Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Our next video is on what we hope will be a very uplifting topic...

There are a couple animations still being completed and you may see some placeholder slides, but we'd love to get your feedback on this nearly-final cut before it goes out early next week!

As always, any title/thumbnail suggestions are always welcome too.

Thanks so much folks!

Han (and all of Team Veritasium)

Files

Should Airships Make a Comeback?

Comments

Lionel Pöffel

Liked it. I have no aviation background, so I cannot evaluate if all the problems with airships were evaluated (and fairly, not too pessimistically, not too optimistically). The only question I've posed myself recently about H2 (also in view of it's planned large-scale usage as fuel) is the following. If a big industry produces a lot of H2, due to imperfections some of it will always escape. And due to its low density, it will migrate to the upper atmosphere rather quickly. Is there a risk of loosing too much H2 over time if we're not careful enough?

Amrit Chandhok

When Derek mentions the 3rd category on the charts saying they are trucks of the sky, the uplifting music is a much louder than Derek's voice so its a bit distracting.

Dragon-Tear

H2 comes from water. The ammount we would put into blimps would not be significant.

Mike Milne

Plus ça change.... In the 1980s several new companies announced their intention to use airships commercially (Airship Industries, Aerolift etc). Back then, I shared an office with a pilot who'd had some experience with airships, and he explained the problems that they would face - they were exactly the problems covered in this video. Sure enough, all those companies failed. Perhaps a sentence or two on the history of ‘Revive-the-Airship’ attempts (such as the Van Dusen spherical airship) - might add some humour and perspective to this otherwise excellent video? Incidentally, my pilot friend said that airship gondolas had to have steel-reinforced floors to avoid passengers and pilots being injured by bullets - apparently airships are tempting targets, particularly in the US.

Lionel Pöffel

Fully aware of that. And you're probably right about blimps. But a large-scale H2 indistry that's supposed to continue for centuries (?) is a different thing.

John Cox

1. Voice whispering "pond 5" @0:22, @1:08, @2:27, @2:57 2. Title is "Should Airships Make a Comeback?", as if it's a choice, but the latter end of the video spends a lot of time talking about the complications of doing so. Suggest "_Can_ Airships Make a Comeback?" 3. Do you have a personal concern over visual pollution? I do. Planes pass overhead quickly (and loudly), but airships don't. They replace noise pollution with visual distraction. The people being interviewed were rather happy with the prospect of having many airships in the sky at the same time, but I'm thinking that it would be disappointing to travel all the way to a historical site only to have a large airship (or two, or three) hanging out a few hundred yards out, occupying much of the field of view of the sky.

Joseph Gill

Maybe add a more well-known plane (747?) or a one-story house to the graphic of the airship for scale.

Paul Weiss

A very nice treatment of what is fundamentally an engineering discussion, rather than a science one. One phrase did catch my attention, given that the initial description of the economic domain of discussion was US-centric, is the concept of international freight shipping as a limit condition requiring a technology break in the logistics systems. In fact, US trade with its very important partners of Canada and Mexico represents an enormous fraction of US international shipping, and is a logistical pattern which does not require the replacement of over-the-road trucks by ocean shipping and/or air freight, so perhaps the boundary might be made more explicit in fewer words than I’ve just used. Second, the requirement for hull stabilization after offloading the payload has a directly analogous historical precedent: the period of European colonial-period exploitation of Western Hemisphere timber resources was one where the mass moved within the trade pattern was highly asymmetrical, and which translated into the widespread use of European brick in the construction of the Atlantic Coast colonial-period cities of the Americas.

Raffi Minassian

Awesome video. Can't wait to watch it with my kids when done.

Tricia Midgley

I love this because I teach 8th graders about how science and engineering really do matter in the world. This does an excellent job of backing up my point. Thank you for making my job easier! I will be showing them this video.

Malcolm Dickinson

Excellent overall! At 16:43, Derek mispronounces the name of the USS Akron. It was named after, and is pronounced identical to, the city in Ohio.

Keith Arnold

Why not have a helium core that floats the base airship with consumable or ejectable hydrogen?

Anthony Roberts

@Keith or a core of Hydrogen surrounded by He. Not sure if feasible but could potentially offer protection by isolating Hydrogen. y surrounding it with a relatively inert gas.... Probably several reasons why it wouldn't work......

Chris Mullin

I like John's suggestion of replacing "Should" with "Can". Answer seems an obvious "No." The scalilng argument runs into the problems mentioned at the end of the video (how to build a big enough hangar, difficulty in constructing a rigid enough air frame, plus the eventual impossibility of sailing upwind). And if the starting cost is $200k to rent a cabin for a week's trip (call it three tons of supplies, furniture, people, and luggage, to be conservative), costs will always be orders of magnitude higher than ocean freight. Labor costs will hurt, too. Guesstimate a similar sized crew since both need multiple shifts of workers, and the difference in mass transported (50 tons on an airship, or 500,000 tons on a ship) makes an airship look ridiculous. Specialized transport to remote locations, perhaps, but not like trucking.

C.J. Smith

Cool stuff. Main thing I noticed is when you're talking directly to the camera, the audio seems louder compared to the other parts of the video.

C.J. Smith

As for thumbnail ideas, some reference to the Hindenburg might be good since so many people know what that is.

C.J. Smith

Maybe text on the thumbnail that says "The next Hindenburg?" or something like that

TerraFlora

Saw the video on YouTube before it got turned private, was there a factual error in the video or was it just mistakenly made public too soon?

Josh Webb

Preview version here on Patreon is private now too. Wonder if that one accidentally got made public instead of the final cut. Or the steampunk mafia got to him.

Marco Currin

Since humans walk in the MIDDLE OF CREATING CREATION...why they have a shadowy area show up before they're face of light...that's time and space...the shadowy are OK...the double slit experiment your seeing ONE outcome past/finite......the you see MULTIPLE OUTCOMES..full speed of life future singularity....you didn't have GOD EXPLAIN IT TO TO YOU WERE NOT LISTENING 2 eyes one of them is gods SILLY...the kids before words never doubt this knowledge