Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful Patreon supporters!We have a video coming out very soon and we would love your feedback. What do you think of the video? Do you like it? Do you not like it? Are there mistakes you notice? Anything seem not quite right to you?Here's the link -- we hope you enjoy ithttps://www.dropbox.com/s/ftq8efwakbgajoh/Experts%20v3.1%20-%20HD%20720p%20-%20HD%20720p%20-%20HD%20720p.mov?dl=0Thanks,Petr on behalf of Derek and the growing team.

Comments

Burt Humburg

Dropbox is locked out at work. Is there another link?

SkaveRat

I have to say, the last 4min or so feel like the longest segue into a brilliant ad read, I've seen so far. Not that it was bad, didn't fit or was off topic, but I instantly knew who was sponsoring the video

Shawn Van Ness

lol I was thinking the same thing -- "wow this one is going to have a huge conversion rate"

Paul Friz

Awesome video! I thought it was great. I have no improvements to suggest.

Adric Menning

I found this a little long for the simplicity of the subject, i feel you though and i know you are trying to pack in a bunch of supporting evidence.

Josh H

Great video.

Poker Chen

generally fine, I think

Ferdi Vol

I find the correlation between an expert and the feedback loop a bit vague it feels more like a feedback explaination video than a video about experts.

Champ Bob

I did think it was interesting, and I definitely relate to skills degrading as you get comfortable with an activity. I do get a little concerned with how "experts" can be chosen in such things as stocks or especially political predictions, but as the video went on, I could simply ignore those examples more

Keith Gould

I enjoyed it. Reminds me to stay uncomfortable at my next tennis match. I’ll probably lose that game though. The point about doctor’s diagnoses is interesting. Seems like over time they become more like the rats. Having said that, not sure I’ll take the residents opinion first next time I’m at the hospital. I’ve both seen and heard of residents botching epidurals that the attending or staff physician would likely not. I suppose I’m also saying be careful encouraging folks to think they have a rare disease and lose sleep chasing things down that rabbit hole. If they are really worried, I think its best to just seek a second opinion.

Miriam Block

While I was pleased to see the little girl chess player, most of the experts shown in the stock footage or animations, particularly in depictions of what used to be traditionally male-dominated fields like finance, are men. Women are shown in places where you are referencing educational roles like a coach or college admissions or as medical students. How about some footage of women looking over x-rays or financial graphs, etc. What could it look like if your footage had women in it with the same frequency that we are in the population? Otherwise, the video is very interesting.

Veritasium

I adore that book (but maybe because it validates my life choices of being a generalist). Range, along with Kahneman's and Ericsson's work, was a catalyst for this video. -- Petr

Veritasium

Hey Miriam -- great point. We have already adjusted the animation, and I will look for some more B-roll. Thanks for your feedback, it is valued -- Petr

Mark Jochum

I was wondering about the example of the casino as a low validity environment. I've recently heard a talk that broke down for the audience how to calculate the payouts for popular casino games to let you know the slowest way to lose your money probabilistically (perfect play jacks or better full payout video poker, btw). A big thing stressed was that casinos are heavily regulated and the machines have to demonstrate the advertised probabilities. While having experience with lots of previous outcomes can't help you predict the next outcome, it could help someone who doesn't understand probability intuit their chances at games of true chance over long periods of time. Scenarios constructed from human interaction like stock prices, or the number of birds that will appear in a tree during migration season, randomness driven by living systems, seems more chaotic / less predictable.

Kurt Allen Raeuchle

I liked it as a whole but felt the whole thing with the guy memorizing pi wasn’t tied in very well. You showed him and touched on the memorization track but then I felt went in a same but different direction.

Wesley Morgan

I agree with other commenters that the pi introduction is odd. IMO, it's a useless skill, and doesn't follow the four steps you outlined. The rest of the video is excellent, and a worthy follow up to your Thinking Fast and Slow video.

Aaron Koblin

Yeah I came here to say I loved it, but I felt like it was left un-ended ... I was waiting and expecting the PI memorization method. Is that dude doing some kind of memory palace or what? I figured you were going to tie it into the chess players pattern matching via some kind of pattern delta compression magic or something.... But I'm left wondering and unsatisfied. :)

Kyle Nishioka

Regarding Warren Buffett's hedge fund bet there is one big point that makes it a poor argument about expertise. The fees of the hedge funds had a bigger impact on the contest of active vs. passive investing than the skill of the hedge fund managers. I remember the bet when it was made and the talk among individual investors and the industry. Everyone was sure the S&P 500 index fund would win over the 10 year time span. Not because they thought the fund managers were stupid, but because the hedge fund portfolio was spread out over so many different funds it would dilute the performance to the market average. When you pick 10 funds of hedge funds, that aggregated portfolio will look awfully similar to an index fund just because of diversification and duplication of holdings among funds. The only real difference in performance will be due to the fee structures of the actively managed funds vs. the dirt cheap fees of an index fund. The challenge was whether the group of fund managers could collectively outperform the index enough to offset their higher fees. It turned out the group as a whole could not do that, which was Buffett's point when he made the bet. He was really trying to shine a light on the excessive fees in actively managed funds. Every news story I've seen about the bet slants their story to make it about professional stock pickers failing to beat Buffett. None of them actually dig into why they failed. Regarding the theme of the video - expertise, repetition, and recognition. The Buffett bet does not strengthen your argument. The fund managers do have each of those elements in their work. Their performance relative to their index is not indicative of their expertise.

Bob Terrell

Yeah, thinking about it, I guess this is true. I was going to say the video was fine as is, but then it got to the end and I saw the first frame and thought, wait, what does pi have to do with this?

Tomáš Kosec

Great video, but the end feels little bit off. Like, I missing some closure? But anyway, great video!

Sam Bebbington

This is awesome, I’ve tried to learn piano on and off for 10 years but I just learn 1 piece and exclusively play it until I get bored and move on to a different activity. This give a clear guide of what people actually need to do to become skilled at a task, practice where it hurts!

Mark Thomason

I love the topic and storytelling. I would appreciate seeing text on screen to visualize the important info (4 points) when they are said and summerized. I also like when outline of the content is briefly onscreen to remind you where in the story you are in case I get interrupted (CNBC's videos do this well). Keep up the good work!

Sandy McDonald

I enjoyed this video. Next time I’m practicing at something I’ll wear over-tight pants to keep me outside my comfort zone,

Paul Nechols

Very interesting and thought provoking. Toward the end I started to see a similarity between the human data sets necessary for expertise and the data sets necessary for good AI. Not to say AI is at or approaching sentence but that the techniques are similar.

Joel Menken

Good job. I did not catch anything out of place. Can’t wait to share the final video.

Kimberly Green

I second the idea of summation bullet points on screen.

Kimberly Green

There's another very common skill development that meets the criteria: language learning. 1. valid environment ... every human conversation (or speech recognition interaction) is a valid development environment. 2. many repetitions ... someone learning a language has to practice over and over to perfect their understanding of grammar, vocabulary, sound formation, context, etc so that they are understood by the listener. 3. timely feedback ... the listener will give you feedback every time, in the form of a confused look, a request for a repeat, a correction if they understand enough but you didn't get it quite right, etc. Level of skill feedback can also be obtained with standardized testing, such as the CEFR evaluations. 3. thousands of hours of deliberate practice ... this is basically the same as #2. Babies become experts at their mother tongue in this way. And many people develop some level of skill, if not expertise, with one or more additional languages.

Bruce Grembowski

I think we needed to go back to the 23,000 digits of pi and hear about how he memorized them.

Mike Jarvis

fantastic! maybe it goes without saying but drive is a underlying element too. Not everyone wants to play or learn chess or guitar....so, the elements that engage are also a factor but perhaps that is simply assumed. There is a good book by Dan Pink called Drive which highlights three elements to motivation at least within business environments, autonomy, purpose and mastery. Perhaps this video is focused on mastery but I also believe there might be something to be said for autonomy and purpose at least in the mind of the master.

Steve Ruis

As an archery coach who has been pushing deliberate practice techniques for decades now, this is most welcome. These ideas need to be spread farther, much farther in the gen pop.

Dominique Hermsdorff

<<...Valid environment + Many repetitions + Timely feedback + Thousands of hours of practice...>> Interestingly, this is the basic description of how computer Deep Learning training works. No artificial magic there, it is as simple as this. Train a network on a valid data set, then it can make inferences. The differences with humans are: - The computer can learn in microseconds what a human needs days to learn. - The computer does not forget its expertise. - We still do not know if massively increasing the size of DL networks will lead to even more human-like reasoning. - We are still learning on understanding how the networks work. As mentioned somewhere in the video an AI/DL can make predictions which are as good as or even better than experts predictions. This leads to immediate policy and legal issues. The EU already has a law that states that decisions such as granting a bank loan can be AI assisted but the final decision must made by a human. In other words, keep a human in the loop.

Robert Blum

I like it - except for the relevance of pi already mentioned by others and the somewhat uninspiring ending. But I’ll remember to keep stepping out of my comfort zone - it’s not practice that makes perfect. It’s deliberate practice.

Jim Wallis

Great video in subject and presentation. Thought provoking, and it suggests practical application, from investing to improving your chess game.

Corsair

calling out deliberate practice vs just repetition seems worth it to me. Another word that feels accurate to me for describing the extra effort is "engaged" practice. Regardless, nice job :)

Ulf Hermjakob

Wow, yet another awesome presentation. Very insightful! Thank you, Derek!

Tracy Petrie

I thought the way you emphasized finding the edge of practice and realizing useful practice is by definition hard and tedious, will be particularly helpful. It answers the bit of your brain asking, "is this _really_ that important?" Yes. Yes it is.

Raffi Minassian

Really excellent video. Well done. Don't see anything off. Can't wait to show it to my kids when it releases.

Johnny Molecule

I really like how you tied together the four criteria needed in determining what an expert is. The theory applies to so many different environments that I really had not considered before. I enjoyed the video as-is, and extend my congrats to you and your team for another enjoyable piece of brain candy.

Thomas H Jozefiak

Great video! The most interesting of your 4-criteria is the "valid environment". Would like to hear more about what goes into environment validity.

zakariae ibn attya

That video was what brought me here, to support you on patreon. I absolutely loved it !