Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

A.O.T replacement Round 1

  • Vinland Saga 215
  • Death Note 337
  • Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood 195
  • Jujutsu Kaisen 115
  • Solo Leveling 62
  • Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba 114
  • Frieren 141
  • 2026-07-21
  • 1179 votes
{'title': 'A.O.T replacement Round 1 ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Vinland Saga', 'votes': 215}, {'text': 'Death Note ', 'votes': 337}, {'text': 'Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood ', 'votes': 195}, {'text': 'Jujutsu Kaisen', 'votes': 115}, {'text': 'Solo Leveling', 'votes': 62}, {'text': 'Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba', 'votes': 114}, {'text': 'Frieren ', 'votes': 141}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 7, 21, 1, 12, 13, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1179}

Content

Comments

Elisabeth Hutchinson

I'm genuinely caught between FMAB and Death Note. Both are peak. I highly recommend getting to both eventually

ima

My favourite reactor commenting on my favourite anime and manga Vinland saga might be too much to take, BUT I still voted it😬😂

Mina E.D

Demon Slayerrrr. Story + visuals + music + characters. I also think everyone getting into anime should give Death Note a watch, as it is a classic

Ron Fehr

I've never watched or heard of any of these, so I was unable (or unwilling) to vote.

Jarron Taylor

Voting demon slayer and Frieren over FMAB gotta be illegal

Chlo

vinland saga pls 🥺🥺🥺

archit vyas

how come you guys not selecting vinland saga....are you serious..wtf

Xanotos

I can't wait for when SoFie starts FMAB.

Jacob Truslow

Sofie I know you would absolutely FALL in love with Demon Slayer, please please give it a shot, I’ve wanted you to watch it for so long. It’s inspiring and emotional, funny and charming. And the story is easily digestible while still being surprisingly in depth. You’ll really connect with it.

Kelsey

Fingers crossed for FMAB -- I know she'll love it if it wins

Mina E.D

For REAL, I actually want it to win so bad

Jaeger

I hope u finish AOT first🥹

Faraam Knight

JJK my goat will most likely not win :(

borntrouble

Frieren is literally the best anime of all time.

borntrouble

A lot of people vote for Frieren over FMAB, just go look at myanimelist

borntrouble

Demon Saler kinda mid, just carried by the animation.

Leora Guterman

Fullmetal Alchiemist: Brotherhood is so good. That said, I feel like you would love Blue Eye Samurai which is currently only one season.

Swisheroo

Full metal has to win 😭

Giulia

FMAB is just a classic

Salim Sadman

Sofie! Please watch Netflix series Dark!

Nina

Because I prefer FMAB. Always have always will 😊

archit vyas

preference is other thing .the show needs to be worthy of a reaction..hype moment and all that ...a slow burn series reaction is kinda boring

Nina

I love watching reactions to FMAB. Seen quite a lot of them and most of the time they're among my Favorites of the entire channel. Nothing boring about it.

archit vyas

well.. whatever the masses prefer

darya

You will love Death Note!!! Its another classic,just as AOT!

Kelsey

I respect peoples' right to have different tastes......but I personally was bored to tears by Frieren. I have a hard time understanding the hype

Kelsey

It's honestly the only anime that comes anywhere close to AOT for me 🤞

frangolin0

Fullmetal Alchemist is the only right answer here without HxH

Razzer95

Demon Slayer or Solo Levelling would have been my pick but looks like they are going to lose out. Don’t mind as much as we already got Peaky Blinders and Dark Knight trilogy to look forward to

darya

YES!!!!

Roveldo

Based on your reactions to AOT, Sofie, I think you should go for something with strong presentation, a good story, and a scope that gradually expands. You seem to enjoy anime that feel expressive and impactful, rather than shows that are simply well written. My main recommendations would be Demon Slayer and Death Note. Death Note has a much narrower scope and focuses mostly on a small group of characters, so it does not give you the same sense of a large, expanding world. Demon Slayer, though, seems like a perfect fit for you based on the parts of AOT you react to the most. I also think you would probably love Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, although its presentation feels a bit more restrained and stiff compared with the other anime on the list. I have not personally watched the others, so I cannot really comment on them. Also, a lot of people call Demon Slayer “mid” and say it is carried entirely by its animation and presentation, but I do not think that is a fair criticism. Presentation is a huge part of what makes any anime successful. If you cut Attack on Titan’s presentation quality in half, its audience would probably shrink by far more than half. Execution matters just as much as the underlying story. I honestly do not think nearly as many people would have kept watching AOT if its presentation had been closer to something like Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood.

Thoshify

Frieren is the best possible contrast to AOT in a positive way. I think, Sofie would love it.

renna

but there is far better than demon slayer when vinland saga or frieren exist...

Sonny

Agree

Robert Technovsky

I dont think she will like death note?also its stretch out with nothing happening for many episodes idk, I feel like most people voted death note didnt even see it lol

Lerm

vinland saga is a must after AoT

SB

Choosing between these options should be illegal 😭 But I hope JJK, Frieren or Fullmetal Wins

alex evans

Same here, Frieren bored me to death

alex evans

Code Geass and Death Note are a must watch if you like reflection and strategy.

Phendan

If Death Note should win, I recommend the dub for this one. It's excellent.

Nick

Glad FMAB is not winning. The original version (2003) is much better.

darya

thats a YOU opinion though, Death Note was a major classic way before AOT came out. Why would she not like it? Its not as much action packed as it is an intellectual strategic show, why on earth would she not enjoy a show that require brain cells?

Roveldo

A cruel, pitiful character with a god complex does not automatically make a show “intellectually demanding.” Death Note thrived in an era when being edgy, ruthless, and maliciously clever was considered especially cool.

Jean

Sofie, I think you'd love "Spy x Family" and "The Apothecary Diaries". You could put them on the list next time

Bruce Ray

Y’all still sleep on Vinland saga. Smh tragic.

Frosty

No HxH?! Better than everything on this list, especially more so than overhyped Frieren and Demon Slayer

DiscoAlexandrite

Folks love when Blank Faced Character A talks to Blank Faced Character B about vague emotions they once felt one time back in the day while nostalgic music plays to trick you into thinking something interesting is going on.

Frosty

Demon Slayer is terrible, no fight choreography/fire works as* animation lmao

Mina E.D

🥱🥱🥱🥱

Rai rai

I know many will consider this a hot take but let's be honest, Demon Slayer is pretty cringe watched as an adult. I understand its appeal for the teenage demographic though.

Rai rai

It's too bad that Mob Psycho 100 isn't more popular, would have been a great pick. I get that most people voting are probably younger guys which really reflects on the suggested shows, a bit shame though.

Allison

Totally agree. I watched the whole thing thinking it would get better or turn a corner, but there was zero character development. I liked it as a concept, but it was such a struggle to finish it and when I did i was just mad lol

Allison

I cannot sit through death note again. It was so overhyped. No character development. No plot movement. Same episode over and over again. There’s no journey. I’d be thrilled with any other outcome. There are incredible options for this channel specifically on this list. I’m obviously Team Anything but Death Note.

The Tale Tree✨

I may be too old for this crew…. But I have no clue what any of those suggestions are. Lol

PBnJ

It’s not really about being interesting because that’s subjective. Not liking Frieren is fine but it is a good watch if you enjoy themes and character work. Frieren is like the perfect show to have playing in the background. It also has good writing regardless of if you find the characters or plot fun.

Jaegerx

Vinland Saga is closer to AOT in terms of its depth, though death note is exciting and very addicting

Muhtasim Mahin

i've seen all of them. Vinland saga is unmatched.

Ivan Zimi

Sofie should whach Frieren regardlees the other, followed by vilnlad. Just because I would love watch her reactions. An anime with profound message and depth. For those who loves LOTR.

Ivan Zimi

Based on the reactions that sofie has been making until now Frieren should be the obvious choice. It's not the most popular I get it, but for her it would be fantastic to watch !!!

Sarah Fatima

Duhh, fmab has to win... it's pure classic...