Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful folks, we have a video coming out.This one was a challenge to make. I hope you enjoy it! Here's a close to final cut -- any notes? anything you like or dislike? anything we missed? https://www.dropbox.com/s/tjph5bsh974mz0d/VERITASIUM_KINETIC_WEAPONS_v3.mp4?dl=0As usual, if you have title/thumbnail ideas, they are very much appreciated.Thanks,Petr (on behalf of the whole Ve team)

Files

Comments

SkaveRat

*bit* anticlimactic in the end, but still very nice and informative video. Seeing Adam in the video, I personally would love to see some videos about how you plan and build these experiments. Something I always enjoyed in Mythbusters. But I understand that it's not the intention and focus of the channel

Sanome

i actually liked it a lot although the experiment didnt work seeing the explanation and all was good

Kyle Nishioka

Why ask for feedback at this point? Replace the watermarked placeholders and that's a finished video. If the point of the experiment was to test the effectiveness of a purely kinetic strike, it would have been a lot more practical to use a pneumatic cannon like the SmarterEveryDay Youtuber does in his experiments, to launch the heaviest baseball-sized object at a target.

Teddy Batkin

I’m sorry that the project didn’t turn out how you expected. The opening with you shouting “This is” gave the vibe of a MrBeast video. The thing I noticed was that you repeat the line of hitting underground missile silos at time 01:28 and 11:30. I just found this repetitive even though they are 10 minutes apart. I believe one thing that should be explained is the scale of the city to the 5 km high the helicopter was supposed to be, to the weight of the cylinder you were going to drop.

Tealcamp8

I think it would be helpful to have an introduction to Adam Savage and maybe others in the video.

Joel Menken

I agree with Kyle, I don’t see anything that needs fixing. I love seeing Adam Savage in your video. I agree, I would have loved to have had his input earlier in the project. I’ve always been a little skeptical about the Rods From God idea, now we have more tests to prove it would be next to impossible to implement. Again great video and I can’t wait to share the final version with my friends. Title: Testing Rods From God!

Veritasium

There have been many times when a Patreon supporter noticed a mistake in the video, or suggested we add an interesting beat. It has made the videos better. You're right, maybe we should do something with Destin -- thanks Kyle. We really do appreciate the feedback.

-

I do see one thing that is very confusing and puts the whole thing under question: how do you even just "drop" something from an orbit? Wouldn't it continue on the orbit you're already on (or to put it another way, isn't something in orbit already "dropping")? Why would it suddenly detach and fall to the ground underneath you? It seems kind of like trying to "drop" things into the sun - don't you need an incredible amount of energy to boost it in the opposite direction of the orbit, rather than merely dropping it?

John Cox

Titles ideas: - The Most Expensive Way To Drop Something - "God" Can't Aim Feedback: 1. Not sure what the goal of the video was. Was it to demonstrate the destruction of a high velocity projectile? 2. It would also be nice to get an explanation for why you didn't drop from 500m. You touched on this briefly near the end of the video, but the explanation given (as I understood it) for why you didn't drop from 3km was that it was so hard to aim. If the goal was primarily to demonstrate destruction, then all you need to do is hit the ground _somewhere_, and as long as you can film the destruction, even with a drone, isn't that good enough? I'd like to hear the reasoning there was such a focus on hitting a target rather than demonstrating the destruction due to a high "v" in the mv^2 equation that was given early in the video. 3. Also, if you're willing to collaborate, perhaps Mark Rober would be interested in helping to design and build a helicopter-mounted system to deliver a rod that isn't so affected by wind and pendulum effects. He _did_ just finish his 5th (and officially "final") version of the glitter bomb, so he might be open to new challenges. That would be a fantastic collaboration.

Bahman Engheta

Rather anticlimactic overall. And hardly any valuable knowledge given the length of the video (as in content per minute).

Gregor Shapiro

I believe you are correct. Releasing a payload from geostationary satellite in orbit would just put the payload side by side with the satellite!

Martin Gee

IMO needs to get to the point of the video sooner. Otherwise just confusing helicopter, metal objects falling, sand castles, etc. "What is this about? Why should I watch?"

Benicio Costales

Great video. Sorry it didn't work out. I do wish you would've consulted more experts, though. Not to be a know-it-all or sound condescending, but needing fins here was kind of an obvious one, and falling cylinders landing on their sides was a thing discussed in a MythBusters episode at some point, so consulting even just Adam ahead of time might have made this investment pay off much more. Still great content, though!

Benicio Costales

And I think you could've made a stabilization system with IMUs and and even an Arduino pretty cheaply. Check out BPS Space on YouTube. He does similar stuff.

Gary Nolan

I love when you do experiments. Seems easier to learn principles versus videos which are very formulaic. Bummer you were unable to get the footage you hoped for, but I love that you did this nonetheless.

Daniel Fleck

I agree with others here that it seems like more thought went in to making a sand castle than the actual drop. To be honest, the physics are shown better in a typical How Ridiculous video even if "Science with Gaunson" is just a joke. The HR guys would probably love to do a collab if you want to give it another try. They've got a lot of experience dropping heavy items from high up. Giant dart was super accurate, and spheres/cubes seem to be the next best bet.

Marc Braden

Sometimes when things fail/don't work out, it's just as interesting as if they had, or even more. So far this doesn't look like one of those situations. I don't know if there's away to re-focus the video to make it more "impactful".

TTST

It seems worth discussing the one somewhat real test of the Brilliant Pebbles Program: See test #2 in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brilliant_Pebbles Note that its failure involved gyroscopes, which I'm guessing were like the ones used in space attitude control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Control_moment_gyroscope As pointed out above, to "drop" a thing from space, it needs de-orbiting thrust. For a successful simulated "drop" from inside the atmosphere, it might also be easier to put some well-aimed momentum into the object from the drop platform, maybe a sling shot? :-)

Michael Lawless

The video was great. It shows just how difficult a weapon like that could be to develop. Great work.