Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi All,

We've been working hard on this next video.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/fl14e456tnee5th/BitFlip%20Derek%20v2%20-%20Large%20540p.mov?dl=0

I'd love to get your input in case I've made any mistakes. I would also appreciate input on titles and thumbnails as this one doesn't fit nicely into a box.

NB: in this draft there are some errors in the animations that will be fixed.

I really appreciate your feedback and support.

Best,

Derek

Files

(No title)

Comments

Terza

Love the video. It's quite an interesting topic, however the pacing at the start felt somewhat slow, but I can't pinpoint an exact cause. Also, if you want to make the BSOD at the end more believable, add a loop of the last bit of sound before it happens :)

Joel Menken

Good job! I love ending on the Windows BSOD. Hahahaha

Stefan Grunspan

EDIT: The ending is great. I take it all back. I think you wrapped it up well. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------8 minutes in, very first impression. Starting with the voting machine distracts from what appears to be the history and science of understanding cosmic background radiation; though an interesting (actually really really interesting that a bit gets flipped in the exact way to change an election outcome). Perhaps you wrap this all back up and current conspiracies about Italian vote changing satellites don’t detract from an otherwise cool video.

Dean Kyfiuk

Really interesting video! I think it would be fun if you put an old 2000s Windows OS error sound over the BSoD at the end. 😅 Suggested title: "How the Stars can Change your Destiny" ... (then put a little picture of Destin in the bottom corner of the thumbnail)

Achia Cohn

In Windows 11 the BSOD is actually green (or black apparently), so it won't be believable for long anyway :)

SkaveRat

nitpick: at 7:00 the emphasis is on "a slight *decrease*", but I think "a *slight* decrease" would be a better emphasis

CharlieRose

Title suggestion How the stars actually affect your life

Ladd

I also found the video really interesting. Caught myself thinking, "but what about parity bits", etc. I thought the horoscope reference irrelevant to the rest of the content and I see the point by Stefan about current vote related conspiracies as a possible distraction, but think you covered it (as long as it doesn't get taken out of context to support more conspiracies). Great job

Kimberly Green

• Just one of the many arguments against electronic voting. Refer to Tom Scott's video for more reasons. ( /watch?v=LkH2r-sNjQs ) • Missed opportunity to tie genetic random mutation to these cosmic ray showers & show how it is effectively the same as the results of the election event. Flipping just a single bit of DNA and mutating a species. • Missed opportunity to explore the level of cosmic ray and it's possible effect on ozone layer depletion, which in turn could further exacerbate climate change (https://physics.aps.org/story/v8/st8)

Anthony May

nice. a point of order about the Toyota 'unintended acceleration' issue. It may initially have been dismissed as mechanical or user error, including the result of NASA's review of Toyatoa's ECU firmware, but the unexplainable deaths mounted up, and eventually Michael Barr's consultancy (an expert in embedded software design) was brought in to perform another reivew of Toyota's ECU firmware, and from what I vaguely remember, they had access to more of Toyota's firmware, and to cut a medium story short, discovered that Toyota's firmware was absolute crap, somehting like 11000 globally defined variables, for example, so it was highly vulnerable to hard-to-trace bugs. So this red herring in the context of 'cosmic ray events' is attributable directly to shitty programming, not bad mechanical deisgn or shitty drivers. https://barrgroup.com/software-expert-witness/case-studies/car-unintended-acceleration https://www.edn.com/toyotas-killer-firmware-bad-design-and-its-consequences/

Peter Van De Bogart

"A Cosmic game of billards. " "particle collider in the sky" For some title ideas. Love the video! Spot on!

katgod

I don't think the Toyota portion adds anything to the video as far as explaining the problem. You don't mention whether the voting machine used ECC. If not shame on the voting machine makers. If they did this might complicate the explanation but many of us will want to know. Lastly for those that are not coders or in the industry you might want to explain why you point at bit 12 but call it 13.

Gnare

People often think I'm joking when I tell them the (transient) computer-related error they see is possibly due to "cosmic rays" flipping a bit or two... (and also why space-bound electronics need to be very "hardened" and extremely redundant).. So, I think this is a great video! :) (and I agree - add a bit of looped audio just before the BSOD at the end :D )

Norman Margolus

Very nice video! You might mention that audits similarly showed vote totals were fine in recent elections. The first time I watched this the sound was out of sync whenever I saw people talking, but when I then skipped to the specific moments when people talk, everything was fine.

Terza

this information has made me furious. what next? are they going to change the acronym bsod to gsod? EW

Dragi Raos

I think that you should have mentioned ways to counter this problem, e.g. employing error correcting memory and in-processor circuitry.

Moritz Latuske

"Computer Bugs Millions of Years in the Making" :) Will this leave viewers (un)reasonably worried and/or wondering how common the consequential or even dangerous errors caused by bit flips actually are? I don't recall you addressing the overall impact of them besides those specific circumstances (Space Shuttle etc.). Maybe add some remark about how relevant it is and how it is prevented in everyday life (not space or flying). Also I second those concerns about the voting conspiracies, as soon as that chapter came up i immediately went "uh, oh that's gonna attract some nutjobs..." But then again you can't stay clear of great examples just because it might feed a few crazy people.... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Great work in any case! Loved the anecdote from Mr. Hadfield - had no idea this actually happened to people. Looking forward to the release and how it's received

Mike Fuchs

Well done and a bit (pun intended) frightening. It's critical information for hardware and software designers, but it may feed unjustified anti-technology sentiment in typical citizens. I would suggest to lean a bit more into a clear segue into "how we avoid or ameliorate these risks so that people don't come away with hopeless paranoia. (EDC/CC Memory, Multiple Processors with error detection and recovery, and so on.)

Peter Genovese

Some suggestions... Title: "Space Radiation Continues to Crash our Computers" 6:13 - I'm sure it's Uranium we're looking at but it's not very clear what exactly it is we're seeing in this shot. Maybe display at the bottom of the image: "Uranium (U) Atomic Number: 92" 19:23 - Instead of an animation of the Sun, maybe an animation of ionizing radiation particles might work better here.

Michael Aichlmayr

At 17:06 you say, "throwing passengers and crew into the roof…" instead of ceiling. Was that deliberate?

Veritasium

The Toyota portion is there because it's such a prominent story that if anyone has heard of bit flips causing trouble it's likely that story. And my read on the evidence is that it's not that convincing.

Veritasium

how long should this loop be? statistically the most likely device for someone to be watching the video on is a phone, probably an iPhone. I'll look for some iPhone errors too.

Veritasium

I haven't heard of the Italian vote changing satellites!

Veritasium

this is a good note. I'll re-record the VO. That part has bugged me every time I watch it. And I'll add bar graphs for the actual levels he measured.

Veritasium

This is a title we had on our list - with "Not Astrology" on the thumbnail.

Veritasium

Good notes! There are so many stories in this arena. I've been thinking about the proposal that cosmic rays could trigger lightning strikes. I think the jury is out on this one but it's an interesting idea. As a cause of mutations and a driver of evolution this is fascinating.

Terza

I would say 1 or 2 seconds would be enough to instill the slight panic into someone who's watching on a second monitor or something similar. Regarding the mobile errors, I don't believe people are as acustomed to them, as they don't occour as often.

Veritasium

We reached out to Michael Barr. He put us in touch with another person. Neither of them were really interested in talking. My read of the evidence is that it's not strong in support of a bit flip explanation. Unintended acceleration occurs with all makes of vehicles and Toyotas do not have a worse record than any of the others.

Michael Aichlmayr

Since cosmic "ray" is a misnomer, and is very often confused with cosmic gamma "rays" which are not the droids were looking for here, some mention of that confusion might be warranted.

Veritasium

it's actually the photographic plate that was exposed by radiation from Uranium...

Stefan Grunspan

Title Suggestion: 1)Bitflips- How billion year old protons could ruin your whole day or improve your speed-run times. 2) BitsFlip and plane dips. 3) When 2+2≠ 4. How Cosmic Background Radiation made my calculator wrong.

Ali Özgür Arslan

Shared a few notes on the Dropbox video review screen.

Eric Jensen

I hate doing the his, but a very clickbait-y title: "How the stars affected the election"

katgod

I was always under the impression that it was user error or possibly bad programming never heard of bit flip as a reason for the problem so I agree with you that it is not convincing. I have also been told that hitting the brake will overpower the engine. I have not tried this experiment but I know that it is not uncommon to use the brake pedal to keep a car stopped while reving the engine to get better 0-60 mph times.

Paul Looyen

Great video. Maybe something like “The Universe DOES influence you., but not the way you think. “

Kimberly Green

Soooo clickbait-y. But probably highly effective for the algorithm.

KaTech

Much of computer memory is protected by both parity checks and, these days, ECC. The information you presented is correct as far as statistics but I am very skeptical that software and the functioning of just about every modern software system could tolerate an error of 1bit/256MB/month. That it can occur in hardware is fine but that it would be exposed to the software or logic layer would be catastrophic.

Andomedo

I believe most consumer electronics do not use ECC ram.

Andomedo

Excellent video! I already knew a fair bit about this phenomenon, but I still found the examples highly interesting. I would call it "Could cosmic rays change the outcome of an election?"

Richard Michael Kip

Excellently done. I am not sure I will be able to avoid a single event upset.

C.J. Smith

I like the crash ending! Could go click-bait-y with something like, How Alien Particles Can Change An Election. Then the thumbnail could show a particle changing a bit.

C.J. Smith

10:49 I think you should put some indication of whether this is in real time or sped up as that question popped into my head and it's not clear. I was at griffith observatory years ago but I don't remember that specifically anymore haha.

Poker Chen

All the time. Pretty much all multicellular life have dedicated machinery to fix the various kinds of damage cosmic radiation cause.

Poker Chen

Good video. At 23 minutes, are you thinking about trimming it down or is this a good length? I can think of both things to add (error correction algorithms) and things to remove (slimming down some of the example effects).

Bruce Grembowski

Great video! The only thing that bothered me was seeing what looks like a DEC VT-100 dumb terminal at 2:12, and then color-coded software scrolling on the screen. Taking a second look, there was what looked like a Rainbow logo on that monitor, but the DEC Rainbow used a different keyboard from the VT-100/131, and the terminal at 2:12 definitely has the older keyboard. Of course, I'm probably the only one who would notice something like this, as I started my career in 1983 with DEC computers.

Caleb Higginbotham

I really like what you did at the end with the BSD 😆👍🏻

Quasitling

Most of the audio seems to be out of sync. This is apparent only when someone is on screen, talking (starting with you at 9:35), but happens through to the sponsorship segment at the end with only one exception, the bit of the pilot interview at 15:57–16:00. [Edit]NB: Someone else commented about out-of-sync audio, but said that skipping around fixed it. I skipped around, but the audio stayed out of sync. And since that one bit was in sync, I think there is some problem in the actual video

Max Bruckner

It would be worth mentioning, that nowadays the transistors in CPUs and the storage cells in flash and RAM chips are so small, that bitflips can happen not only because of cosmic radiation, but also because of the tunnel effect! There is even an exploit, that attacks this behavior in RAM chips to intentionally flip bits, which can be useful for circumventing security sandboxes for example. See the Row hammer exploit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Row_hammer

Kimberly Green

I'm incredibly humbled that my feedback led you to add the segment on DNA changes, starting at 21:07 in the final video. Thank you for letting me speak and be heard!

KaTech

Every PC/Desktop/Laptop/Cellphone you use today uses ECC to cover at least some portion of its memory; the heat generated by the CPU causes more errors than cosmic rays so they have to have recovery schemes for the performance modes of modern processors. That isn't actually the point though. The effect doesn't actually present a true data loss at a rate of 1bit/256MB/month. DRAM is protected by parity which would detect a single bit error; however, DRAM is refreshed tens of times per second so that single error would be spread across the parity refresh of the memory so such an error would be removed before anything at the logic level of the program or processor would see it. SRAM (what the CPU uses) does not use capacitors to store bits. It uses a feedback loop of several gates that is stable by amplification so a charged particle stream wouldn't change the data at all unless it could force at least two of the gates to go meta-stable. Data storage, chipsets, graphics memories, etc, are all covered by error detection and recovery schemes to push the actual information loss (as opposed to data representation state) down *much* further than the capacitive cell error rate quoted. I think the information is both curiosity forming and compelling in that it challenges our ideas about the world being predictable and without noise; however, it is a bit sensationalizing to imply that any significant number of the BSoDs, transaction errors, system failures, glitches, etc. that any of us experience have anything to do with SEUs; the actual loss of and corruption of information is *many* orders of magnitude lower than the statistic quoted for hardware state faults. ECC is actually designed more to prevent intentional bit flipping than to prevent cosmic ray resilience. I am not arguing that these events do not occur nor am I saying they are trivial to modern systems; the systems are simply more resilient than the raw error probability implies.

John B. Leonard, Jr.

I have a question: after watching the "Bit-Flip" video for the 2nd time, it occurred to me that, 53 years ago, as I was watching TV coverage of Apollo 11 landing on the moon as an Airman in the USAF, could the infamous "1201" alarm, followed by several other errors that hinted that the memory of that ancient computer (now, not then) was getting overloaded actually have been caused by the subject of this video, rather than the over-tasking of the on-board computer? In other words, Mission Control made the right call, but for the wrong reason. The mention of an increase of cosmic rays with an increase of altitude prompted this brain-burp in this old guy.