Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful supporters!We've been working hard on a video, and would love your feedback. There's a few animations that need to be polished, and the music and sound effects will change, but it's pretty close to a final version. We would love your feedback -- what do you think of this video? Which parts work for you? What doesn't? What mistakes are we making? Is there anything that is confusing to you? Is there anything we should add? Is there anything to take away?Any and all feedback is encouraged. We've been incorporating your suggestions into our videos, and it has made our videos better.Here's the link to the draft -- https://www.dropbox.com/s/0r21wrxnq3cycu8/20220615_VERITASIUM_HABER_v3.mp4?dl=0Thank you so much,Hope you're having a lovely weekend.Petr (on behalf of Derek and the whole Ve Team)

Comments

Sam Bebbington

Really great video, I don’t think there’s anything I’d add. If you wanted, you could add a dedication to those who lost their lives during the war(s), but only if you deemed it appropriate. Science is an amazing thing but to every invention, there’s a way someone can use it for “evil”. There’s no way to stop the double edged sword, unfortunately that’s a job for politics and not scientists.

Joakim Warholm

I loved it. It seems like our wisdom is not growing in line with our power, which is terrifying.

Leak

One thing I thought was missing in the latter half of the video was a mention of at what point Haber received his <strike>Dynamite</strike> Nobel Prize... (Spoiler: 1918)

Daniel Varga

Very good video, loved it. Everything is very understandable and clear, although deep phylosophical and ethical questions are raised. Your answer, that you give at the end, rings very true for me and concludes the story in a satisfying way. Wouldn't change anything.

Peter Van De Bogart

Love it! Only thing i see missing is the domino effect he caused with neurological disorders due to low amino acid content of the plants grown using his nitrogen fertilizers.

Robert Blum

You didn’t close the loop on the Nobel Prize (when/for what) and why there was such backlash.

Jim Fox

I liked and can’t really recommend any major changes. I really liked your video wrap up at the end where are you juxtapose the positive benefits of science along side the negative. It reminds me of the old saying “just because you can do a thing doesn’t mean you should do a thing”. Society as a whole must find a solution to the management of new technology and how it should benefit society. And given our human nature that is a very difficult thing to manage. One small edit I would probably make, agree with one of your previous Patreon’s comment that it did feel like that you didn’t close the loop completely on the Nobel prize part of the story.

Anne Herrington

I read about this and several other scientific miracles/disasters in “Pandora’s Lab” by Paul Offit

Izzy Armas

Excellent. I agree with others on the Nobel. Good stuff!!

John Cox

Impression: A sobering story. I have a bachelor's in chemistry, so I personally consider it with a neutral stance, but Fritz Haber makes it look like reading the Necronomicon. Yes, you can gain power, but it'll cost you severely. It seems like everything gets weaponized, if possible. I'm glad to see you mentioning this bluntly. After watching, I'm thinking that it is, perhaps, ironic, that the German Empire was willing to use such barbaric forms of warfare when it was German "barbarians" who were significant in the felling of the Roman Empire almost two millennia before, even though the German Empire was considered by some to be a continuation of the German Holy Roman Empire, which itself was considered a continuation of that same Roman Empire, even to the use of the eagle as their coat of arms. Feedback: 1. Possible title suggestion: "The Man Who Accidentally Killed The Second Most People In History" (half joking :) ) 2. Maybe mention consequences of fertilizer washed out of farms by the rain? It tends to fuel algae blooms that eat up the dissolved oxygen in water. 3. @10:28 "In fact, around 50% of the nitrogen atoms in your body came from the Haber Process." Source? Maybe paste it on-screen to where this number was calculated/estimated? 4. @12:00 "[The blast] killed 218 people." Source? A quick google search for "beirut explosion death toll" says 217. I can imagine that different sources will yield slightly different numbers, so adding a "according to " phrase could satisfy the pedantics like myself. 5. @14:27 Possible animation mistake: Otto Hahn's square picture starts coming out of the middle of Fritz Haber's head. 6. @15:15 "More than 5,000 allied died this way in the first attack." Source? A quick google search yields "over 1,100". https://www.kumc.edu/school-of-medicine/academics/departments/history-and-philosophy-of-medicine/archives/wwi/essays/medicine/gas-in-the-great-war.html#:~:text=Chlorine%20was%20deadly%20against%20unprotected,their%20advantage%2C%20gaining%20little%20ground.

bpatb

Agreed. That's the only missing piece for me. Circling back to the award of the nobel prize (when was it?) and the reactions of his contemporaries, etc. A few minutes on that would be the last piece of this particular puzzle for me

Kimberly Green

I think to further drive home your ending, you could have drawn parallels with the atomic bomb. Developed in another war, atomic knowledge has led to massive geopolitical shifts, the potential death of the entire human race, reliable power for millions of people, space exploration by spacecraft powered with it, and all kinds of other double-edge sword aspects.

Corey Gemme

The two disconnects that stood out were in the beginning talking about Haber and then all the sudden abruptly jumping to Islands with bird poop. Needed some sort of connection even if it’s just saying “what on earth does this have to do with islands with bird poop?” It needs an acknowledgment that the jump was intended. Second slight disconnect was that after we learned the importance of nitrogen, what was explained was the creation of ammonia. With no segue from how ammonium apparently can be converted to Nitrogen? And the above mentioned closing over the loop from previous posts. Otherwise very interesting video and well done. And I am enjoying my shade ball immensely by the way just in time for our heat wave here in Southern California :-)

Joey Luther

@8:20 Is he spinning the wrench to loosen the apparatus? Seems to contradict the commentary

katgod

Very interesting as they said on laugh in. Liked the way you wrapped it up at the end and can't help wonder if you recently read How the world really works.

Mike Jarvis

it's a good story and well told. I think the focus of the ending could be portrayed in the segments too somehow. It's a question of cultural values during his day. What were the elements and differences in values that prompted his patriotism and did these change when he ultimately was awarded the Nobel Prize? They likely changed over the culture shock experienced in the aftermath of the results and people were not only shunning the scientist but themselves in their own participation of a system that allowed science to extrapolate the cultural values into the horrors everyone experienced and witnessed. Sadly we repeated the scenario in WWII with the use of the atomic bomb. And then again in Vietnam with chemical warfare. Maybe we didn't have enough time to learn the lessons or maybe we never will?

Paul Nechols

A very interesting video of....what exactly? is it about the chemist or the invention? Maybe if you started with the necessity of nitrogen for life, then mentioned the use of guano as a nitrogen rich fertilizer it would more smoothly segue into the necessity of Hauber's ammonia synthesis. Then you might mention how that combined with nitrates to form the fertilizer that saved the world, and as an aside created a more efficient explosive. Hauber's life could be inserted into this narrative maybe more smoothly. The evident change in his personality from the pre war years to his institute years was interesting but he wasn't shunned because of the ammonium nitrate but because of the poison gas. By the way, fun fact: around 1916 Germany started using phosgene gas because chlorine was insufficiently lethal. Why bring up his wife's suicide? It seems that she had been seriously depressed for a while and you offer no proof that Hauber's war work was the cause. Finally,, was hauler still associated with the institute that carried his name when it invented Zyklon-B? If not, should he be tarred with that brush?

David Durant

Great video. A few small things. It might be interesting to mention Norman Borlaug as someone else who greatly increased crop yields but without the baggage of this person. I agree with folks above that it would be good to mention the effects on nitrogen run-off and compare the idea that poison gas would "save lives" with the same thing being said at Los Alamos. Finally, you might mention in passing what happened to one of the "guano islands" when the poop ran out : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Nauru.

Bob Terrell

Graph at the 6-minute mark could use text on the bars. Also, I don't know enough about eV to know why 2 is a little or 9 is a lot (or is it all relative?).

Bob Terrell

He probably deserves a separate video.

Veritasium

Haven't read How The World Really Works yet, but the whole team are big fans of Smil. Smil's book "Enriching The Earth" is one the main sources for this video -- Petr.

C.J. Smith

I like it! I think you bring up a really thought-provoking point at the end. One random thing that's probably not a big deal - it felt a little odd to me how you compared pacifist einstein to patriot haber, seemingly implying pacifists must not be patriots. But knowing that in a lot of contexts patriot does seem to go hand in hand with the military, I looked up the definitions... and boy do dictionaries give very different definitions. Wherever google gets theirs would agree on the willing-to-go-to-war meaning, but merriam-webster says "one who loves and supports his or her country", which to me would not exclude a pacifist. So yeah, thought I'd bring that up as something to think about.

Simon Cole

I like the story-telling approach. Like the comment above, at 06:16 electron volts don't mean much to a layman like me, so adding a comparison measure (such as the LED light in your phone is ## electron volts). At 10:00 it would be great to add a bit of information about the export of the product or process and it's uptake around the world (everywhere?) to justify the claim that it enabled the huge population growth (after all, it's central to your introduction and the main thrust of the video). At 17:16 when you refer to the end of WW1 how about mentioning Haber winning the Nobel Peace prize again, it being the time it happened, and mention what year it was (1918). WHY was he awarded it, after what he did in the war?? Bizarre. It would be good round up the story like that, otherwise it's a hanging mystery.