Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Back in 2019, I emailed the National High Magnetic Field Lab in Tallahassee Florida because I wanted to come and visit the World's Strongest Magnet. We had a visit scheduled. Then Covid hit. Then just before another planned visit in 2022, the magnet broke. This video has been a white whale for me and now I've finally managed to get it done.

I would love your feedback on this preview. Anything you particularly like/don't like? Any sections that could be better explained?

Thank you for your ongoing support of this channel. I value so much your input on these videos.

Best,

Derek

Files

World's Strongest Magnet

Been working on this video for a long time!

Comments

Robert Blum

Nice! Just two comments: 1. When you introduce the facility, the year on the Guinness certificate is a year off from what you’re saying and the plaque before has a different year on it (construction of facility) so this is a bit confusing/distracting. I’d use different visuals/ change the timing. 2. The animation/ intro to magnetism is run and spoken way too fast - impossible to understand as is so you might as well skip it. Or speak at a slower pace so folks have time to look at the animation. You could just focus on the magnetic domains, which is done well.

Віталій Єфремов

I like it. Maybe it's too complicated. Just want it to be a bit simple. Maybe adding some story about André-Marie Ampère. Maybe too much attention to superconducting levitation. Just want my children liked it too. Sorry for my bad English. Thanks a lot for your work.

Veritasium

Good feedback - I'll rework these two sections

John Cox

1. For the intro with the Tesla comparison, would an animated bar chart be feasible? A bar chart could convey the comparative magnetic field strengths quickly and concisely. 2. @3:33 What are we looking at that takes 47,000A? They look like capacitors or heat sinks, but you say "outer superconducting electromagnet" when showing this. I don't see cryogenic coolant around there. Are we looking at superconducting magnets or something else? 3. @9:44 Is the IR video offset from the regular video? If that's the effect of the magnetic field, it would be cool to call that out. 4. @12:08 Did this national lab just have a potato canon just lying around? Is this normal? No one seems surprised that they just have one available for this experiment. 5. @16:39 There is a guy holding something on a string just before you show the levitating strawberry. I trust you with this footage, but that probably isn't the best transition :). Is there footage of him cutting the strawberry loose? 6. @20:42 Is that the pokemon Electabuzz on the door? 7. Would you send a calendar event to try to check back in 5 years and see what kinds of research has resulted from this kind of magnet? I am very interested to see what he means by "just barely scratched the surface" in terms of materials advancement.

Chris Mullin

I agree this is a tough concept to explain in detail. Could you tie the behavior of electrons around a nucleus as a current to the effects of currents in the conductors later on? The animations of how different atoms or domains could cancel each other out were very effective. Could you refer to those when you describe how different materials react to the field, eg. conductors get their currents lined up by the field, diamagnets get atoms lined up, etc?

Chris Mullin

Also, the clip with the dent in the water was to short, and we didn't know what we were looking for until after the clip was done. An animated arrow pointing at the dent you're talking about would help a lot, too.

John Ty Dibble

This is just my idea for a hook to grab the attention of your audience and draw them in. Play on words intended magnetically of course! Introduction: This is an inflection point. Talk about what an inflection point means in math, physics and philosophically. How we see things changes as our viewpoint changes. Illustrate a small magnetically created deflection/inflection. Proceed with the rest of your fantastic presentation. Thanks so much! You ALWAYS. Make my time listening worthwhile!

Michael Tuvim

A bit too much on the failed coil: inside, outside...

katgod

Very interesting, in case you don't know the old analog speedometers produced a torque based on the rpm of a magnet that spun in an aluminum cup. This was my introduction to eddy currents.

Folland Family

At 7:35 plastic, something else, copper and aluminium. what was something else? the line lacks the rigour your videos normally have. Cool demonstration of the metals.

Veritasium

2. That's where the current comes in, so it's part of the power supply 3. That's just the dodgy FLIR iPhone attachment 4. Yes, they use the potato cannon on their open day *shrug emoji* 5. Yeah we lowered objects into the bore on an aluminum cup attached to some thread 6. Probably yes 7. That's a good idea!

Veritasium

totally! That's meant to be a temp line. I think they are two different types of plastic. I'll replace.

Paul Weiss

Great stuff. The presenter seems to having too much fun! I think that an area which could be beefed up to keep a larger audience nodding their head with understanding might be more graphics explaining eddy currents, since those phenomena take up a large part of the video’s run time.

Daniel Turner

I find the lack of engagement on this platform disappointing, so time to reconsider my monthly pledge and settle for Dr Muller's everlasting gratitude. Akin to that I received when backing the Snatoms campaign on Kickstarter.