Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello all, thank you so much for your support and feedback. We have a video is coming out really soon -- hopefully tomorrow.There's still a few animations to fix and placeholders to replace, but it's not far from the final version. We'd absolutely love your feedback.https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/5d1hzphkvon28g4nmxc9e/VERITASIUM_IQ_v3.mp4?rlkey=x28h3iauvfuypzdoydouekz4f&dl=0If you have ideas for titles/thumbnails, please let us know.Thanks,Petr on behalf of Derek and the whole Veritiasium team

Comments

Matthew Yurish

One minor suggestion: when phrases like "3 times higher" are used (such as with the commentary about the death rate of servicemen with lower IQs around 14:15), it always makes the implication ambiguous to me. Does that mean "3 times the base value" or "the base plus 3 times the base (i.e., 3 times HIGHER than the base, or 4 times the base)." It's a minor quibble, but I feel like saying "3 times as high" is clearer and more explicit than "3 times higher", but I recognize most people will understand the implication is "Y = 3X" and not "Y = X + 3X"

Pavlo Pravdiukov

"3 times higher" is just base multiplied by 3. You'll never hear "1 time higher". So multiplication is already included in the phrase. But if you want to make it ambiguous, use "higher by 300%" 😉

Stephan DB (FlyingSteve)

Good to have included physical brain size! It is often a clear component in explaining why some animal species seem so much smarter (i.e. more capable of complex tasks) than similar or related species. Most correctly, it is brain size compared to body size - a bigger body in general needs more neurons to steer its basic functions, but more brain mass than that enables higher intelligence for that species or individual. "(Brain) size matters" :-)

Benedikt Heinen

One small suggestion - and it's minor: About 20-21 minutes in, you explain the concepts of fluid and crystallized intelligence. I'd switch the two labels around, because in the video, your arms are pointing in the direction of "fluid" while explaining "crystallized" and pointing in the direction of "crystallized" when explaining "fluid". Not sure how much effort it would be to switch that in the video..

Pavlo Pravdiukov

When I heard about the military not accepting people with IQ below 83 I thought to myself: "what an interesting artificial selection. Wouldn't it make people dumb in the long run?" And then you went into discussing exactly that later in the video! So I'd say this video is well-structured. Also, not giving answers to the sequence tests is really nice! I tried to solve them myself, with more complex patterns at first.

Kelly Snook

I really really enjoyed this piece! I would have loved to see some discussion on gender, although i suppose just one example of correlation between genetic factors is probably enough.

Paul Weiss

I thought that the essay did a good job of acknowledging the vexed history of the metric’s use while not simultaneously rushing for a position on the parapets.

Aaron Koblin

Fascinating! ... didn't realize how dark the US history related to IQ was. Oof.

Veritasium

Thanks All! Derek here, re-working the video at 2am. We may be a little delayed in the public launch but I appreciate the feedback. Keep it coming. We'll try to dot all our i's and cross all our t's before releasing this.

mpartel

The thing at the end about 20% potentially being a large number seems suspect. Surely studies (perhaps the ones that establish the "at least 20%") give us at least some ballpark limits. If not, I think it's worth explaining in more detail why.

Andrew Alvarez

Hey Derek, I like this video a lot but I have a couple concerns. 1) When you talk about the miliary’s use of IQ scores, I think there are some important asterisks you should add, like how the military doesn’t do a formal IQ test but instead an ASVAB score that only roughly matches IQ, and how, AFAIK, civilian employment by the military of low-scorers is not prohibited - only enlistment is prohibited. Source: https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/37491 2) I feel like the practice effect on increasing a person’s IQ test score should be expounded upon a bit more. My understanding is that it’s a pretty major effect in that it reduces the validity of test scores. You mention that it adds about 8 points, but doesn’t it depend on the amount of practice done beforehand, and the quality of the strategies developed? I obviously don’t know, but I would think the effect could be greater than 8 points depending on the extent of the practice.

Veritasium

Thank you! Regarding pt 2 I think it depends on the predictability of the tests. For a lot of the results mentioned in the video, we've gone with averages take from meta analyses.

Mario and Claudia Bottion

Thanks for doing this video. It touches on very deep subjects that are underlined our mindset of other people. I felt that you touched all bases and provided a fair view. Well done!!!!

Edith Dubiner

Thank you Derek, nice video. Most of the content I knew, but not about the US army (only enlistment - thanks, Andrew) or about the dark US history related to IQ (brrr...). One thing that I think deserve mentioning is the new-ish concept of emotional intelligence. Would be interesting to know the correlation it has with various success parameters compared with the IQ correlation with such parameters.

Mike Milne

I enjoyed the video - a good overview of the history and current practice of IQ testing. Your experience of taking the test adds an interesting personal angle - you implied that, given more time, perhaps you could have done better on the pattern matching sections. Is there a correlation between reaction time and timed IQ test scores?

Raffi Minassian

Excellent video. Thought provoking as usual and super fun to watch.