Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful Patreon supporters, this is Petr who works on the videos with Derek. Derek went to sleep an hour or two ago (at 4:00 am his time...) but I live in Sydney so I'm finishing some things up for tomorrow's upload.First off, thank you so much for the people who watched the draft of tomorrow's video and have given their feedback. We've taken it on board and the video is better for it.I am asking for your help again with the title/thumbnail selection -- you know the drill by now. Hundreds and hundreds of hours go into these videos and we want lots of people to see them, so we need to get the title and thumbnail right.Please fill out this google form to vote for which is your favourite thumbnail (mountain or balloon), and which is your favourite title (mess up or chaos).If you have any other ideas or suggestions of the right way to package this video, please comment!Thanks,Petr

Files

Comments

Paul Looyen

Hey Petr. For me the blue and How galaxies mess up our lives. Text clearer on blue

Veritasium

Talk to me -- what kind of ticks do you like? Is the content of the title/thumb intriguing enough for you to click on anyway?

Nick DiCandilo

what about something like "How Distant Galaxies are Dangerous to You", impact to me specifically causes more curiosity about the content of a video.

Roman K

Instead of checkboxes with text try putting small overlay images that illustrate those points.

Timothy O'Brien

I prefer the blue thumbnail, perhaps with "impact our lives" rather than "mess up our lives"?

Rudy Alvarez

Hello for title I propose something like "Entropy, how galaxies mess up with us every day"

Marco Trevisan

I do like more the blue one and «impact our lives».

Veritasium

Yeah, when I see "Mess Up" on YouTube, I'm not sure I like it so much. Impact could be good, but I want to imply that it's a negative impact...

Radde

I think the Text in the picture is too much, you want it to be more visual, like a picture/symbol. After that comes the Titel with enough Text Info to catch the attention.

Marco Trevisan

By the way, I like how none of them smell like clickbait. I wouldn't like something as «THIS thing from distant galaxies impacts your life», or «Distant galaxies are messing your life, learn why before Sunday to prevent your laptop and plane from crashing».

Marco Trevisan

By the way, «cause chaos» seems ambiguous to me. I don't know if it's intentional, but without the thumbnail I would think if it has something to do with chaos theory (already addressed by Derek), such as the fact that orbits of stars have chaotic trajectories within galaxies. That's why «impact our lives» shows better to me what the video is about.

Damon Monkey

Blue background seems better because the contrast is better? Or the text is bigger, unsure which. Causes chaos would make me more likely to click it

Veritasium

How about "Impact Our Lives" like a few others have suggested? Would you still click on that?

paulo murineddu

The blue thumb is awesome, I think just that should do the trick. Otherwise, if you really want to use those ticks, I would reduce the font a bit and change the tick color from red to black maybe?. Although I have to say: the longer I look at it, the more I appreciate it.

Dariel Barroso

I would click "Impact our Lives" over "Mess up our lives" which seems a bit childish over "Cause Chaos" which seems pretty ambiguous

Flavio Poletti

How Distant Galaxies Impact Our Lives (No, It's Not Astrology)

Abhijeet Krishna

How about 'interfere with our lives' or 'impact our lives' as others suggested, would click on either of those more than 'mess up our lives'. I was drawn more to the non-blue thumbnail more, however voted for the blue one as the text is larger, more readable with better contrast. However neither thumbnail resonated with the video title to me. Was the intention to keep them a bit vague? I kept looking for a galaxy in the thumbnail

Moritz Latuske

I voted on image & title on the form but i'd like to point out the phrasing "interference" these days will probably be understood as *human* interference in elections, which the video is not about.

Damon Monkey

Yeah, that'd probably work even better. :) Nice!

René Morales

I'm a big fan of sarcastic anthropomorphism. 🤓 So I'd suggest something along the lines of: How Distant Galaxies Like to Screw Up Our Lives; You're Right, The Universe IS Trying to Tell You Something . . . It Doesn't Like You How Distant Galaxies Like to Wreak Havoc I also agree with other folks that the tick boxes are a distraction. The blue thumbnail (although I actually voted for the balloon) with imagery overlays of a plane in flight with some flame element either from the engines or tail; then have a fragment of flame element from the plane lead the eye to a voter ballot on fire, then to a server / computer network with blue screens of death on all monitors and smoke coming from them. Just spitballing ideas. 🤓 I'm a new Patreon and this is the 1st time I've been able to participate in your requests for thumbnail feedback. This is fun. 🦄

Kimberly Green

Checkboxed text on a thumbnail detracts from the impact. It looks very old-school. It also conveys "We wanted a longer title but we couldn't make it fit. So we just threw it on here." Also, the whole video centers around effects from *distant* galaxies. But every thumbnail has Earth-centric imagery. It doesn't tie well with the proposed title. I think you need to rethink the entire thumbnail and title combination.

Quasitling

Saying that it’s a negative impact is unnecessary if the image already conveys that sense, and the blue thumbnail at least does that implicitly. I prefer “impact” or even “affect” over “mess up”.

Quasitling

Talking about “distant galaxies” isn’t the best choice. Not only is it wrong—the video identifies exploding stars and black holes, not galaxies themselves, but it fails to play into the way you start your video (like astrology, but real). I would suggest “How the Stars REALLY Affect Our Lives”. It’s slightly click-baity, but I think appropriately so. It would work especially well if paired with the image text, “It’s not astrology”, which I think would work better than the bullet list. (I think the bullet list is too much text.) This is a tweak on a suggestion by another poster in the other post.

Natalie Hansen

Generally I like Option A. They all feel "roughly" the same. I think the Title is on the right track, but I feel like it doesn't quite have that "impact" that the video is trying to convey. I didn't vote because the check-boxes feel very odd to me. They are difficult to read on a smaller preview and visually distracting (lacking a punch). I think you would be better off focusing in on the major thread a bit more which could be along the lines "How reliable are Computers?". Which to me is a bit more "honest" and a bit more click baity :)

Natalie Hansen

If politics were a bit different I might have suggested, something along the lines of "Cosmic Rays and Elections" but that seems a bit to close to pulling in the wrong audience (for the wrong reason)

Richard Neilsen

Minor feedback: I find it easier to assess the four options when they're presented as an array of all four options, than when they're split into two orthogonal questions for image and caption. So for the Google poll when asking patrons, I'd recommend just showing all four options and saying "which one do you like most" rather than separating it out.

C A

Commenting on the suggestion of "the Stars" vs "distant galaxies": I see the point that "the Stars", when used casually to mean anything on the night sky other than the moon, is a good term that potentially encompasses both black holes (some in the center of distant galaxies and some as the corpses of stars in our own galaxy) and supernovae (mostly in distant galaxies). But "distant galaxies" is catchy, because it stresses out how far they are and how incredible is the fact that they can have any impact whatsoever on our lives.

Dan

Hmm, I'm not sure any of those thumbnails effectively grabs my attention for the subject matter.

Bruce Goren

While maybe a bit misleading and aggressive…”Is Astrology Real…no, but…”

katgod

I also like Quasitling's idea, otherwise top left but it really isn't very compelling.

Sam Bebbington

The butterfly effect from galaxies far far away

Moritz Latuske

I see Petr took it up a notch with the thumbnail... Nice! :D Pretty sure people will tend to click that.

Poker Chen

Watched the final product on YouTube just now. The sequencing is IMO significantly improved, with clearer explanation of stuff you have introduced. Nice job!

Shad Sterling

I would never have clicked on these titles & thumbnails. I watch your videos because I subscribed before you turned your title & thumbnail style into clickbating, and while the content is still good enough to stay subscribed, I wouldn't subscribe now. I hate titles that hide the subject of the video, and even the current title & thumbnail (completely unrelated to these) sounds like hyping up nothing. By giving your content the same sort of cover designed for worthless content, if I saw it that way first I would assume that your content was also the same sort of worthless content. I get that you're trying to reach a wider audience, and probably some of the changes have been good, but you've past the point where people who apply a halfway decent bullshit filter to what they click on will skip it - or, worse, you're encouraging one of the bad ways people engage with content online, rather than striking a balance between catchiness and communication.

Brad Hallisey

Have you watched his videos on the YouTube algorithms and why clickbait is necessary? It does change your perspective some, although I tend to agree in the dislike of it.