Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful people,Here's a draft of a video! It's coming out really soon -- next day or so. Would you please look through and tell us what you like, what you don't like, what feels good, what feels wrong, what facts we got wrong, and what stories we should include.There's still a few animations that need updating, and the ending is a little rough -- but we'll get there very soon.Here's the link -- https://www.dropbox.com/s/98y4h67hsbvwqwq/VERITASIUM_PENNY_DROP_v5.mp4?dl=0I cannot overstate the important of your collective feedback to making the videos better.Also -- any title/thumbnail ideas?Thank you all so much,Petr on behalf of the Ve team.

Comments

SkaveRat

10:03 - you say 14cm diameter, but the graphics show 20cm

natbusa

Hi, at the beginning plume vs hammer, there is some oversimplification: it's true that drag is proportional to square speed, but (not in the story) is also proportional to the projected surface (which is bigger in the plume imo) and also the drag coefficient is not the same for plume and hammer ....

natbusa

I am not sure (take the below with some healthy skepticism) but it should be the case that the drag coefficient of the plume is much bigger than the one of the hammer due to vortices and pressure differential (same reason why long boats have less drag than short boats). Could you verify that? Fdrag = - (1/2) • ro • v^2 • A • Cdrag

Dominique Hermsdorff

I don't like, it's entertainment not science documentary. I could not watch beyond the helicopter sensational introduction and just skimmed over the rest. IMHO, it's a departure from most episodes from which one does learn useful facts.

Veritasium

That's a shame you didn't like it. I feel like there's more than a few useful facts in this video. Thanks for your support anyway -- there's a fair few "deep" science videos in the works. Have a great weekend -- Petr

Bruce Grembowski

I feel like we are teased about the idea of dropping flechettes from the helicopter at the end. Overall, it does feel like an episode of Mythbusters, which isn't a bad thing :)

Raffi Minassian

WOW! Phenominal video! So many things in there which I have tried to explain to my kids and haven't succeeded. Now with these visuals and the excellent explanations, I'm confident they will finally understand. Can't wait to show them when it is released!

Eric Moss

Overall, the video feels pretty good, I have two minor points though: 1. The transition at ~4:30 feels a bit clunky. The viewer goes from watching a super exciting scene with adam savage hurling projectiles out of a helicopter to discussing the science of air resistance rather abruptly. One suggestion on this part is that when the question "Why aren't pennies more dangerous" is posed, don't immediately answer it. Leave it as an open question so that viewers are inclined to stay engaged into the technical explanation. 2. The explanation of penny terminal velocity at 10:30 feels like a bit of a stretch, as I don't feel anything groundbreaking is being shown there. I intuitively expect any object at the top of the frame to be traveling as fast as an object on the bottom of the frame, since there's such a small height difference between the two compared to the height they were dropped from. Additionally, the time period their velocity is sampled for is so small that even if there was a difference in velocity, it would be hard to tell. I feel like a verbal explanation works fine for this particular point, and the graphic doesn't add a whole lot.

Dragon-Tear

On 17:20 wish you had let Adam finish because it's not right to only say "the object falls in the position with the highest resistance". Otherwise those mini darts would also fall sideways and slower, wouldn't they? Think Adam wanted to continue it being also the position with a sufficiently stable equilibrium. It's somewhat similar to how you cannot balance a bullet on its tip on a table either. Its stable equilibrium is on its side. If there isn't a very stable equilibrium or there is more than one (like the penny), then they tumble. Reminds me.. haven't you made a video on equilibriums? lol

C.J. Smith

8:00 30 times verbally vs 60 times text

C.J. Smith

17:32-18:44 seems like it could use some background music or something, particularly for the silence at 18:33

Edith Dubiner

I learned about two terminal velocities. Thanks!

Dave Kircher

Overall the video is informative and I like the concept of a collaboration with Adam Savage. But the helicopter demonstrations feel clunky. I was thinking early on that the helicopter didn't seem high enough to represent the empire state building. And later when you admitted that it wasn't full height really made me question why you'd let us believe it to be a full scale test earlier. The reasons why make sense, and I'm sure the math is correct. Just feels like a letdown. It feels even weirder when the pen drop is taking place and it seems like nobody did the math for it. For the example of shooting straight up vs shooting in an arc. I don't understand why shooting it straight up would lose spin at a different rate than the arc. Even though you cite the spin during the arc as a reason it won't tumble. Is the additional loss of spin just due to air time?

Veritasium

Derek here: the drag on the feather is simply its weight, which is a fraction of a gram. After falling a meter or two the drag on the hammer is greater than this but I will double check the calculation

Dominique Hermsdorff

Hello, thank you for replying. It's just that I thought the helicopter sequence was kinda too much and I also thought about the production cost of renting and helicopter (!) You could have done the same thing from an actual building, a crane or a natural rock. Meanwhile I love your channel and I'm a patron. I'm learning things from your videos and it does happen that they trigger buying books to learn more about a topic you presented. Some of the math problems you discussed in previous episodes are mind-boggling. I already knew about the different types of infinite (Cantor) but you presented it extremely well. The recent episode about the black hole pictures was also excellent. Good job! Keep it on.

Dean Kyfiuk

Hi, the whole section of feather vs hammer feels like it reuses the same footage over and over which gets a little dull. It might be more engaging if you added some force vectors showing the gravitational and drag forces as each object speeds up to it's terminal velocity. You could see the Fg on both, but how much more quickly the Fd grows and cancels out Fg for the feather.

Josh Webb

On the Felix Baumgartner part, there were 2 occasions when the number spoken and the number on screen didn't match: 1,357 km/h spoken & 1339 Km/h on screen (Also the SI prefix for kilo is a lowercase k - label on the measurement point and the x axis has it capitalized). Spoken "30 times less dense" & shows "60 times" in text on screen. Edit: I tried separating the immediately following paragraph off with joking pseudo html tags, indicating the beginning and end of a tangent, but the whole tags and not just the punctuation were stripped from this comment when posted. I personally don't care for "___ times less" phrasing, unless you're dealing with multiplying negative numbers. I feel (for example) "one 30th" or "one 60th" is more clear/accurate. But, I acknowledge the linguistic trend toward accepting "times less" as indicating division despite "times" indicating multiplication and "less" indicating subtraction. Another occasion where the spoken and on-screen numbers don't match is in the hail section "hailstones have been recorded up to 14 cm in diameter" but it shows "20cm" on screen. (Also, there should be a space between the number and the unit https://www.nist.gov/pml/owm/writing-si-metric-system-units#spacing )

Gregor Shapiro

Ban RayJ Johnson! [ user/creators?u=71658469 ] I would like to have seen spinn stabilized pennies both in the horizontal plane and the vertical plane in Adams wind tunnel.

Gregor Shapiro

Also ban Tion Cogin [ user/creators?u=68916797 ]

natbusa

Hi Derek, thanks for replying. Here is my calculation, assuming: weight of feather 1gram, weight of hammer 1000grams, terminal velocity feather 0.2 m/s (roughly deducted from video), terminal velocity of hammer falling down (guessed) 70m/s, speed of hammer after a fall of 2m : 6m/s, projected area of feather is 10 times of projected area of hammer. Drag force feather: 1grams (equilibrium), drag force hammer 7grams (after falling 2meters and not in equilibrium): as stated in the video higher than that of feather: confirmed 👌. However the drag *coefficient* of the feather is roughly - from the numbers above - 12 times higher than the drag *coefficient* of the hammer. The last is why the drag *force* is counter-intuitive, as correctly stated because, despite the low drag coefficient of the hammer the speed of the hammer makes the drag *force* on the hammer bigger than that on the feather.