're also not "safe" Also, (A) comes across as a irodeinaselfdrivingcarhowscaryisit.com with a simple "Not Scary." answer, doesn't suggest any depth to the video

Andrew Abo

Yeah, it's not obvious there is no driver despite the big red arrow. Need some better emphasis to convey the driverless aspect.

Paul Pluzhnikov

The question of "How safe they are?" is surprisingly difficult to answer, and very nuanced -- there are multiple axis, and it's impossible to measure safety directly (at least not with the current number of miles driven). So you can't _really_ answer this question in the video, and that makes the B variant bad.

Nancy Flores

Possibly: DEATHTRAP?!?: Driverless taxis are coming.

Sam Bebbington

Right hand drive cars > left hand drive cars On another note, title: Alexa, drive my car.

Christian Leichsenring

Wait, why are you even asking when you take a poll that has an overwhelming majority for B and go with A anyway?

Magnasium

I guess Derek takes several factors into consideration, and this poll is just one of them, not the guaranteeing one. After all, we Patreon supporters are not representative of his YouTube audience, and thumbnail choice will primarily affect them, not us

Christian Leichsenring

Sure, but if this poll, so clear-cut and just between two options doesn't decide it, then those other factors must've been overwhelming to begin with, right? So why even ask?

Max Bruckner

Now having watched the video, my main concern are fleet wide exploits. This concern not only applies to self driving vehicles, but all vehicles connected to an outside network (like the internet) that also are fully controlled by computer systems (essentially cars, where throttle, brake and steering wheel are not mechanically connected to their functions directly but are only digital inputs to a computer system controlling the actual car). Because this means, if a remote exploit is found, that can control the car's functions, it can be used to remotely control every single car of that model or even an entire line of models at once, which is just a really terrifying thought, especially if you couple that with terrorism. From my experience, fully fortifying an IT system against intrusion and takeover isn't achievable in practice with even slightly complex systems.

Peter

For New Yorkers, it feels like a different question. Sure, an autonomous vehicle is safer than a sleep-deprived taxi/Uber/Lyft driver. It’s a matter of the gridlock issue. Imagine the new autonomous world as a pedestrian or manual driver. You know an autonomous vehicle is engineered not to hit you. In traffic, nobody will ever let a Waymo car merge in front of them. When at a crosswalk seeing a bunch of Waymo cars approaching, New Yorkers would just cross even at the “don’t walk” signal knowing the cars likely won’t hit them. Real drivers would run red lights more if they see their “opponent” is an autonomous vehicle that will slow/stop even if they have the right of way. Drivers for a ride service are already aggressive drivers, and how do you think they will treat their Waymo counterparts? There’s no way riding in a Waymo will ever get you to your destination faster because it won’t be as aggressive, and if prices are roughly equal, I think many New Yorkers would choose speed.

Big Badaboom

New Yorkers have always done that, that's what makes us New Yorkers... We are not stupid, but I think there will be a more efficient and effective traffic pattern in NY if there are lots of autonomous taxis moving around... and please, just ask the cops to stay of of traffic management...