Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful Patrons,We have a new video coming out very soon, and we'd love your feedback.Here's the link -- https://youtu.be/BBqMB2-NdCkWhat do you think of it? Are we making any errors? Anything bothering you? Anything not clear? Does the story check out? There's a lot of math, and we've done our best to get it right, but it's possible some mistakes have slipped through -- please help us find them.Thanks,Petr on behalf of Derek, Emily, Ivy, Albert, Jakub, Fabio, and Alex who actually made this video

Comments

Patrick W. Gilmore

Starting at 2:37 (Einstein), there is a small rectangle on the left side in the middle. It looks like it is magnifying something? Continues until about 3:46. I checked in multiple browsers.

Pavlo Pravdiukov

It looks intentional, maybe some film appeared like that in the past, but it is a little distracting.

Patrick W. Gilmore

Also, OF COURSE Gauss figured everything out centuries before anyone else.

Leak

I'm pretty sure that's something akin to Super 8 film perforation, i.e. the holes in analog film to transport it through the projector: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Film_perforations And given the age of the material in those parts, they're probably authentic..

Aaron Douglas Hainey

Great video, loved it! Perfect combination of maths, its real-world applications, and history :)

Camille Roch

Very interesting. But the math for someone who doesn't understand "sin and cosin of a wave of a frequency" is a bit to much. I felt I needed to take a class to understand. But I don't know how much it could be simplified or have more explanation so I would understand the math. But the rest about the politics and history was perfect.

Christian Leichsenring

Pretty sure that technically, the common video compression algorithms use DCT, not DFT/FFT.

Brentwahn

Compelling and awesome as always. So interesting!

Sanome

interesting and impressive video

katgod

A very nice explanation of FFTs probably the best one I have seen.

Bob Terrell

I'm not sure it's appropriate for this video, but I could go for an in-depth guide to FFT. The video went through that pretty quickly. Maybe use some numbers or examples? FFTs, part 2, perhaps.

Gary Nolan

I struggle with the math, but I’m not great at complex math. I generally understood the concept you were trying to convey, which is what I think you’re typically going for. I found the video compelling.

Henner Zeller

I have two comments. The term "DC offset" (around 13:23) for the zeroest component would be a bit confusing for someone first learning about the FFT. The first part of the sentence "a systematic shift" is a perfect explanation already. Don't make it more complicated by adding the concept of "DC offset" which only someone with more signal processing background would understand. If you want to keep it, maybe phrase it "a systematic shift, also referred to as DC offset", so that it binds the definitions together. The whole section about two dimensional FFT is very hand-wavy and hard to follow. Compared to the previous 1D FFT, now the zero frequency is in the middle, but that is not mentioned. Then it is referred to "the columns", but it sounds like it is referring to the columns of the original image, while it is the columns from the result of the first FFT. It is shown in the visualization, but the text makes it confusing. Maybe refer to it along the lines of : "then a second FFT is done from the columns of the first transformation". That way, visualization and narration go hand-in-hand. In general a good film, tying together a bunch of interesting information that I have heard the first time. #TIL where the peace-symbol came from and that fast signal processing was first desired to analyze seismic activity to monitor bomb testing.

Brian

No notes. Outstanding as is.

Gregor Shapiro

Don't (ever) use " Xxx times less" [e.g. "fifty times less"] use a decimal or fraction [e.g. "one fiftieth"] when talking about multiplying with a value less than one -making the result smaller.

Didier de Gery

I would have liked to get a little more explanation of video compression. It went by so fast. Maybe that is the only alternative to a full explanation. Anyways, I learned a lot. Your videos are always surprising and enlightening. Thanks

Dean Kyfiuk

Sorry for the late advice, but I'm not clear on the Y axis of the histogram at 4:29. Is it supposed to be number of bombs donated above or below ground? Edit: It became more clear as I continued to watch... But I was uncertain at first.

Patrick W. Gilmore

It lasted past Einstein's section. So clearly not pay off the original.

Tracy Petrie

Awesome video. I particularly like how you find a pretty compelling way to make the relevance of the FFT come alive. The usual "you use it when you use your cell phone..." kinds of examples are good, but this one is (pardon the pun) powerful. Meanwhile, a couple of comments about the video: 1) it probably isn't that important, but the standard wrap-around you get in the plots (see, for example, around 11:38) isn't mentioned or explained and 2) I agree with some of the other posts that the explanation of the Fourier Transform is one of the best I've seen (even Grant is probably applauding you) but that the _Fast_ FT explanation is, well, a little _too_ fast. So for example, showing you only need to do 2 multiplies at around 16:34 might be extended to show it individually for F1, then F2, then F3...then layer those frequencies on top of each other to illustrate their all the same, _then_ show the other points that are also the same calculation. Finally, it's too late for big content changes but there's another overlap between the relationship of the FT to war and the FFT to war, namely (if memory serves) that Joseph Fourier created the FT to deal with heat transfer in Napoleon's cannons to try to speed things up. And then, just for a tiny tiny silver lining, there's RadioLab's or Nova's episodes on the "bomb pulse" that has powered some important biology research (see https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/bomb-pulse/). Superb job, as always.