Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone,

Thanks so much for all your great feedback on our videos. We've got a new one coming out tomorrow and we'd love to hear from you.

You know the drill by now - we'd love some help picking a title/thumbnail. Before watching our sneak preview, we'd be very thankful if you voted on your favorites in this Google Form. First, let us know which one of these two videos you would most likely click on:

Then let us know which one of these two videos you would most likely click on:

(Very open to other ideas or ways to improve upon these.)

And now, enjoy the preview! There are a couple placeholders and changes incoming still. Please take a look and let us know your thoughts, suggestions, etc.:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/za06f7zboh0a193/20220616_VERITASIUM_100P_v4.mp4?dl=0 

Thank you so much for your valuable feedback! Hope you enjoy!

- Emily and the entire Ve team

Files

Comments

dug

I'm confused by how the probability of a random arrangement of boxes contains a loop of length L is extended around the 9 minute mark in the video. If the probability is 1/L, it implies a loop of length 1 exists with probability 1, which shouldn't be the case. (For instance, the orderly arrangement of 2-100 and then a 1 contains a single loop of length 100, and no loops of length 1.)

Bob Terrell

I think the probability isn't 1/L in the general case; it's only 1/L for L > 50, because it's not possible to have two loops of length 51 with 100 boxes. Like if you have 8 boxes, they might have loops of 1,3,4 or 1,2,5 or 1,1,1,5, so there's more than one combination for 1, but you'll never have more than one 5 in a set of 8.

Bernard Gisin

I find confusing the way to explain the number of possibilities to have a loop of length 100 is 100! / 100. I prefer saying that the first box has 99 possibilities, since it cannot contain its own number. The box pointed by the first, has 98 possibilities, and so on. You get 99x98x97x...x2x1x1, which give the same number as you, but for me this way is easier to understand. Thank you for this interesting puzzle. I didn't solve this puzzle, but I should have, since I already saw a puzzle where either everyone looses or a majority wins. The puzzle is : every prisoner has a white or a black spot on their head, every one can see the spot of every other prisoners but not their own spot. They cannot communicate. If a majority can tell the color of their spot, they a free. What is the best strategy ?

icdb

I really like this riddle and this particular explanation.

Britta Bolander

Just finished watching this video! One interesting parallel to this "loop" thinking that underlies the riddle is actually found in music theory. There are only 12 notes in the Western style of music, A through G with some notes having 'accidentals', AKA sharps and flats. A scale is just a predetermined order that those notes are played in. The notes of a C major scale are: C - D - E - F - G - A - B - C. Once you reach the B you loop back around to a C, just an octave higher. When you get into more advanced music theory you start to learn about 'modes', which are essentially just a rearranged order of a given scale. They have super weird names but it's the same concept as in the video! For example, the Lydian mode just means the scale starts on the 4th note. So if we apply that concept to our C Major scale it becomes: F - G - A - B - C - D - E. This scale is called F Lydian. It has the same notes as C Major, but it just starts on the 4th note in the scale, F. This transposition is exactly the same way of thinking that the prisoners could use to counter the malicious prison guard. I don't know if anyone else will find this parallel as interesting as I do, but I just thought it was a funny connection in the style of thinking! As I got further into the video I didn't quite understand why it was so confusing, but once I realized that I was already used to a similar 'loop' concept it made a lot of sense why I had an easier time understanding it.