Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi All,

This video will be going live in the next few days and I would love to get your feedback. There are still a number of sections where we are missing visuals but please let me know what's working for you and what is confusing. And let me know if you spot any mistakes etc.

I cannot thank you enough for supporting the channel and for providing feedback on early drafts of videos. It really helps to have extra pairs of eyes check over everything and help shape the narrative.

Best,

Derek

Files

What Everyone Gets Wrong About Energy

One of the most important, yet least understood, concepts in all of physics. Head to https://brilliant.org/veritasium to start your free 30-day trial, and the first 200 people get 20% off an annual premium subscription. If you're looking for a molecular modeling kit, try Snatoms - a kit I invented where the atoms snap together magnetically: https://snatoms.com ▀▀▀ A huge thank you to those who helped us understand different aspects of this complicated topic - Dr. Ashmeet Singh, Supriya Krishnamurthy, Dr. Jos Thijssen, Dr. Bijoy Bera, Dr. Timon Idema, and Dr. Misha Titov. ▀▀▀ References: Carnot, S. (1824). Reflections on the motive power of heat: and on machines fitted to develop that power. - https://ve42.co/Carnot1890 Harnessing The True Power Of Atoms | Order And Disorder Documentaries, Spark via YouTube - https://ve42.co/OrderDisorder A better description of entropy, Steve Mould via YouTube - https://ve42.co/Mould2016 Dugdale, J. S. (1996). Entropy and its physical meaning. CRC Press. - https://ve42.co/Dugdale1996 Schroeder, D. V. (1999). An introduction to thermal physics. - https://ve42.co/Schroeder2021 Fowler, M. Heat Engines: the Carnot Cycle, University of Virginia. - https://ve42.co/Fowler2023 Chandler, D.L. (2010). Explained: The Carnot Limit, MIT News - https://ve42.co/Chandler2010 Entropy, Wikipedia - https://ve42.co/EntropyWiki Clausius, R. (1867). The mechanical theory of heat. Van Voorst. - https://ve42.co/Clausius1867 What is entropy? TED-Ed via YouTube - https://ve42.co/Phillips2017 Thijssen, J. (2018) Lecture Notes Statistical Physics, TU Delft. Schneider, E. D., & Kay, J. J. (1994). Life as a manifestation of the second law of thermodynamics. Mathematical and computer modelling, 19(6-8), 25-48. - https://ve42.co/Schneider1994 Lineweaver, C. H., & Egan, C. A. (2008). Life, gravity and the second law of thermodynamics. Physics of Life Reviews, 5(4), 225-242. - https://ve42.co/Lineweaver2008 Michaelian, K. (2012). HESS Opinions" Biological catalysis of the hydrological cycle: life's thermodynamic function". Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 16(8), 2629-2645. - https://ve42.co/Michaelian2012 England, J. L. (2013). Statistical physics of self-replication. The Journal of chemical physics, 139(12), 09B623_1. - https://ve42.co/England2013 England, J. L. (2015). Dissipative adaptation in driven self-assembly. Nature nanotechnology, 10(11), 919-923. - https://ve42.co/England2015 Wolchover, N. (2014). A New Physics Theory of Life, Quantamagazine - https://ve42.co/Wolchover2014 Lineweaver, C. H. (2013). The entropy of the universe and the maximum entropy production principle. In Beyond the Second Law: Entropy Production and Non-equilibrium Systems (pp. 415-427). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg. - https://ve42.co/LineweaverEntropy Bekenstein, J.D. (1972). Black holes and the second law. Lett. Nuovo Cimento 4, 737–740. - https://ve42.co/Bekenstein1972 Carroll, S.M. (2022). The Biggest Ideas in the Universe: Space, Time, and Motion. Penguin Publishing Group. - https://ve42.co/Carroll2022 Black hole thermodynamics, Wikipedia - https://ve42.co/BlackHoleTD Cosmology and the arrow of time: Sean Carroll at TEDxCaltech, TEDx Talks via YouTube - https://ve42.co/CarrollTEDx Carroll, S. M. (2008). The cosmic origins of time’s arrow. Scientific American, 298(6), 48-57. - https://ve42.co/Carroll2008 The Passage of Time and the Meaning of Life | Sean Carroll (Talk + Q&A), Long Now Foundation via YouTube - https://ve42.co/CarrollLNF ▀▀▀ Special thanks to our Patreon supporters: Emil Abu Milad, Tj Steyn, meg noah, Bernard McGee, KeyWestr, Amadeo Bee, TTST, Balkrishna Heroor, John H. Austin, Jr., john kiehl, Anton Ragin, Diffbot, Gnare, Dave Kircher, Burt Humburg, Blake Byers, Evgeny Skvortsov, Meekay, Bill Linder, Paul Peijzel, Josh Hibschman, Mac Malkawi, Juan Benet, Ubiquity Ventures, Richard Sundvall, Lee Redden, Stephen Wilcox, Marinus Kuivenhoven, Michael Krugman, Sam Lutfi. ▀▀▀ Written by Casper Mebius & Derek Muller Edited by Trenton Oliver & Jamie MacLeod Animated by Mike Radjabov, Ivy Tello, Fabio Albertelli and Jakub Misiek Filmed by Derek Muller Additional video/photos supplied by Getty Images, Pond5 and by courtesy of NASA, NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center, NASA Goddard Flight Lab/ CI Lab, NASA/SDO and the AIA, EVE, HMI, and WMAP science teams. Music from Epidemic Sound & Jonny Hyman Produced by Derek Muller, Petr Lebedev, Emily Zhang, & Casper Mebius

Comments

James Lear

The Carnot cycle explanation was a bit confusing to me. 1. I suspect the small volume of air at 4:40 should not be orange; PV=nRT for approximately constant pressure of a sealed container implies lower temperature before the chamber is heated. 2. At 4:50, why does the air continue to expand? Is it momentum from the flywheel, reducing pressure and temperature? 3. At 5:05, why is the air already the temperature of the cold bar? Is the cold bar a heat sink for increased temperature when the flywheel's momentum reduces volume? It seems like I'm missing something or the contact with hot and cold should be mostly in phase with expansion and compression. 4. At 6:40, why is the work done by hot always greater than work done by cold? I mean, pressure changes due to temperature change drives the engine, but it seems like an explanation is missing. The rest makes sense to me. I stumbled mentally on neutrinos having so much more of a measurable concept than the early universe - but that resolves when you reiterate that entropy units increase with time.

Bartosz Błaszkiewicz

I'm at 14:22 and I like the video so far, but as for the demonstration with those 8-atom bars (and 80-atom later on) I'd like some clearer emphasis that this is not how heat transfer works, but close enough for our demonstration.

Bartosz Błaszkiewicz

19:50 - energy evenly spread out is not the highest entropy. In fact it is another kind of order. That's why this state was very unstable (an unstable equilibrium). Lowest quantum fluctuation would allow gravity to concentrate energy at that point and form a star or a galaxy.

Bartosz Błaszkiewicz

22:00 There is no such thing as "degree Kelvin". It's just "Kelvin".

Ryan Hamilton

I agree with James, and found the Carnot cycle confusing. It makes sense that the hot bar would cause the air to expand, while in contact. (Since the air is otherwise cold). But I don't think I understand why it would continue to expand after the bar is removed. And further, once the air cools down, why does bringing it in contact with the cold bar do anything? That being said, I loved the video!

Ryan Hamilton

Great to see the return of "ask people on the street" to Veritasium. I always love those segments.

Robert Blum

Thanks for posting this. Great material. Two comments: 1. When you introduce Jacob Bekenstein and the paper he published as a grad student in 1972 (he was 25 years old at the time), you simultaneously show a picture of him at 62. If there are no better pictures then maybe change the wording/timing, so it’s clear that this is not him as a grad student. It’s a little distracting. 2. At 23:47 you state that the “arrow of time itself would disappear” but you have not previously mentioned that the increase in entropy defines the direction of time. It would be nice to add it somewhere earlier in the vide - for example how we can tell whether a movie is running forward or backward by whether things become more or less or organized/ whether the entropy is increasing or decreasing.

Kyle Nishioka

Is this Say without using the word meme but with entropy? I remember my chemistry and thermodynamics professors in college struggling to simplify the concept of entropy down to the level where an undergrad could grasp it. Chemistry had it particularly hard because the lecture ends at the point where we look up the value of entropy for any element in our text books and use it in our calcs. This video is trying to compress what should be a very long physics course rather than slicing it up into bite sized pieces. This may sound harsh but I don't think this video will help the average person understand entropy. Too much detail at the beginning without laying the ground work for where you are ultimately heading. There's no through line to link the beginning to the end unless you already understand entropy. When I watched the ending of the video and then looped back around to the question at the beginning, it was very clear how far the topic of the video strayed from the intro. Minor nitpick. I remember the definition of absolute zero requiring all the atoms being arranged in a perfect matrix in addition to being stationary. Not sure if this is really true.

pglpm

Derek, I always refer my students to your videos for insight and an invaluable visual understanding. Thank you so much for the continuous amazing work. There's one video that I tell my students to avoid, though: the one about the speed of light, which unfornutanely misses a couple of important points and introduces several misleading or incorrect ones. The present video unfortunately suffers from the same problem. Some confusing or missed points: • What do you mean by "energy spreads out"? it seems like you mean spatially, but that's misleading. • Please don't present entropy as "disorder". There are states, eg for liquid crystals, that are more "disorered" than others from all possible points of view, and yet have lower entropy. See https://doi.org/10.1021/ed079p187 or https://doi.org/10.1119/1.1287353. I always have to spend quite some time trying to eradicate that idea from students. An honest and simple way to introduce entropy is as an upper bound to how fast heat can be transferred into a body – which is also clear from the equation Q ≤ T⋅dS/dt (Q is energy/time). See eg https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4612-5206-1 around p. 67. • The entropy of a system depends on the scale and the way we describe the system (unlike its energy: for the latter, the "forms" change, not the total amount; but see below). So there's no such thing as "the entropy of the Earth" or "of the Sun" or of a glass of water – one must first specify how and on what scale those systems are described: atomic level? continuum level on a metre-scale? or on a km-scale? See for example https://doi.org/10.1002/cpa.3160140312 (around p. 325). • We live in times where relativity theory is not just a theoretical curiosity. General relativity says that it's a tricky matter to define the "total energy" of an extended system. Locally, energy density can always be conserved by a change of coordinates. But globally energy is in general a balanced, but not conserved, quantity. On both points see eg https://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/GR/energy_gr.html and Landau & Lifshitz https://doi.org/10.1016/C2009-0-14608-1 (the last footnote of §95); but the same discussion appears in Misner-Thorne-Wheeler's Gravitation. • I agree with James's comment about expansion: it'd be clearer to somehow mention that the external pressure exerted on the piston is slightly less than that exerted by the gas; that's why the expansion continues. Apart from these points, the illustration of the equipartition theorem and its effect when systems are coupled is very neat. But here too it's important to warn students and viewer that there are systems (say, granular materials) which show violations of it. The historical background is wonderful as usual. I know it's really hard to explain some things simply without ending up giving wrong information – most of your videos are great because they address exactly this problem. "Teaching thermal physics/ Is as easy as a song:/ You think you make it simpler/ When you make it slightly wrong!" (M. W. Zemansky, https://doi.org/10.1119/1.2351512)

Daniel Turner

Finally, Patron engagement on an upcoming video! And yet, due to the recent lack of engagement, I've already opted to cancel my Patreon pledge. So long and thanks for all the fish.

Edith Dubiner

Thank you for the video. I suggest tweaking the sound level so the animation parts fit better with the parts when you speak directly to the camera. As a girl, I found the idea of entropy and physics that is not time-symmetric very perplexing. I wish I could have watched this video back then... On the whole, I thought the concept of entropy was explained very well. I especially liked (1) the narrower distributions for possible combinations as the number of "heat packets" increase, and (2) mentioning that the interesting systems are when we have a mixture of low and high entropy. After reading pglpm's comment, I feel like I probably don't understand as much as I thought. Perhaps add clarifications in the video (could be written side-notes) when there are oversimplifications or non-precise terminology. It would also be nice to include links for deep-dives in the description. Finally, I do not require Patreon engagement or any other bonuses to be attached to supporting the channel. I am just happy I can contribute in some way to the generation of this valuable and high quality content. Keep it up!

John Cox

What struck me was that each of these scientists tend to be known for one thing. For all their years of study, a career in science ends up pushing into the unknown just a little bit.

Roger Neyman

The flip side of low entropy is high potential for novelty, choice, and the like, and that may be tied to the nature of consciousness. Such speculations ought to be part and parcel of discussion of the 2nd law and entropy, because thermodynamics is different from all other laws people run across as they learn physics. It's of a completely different order. the successive layers of order leading from quarks to atoms to molecules to substances to living cells to higher order organisms to civilizations all ultimately feed off that ultimately highly ordered initial conditions of the cosmos. Such complexity can only arise in states where the higher-energy domains, usually too simple to support evolving complexity, can no longer dominate. Merely the number of proteins that can be created outpaces the universes physical capacity to explore that possibility space. This is part of the essence of complexity - that it opens up possibilities. The fact that such complexity arises surfing the wave of increasing entropy is a profoundly important statement of reality. (This is why the 2nd law seems so out of place among the other laws of physics.) So what does the sun provide us? not just concentrated energy, but, importantly, distant concentrated energy that can be safely channelled. A small portion of the sky, very hot, that differentially interacts with the complexity in the terrestrial sphere. One small quibble, but I think worth mentioning. You say that energy output from the Earth equals energy input from the sun. In the long run, of course, that is true. But we are experiencing global warming because we are at disequilibrium. Even if our GHG budgets went instantly to 0 net we would continue to experience warming for several decades. The details of how energy is transformed as it passes from the 3K hotspot to the 3C average out is very important.

Patrick W. Gilmore

GREAT video. First, I did not realize the input from the sun equaled the output to space. I thought we radiated less because we used some of that heat to make things (e.g. chemical bonds). Are you saying that we use the Entropy to make the chemical bonds, not the energy? I do have a few suggestions on how to make the video slightly more clear - at least for those of us who are easily confused. First time I watched the video, it was not 100% clear to me the energy in the perfect Carnot engine was _stored_ in the flywheel. I know you described it like that, but "steam engines" turn a wheel which pulls energy out of the system. Like a train wheel or a ferry paddle or .... Obviously this is my error. But if I made it, others may too. Perhaps make it a bit more clear that the energy gets stored in the flywheel, not put into, for instance, moving something. Also, at about 7:00, you say it is not 100% efficient because the hot gas is pushing more than the cold gas. You represent this with arrows - big arrows for hot, small for cold. They are not the same size, so clearly the amount of work is different. But then you claim to fix this by increasing the hot side (even bigger arrows) or decreasing the cold side (even smaller arrows). Now the arrows are farther apart in size. How did that fix the problem? Finally, just 'cause the gas is at Absolute Zero when the piston is very very very high up does not mean there is zero pressure as the piston gets closer to the bottom. Won't the gas heat up as it is compressed? So why does that make it 100% efficient. Finally: The Placeholders caused me a bit of an issue. For instance at 21:20, you talk about "entropy is defined as the heat going into an object over the temperature - which can be re-written like this". But all I saw was "Placeholder".

Mike 1.0

Good documentary and a rather ambitious topic. I concur with some other statements on the representation of entropy. I'll restate in a more simplistic fashion. The latter part of the documentary makes heavy reference to entropy after introducing the concept. Viewers may lose sight of the basic concept of entropy as we delve into abstract application. It may be useful to draw a line back to the basis of entropy - connect the dots - for the viewer to illustrate a more cohesive understanding. (For some reason, the image of Steve Balmer gesticulating on stage shouting "entropy! entropy! entropy!" amid his flop sweat came to mind. Don't Balmer the viewer.) Perhaps limiting the abstractions and expanding more on the application would help, compromising content for length. Finally, there is no means of inserting a line break into these comments via mobile phone keyboard, for lack of a Shift button, and it's maddening.

Thein Lin Aung

Inspiring video. For me, why the entropy was lowest in the beginning of the universe and the connection to gravity is not clear. Has gravity always been there even in the "clumped" state? If so, how does it contribute to the eventual increase of entropy?

Benedikt Heinen

In the beginning of the video - about the question, how much radiation earth reflects - "what are we getting from the Sun?":

Stefan Grunspan

Here’s the question my son had after watching. “Is energy like velocity, like a vector? Or is energy like temperature? Because it seems like energy has two values associated with it, quantity and order?”

Benedikt Heinen

The amount of energy the earth loses, wouldn't that include heat lost from the earth's core cooling over time? If so - shouldn't what we get from the Sun also count towards offsetting some of the earth's own temperature loss?

C.J. Smith

13:09 While I understand the idea, I'm trying to figure out how you got those specific numbers. The animations you show have the right bar in the same state the entire time the bar counts up, however given the graph at 13:24, the fact that it's symmetrical around the average number of packets means that you're also considering the arrangements within the right bar. In any case, maybe a quick display of the combination calculation would be good.

C.J. Smith

In general this is certainly a confusing topic. There were a few things in here that are currently difficult for me to wrap my head around, for example the heat engine part that others commented about. I'm also pondering the bit where gravity plays a role in entropy - if matter being spread out means low entropy and energy being spread out means high entropy, does that mean highest entropy (heat death) is matter all in one place but energy evenly spread?

Roman Rodak

Beautiful amazing video, thank you! The only thing that i felt would need some explanation was about the "concentrated" energy of sunlight - how does life on Earth use this? why infrared photons can't be used for the same processes? is it only organic life that uses this, or are there some anorganic processes that can benefit form sunlight to lose some entropy? But I'm afraid I know the reason, it would be too much to include in one video.

Richard Kaufman

Yes, it is a good video. I like presentations like this that start with the historically accurate investigations that Carnot and Clausius did into steam engines. From that context, it always seems that an increase in entropy is discussed as the decrease in "useful" energy. Although seemingly implied, I believe we should come out and say here that, "Entropy generation reduces the amount of 'work' that can be generated in the universe." Clausius (and Carnot) also considered idealized temperature reservoirs which resulted in "entropy", or the Principle of Entropy Increase. To me, there is an irony that Clausius developed the Principle of Entropy Increase, which points to a limited amount of work that can be generated in the universe, from a cycle that utilized temperature reservoirs with a seemingly inexhaustible supply of energy capable of producing work.

TTST

This is a wonderful video. Looking forward to sharing it with many people. Two comments: 1) Consider briefly summarizing the history of Helmholtz Free Energy (or Gibbs Free Energy), because it might help connect the dots. (Helmholtz is also an amazing historical figure: polymath surgeon who measured the speed of neuron conduction, identified vortices as topological invariants in fluid flows, and then turned to thermodynamics to help build the foundation of modern physics.) 2) Toward the end of the video, you setup a connection between life and entropy gradients. (Wonderful.) Could you take an additional step and pose a question to the SETI community? Something like, "Maybe the search for extraterrestrial intelligence is really the search for planets with steep entropy gradients?"

Liran Katzir

I love the Video. For some reason, I remember that Earth is cooling down as a whole.

pglpm

It seems engagement doesn't matter anyway.

Keith Arnold

Somwhat like the old James Burke series

Keith Arnold

Great video on a difficult topic! Is it not more complete to say that the energy we perceive comes from solar, geothermal and nuclear? Clearly solar is the vast majority of low entropy energy but not the only source. It may also be instructional to explain that energy from oil, gas, hydro, wind … is effectively solar.

Keith Arnold

I agree with others that the Carnot cycle was a bit unclear. Also, you show a fly wheel, presumably doing some work, but the energy transferred is not considered in the explanation.

Tommie Marshall

I loved this video. Entropy is such an underrated topic!

Bahman Engheta

For the efficiency calculation, aren't you missing the first summand? It should read Efficiency = 1 – 293 K ÷ 433 K = 32% and not just 293 K ÷ 433 K.

Mike Milne

For me, the section on heat engines at the beginning was too long, and confusing - and I'm still not sure why it was necessary. Most people understand the concept that any machine loses energy to its surroundings through friction, etc, but to my mind the overlong heat engine section didn't really clarify that at all. I understand that it formed part of the history of the 'discovery' of Entropy as a concept, but I don't think that fully justifies it. A good friend of mine, a movie director, once said "if you're having trouble with a scene, try reading the script without it".